Food and service was amazing! We were told they make the dough from scratch. We got a cheese pizza, breadsticks and marinara and everything was so good, we'll definitely be back. read more

We got the veggie pizza and a salad to share and it was all delicious! Carryout pizza can be so mediocre but this was far from it! Very pleased with our dinner! Added bonus, I placed the order wrong online and received a call to confirm that what I had ordered was actually what I wanted! I can't imagine a chain pizzeria doing that! read more

We just moved to the area and tried Michelangelo's pizza. It was outstanding!! I've ordered take out several times since and everything has been great! Last night we ate at the restaurant and it was excellent! Great friendly service and excellent food! read more

Ordered food for a group of people for lunch... all individual meals. I will say that some of the meals were really good, some were pretty average. (Pizza and calzones - good. Baked pasta meals - average) What was most impressive was the service. One guy ran the whole show! Took orders, made and served the food.... And he did it with a smile. I know help is hard to find in the service industry right now. So kudos to this small business for making it work while short staffed. Hope others see the value of small business owners who are working hard to keep their businesses open. read more

I would of been way better off throwing a frozen pizza in. The worst and most expensive pizza(30 for a large 4 topping) I've ever had. Under cooked,caned mushrooms and hardly any cheese ir sauce. read more

Love their pizza and the service is always so nice! Not sure why they only have three stars because they definitely deserve more. Glad to have such a place so close to home. read more

A disgrace to call this pizza. Super thin seemingly store bought crust. Actually a store bought crust is likely better. No real flavor in any of it.. closest flavor profile is burnt and stale. Even adding sausage couldn't elevate this pizza. read more

One of the worst meals I have ever had! I order pasta with noodle's and got some type of lasagna with all cheezie sauce. The Italian sausage was burned. The Cannoli were frozen solid and could on eat them. And then to top that off they forgot me salad (which was refunded). This is not the first time I had issues but will be the last. read more

We ordered broccoli on our pizza and it was all frozen tasteless broccoli stems. Terrible. I ordered an appetizer and it was so over cooked I was afraid I was going to break a tooth. I am not a fan of their food. read more

I used to enjoy coming here, but recently the quality of food and service has declined dramatically. I ordered dinner for my SO and I and not only were the portions diminutive, but barely warm and dry as well, as if it had been sitting for quite some time. I only received half of my side order as well. All in all I believe I will not be ordering from this place again read more

First, said delivery within an hour and that they'd call as we were in the lake. No call. Promised napkins, plates; ketchup, Cheese and peppers - none delivered Pizza was marginal at best especially with the green canned mushrooms. Marvel your money. read more

Foods was mediocre to say the least. The marinara sauce tasted like they dumped sugar in it. Salad was basically a large container of iceberg lettuce with olives, pepperoni and onions thrown on top. Chicken cordon blue sandwich was dry with a piece of chicken a slice of ham and thin cheese with no lettuce and tomato and no condiments. Wouldn't eat here again if u paid me. read more

I'm fully convinced this is the best pizza on Earth. I first found out about Michaleno's from a friend, and was utterly blown away by the quality from the first bite. Ever since then, I've been back time and time again and the experience is always as wonderful as ever. The place is kept up super well and is nice and clean always. The service has always been excellent, as well. The pizza, though, is the crown jewel of how incredible this place is. Every single aspect of it is top notch. The cheese, sauce, crust, pepperoni: All as good as you can get. It's a thin crust, so if that's your thing, I highly highly recommend Michaleno's. It's a great place to stop before/after a movie at the nearby theater, or if you're just in town and craving a heavenly, one of a kind pizza. read more

Stopped on my way through town and was pleasantly surprised, not sure why only 3 stars, the pizza was great, the garlic bread was really good, add the cheese it's not overwhelming and I think I ate more than even the pizza. Great clean place and fast carry out. Will go back! read more

First time ever visiting today! I can't recall the last time I had a baked pasta dish but the one I had today was amazing! Cheese super melty, Italian sausage really flavorful, sauce was really tasty and the dish was super filling and for an excellent price! Iwill definitely be back to try the pizza! Awesome service too, I think the owner was the one who helped me, extremely helpful and friendly, can't wait to take my fiancée here! read more

It was excellent to find a place that would deliver to Jackson since even the bigger chains will not come this far. We wanted a good local pizza place and Michaleno's is a good option. We order a fairly standard pizza, so I cannot speak on their specialty pizzas or other items, but for delivery, it is hot, the crust is crispy and it tastes good. It is a bit expensive for what it is and I would expect more fresh items rather than packaged, but it is good. The drivers have been quite nice and since our place does not show up on map programs directly, they are always good about calling and making it here promptly. I do wish the phone service was a bit better - sometimes it is great, other times, it is cold and mechanical. It is also apparent that there is no computer tracking as we always have to give our complete information. A few bumps in the road, but still a good option for those in the area that want good pizza. read more

My wife and I dined at the West Bend location of Michaleno's, which has the same owner's as the Kewaskum location. The wait staff was extremely friendly and the restaurant is relatively new and clean. I was really excited to see the menu had a rather extensive selection of Italian food in the hopes that this would be the place we could go if we needed an Italian food fix. Since the restaurant seemed to be known for it's pizza, that's what we got... one taco pizza and one "blanket" vegetable pizza (I.e., a "blanket" pizza has a crust on the bottom and the top.) My first disappointment was when I learned that thin crust was the only option. Ok, fine... I can deal with that. Unfortunately, neither my wife nor I were impressed with the pizzas. There really wasn't anything "taco" about the taco pizza that I could tell. No lettuce, no tomatoes, and no taste of taco seasoning on what little beef there was. I've had some really good taco pizzas at various restaurants and this didn't even come close. It looked like a pizza you'd get in the freezer section of your local grocery store... lots of cheese but not much else. I guess that'd be fine if the pizza was really inexpensive, but it wasn't. The vegetable pizza also didn't live up to my expectations. For much less money, the Papa Murphy's gourmet vegetable pizza is way better. The pizza lacked any real flavor and although there was a decent amount of vegetables, it was no Papa Murphy's (not to mention we paid a lot for the pizza because the menu didn't have a "blanket" vegetable pizza which means we paid extra for all the toppings.) So sadly, I really wanted to like Michaleno's, but I'm afraid I won't be back. There's nothing special about the pizzas that I can't get at pretty much any cheap(er) pizza joint. Perhaps I'm too much of a pizza snob, but if I actually go out to eat to get pizza, I expect it to be at least as good or better than something I could buy pre-made. read more

Ordered 2 "Italian Beefs" and fries. $23. I ordered 1 without peppers. They said "Oh we don't have peppers on our Italian Beefs". All right so probably not a real Italian Beef. So we get sandwiches and Honest to God, 2 pieces of beef on a bun. Please don't waste your time and money on ordering a sandwich. Only reason 2 stars instead of 1 is taste was decent read more

Michaleno's Pizzeria - One half of the "Italian Beef". 2 small pieces of beef. What a joke - Pizza Near Me - West Bend, Wisconsin

Michalenos is one of my favorite pizza places in west bend. I go here at least once a week and have yet to be disappointed. The owner and staff are extremely friendly! My favorite is the chicken alfredo pizza. The crust is fantasic, and they offer a wide variety of toppings. I love all of the options they offer; pastas, appetizers, fish fry, wings, desserts, etc,. Give them a try next time you're in a pizza mood!:) read more

Great place for quick pasta. Their baked manicotti is amazing. The cheesecake bites are to die for!

I've eaten here more times than I can count. Everything is fresh and delicious always! You can get things custom difference way you like and they're always amazing about it. If you have food allergies like i do you will be happy that they pay special attention to how they make the food. You won't have to worry about having an allergic reaction because they take every precaution possible. I love this place and it is 100% worth going to! read more

My husband and I have ordered from here couple of different times their selection of food is really good if you're not in the mood for pizza they've got other Foods to satisfy your needs read more

I love their food! Fast delivery and easy ordering! They even deliver to the town of Polk!!!! They even give you a pizza free after you purchase 10! read more

I'll preface this review with the fact that the town I am from (Kenosha) has many excellent Italian restaurants. So I'm a bit spoiled when it comes to good Italian food. Sorry,. I want local restaurants to do well and to be there for people. But... (sigh) We went here recently because they had a groupon for just the Italian food side of the menu (no pizza). Given that we like to try different places I thought... hmm.. who knows. Maybe West Bend finally has a decent Italian option. This was really just bad. Groupon was for 1 appetizer, 2 entrees and 1 desert. Appetizer was eggplant (deep fried of course). Out of a bag.. at least it was hot. Wife had spaghetti, sauce was almost sickly sweet, reminded me of Prego out of a jar. Noodles out of a box. I had the "Baked Gourmet Ravioli" - Italian sausage. They were frozen out of a bag. If I didn't know I ordered the italian sausage ones, I wouldn't have been able to tell you what kind I was eating. Same sauce with way too much baked cheese on top. Desert - brownie bites. Umm.. out of a bag deep fried in the same oil that everything is fried with so they tasted a bit like the appetizers. Nothing was fresh here, I don't know if they make their own sauce, but come on, good sauce isn't all that difficult to make. We did not take the leftovers home. Not worth the calories to eat. I'm giving them two stars because the service was pretty good and the pizza *looked* good (other people there were eating pizza), but I can't speak for it. If you go here, don't get the Italian food unless you are a Prego/Ragu fan. read more

The hidden diamond in the rough of pizza shops! Staff are super friendly and personable. Great Italian dishes, buckets of chicken, and pizza. Highly recommend!! read more

The only pizza I will order at this place is their Taco pizza. The other pizza's I have tried here are average at best. I also had their lasagna one time and again average (was pretty bland in taste). The owner is very nice but the lady answering the phone to place an order needs some help in the customer service area. Normally when a person calls a business they are greeted with something along the lines of "Thank you for calling ____, this is ___, how can I help you?". The lady literally answered the phone like she was at home by simply saying...Hello. No acknowledgement of place I called, or her name. I had to ask her if I called the right place. Oh my... read more

Great Pizza but the customer service stinks!!! It took almost two hours to have a pizza delivered and the owner did have two times to contact us and he did not bother to do so. read more

I wish I could give this place lower than a one star but I cant. Horrible service. Horrible delivery times. Driver can never buzz a door has left without delivering several times. Order has been not messed up maybe twice. I give up on them. Last time i ordered the delivery kid came knocking on the door asking if he gave me his delivery bag. Needs new staff very sloppy read more

Let me start out that I do a lot of traveling around the country. every time I go I try at least one local pizza joint. so I have had all kinds of pizza, I took the family here to try it and Michael the owner was Exceptional. great service and spent time talking to my family and kids. the pizza and garlic bread were Great. crust was just right and flavor was exceptional. now we only had a sausage pizza cause we were with my kids but they couldn't get enough. Well worth a try!! read more

We had a wonderful experience here! We didn't think anyone deliver to Allenton and when I used Yelp to try and find a place this was the only place that did so we have it a try. Customer service was GREAT AND THE FOOD WAS EVEN BETTER. It was great to find such a place to deliver that has excellent food. Highly recommend the sour scream and chive fries. Amazing! read more

I ordered food, checked it over and then placed it for delivery. Then they got to my house and delivered different stuff. I called and they made me pay for what they missed. read more

We visited on a recent weeknight. There were two other diners in the small, uninspired dining room. Two people in the kitchen, one person at the register. Not a lot of delivery traffic. It took half an hour to get a salad and a mediocre pizza. I've had better food in hospitals and schools. If you're looking to feed kids who prefer bland food, this is your place. read more

Delicious Pizza!! Loved the Fiesta Pizza! The Raspberry Chimis also tasted great! Nice, local business - you get to talk to the owner who makes your meal and is geniunely concerned about making it a good experience - he enjoys what he does and it shows! What a refreshing break from chain restaurants. I would definitley recommend, and cannot wait to return to try other menu items!! read more

We ordered pizza and wings here recently from their West Bend location and enjoyed both very much. My husband and I actually really enjoyed the wings, they didn't taste like they came out of a bag. Very crispy, hot and great flavor. We ordered the hot wings, not to spicy. The sausage pizza was good as well, really enjoyed the sauce. Will be ordering again. read more

My family and I have has great experiences with their delivery pizza. It's not the most amazing pizza I've ever had, but it's good and it sure is nice to have a delivery option in Kewaskum. read more

Granted I had a $10 Restaurant.com Gift Certificate, but still paying $12 for a VERY thin & wimpy cheese & pepp pizza and their mix app of 3 chicken nuggets, 2 broccoli poppers, 2 chedder jalapeno poppers (asked for creamcheese) and 2 mozz sticks.. This was NOT good pizza and the stuff was near cold by the time I got it home. For the price this was not worth it and we won't be back. read more

9:00 on the dot our food was ordered was told it would be about an hour, no problem. 10:14 called to check up on the status as some of us were tired and hungry just wanted to eat and get ready for bed. I was told by the gentleman on the phone that are food was walking out the door that moment, no problem. He said thank you and hung up (no apology) 10:35 my sister calls and asks to talk to the manager, manager explains they are short staffed and he's sorry. 10:43 the delivery driver calls to confirm address ( I told my address two separate times to the gentleman that answered the phone.) Verified address with driver and he said he'd be here in three minutes. 10:54 the delivery driver shows up (1 hour and 55 minutes from when the order was placed) pay the the delivery driver in full + tip ALWAYS TIP YOUR DELIVERY GUYS/WAIT STAFF it's not often it's their fault your food is running late. Put the food on the table for 5 hungry people. Pizza is cold, cheese curds are rubber and garlic bread is day old bread with butter on it. Called back to the pizza place for the 4th time, this time I talk to the owner, explain my frustration in reply I get "I'm sorry, I tried to call you back" (that is a lie)"really busy" "we keep or pizza in warmer bags I don't see how it could possibly be cold" (apparently I'm a liar now. Although, if the pizza walked out the door at 10:14 like I was told it took 29 min to get to my house 3 miles away.) He then told me that I didn't give him the chance to make things right, as if the 3 previous phone calls weren't enough chances. "What can I do to make things better" to which I replied nothing as me and my family will not be contributing our hard earned money to a buisness who is not only late with mediocre food, he also passed the blame on to me for 'not giving him a chance to make things better' read more

I just had the worst experience ever with this restaurant. I called in a delivery order around 5:30 pm and 6:45 I called to see what was going on. The man that answered the phone said that the delivery driver was just walking out the door. So I hung up and waited some more. 15 minutes later...no food. So we called again. They said the delivery driver was just walking out the door now.....so the last person I talked to flat out lied. By this time its been an hour and a half and its 7pm at night. my kids are starving. We got the manager on the phone, a woman, and we said we wanted to cancel our order and go somewhere else. She offered us a $5 coupon off our next purchase. I think they can shove their $5 coupon up their ass. I should have gotten my meal for free plus a $5 coupon. The manager didnt even seem to care one bit. Needless to say, I will never order from this place ever again. Nor the kewaskum one either. That was the worst customer service of all time and now my poor children wont eat until at least 7:30pm. Shame on you Michaleno's. Its a shame too...I loved your guys food. read more

Some of the best Pizza, Pasta and sandwiches out there. If you want great food from a Local company you won't be disappointing. The owner is a stand up guy! Will be going back! read more

I had the Italian sausage lasagna, and it was the best I've had in many many years. I definitely recommend this to anyone who enjoys great pasta. read more