This business is a rip-off! They scammed my family for several thousands of dollars. The job was…read morehaphazard incomplete as Manhattan Roofing repaired half the roof, but NOT the entire roof of the whole building. They did not show photos of the completed work and partly negligent from my party as no one was physically able, ready and willing to climb the roof to make a visual assessment of the alleged completed work. My party has become dismayed, dispondent from the deficit and utter dysfunction horrible work from Manhattan Roofing including the financial pain of being cheated and scammed. The absence of work completion. It is the consequences and the effect of NOT doing. My party and I are victim who grapples with these plaguing consequences. Forward. Years later, the continual plaguing problem of leaks and water damage from rain, snow and all elements entered. The workers from this rpofing business did not enter the roof but used a long ladder from the side of the building to do this haphazard work. Ergophobia? Or, acrophobia of heights? Money hungry! Construction contractors from another business was hired year 2024 to take corrective action for repairs to be thoroughly completed to thwart effects from elements.

I worked with George to repair my parent's roof in NY. We got several bids from different vendors…read moreand George gave us a good bid, has a good reputation on Yelp, and seems pleasant enough to work with. There was some slight damage done to neighbor's window screen (from debris bering tossed from my roof), but George acknowledged and took care of the issue with no fuss. The job was done super fast!! (2 days). George was patient with working with me and my parents. A+++++++++++++++++

After years of putting it off, I finally decided to replace the roof after years of chasing small…read moreleaks and drainage issues. Every contractor who came before seemed to patch a different area, but the problems always came back eventually. Goldenberg Roofing BK broke the cycle. After inspecting the roof, they showed us several areas where water had been ponding for a long time and explained how the existing drainage layout was contributing to the deterioration. The project involved a full tear-off, new flat roofing system, updated flashing, and improvements around the drains. The crew worked efficiently, kept the roof organized throughout the project, and provided updates along the way. We've been through several major storms since completion and the roof has performed exactly as hoped.

The photos below speak for themselves. I had my roof done in late 2016. Since then, Eden…read moreGoldenberg's team has attempted to fix the perpetual leaks in my skylights three times. I never needed a new roof...merely new flashing on my skylights. My daughter's ceiling has been repaired and painted twice before these photos were taken just today. Notice the sloppy tar work on the skylights. He stood me up on December 21st, 2017 to 'scrape off' the visible tar. Never showed and offered $1500 back to use someone else. It's all memorialized in text massages. I've yet to receive any restitution. His work and his word are worthless. Since posting this review this morning, I have gotten threatening text messages from Eden Goldenberg with respect to my livelihood. Beware of this businessman. In response to Eden Goldenberg's message below...the house was built in 2003. I don't consider that to be 'very old.' Update...Filed small claims court suit in April 2018. Eden Goldenberg never showed. I was awarded the total amount by the judge (4K+ court costs). If more dissatisfied customers go up against this dubious character, he will be forced to stand by his work! 11-1-18 The new photos were taken yesterday of a different skylight than the ones previously posted. If you need roofing, please be certain that Eden Goldenberg does not run the company that you're hiring. He very well may have changed the corporate name by now.

DO NOT USE THIS ROOFING COMPANY!…read more In 2021, I was looking to redo my roof and I went with this company. They came the very next day for the consultation and promised they could start the day after and it would be a one day job. However, they ended up showing up late afternoon in the winter so they had to come back the next day to finish up. Even though they promised to show up in the morning again, they did not show up till late afternoon. This 1 day job ended up being 3 days. We had signed a contract stating there is a 10 year warranty on the roof and the manager/supervisor promised if there was any leaks within 10 years he would come back and fix it. I have a voice recording of him saying this and a copy of our written contract of course. Less than 1.5 years later, in 2023, my roof is leaking again. I have been reaching out, calling/texting etc but this company will make up every excuse in the book not to show up. After months of promising to come "the next day for sure 100%", they will not show. Finally, they showed up 1 time just to inspect and they told me they didn't have the materials and they would come back tomorrow to fix it. Of course, they never came back. They texted me saying I would need to buy the materials, because the guarantee in the contract only covers labor costs and not materials. He offered to help me buy the materials for $80 or I can buy it myself. They made it very difficult for me to buy the materials by sending very blurry pictures and misspelling the name of the product in hopes that I would give them money instead. In the end, I was able to buy the materials, but they never showed up to fix it. In the end, they blocked my number when they realized they were not getting any more money from me. I used a new number to call them and they immediately picked up. After realizing it was not new business, they told me I had to pay for labor to fix my roof despite being well within the 10 year warranty. They are now making up another excuse that the leak is not from what they worked on (which is a complete lie as they redid my entire roof). In the end, they never showed up (after promising they would, of course) and blocked my second phone number. I have evidence of everything I stated above about this company (contract/license/text messages/phone logs) and I am happy to share with anyone considering using this company. TLDR: Your roof will leak again shortly after the job and they will not come back unless you pay them more to fix their own work.

Alban answered the phone right away. "I am on the scaffolding!"…read more Alban showed up same-day. WHAT???? I am impressed with their service, value and humility. Their price was right for both materials and labor. It is easy to get ripped off in NYC. It is good to know there are people who charge a fair fee and do excellent work. Six stars.

I contacted Charles about a leak that started the night before. He got back to me right away, and…read moresent one of his guys to come look at the place first thing the next morning. The guy was very considerate and looked at everything, then he called Charles back, who called me, and quoted me $6,500 to replace the entire 250 square foot roof. He kept saying it was 500 square feet, which it definitely is not (he had not seen it in person). I tried to talk through various options with him, but as soon as it became clear I likely wasn't going to spend $6,500 on the spot to replace the entire roof, he became disinterested and eventually hung up on me. I get Charles not wanting to waste time, but the numbers he was throwing at me seemed very large, especially for the situation. He wasn't wiling to talk through things at all unless I was going to commit to thousands of dollars on the spot. Also, after some less rushed research, $6,500 is a very high price for a 250 square foot flat roof. Charles seemed like a nice enough fellow - but I can't help feeling that I narrowly escaped being taken for a very expensive ride because i needed work done quickly - as anyone with a leaking roof likely can relate to!

EDIT (6 Months After Install): Two of the leaks that existed before the re-roof have persisted…read more Charles is always quick to answer the phone and send his team (honoring his warranty), but unfortunately they haven't solved the actual issues. Therefore, it's hard to give them more than a couple stars since the main value of having a roof is to prevent leaks, which this roof currently does not do. ORIGINAL: In short -- highly recommend. We called C. Johnston after suffering from sporadic leaks in our new apartment for the last 6 months. Charles, his sons, Santiago and the crew did a phenomenal job on a difficult project that involved laying down a new roof and replacing a skylight at our coop in SoHo. Much of the roof was underneath a large deck that had to be moved (and then reassembled) in order to replace the roof. The deck was put back together in great condition, and the new roof has withstood a few storms already with no leaks. The price was fair (Charles specifically made a point to not oversell a more expensive method when it wasn't needed) the communication was clear & frequent, and the team left my place in better condition then when they arrived. FWIW they're also the only roofers we've had that haven't tracked tar anywhere in my apartment. If you're considering a new roof in NYC, you'd be dumb not to call C. Johnston.

I do most of the repairs and maintenance on the property I own and manage. My tenant texted me…read moreFriday evening with a video of a water leak coming from the attic/roof. The next day I inspected the attic thinking that maybe the solar panels installed two years ago may be the cause. To my surprise and relief the cause was a missing plastic cover that was on the roofs powered exhaust vent. It had blown off during Fridays storm. Luckily my tenant had stored the cover but did know what it was. The vent with the cover on looks like a mushroom. On Sunday, I used Angie 's list to located a Staten Island roofer since my Brooklyn guy had not yet called back and I didn't want to risk another rain storm. The first contractor that called was already talking about replacing the exhaust vent at about $1600 for the job I cut him short since I only wanted a cover replaced. I said this is not looking good . Good bye. About 5 minutes later Marke calls me I got lucky, real lucky in finding a guy that did not try to cheat me. I told him all that was needed was to replace the cover. I texted him the photos of the cover. He stated that he could possibly fix the cover once he takes a look at it. It may be hard to find a replacement. At 10am he arrived at the house with his father. (Once he said that was his father, I knew I had the right guy) He inspected the roof and confirmed he could do a decent repair. He showed me pics of the roof vent. No need to change it. He used metal strips and screws to attach the cover. Then he placed ice/water shield and adhered it to the cover. He took pics again after the repair. The price was very reasonable The honesty was superb The time arrangement could not have been better. I paid cash and he later emailed me an invoice as I had requested. He is a good man who works with his father and since he did not steer me wrong, I decided to give him an excellent review!! I hope you call him if you ever do need a reliable and honest roofer. By the way, my Brooklyn roofer did call me back and confirmed that he would have done the same.

High quality work and fast service. Roof repair surpassed prior contractors. However, payment…read moremethod was not communicated prior to starting the job. Would hire again if this is incorporated in the future.

The roof had developed widespread surface cracking, but the recurring bedroom stain appeared only…read morewhen snow melted slowly rather than during ordinary rain. Test openings found damp insulation beneath several older repair areas, indicating that the moisture had traveled farther than the visible stain suggested. The owner compared removing only the wet sections with replacing the complete roof. Because the existing modified-bitumen system was heavily patched and approaching the end of its service life, full replacement was selected. NY Roofing removed the old roof to the deck, deteriorated material around the hatch was replaced, and tapered insulation was added to improve movement toward the rear drain. A new two-ply modified-bitumen system was installed with fresh wall flashing and metal edges. Materials were lifted from the street during a restricted delivery window, while the neighboring roof and occupied rooms below received additional protection. The finished surface had a consistent slope instead of the shallow depressions that had formed around earlier patches. Following several rainstorms and one freeze-thaw cycle, the bedroom ceiling remained unchanged.

NY Roofing delivered a smooth, stress-free experience. Eden and Mike were professional, attentive,…read moreand detail-oriented, and the roof replacement was handled with care and precision. The site was left clean and nail-free, and the finished roof looks solid and professionally installed.

I was looking for an insured contractor to redo my roof and gutters, and he was the most thorough…read moreand transparent of all the contractors I contacted. The job was done well and fell within the estimated time frame they estimated it would take. The workers were all professional and diligent. While working they noticed other issues which they graciously fixed without extra pay. Even after the job was done Jimmy continued to follow up and explain everything so we would understand, I appreciated that. I would highly recommend them to anyone looking for a respectable and professional contractor. I had a pleasant experience.

I dealt with Jiimmy , he was amazing . The crew did a wonderful job replacing my roofread more

Antonio and his team did my parents (mom's) roof and gutters. At the time of his initial estimate,…read morehe even promised to patch a cracked ceiling as a courtesy. Pro-Serve did an outstanding job on our roof. They were quick, efficient and very detailed oriented. Our roof and gutters are great and we have had no issues and it's been about 2 years now. Although the ceiling was not fixed at the time our roof was completed, I only recently contacted Antonio on fulfilling his initial promise and patching the ceiling. Antonio did NOT have to appease our request, but he did anyway bc he is an honest and good man and cares about his customers. Kindness matters and our family is very appreciative that he went out of his way to accommodate us, especially after such a long period of time. That it itself tells you what kind of man and company he runs, so I have no hesitation recommending his services to anyone. Thank you, Antonio for all that you did for us.

I initially asked the owner to come to my place and give me a quote on a gutter that is leaking. He…read morewas very prompted with messaging and gave me a quote on the spot. The one thing that I'm angry about is that when he put his ladder to look at the gutter he actually made it worse. He banged on the my aluminum gutter so hard that it bent. I was on the roof watching him do it. When he climbed the ladder he said my gutter was bad and that is bent... and then i told him that it was straight until he banged his ladder into it and he replied that there was no other way to get his ladder up without doing that. At the moment I didn't think much of it and so today i had another person give me a second opinion and told me that the other person should not have bent my gutter with his ladder like that. That was very unprofessional of him to make my gutter worse and then blame me for it. For that, fuck him.