My first stop upon arriving on Santa Catalina Island was this Mi Casita. I ordered a pineapple margarita, pina colada, and chicken fajitas. Everything tasted fresh and the service was prompt, but be aware that the prices are on the higher side, which seems to be the norm on the island. Overall, a delicious and satisfying meal. read more

See all

Had lunch there and we were underwhelmed for sure. Chips & salsa are not fresh and cost $5. I'd rather buy a $5 bag of Tostitos they would have tasted better. I had the Ranchero Enchilada which is cheese enchiladas covered with oretga chilies, chile rellano sauce and a big dollop of sour cream. It was mostly chilis, not much cheese and the side of refried beans were mediocre at best. My husband had the Casita tacos, and he wasn't impressed either. I ordered a Cadillac Margarita in the rocks, no salt. It was delivered with tons of salt, so much so that my first sip was straight salt from the bottom of the glass. It was warm and way too sweet for a Cadillac. I couldn't drink it. Service was friendly and efficient and the restaurant is cute, albeit cold because every window is open I don't recommend and think the other Mexican restaurants have way better tasting, true authentic Mexican food. read more

We landed in Avalon and were super hungry, this restaurant is just around the corner and can be found easily. The ambiance is super cute and the decor as well. They have yummy cocktails and would highly recommend the pina colada. We ordered guacamole, burritos and fajitas, the food was fresh, made to order and tasted excellent. We really enjoyed the service and the warm corn tortillas. The rice had a nice flavor too. Overall loved this restaurant and the views too! read more

Mi Casita - Guacamole - Mexican Near Me - Avalon, California

Came here in arriving to Avalon aka Catalina island with a large group Service was slow but the servers and people were really nice The food was decent but not blow me away but the amount of carnitas on the plate was great and same with the fried fish Portions are definitely big and it does the trick overall read more

Took a cruise recently and one of our stops was on the Island. We decided to stop here for a quick lunch after looking at the shops. When we first walked in, there was nobody at the front to help us. I finally saw a waiter in the back who noticed us, but did not help us. Finally someone came over to seat us. We asked for water and got bottled water. Can't remember the reasoning for it. Actually took over 15 minutes to get our "water bottles". A waitress came and asked us several times if we wanted to order something yet...even though we barely got a chance to look at the menu. After she came by a 3rd time, I felt obligated to order someone for now. So I got chips and salsa, which wasn't complimentary. usually they are at most places. We finally placed our order. I got a burrito and my boyfriend got some tacos. We both didn't enjoy our meals. Did not finish it or take it for leftovers. I really just had the chips and salsa. Was disappointed. Salsa was good. The bathroom was not very clean and smelled. I could not wait to get out of there. Also, looked like someone peed on the floor and the trash was overflowing. It was not to loud in there and they had music playing. I would love to go back to the Island, but we are not sure if we want to come back at this time. read more

Mi Casita - Mexican Near Me - Avalon, California

I was at mi casita 2 days ago and I have to say that food it's a 5/10. lack of flavor and way to dry. Service it's good in the way that the staff it's very kind and attentive but our food came first than our drinks (cokes) Ambiance it's great. The place it's really cute. read more

Mi Casita - Mexican Near Me - Avalon, California

See all

Definitely one of the best asada I've ever had. The steak torta OMG is mind blowing, I'd definitely go back there to get me another bite of it. Nachos and tacos were good too, but no salsa?? Customer service was very attentive too. They'd come up and ask how was everything every few minutes. read more

See all

Do not recommend at all. We ordered chicken taquitos and they brought us beef taquitos because they didn't have chicken but didn't ask us if it was okay. The beef quesadilla was way too heavy and the sour cream was chunky and when we asked why it looked curdled they said it's just got it comes? Huh?? The decor is super cute but if you look around the seats are torn and walking out of the bathroom we could see the server using his fingers to scoop the sour cream and guacamole on the plate. Their salsa is straight out of a jar of El Paso salsa, salsa should always be fresh at a Mexican restaurant when it's that easy to make.They don't even list the price of drinks on their brunch menu, way over priced! The drinks were the only good part of the meal. read more

Mi Casita - View - Mexican Near Me - Avalon, California

This has to be my worse Yelp review ever. Rice was cold and looked and tasted like it was frozen and just left out to thaw out and be served . No flavor on rice . Enchiladas lacked sauce on top. Flavor and texture on enchiladas were 5/10. Only savory part of dish was the beans. Our server kept forgetting our drinks order and wasn't servicing our table unless it was to order more food. Please save your money and go eat somewhere else and make sure you Yelp it before going!!!!!! read more

Mi Casita - Only allowed 1 refills ! Cup size smaller than a 5 flu. oz tapatio bottle! - Mexican Near Me - Avalon, California

See all

I would like to preference a few things before I begin... 1- I love, Love, LOVE and eat Mexican food, A Lot, from a lot of different Mexican restaurants 2- I will order a Cadillac margarita even if it's not on the menu, because the ingredients are there 3- The waitress appeared to be running around. Now that I got that out of the way, let me give my honest review. My husband, son and I got off the boat and immediately knew we wanted food, our staple, Mexican food. So of course, the first place we see is this restaurant. We go in and ask the guy at the front desk if they have a kids menu, he hands us one without any other questions and continues about his business. After several minutes later, he comes back to see us. When we get to our booth, I flipped the menu over and tell my husband to order me a Cadillac margarita while I go wash my toddlers hands. There is a line and two stalls, so from the time I get to the line and back to the table at least 10 minutes passed. So I'm assuming my drink is already at the table. But once I get to the table, no drinks, no water, no chips and my husband tell me no one has even approached him to order. We sat there for so long but I started looking up another Mexican restaurant on the island we can go to, but just before I was about to make a suggestion, our waitress comes up to us. Honestly I don't remember her name but I'm not sure she gave it to us. We sat there for so long we already knew exactly what we wanted, so of course we ordered everything. The waitress brought us chips and salsa, bottled waters and then our drinks and food. Honestly it didn't take that long. We ordered two margaritas, a sampler with Taquitos, calamari, cheese quesadillas and chicken wings (a strange combination) and a side of rice for the baby. Our drinks were watered down and I can't tell you what type of tequila they used on my Cadillac, it tasted like chemicals. They was barely any calamari on the plate and the babies rice was from dry. Hell the best this about the food was the warm tortilla chips. Just look at the photos. What I know as someone who frequently dines out, restaurants owners do not, DO NOT, need to skim down their staff or quality of food, due to rising cost. I know prices are increasing and higher wages are being forced, but I can guarantee it's worth it, not only will you get quality workers, you'll get dedicated customers. We already planning out next few summer trips to the island and I hate to say it, but this won't be our stop. read more

See all

1. Food- all three of our dishes were pretty good. I liked the white beans, chili verde was good as well. The margaritas were just ok. Funny flavor not my thing. They are big probably need more alcohol in the drink. 2. Service was quick ( restaurant was empty at the time we went). Waitress was very friendly 3. Ambiance- well it's a Mexican restaurant haha. Overall the food was good but the price point was over board for Mexican food. Three plates , three drinks 160.00 including tip. Too much for Mexican food read more

See all

Mi Casita was actually a pretty legit Mexican spot here in Avalon, with a good Chorizo con Huevos burrito that hit the spot. Pepsi instead of Coke prolly' would work in Mexico, but otherwise, this place gets my authentic thumbs up read more

Mi Casita - Legit for Catalina Island - Mexican Near Me - Avalon, California

Overpriced and under delivered with mediocre flavors that seemed to be sourced from the Von's around the corner. I swear we just paid to eat Tostitos. The best thing about the space was environment. I would say this is a skip. read more

Little cosy restaurant the food was ok but the service was pretty good they have a full bar and a tv so you could watch the games wile eating or just have some drinks read more

See all

Went to Mi Casita with my family today. It was busy and the vibe was noisy/chaotic. The service was somewhat inattentive but the server was pleasant when we interacted. The chips and salsa were good but cost $6. We had three burritos and one person a plate of enchiladas. Everything was fine, not good and not bad. It was passable. I thought it was a bit overpriced for what we paid. read more

We came in for breakfast cause the Pancake Cottage was long wait. We usually go to Coyote Joe's for Mexican in town. I was very surprised at the good service and yummy Mexican breakfast of this place! We had vegetarian omelette and two orders of carne asada and eggs. The breakfast potatoes on my plate had chorizos in it cause our server didn't know that I don't eat meat. He offered to bring me some Mexican rice which was nice. The veggie omelette was so flavorful and yummy, steak and eggs were so good as well. The service was very friendly and attentive the entire time. We will be back for some more yummy Mexican soon! read more

See all

HUGE margaritas and average Mexican food. Someone approached me to ask what I got so I guess the carne asada is the move? It was good though - just not the best Mexican I've had and there are definitely better restaurants on the island read more

Mi Casita - Carne asada - Mexican Near Me - Avalon, California

Wife and I had pleasant time. She ordered a quesadilla--why, I am not sure since she is from Tamazula de Gordiano, and I had the shrimp and chips. The shrimps were good, but my wife said the quesadilla was awesome...weird since she generally does not like them. I had a Bloody Mary...4/5. BUT I am asking a Mexican restaurant to make a non-Mexican drink. Overall, a good experience. The ambiance was awesome. They have two stories...nice big windows that let sunlight and breeze in. Service was a little slow at the beginning, but got better. Check it out when in Catalina! read more

See all

Currently closed for a remodel. Website says they'll reopen September 2025. Bummer, we've come here every time we visit Avalon. Love the tequila Cazulas and their nachos. Oh well, next time! Looking forward to the remodel!! read more

Came here after one of my Catalina tours around 3pm on a Friday. Restaurants are typically very busy around 5-7pm. It was rather busy for an afternoon and it took awhile to get service but the food still came out pretty quick once we ordered. I saw the mediocre reviews about this place and this is my conclusion: If you get non traditional Mexican food you might be disappointed. But if you get any of their traditional plates, soups and stews and especially the margaritas, you will be AMAZED! I had the pozole and Chile rilleno plate (and yes I finished both) my husband had the mojarra fish plate. The portions are only slightly smaller than on the mainland but I was still full and happy regardless. This is one of the few places where a margarita doesn't taste too liquor-y and just plain tasty (still got buzzed though, don't get it twisted haha). Try it out! read more

Mi Casita - Chile relleno plate, the beans were smothered in cheese drooool - Mexican Near Me - Avalon, California

Burn it to the ground. I mean it. Worst food and service ana and ever. Filthy dirty. They allow dogs to lick food crumbs off the floor. Our order was all mixed up. They for got our drinks. Food was very cold. It was right out of the refrigerator on a worm plate. One thing they didn't forget to add a 20% tip on a party of seven. That's probably the only way they can get their tips. Very lucky I didn't get food poisoning. They should get zero stars. read more

See all

BIG SHOUT OUT to Dalia for making this day SO especial for us with her great attitude, service, and beautiful smile!!! We are celebrating my son's birthday and she went above and beyond to make sure his celebration was one of a kind!!! THANK YOU FROM THE BOTTOM OF MY HEART Lucia read more

Always up for Mexican food and heard good things about Mi Casita.We were sat immediately on a busy Saturday afternoon. The service was decent and our food arrived fast. I ordered their carne asada plate and it wasn't bad.Good flavor and modest portions. My fiancé ordered their shredded beef burrito. She had no complaints. The prices are on the higher end. We did love their panela cheese appetizer. Super delicious. Also enjoyed their michelada mix. Overall a good experience. read more

See all

Got a breakfast burrito to-go. It was really good! They charge .65 for to-go orders... :/ read more

We've been here twice, the first time service was horrible and food was overall bland. We went again this trip (not sure why) and the service was much better but the refried beans were so salty that the kids wouldn't eat their burritos and I left my beans on my plate. My chile rellenos were good although different than I'm used to. The draft beer we ordered had an odd smell, like glasses weren't cleaned well or something. Chips and salsa for $5, chips were good but salsa tasted like it came from a jar. Hope they can clean up the place and improve the food. read more

Really good food, decent portions for the price and relatively speaking to other places on the island. I personally found the service to be quite slow and it took a long time for orders to be taken but the food came out fast. Something to note is they don't have water for free and only has bottled. Still, food was nice, just keep in mind wait time and lack of water read more

See all

It was my first time here because I got confused with another Mexican restaurant on the island. It was recommended by a local so I thought why not. They were crowded but the service wasn't that great. We had to constantly ask for basic things like salt, pepper, and hot sauce. The drinks were tasty. The food was decent I ordered the rolled tacos and they were a little overdone. Another thing was the service was a little slower than I am used to and others were served before we were. I wouldn't mind eating here again but it wouldn't be my first choice. read more

Basic Mexican restaurant in Avalon. $5 for chips and salsa. $14 for guacamole which you basically have to make yourself. Also the person for the guacamole was terrible for the price. I don't recommend. The salsa was delicious though. They got my order wrong as I asked for no beans since I'm not big on them. They gave me beans, but when I told them they brought out extra rice. But still, some of my dish tasted like beans. Anyway, the food was as you would expect. It was decent. Enchiladas were ok. You have to pay extra for lettuce and sour cream on top. Basically, they charge you for every little thing that should come with the dish already. read more

See all

Literally spent over $200, food was not worth it in my opinion. The beans tasted like they were from a can and rice tasted old. The meatballs in the Albóndiga soup tasted like they were out of the freezer. The enchiladas were stale and even the burger was ehhh. Honestly the best thing that we had were the fries. I say skip this place and hit up other little restaurants instead! read more

I was saying up the road, about a 1 minute walk, and was recommended this eatery to try after I completed the Avalon 50-miler. Apparently, there are other "Latin" eateries I could have tried, but the recommendation was mostly for the margaritas the food. Service: Fast and barely any wait Food: Meh, nothing to scream back to my family in Mexico about let alone when compared to how I cook. Drinks: Margarita was ok, but my husband makes them better, and I've had better in living in SoCal. I also ordered an orange soda and ekkkk it tasted awful, so I barely touched it. Will I be back to eat here if I run Avalon again, possibly not seeing I can spend the same $50.00 at something better on the island . read more

Stopped by to have lunch here while exploring the island. The restaurant is very loud, making it hard to have a conversation. We were a party of 5 and all were dissatisfied with our meals. Chips and salsa is not included, and you must pay for them. We ordered guacamole at $14 and it stated 4 scoops. Well it was 4 cookie dough sized scoops. The kitchen messed up a couple of orders. Niece asked for beans no rice, and she got a plate full of rice. I asked for no beans on my burrito, and it was all beans. Had to send it back, after having to ask for our waiter several times, a waitress was annoyed and took it back. I received a subsequent burrito full of cheese, very little chile verde, and a spoon full of rice. All the food was not very good for being a California restaurant. Service was even more disappointing read more

Cristina provided excellent service! Everything arrived on time and she was very responsive to all our requests.

I really thought we were in for a great meal here.(I was wrong) instead of making frying the shrimp the way your supposed too( they steamed it instead with small portions and after asking for a glass of water- instead they sell you bottled water-WTF! We're already spending a lot here. How petty can you get?(p.s.the carrots were not fully cooked!! Us 4 will not return here. read more

See all

Bad service, bad, food, tourist trap. 45 minute wait after ordering. Taco Bell is better. Bummer ,. Zero stars I would. read more

I am trying to save your money, please do not come here for breakfast. You will probably only come here because there's no wait time but theres a reason for that. As a Mexican, this is by far the worst Mexican food I have ever had. Mom got an overcooked omelette, dad got the world's smallest and saddest piece of steak with the coldest hash browns, sister got a burrito with absolutely no flavor, and I got a chorizo burrito that tasted only like bell pepper. I only ate half my burrito because I was hungry but I wish I didn't. The picture will show you a nasty chunk of chorizo. On the positive side: waitress was friendly. 04/13/24 9:30am read more

Mi Casita - Chorizo burrito - Mexican Near Me - Avalon, California

Not a friendly environment, waitress too pushy "asked for a glass of water, they said they dont have it. They will sell a bottle of water. Also, there are no prices on the menu... read more

After reading the reviews for this restaurant we were a little reluctant to eat here but we rolled the dice once we were greeted by Oscar inside. He did an amazing job explaining things and understanding what we wanted to order. We went light with the sampler platter and an extra order of chicken wings cooked extra crispy. Everything was wonderful!! We didn't try a full meal so I can't comment on the rice and beans but the items on the sampler platter were great! We had quesadillas, taquitos, chicken wings, and calamari on that platter. The salsa was great, we had both the mild and the spicy, and the chips were crunchy and warm. The ambiance was great but just like everywhere else on the island, the bees are fierce! read more

I was really hungry when arriving to catalina, but the burger here was just not to my liking. My mother had gotten the camarones al mojo de ajo and she expressed how the beans tased canned, and how the rice was wet, tasted like water she said. My younger brother didn't even like the grilled cheese. Some of my other family members also agreed that the food was disgusting; therefore, I don't recommend this place. It's very well decorated and looks as if it could be good but do not fall for this! read more

Mi Casita - the front of Mi Casita. - Mexican Near Me - Avalon, California

We were in a hurry to go catch a boat and we stopped in here The food was good the service was a little slow. My granddaughter found a hair in her food. But it wasn't a long hair it was like it fell off the mustache. Either way I would give this place another chance. Drinks were good atmosphere was nice. Only 3 stars because of the hair and the service was a little slow and we were the first ones in there. read more

Mi Casita - the name of the restaurant - Mexican Near Me - Avalon, California

See all

Rolled the dice on this place with my girl. I was in the mood for Mexican food and a margarita. We ordered the ceviche for an appetizer. It was ok after some much needed Tapatio and lime juice. Added in. I ordered 2 margaritas for myself and my girl. When they showed up we were definitely impressed by the size of these drinks. Well that's where unfortunately this story goes south of the border from here. Im 100% sure these are the most watered down margaritas on the island. Huge waste of money. Seriously, not even so much as a slight buzz. I hoped the food would be good at least after that let down. I ordered one beef taco with rice and beans. The beef was dry and burnt. The rice was kinda stale tasting. So no bueno on the food or drink. Service was good from Alex our waiter, but it all ends there amigos. Check out the other spot on the beach side if you want Mexican. It looked better. read more