To make this review short: I placed a cake order for my husbands 30th birthday. The first photo with the pink cake is what I referenced when placing the cake order. The second photo is what they originally presented me when I came to pick it up. The 3rd picture is their second attempt at making an ombré black gold and white cake. I have been a long time customer and even ordered my wedding cake here. After the last several items ordered from here being terrible (work wise and tasting), I will be taking my business elsewhere. The workers here agreed it wasn't what I asked for and offered "store credit." Why would I want a store credit when it was your fault? Businesses like this should stand behind their work if it's not what was originally discussed. Furthermore, I had to push to get a measly $10 back for making two trips up to this bakery because of their mistake. The icing on the cake....the girl who helped me the second time told me the colors I requested are "hard to blend." Interestingly enough that wasn't mentioned when I placed my order and you swiped my card. Then proceeded to blame the girl who took my order because she was "new." I will never spend a dime here or at their winery after this type of customer service. Order at your own risk. read more

See all

Absolutely love their cakes and order from them regularly for all birthdays and events. Stopped in today at 4 PM to pick up a cake order. It was very claustrophobic and I'm concerned about covid precautions. They had 12 people in line the whole time I was there, and they have about 15-18 different shelves with displayed inventory in the middle of the store. People were not standing on the six feet apart stickers while in line. The woman in front of me kept getting out of line and looking around at everything in the display cases, etc. the woman behind me was standing about 12 inches behind me. I'm sitting in my car writing this review and just saw 5 more adults enter the store and no one leave. I think they need to minimize their displayed inventory to create space for guests and possibly enforce better distancing strategies. read more

First time there, I walked into the place it was very clean, when I walk into anywhere that I buy food from that is one thing that I look for. The people that work there were very friendly and very helpful. I Bought a carrot cake for $36, I was debating on getting it I thought it was going to taste like a regular cake from giant eagle, (I was surprise) Melted in my mouth definitely will go back there again and buy A Nother, Can't forget to grab some macaroons they are one of the best I have ever tried In the area. read more

I'm a big big fan of their cakes, macaroons and cupcakes. They are irresistible. I remember buying a dozen macaroons once and finishing them in 10 minutes or so. They have become are new favorite for birthdays and special occasions. Also, their staff is extremely knowledgeable about their offerings. read more

Amazing Italian bakery! Their cookies and cannoli are to die for and everything is always freshly prepared.

This bakery is unbelievable! My daughter got their macaroons as wedding favors for her wedding and we went back at Easter to get some goodies and the line wrapped around the entire store!!! Their bread, cookies, pastries are all fantastic and so detailed! Wonderful place but plan ahead around the holidays, parking is limited and it fills up fast! read more

Absolutely love this bakery! Everything is delicious. One of the best things about Michael Angelo's is that they listen to you and give you exactly what you want. We just had a cake for a baby shower and it was perfect! Almond cake with buttercream frosting. Beautiful and amazingly delicious! read more

Michael Angelo's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Broadview Heights, Ohio

Mama Mia! This is the bakery! From donuts, to their super fabulous cakes, wedding cakes, cookies, coffee, tea, tea cakes, breads....what your eyes see and what you drool over is exactly how you imagine it would taste! Yum is such a understated word here. Very professional, clean, friendly, and closed on Sundays. Six days you work and on the seventh you rest. He is being blessed. He's a bit more costly than your other bakery's out there, but....you get what you pay for. I've purchased several of his tiramisu cakes to bring as gifts and I am a hero every time, it's just loved so much. To me, to see someone so happy over a great cake NOT made by me, is priceless! ;) Give Michael Angelo's a visit. DON'T go hungry. Just the aroma alone is fantastic. These boys know what they are doing and do it well! Two brothers: Michael & Angelo. Thank you for gracing Parma. read more

It does not get any better than this! Great Service! Very helpful in understanding your event or celebration and takes the time to make it perfect! The quality is bar none the best! Very professional and the finished product is designed to impress and it does! read more

I was very dissapointed in this bakery. I went to order around 60 cupcakes for a party I'm planning, and received absolutely no help from the staff. I waited in line and eventually left because the workers seemed more concerned with their "regulars". It appears that they only have speciality cupcakes with cream on the inside - something I didn't want. If you want cupcakes without anything inside, it appears that they only carry plain white cupcakes with frosting. Also, the baked goods seemed very overpriced compared to other bakeries in the area. The other pastries looked delicious, however, I wouldn't know how it tastes as I was ignored by the staff. read more

The cake at our Baby shower tasted delicious. Just we were unhappy with the person who decorated our cake. Was this person experienced and rushing or a beginner learning decorating skills on our cake? The pink butter cream on our cake was not mixed evenly, there were dark red smudges on front of the cake. Was this person's handwriting nice? No. Instead of "It's a girl!", there was "It's AGirl!" Sloppy, very sloppy. This cake decorating person shouldn't work for excellent bakery like MichaelAngelo's and damage their reputation. With this experience I will not recommend ordering cakes for special occasions from this company. read more

I generally like this place, but they advertise being open at 7 and when I came in this morning, the entire pastry side was empty. They don't generally come out until 8 AM the staff member said. Well, if you aren't going have the product that you primarily sell in the morning ready at opening time, then maybe you should open later? Or start baking earlier? Just a thought. Hate to leave a 3 star review because I do like this place a lot- does a great job with breads and pastries, but this is a really dumb policy and I hope that they change it. read more

This is now my bakery! If ever I need to get a cake or bring a treat to or a party or get their awesome cinnamon bread for my breakfast this is where I will be coming. They provide fast service and a couple times I called ahead to make sure They would have what I wanted and they were happy to put it aside till I got there. The cupcakes are the bomb and I've only just started trying all they have to offer! Haha there goes my diet! read more

They gave me the wrong wedding cake. thats really all I have to write. When we went to complain, we were told that we shouldn't have cut it up and eaten the cake if it was wrong (which at a reception is impossible to do) We refuted the charge with the credit card company and won since not only did they give us the wrong cake, the owner acknowledged it (told us he had 30 other cakes to do that weekend) and offered no help or common courtesy. read more

It all started with my brother wedding cake. Then came a popcorn cake. I went to Wilton for cake decorating classes. I went back to Michael Angelo. I bought a cake made like a present for my aunt. It was the best. I love them!! This was April 14 weekend. We are going back in May and Aug. My brother started this Leon Reaves... read more

I work at the jump yard and as party host we get so excited whenever families bring in cakes from Michael Angelo's! They're always stunning! They have the best Paczki ever ! read more

We use to love the bakery and cakes from Michael Angelo's until a few bad birthday cakes ago. The first mistake we just overlooked because of the volume of cakes they create. The second mistake was fatal. Paying a lot for the wrong cake for a child's birthday party is unacceptable. Then they tried fixing the problem with some store bought frosting and a bottom layer cake that didn't taste the same as the top layer. Complaining went on deaf ears. With my daughter getting married soon I talked her into a cake tasting. Yeah, what is wrong with me. Burn me once shame on you, burn me twice shame, shame one me. Went there this weekend and got the worst customer service possible. They couldn't of care less about what we wanted. It was pretty much finish the cake and let me know what your plans are. We are so over your bakery. Michael Angelo, did you forget what made you special?? read more

Not the best customer service. They're pretty busy and they know it so you're not very important to them. If you're going to spend a lot of money on a cake, spend it somewhere where they'll actually appreciate your business or at least seem excited to help you plan your special cake. They also charge you for the credit card processing fee for charges over $150. Cool. Oh and you're definitely not anything special if your cake isn't over 3 tiers. That's what I was made to feel. They also sell days-old bakery. They're closed on Sunday's but don't start over on Monday. I've had some parfaits and cupcakes that were very dry. When they're just made though, they are delicious. I definitely don't like waste, but why not sell old items at a discount so at least the customer is aware of it? read more

My fiancé ordered my birthday cake from this bakery and it was supposed to had been ready at 12, it wasn't. We had to wait for it to be finished on the spot and it wasn't ready until 12:30 which made me late for a something important on my birthday. THEN, my cake was supposed to be black fondant with a gold logo, someone made the cake one side black and the other side white & yellow marble fondant as if they had ran out. The logo wasn't clear or drawn on as it was supposed to have been. The fondant work was terrible. It literally looked thrown on, very patchy & not smooth. This was supposed to be the highlight of my birthday and it was ruined. They had a picture of what was expected and he physically in person stated what he wanted for this small 2-3 person cake. I couldn't take pictures with my cake at all. However, it did taste good hence the 1 star but it looked nothing like the fondant work the post online. I'm still crushed about my birthday cake on my birthday. read more

This is my neighborhood bakery. This place has the best pies, bread, pastries. So so good!

Michaelangelos bakery is phenomenal! As soon as you walk in you can smell the fresh baked cookies and cakes! They have such cheap sugar cookies with frosting which just happen to be my favorite.. They are absolutely amazing! I'm getting married in the summer and want to do a cake tasting with them! I'm sure they are reasonably priced and extremely good! I've also tried their gourmet cupcakes! The cannoli cupcake is TO DIE FOR!! This place is a great place to get the best bakery! read more

The cakes here are fabulous and I order one for every holiday, bday, anniversary, etc. and would never go anywhere else for a cake. The only thing that disappoints is the cupcakes. I ordered every flavor and had a taste testing party cuz I was so excited about the cupcakes. Well, the cupcakes were dry and not as flavorful as I was expecting. Maybe my expectations were too high but it was very disappointing. Still looking for that perfect cupcake...... read more

We have been a customer before, with great results. Also, we have friends recommend and rave about this bakery. However, after our most recent visit here, we were essentially ignored for 15 minutes while waiting for somebody to assist us. We were hoping to get a custom cake for our daughters birthday, but instead we left feeling insulted, due to the several people served before us while we were waiting. I guess we're not important enough for service at this bakery. We'll just have to find somewhere else to do our business. read more

Just found this gem right in my neighborhood! Fresh baked goods that are delicious! It's like a little Italy on the south side.

Best Bakery in town ! We ordered our gender reveal cake from here . It was so tasty and the job on the cake was perfection . read more

Michael Angelo's Bakery - Gender reveal cake - Bakeries Near Me - Broadview Heights, Ohio

I've been going here since I was a kid. Love it. Cannot sing it's praise more. One of my favorite bakeries and extremely consistent. They do very decadent and beautiful cakes and serve the best desserts. read more

Outstanding! Michael Angelo's Bakery was recommended to make the cake for my friends' 50th Anniversary party. The chocolate cake with buttercream filling and frosting was delicious! The staff was so kind, helpful, and efficient. I would definitely use them again. read more

They have the best pastries and macarons here. Not even a competition with other bakeries around. They make everything so good and fresh, and they are always so busy, which is a good sign! This bakery is hands down the best and the workers are all very friendly! read more

Delicious and beautiful! I love the way my 1 year olds cake turned out. They did such a fantastic job and it was so tasty! Everyone raves about how yummy the cake was! read more

Michael Angelo's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Broadview Heights, Ohio

Very Disappointed in Michael Angelo's. I called in earlier saying I wanted to place cake order and asked how late they were open . ( they said 5pm ) I arrived at 4:45 . When I got there the girl behind the counter went to find someone to help me. She came back and said that everyone was "busy downstairs" and couldn't help me . She then asked if I could come back Wednesday ( today is Saturday ) . I explained to her how I drove 30 min to get there and that I already knew what I wanted. I didn't need to flip through books or talk about flavors. I literally just had to place my order . I told her it would take all but 2 minutes. She then said she would go back and ask downstairs. This time she returned and said the people who take the orders "left for the day " . Then said again that maybe I can come back Wednesday . First she said they were busy then she said they were gone. I was annoyed at the inconsistency of her story . I believe this was a case of workers not wanting to do their jobs . They want to finish up and rush home. The establishment was still open so they should be ready ,willing and able to serve their customers. Especially since when I called in and stated I will be placing an order nobody ever said to be there by a specific time . I will NOT be returning on Wednesday and they just lost a customer. Such a shame because I have purchased cakes from there before. It truly is a shame how employees can put a bad name to a business. read more

We have been a long time customer of this bakery. However, today after the rude and not accommodating girls at the register I don't think we will return. I asked for 4 "fresh" cannoli. There were some left in the cooler and she told me that I HAD to buy those first. I asked when they were filled. She said this morning. It was 6 o'clock when I was there. Basically she wanted to sell me 9+ hour old soggy cannoli and REFUSED to fill fresh ones. Needless I say we did not buy the old soggy cannoli. We left and will not return. read more

Ordered a wedding cake from them, and it was the wrong cake. Need I really say more?? It wouldn't have been so bad had I not been refused a refund. Instead the owner would only offer a 40% refund - HIS PROFIT MARGIN. I truly could not believe his gall. Typically when a service or product is contracted, and the wrong product is delivered, the seller will be happy to take responsibility for the mistake and issue a refund if for no other reason in hopes that the customer won't do something like this and publicize to the world how inexplicably inept his business is. NOPE. I eventually suggested he return 70% of the total cost (split the difference) and we call it a day, but no he refused to give anything beyond his profit. Now I get to be reminded of this garbage in a year when my wife and I eat a cake we do not like and did not order. I implore you to take your business elsewhere, unless you don't mind ordering a wedding cake and having them deliver something. read more

I've ordered cakes from here before and they have always been amazing but I must say they exceeded my expectations on my husband's 50th birthday cake. I emailed them a picture to do an edible scanned image and it came out perfectly! I ordered a double half sheet, half chocolate cake with chocolate mousse filling and half yellow cake with raspberry mousse filling with white buttercream frosting. It was so moist and delicious and not overly sweet at all. Everybody loved it and couldn't stop talking about it. Many people told me about this place and now I do the same whenever anyone asks for a good bakery. People can be negative but let me tell you this is one of the best bakeries around! The amount of people that go there speaks volumes. If you have to wait in line so be it, they get through it quickly! read more

So sad. Wanted to be give this store a good review. Came from Chicago and got a cake for my dads birthday. Called ahead and ordered a cassata, and when it came time to cut the cake, it was some sort of chocolate...which my dad doesn't like. So disappointed. read more

One of the most beautiful bakeries I have ever been in. I ordered peanut butter cheesecake it was the most delicious cheesecake I've ever had I have to say. I also ordered a birthday cake from them the service was wonderful. My family has ordered cakes from them in the past they are always gorgeous so if you're looking for a nice fondant cake or two-tier cake I recommend Michael Angelo. read more

Best bakery in the area by a mile. Cupcakes and parfaits are to die for. They also specialize in custom cakes. Super friendly staff who are always willing to help. read more

Their variety of selection is one of the best, from cakes, cookies, cupcakes, bread, and pastries as their main attractions. I have also tried their paczki which was pretty good. No complaints here, but this is probably my 3rd favorite bakery in the area. I prefer their whipped frosting over their buttercream for their cakes, and that's probably what steps it down a notch for me. Comparatively, their pricing is also on the higher end. Still a great bakery! read more

I'm really not sure how I keep on forgetting to post a review for this DELICIOUS bakery. But I do. I believe that my mom has been ordering cakes for family get togethers for at least the last five years. We had our wedding cake done from here, as well as numerous birthday cakes for our family. Usually, we get a casada cake, which consists of vanilla cake with strawberry and cream filling. Of course when my birthday came along, my mom offered to get me a cake. Yes, I may now be 32, but am an only child, so don't hate! Anyways, this year, my mom decided to surprise me and get me a purse cake, since I had been talking about this amazing silver Coach purse for at least six months on a daily basis. Thankfully, my hubby got me the purse, but my mom decided to be extra thoughtful and get me a purse cake. Being seven months pregnant, I wanted something different for a cake, so I decided to ask for chocolate with the mocha mousse filling. OH MY GOSH WAS IT DELICIOUS! They really went all out on this cake and was really perfect. I will post a picture of this beauty, it was seriously on point and am now excited to use this bakery for more future family get-togethers. It makes me sad that I don't live in Cleveland, otherwise I'm pretty sure I would be here every week! read more

Michael Angelo's Bakery - Delicious custom made purse cake with chocolate cake and mocha mousse icing. So good! - Bakeries Near Me - Broadview Heights, Ohio

Been here once, picked up a tiramisu cake and macaroons. The cake was fabulous as well as the macaroons. I find the cakes a bit pricey but good. read more

I had my daughters first birthday cake ordered here and it turned out perfect. Beautiful and delicious. Everyone asked where we got it from and I proudly told them where. We had red velvet one layer and the Italian strawberry cassata. I wish I knew how to add a picture of it. read more