Cancel

Open app

Search

Michaleno’s Pizzeria

3.8 (4 reviews)
Closed Closed

Order Michaleno’s Pizzeria Takeout or Delivery

Michaleno’s Pizzeria Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

More like Michaleno’s Pizzeria

Recommended Reviews - Michaleno’s Pizzeria

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

11 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Mike H.

Mike H.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Michaleno’s Pizzeria

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Italian 239 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Jim's Place

Jim's Place

4.9
(14 reviews)
13.3 mi
$

I've known of Jim's Place for a while because their flavor burst ice cream cones (which are…read morestraight out of a 1990s McDonald's) had social media abuzz, but only recently had the pleasure of stopping for the first time. In addition to a mint flavor burst ice cream cone I ordered a cheeseburger and wonton mozzarella sticks. The wonton mozzarella sticks are an incredible value given how many you get for the price. Crispy on the outside and had good cheese pull. The cheeseburger, which had a nice flaky bun, had excellent flavor and is one of the better burgers I've had in the area. It made me sad that I hadn't visited Jim's Place before. I wanted the blue goo flavor of flavor burst, but they were out of it that day, so I went for mint instead. It wasn't super strong like I had hoped, but you could taste the mint. I would probably get a different flavor next time (hopefully they have blue goo available at that point). The gentleman that took my order and made my food (who I assume was Jim?) was very kind. I originally ordered to dine in and switched to to-go as he was bringing my food out because of an urgent matter. He boxed it up for me and never once had an issue with the sudden change. I appreciated it very much.

My first time being at Jim's place was fantastic. I really enjoyed their signature pizza and their…read morevariety of food and drinks to choose from their menu. Despite the fact the restaurant alone was small and the tables were close together, the staff was friendly and very busy. I really enjoyed how they decorated the walls with nostalgic memories such as the gumball machine, 70's music, beanie baby crane and a lot of "my name is Jim" tags for everyone to remember. I would move the tables out at a little further for people who want a lot of space. Also, there needs to be a parking lot made behind or next to the restaurant so that no one will have to parallel park and walk there. I would definitely recommend this place for anybody who loves delicious food at great prices.

Photos
Jim's Place
Ice cream and pizza, what more do you need?
Ice cream and pizza, what more do you need?
We've lived in Wisconsin for over 6 years and have yet to find a decent pizza place. Our search is over.

See all

We've lived in Wisconsin for over 6 years and have yet to find a decent pizza place. Our search is over.
The Twisted Pair

The Twisted Pair

4.0
(26 reviews)
7.3 mi

I saw a post on social media that Twisted Pair's pizza of the month for February 2024 was chicken…read morecordon bleu and thought what a great time to make my first stop for a meal. I drove up for dinner one night and got cheese curds in addition to the chicken cordon bleu pizza. The curds looked like they would be really good, but I couldn't get over how greasy they were on their bottom sides. Each piece was sitting in a pool of grease on the tray and it made the taste a little unpleasant. What a shame. The chicken cordon bleu pizza was exactly how I expected it to be if not better. The crust was chewy, which I enjoyed, and all of the flavors had a chance to shine instead of one dominating the rest. I particularly liked the breadcrumbs on top as they gave the pizza another texture to work with. The chicken could have used a little seasoning, but that's minor. I'd be up for trying other pizzas of theirs as well considering how good this one was.

Stopped here on a Friday evening for food while camping in the area…read more I ordered the blackened shrimp tacos and my bf ordered a burger. Lets start with the appetizer- the cheese curds. They were huuuuge blobs of cheese and it was not appetizing at all to even eat. We literally left over half of them and picked at the smaller cheese curds. 0/10 Tacos- absolutely disgusting. Definitely nothing blackened about it.. shrimp had zero color and flavor. The tacos were soggy with a mushy mango salsa and a blob of crema. The same way I received the food the same way i left it. 0/10 My bf ate not even half of his tasteless burger. Our dinner consisted of drinks that was about it. Our waitress was overly friendly however we will never ever come back here.

Photos
Ribs served with French fries or smashed baby reds ans coleslaw.
Ribs served with French fries or smashed baby reds ans coleslaw.
Crab cake sandwich served with French Fries.
Crab cake sandwich served with French Fries.
Crab cake appetizer.

See all

Crab cake appetizer.
Il Ritrovo

Il Ritrovo

4.3
(398 reviews)
30.1 mi
$$

Had a delicious lunch at Il Ritrovo today. We opted to sit outside and enjoy the beautiful weather,…read moreand were able to be seated immediately. Our server Dylan was excellent, and the rest of the staff kept our waters filled and dishes cleared. We tried the Vegetariano panini (fantastic) and the Lombardia pizza Bianca (also fantastic). Everything is clearly prepared with intention - the greens on top of the salad were perfectly dressed, and the veggies on the panini were chopped into small, uniform pieces so every bite was perfect. It was hard to decide what to order, so we will be back to work our way through the menu!

Cute place but SUPER TINY. the place was super busy and cramp. I think if you get a booth you're…read moreokay, but because it was just us 2, we got seated right by the door, in the middle aisle. It was IMPOSSIBLE to talk to each other. It was so loud, we were basically yelling at each other, the waiter too. Our table was so tiny, it barely had room for our food. What if we had ordered more? Our waiter was super nice and very knowledgeable. However, when he was telling us about the pasta special, we both heard him talking about adding berries to it. But when it came it, we were confused what he was even talking about. The pizza was great BUT only when you eat it fresh. After it got to room temp/cold, all you could taste was the burnt crust. Unfortunately, now that it's off my list of place to try, I probably would not go back. Also, we had to wait 30mins which was fine but a party of 2 who came AFTER us, got seated before us.

Photos
Dining room
Dining room
Il Ritrovo
Interior decor

See all

Interior decor
Harry's Pizza E Vino

Harry's Pizza E Vino

5.0
(22 reviews)
24.0 mi

Excellent pizza, the crust is perfection! High quality ingredients! Love this place, and so happy…read moreto support!

First visit to Harry's Pizzae Vino in Elkhart Lake was excellent! I went with a friend, and he…read moreordered tje Lemon Pizza, and I ordered the Beef Marsala pizza, neither of which I've seen on a menu anywhere before. The lemon pizza featured lemon flavor, of course, but it was perfectly balanced with the flavors of the smoked mozzarella, basil, arugula, and EVOO! The Beef Marsala was rich, but not too rich, in flavor with very tender pieces of beef braised in a red wine reduction and accompanied by mushrooms, creme fraiche, basil, mozzarella, and a delicious Marsala demi drizzle The crust on both was perfectly crispy with a slight chew. They call it Roman style pizza, in that the dough is made fresh in-house in the same manner the traditional Roman pizza (think thick, rectangular pizza) dough is made, but as a "pie" shape, you get a light, crunchy edge and crispy thin crust. It was unlike anything I've had in the Milwaukee area. My friend and I also started with glass of Macedonian pinot noir and finished with a traditionally small pour of Vin Chaud, which is similar to mulled wine. Both were fantastic! There are some gems in Elkhart Lake, and Harry's is one of them. I highly recommend you add Harry's to your list when in or near Elkhart Lake. This is the same family that opened Harry's Prohibition Bistro and Harry's Diner in Sheboygan, which I've also enjoyed in recent years!

Photos
Harry's Pizza E Vino
Campfire Pizza
Campfire Pizza
Inside. Very comfortable

See all

Inside. Very comfortable

Michaleno’s Pizzeria - italian - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...