Great NY slice! Stephen and the team were extremely hospitable and they had me try a couple of…read moretheir homemade sauces. The garlic sauce was outstanding! They use it for salad dressing and you could put it on almost anything. The marinara was even better and they will be packaging it and selling it in stores very soon. Definitely make sure you get some! I spoke with one customer and he drives all the way from Mableton to get his pizza here. They have been at this location for 34 years!!! That should say it all!!! Thank you Stephen and Labella's for an awesome experience!

I came here with a friend recently and I was very much so not wowed. I'm fairly surprised since the…read moreaverage rating is so high. The vibes and aesthetics of this place are just so off. We had planned to eat the pizza there, but when we walked in the place was a lot smaller and dingier than I expected. There was zero ambiance. They had more of a waiting area than a dining area, which was surprising to me. Luckily my friend lives nearby so we just took the pizza to go. While we were waiting, employees came and sat at the table next to us and were putting together pizza boxes. It's just weird, I don't get it. I would either make a legitimate dining area (one not used for side work and much nicer than what is currently in place) or get rid of the tables altogether. They're old and in the way. Turn some music on, clean up the interior. Also the outside of the place is a bit run down. Parking lines so ancient you can't see them- that kind of thing. The pizza was pretty good but not amazing and for $22.75 I need it to be amazing. I like supporting small businesses, but when I can get a better tasting and cheaper pizza at Dominos, that's unfortunately the route I have to go. Especially when the spot has no ambiance. Sadly I will not be back unless they someday reduce prices, add more items to their menu, and create a real dining space.

I haven't been to this place in over a decade but when my friend's daughter said she wanted pizza,…read morei immediately thought of MPZ. Same casual environment, same great prices and same fresh ingredients! She was so surprised by both the size and flavor of her individual slice. HUGE! I ordered a side salad and was so pleased to have fresh, mixed greens (not iceberg). Likewise, the remainder of my meal was just as tasty. Prepared as I requested.

We got the chicken Alfredo pizza and it was EXCELLENT! loved the breadsticks too. great pizza…read moreexperience!!

My love for Rosati's runs deep!!!!! Pizza is amazing!!!!! Their sauce is so good! Great Chicago…read morepizza!!!! I was told by Rosati staff that the owners are from Chicago!!!! Thank you, because we dine out at Rosati's almost weekly! Love their deep dish Chicago pizza. My favorite is their thin crust cheese or thin crust pepperoni, sausage and hamburger meat! I would recommend 100x! This is a very small pizza restaurant. No seating for dine in. We always order ahead and pick up. Usually a 20-25 min wait. Trust me the pizza is worth the wait. Best pizza in Marietta!!!! Always great staff and even better food

Spagetti and meatballs, itialian beef (dipped), and italian side salad…read more The Spagetti was outstanding! A huge and welcome surprise! The sauce and meatballs were perfect. The side salad was also very delicious. Now, the beef. 7/10. Beef needs to be sliced thinner, so thin it has only one side. The seasoning was a little off today. Usually the beef is spot on, off day today?

Someone brought this in for lunch for work and I was very impressed! I had a margherita pizza and…read moreit was very flavorful! I love the Italian seasoning in the cheese and the cheese to sauce ratio was perfect for me (I like less sauce and more cheese). Would definitely want to go and dine in one day to get the full experience!

Interesting and Different flavors . It was fresh tasty ingredients. The sauce is different than you…read moreexpect.

We ordered 10 pizzas for a family event. Service was great and so were the pizzas!…read more Highly recommended and we will be back

This is NOT true Naples pizza. It's a fake version. I have…read morebeen to many throughout Italy and None serve Italy's finest on thin paper plates! No table service. No beverages in glass and ice! Pizza itself? Toppings ok. SM Sauce is too thin. Not enough cheese. Dough was not cooked enough. Spice is good. $18, no thanks for an undercooked too thin pie. No table service! No iced soda drinks. AND EXPECTING A SERVICE TIP. LOL. Owner and customers need another trip to Naples to sample real Neapolitan pizza. I give the owner a good attempt to bring Naples pizza to Atlanta. Too many try, too many fail. This joint has a chance with a few improvements. Ditch the thin paper picnic paper plates for starters! If you desire to use paper plates with no table service, then reduce your prices. Keep up the good work. You have a good following, just make a few minor changes that would make a big difference. Or maybe a paper plate self service joint is what you want. If so, the pizza will only decline in service.

Honestly this is my go to pizza from now on. I don't even live in Marietta and I'm going to travel…read morethe 17 miles just to get pizza from here. Reasons for this: 1.) reasonably priced: the plain cheese in 14" is 17 bucks and worth every penny. I can see why Dave Portnoy gave it a high rating. The cheese is good, sauce is amazing, and I love the well done pizza dough which was amazing. 2.) the specialty slices: I got the chicken bacon ranch slice, thought it would be only ok cause never really have high expectations for pizza by the slice. I was so damn wrong. This pizza was elite. Like for $7 I got a deal. This slice was huge, the chicken was stacked twice as thick as the dough, the bacon and ranch were amazing, and 1 slice was more than enough for a meal for me. 3.) service is on another level: I ordered the Portnoy cheese pizza 8.1 and because it wasn't "well done enough" according to them they gave me the original pizza and then remade it to the correct well doneness. I didn't ask for it they just did it, I wouldn't have known the difference in the doneness at all and would have been just as happy with my pizza. Like this is above and beyond anything any other pizza joint has ever done. They support their end product enough to tell you they messed up with out you telling them and making it right just because. A++ service. 4.) ambiance: this place has pinball machines on one side and old gaming cabinets on the other side. I love it, very nostalgic of old pizza places from my neighborhood growing up and love to see it here in my new home. Needless to say, you need to come and get a pizza or a slice from here. You will for sure leave pleased.

Thanks to The Prez for this recommendation. I live near…read moreDawsonville. Came here on the way home from The ATL. Couldn't wait to get it home! The Portnoy was a 5-star+ pizza! Great flavor, perfectly cooked, nice undercarriage, yummy crust. Regrettably, my pepperoni & sausage was burnt on the bottom. Charred. As such, I couldn't get past a 1-star, because the aftertaste was just charcoal. Bummed. Cheers! RL

Pizza is excellent. Had the classic and it did not disappoint. Wings were really good. Good…read moredraft selection. Service was top notch. Place has a great local joint vibe and tvs all around. Would definitely recommend this place and return next time we are in town.

Awesome pizza and a great selection to choose from. We ordered some assorted pizza's for a party…read moreand everyone loved the awesome pizza's. Margherita and Santa Fe chicken was my favorite ! They did a great job in cutting in smaller slices as snacks. You have to try the great pizza's from this place.

I am 69-years-old, grew up in a New York suburb that was largely Italian, and have been searching…read morefor my entire adult life for pizza outside of New York that could measure up to the pizza of my youth. I have finally found it. Carlo's pizza not only measures up, it is up there with the best pizza I've ever had. A perfect blending of cheese, tomato sauce and oil, with a thin, firm, tasty crust. Very generous and high quality toppings, particularly the anchovies. Yes, it's expensive, but worth every penny. I only wish they were open more hours than they are at present.

The best pizza I've eaten in the area. Maybe the best pizza I've had in GA. I'm no pizza…read moreconnoisseur but I think I know a good pizza when I have one. I had two slice, one plain cheese and one with the specialty meatball slices. The pizza was delicious. It was perfect. Idk if I was just really in the mood for pizza or what but my first bite was like the scene in rattouille when Remy was experiencing a euphoria from his food. Service was good. One of the best pizza slices I've ever had for sure, definitely try them out if you're looking for a good pizza.