Quick service and delicious food! The garlic bread was pillowy, and the pizza had the perfect ratio of cheese to sauce to crust, plus it was heated in the oven before serving. My only nitpicks are that the pizza is kinda hard to hold because of its flimsiness, which is just par for the course with this style of pizza, and the pepperoni was really greasy, which is par for the course for any pizza of any kind. Also, bonus points for a quiet, inviting atmosphere, making it sensory-friendly for my Nana and I who are on the autism spectrum. read more

Excellent, good old fashioned pizza, with some "updated" options, like pesto veggies, chicken bacon ranch, etc. I thought it was great. We were given a garlic roll with warm butter that was super delicious! read more

Great pizza but very expensive. They use and app that charges a fee for the business?? That's weird

Whenever I'm in West Bend and in need of a meal (assuming it's not for a fish fry on a Friday night), Sal's Pizzeria is always the first place I think of. On this particular visit I got my favorite: lasagna pizza with garlic knots. If you mix together the large dollops of sauce, meat, and ricotta cheese on the lasagna pizza, then close your eyes and take a bite, you'll almost forget you're eating pizza and not actual lasagna. It's heavenly. The garlic knots are soft and they don't skimp on the garlic. I'm also a big fan of their stuffed sausage and pepperoni pizza, which has mozzarella cheese and ricotta cheese in it too with sauce on the side instead of in the pizza. My wife enjoys their mac and cheese pizza. The Sal's in West Bend is far superior to the one in Hartford. The slice selection in Hartford is usually very basic and limited in comparison and the garlic knots are smaller with less garlic on top. The Sal's in West Bend is worth the drive even if Hartford's location is closer to you. read more

See all

Great service, super polite employees. They always have something. If you wait until they close you may not get the exact flavor you want because they sell out of a lot for good reason. But definitely come at lunch time especially on Friday to see and TRY all the flavors they can make. Yum! Only pizza place I eat at in town, by slice or buying whole. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Slice of: cheese thick crust, pepperoni & sausage slice, and two garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - West Bend, Wisconsin

Outstanding service and pizza is delicious! The slices are big and they have very unique options like lasagna pizza and chicken parm on the weekends. Our girls love the garlic knots! The manager is awesome! He is very kind and really hustles! It's a very welcoming neighborhood pizza parlor. If you visit downtown West Bend I highly recommend trying Sal's read more

Pizza is always great and greasy. Service is always friendly and happy. Definitely will be back!

Pizza was the worst I ever had and the service was, well let's say sloppy at best. Will not go back. There are better places to get pizza in West Bend. Zero stars. read more

Stopped by West Bend and needed someplace quick to grab a bite to eat. Found Sal's and found a reason to come back to West Bend some time in the future. I had the deep dish pizza -- it was outstanding. Many other great items on the menu, too. Can't say am enough about the great workers, either. If you are looking for a local pizza shop, this is it! read more

About as close as you can get to NY pizza in the Milwaukee area. Love the garlic knot!

Best in West Bend. Great place to stop in for a slice or order one to take home. Garlic rolls are fantastic.

Best pizza and calzones in Wisconsin. They perfected true East Coast flavor and eating here reminds me of my New Jersey roots.

food was incredible! Brianna provided great service and was so personable! I would definitely recommend!

Review from a13 July visit - Stopped in after a successful farmer's market shopping trip, as we have always wanted to visit this place and I am not sure why we waited so long after this visit. Reminds me of an East coast pizzeria, in that the way it is presented and then reheated in the oven prior to serving (although not all places do that). There are about 6 tables and a high top area for eating, not bad for a mostly to go spot, from what we can see that is. We both ordered the lunch special of a slice, garlic know and drink for $5, yep $5 and totally worth it! My wife ordered the gyro pizza which has a tziki sauce as the base, and topped with the usual gyro meat, tomatoes and onions. The slice was huge and after starting with the garlic know she was unable to finish the slice, maybe about half if that. I ordered a slice of their supreme pizza that had plenty of cheese and toppings, not to mention flavor. The red sauce had great flavor, that attention to detail is something that I really appreciate. There are several pizzeria's around my area and their red sauce is the most lacking part of the pizza, just plain marinara sauce at best. The slice was the perfect size, nice and big. The garlic knot is like a hybrid between a garlic knot and a roll, but it was tasty, I should have ordered a cup of sauce to accompany it. If we lived closer to West Bend we definitely be here more often! If you are up in the area you should check this place out. read more

See all

Loved the pizza. Had a Sicilian deep dish with sausage and pepperoni and couldn't resist adding a slice of thin crust, cheese only. Both were great. The crust on the Sicilian was light and crunchy, delicious toppings. The cheese slice was perfect, tasty cheese, great sauce, nice crust. The "kitchen" team stood out to me. All four of the team moved like clockwork, a well oiled machine, doing whatever needed to be done. Take an order, move pizza in or out of the ovens, collecting payments. From behind the counter, backed by pizza ovens, busy as hell, the guy who took my order glanced over to our table asking if I needed anything. I watched one of the guys making pizzas, amazed at his craftsmanship. No really... forming the crust, adding toppings with precision, not stingy, tons of cheese. Nice job. Wish we had a place like this near me. read more

I only ordered once from Sal's. The food was never delivered and they refused to give a refund. Avoid!!!

Not many pizza options in West Bend for a good slice. Pretty much in my opinion it's Sal's, Michaleno's or Maricio's. Sal's is the only one that has that New York style type pie. Sal's is also the only one that offers pizza by the slice. Awesome deal being able to grab a slice and a soda with a garlic knot at lunch for $5. Getting a slice lets you figure out what you really like and what you may want to order a whole pie of at some point. The regular pizza does tend to be a little on the greasy side in the middle. That is the New York style after all. Fold it up and there's your slice. I'm somewhat partial to the Sicilian slice, with that thick crust. Great flavor & I really like that crust. Sal's offers delivery and the large pie easily feeds 4-5. Sal's is locally owned and operated with the owner there most days. It's great being able to support the local guy. He treats his customers right and sees that the employees do the same. As a sign on the menu reads " Damn right it's good pizza". read more

Eat pizza by the slice for me! Many novel combinations. Today fet Ravioli spinach. A+! With a house made garlic knot and soda for $6.50, better and better every time. Friendly quick staff. I'll be back. read more

We love Sal's in West Bend! I lived in NYC for a few years and Sal's does NY style pizza right. Best in town for sure. Sometimes the sauce runs a little too spicy for me, probably too much black pepper. Otherwise we love it. read more

The best !!!! the owner knows pizza, would recommend to all in the area! New York pizza at its finest, as well as the dessert was fantastic! Will be back with my family! read more

Their pizza is pretty good. I like how they give free garlic knots when you order a pizza. The pepperoni pizza is always very greasy though, so I only eat here once in a while. read more

Good fast meal! The pizza was good, and the kids were happy with their Mac & cheese pizza. Each slice of pizza comes with a large garlic ears knot. It's called New York Style Pizza, and it did remind me of a pizza place in NY near family. Gyro was good too. The cannoli was good, but the middle was missing filling, recommend pushing the filling from both ends before eating. read more

Great service! good sized slices of pizza in so many different varieties. Great for if you're looking for something quick and don't want to break the bank on a pizza. You can just order once slice instead of a whole pizza that will likely end up tasting like the most disappointing left overs you've ever had ! all seriousness though, the staff are great & they're always going above and beyond. Me and my s/o came in a couple minutes after they closed completely unaware and they pulled out their chairs and took our order and tossed in fresh slices for us and even offered left over pizza instead of being wasteful. overall, 10/10 cute little place with a wide selection of foods! read more

Best Pizza in Wisconsin hands down. Especially good if you get them to heat you up a single slice, it's nice and crunchy. Lots of Great Pizza Choices too! read more

First off, this is NOT Sal's in Cederberg. It's easy to order from the wrong one. Please keep a close eye on the URL of the website. I ordered from them and they let me cancel my order as I was meaning to order from the other one. I'm not from Wisconsin. For that 5 stars. read more

Good pizza and I actually liked the garlic knots if they were a bit basic. Loses two stars because none of their employees were wearing masks and we still have an ongoing global pandemic. ‍ read more

It was just ok. Firstly, none of the staff were wearing masks. We'll, they were wearing them, but around their necks and not over their mouths. The crust on my Mac and cheese pizza was very dark so the taste was affected. The second pizza we ordered was ok. The garlic knots are not very garlicky- more like a buttered dinner roll. Onion rings and mozzarella sticks were fine - basic fried fast food. For these reasons, it gets a 2. read more

Sals has the best pizza in West Bend! If you haven't already tried the spinach feta specialty pizza- you need to! It's a 10/10!

We stopped in for their lunch special and when we picked up our order, we were informed they were out of garlic knots. The special is a slice of pizza, garlic knot and soda for $5. No apology from the kid behind the counter. I'm going to ask for my missing garlic knot the next time I'm in downtown West Bend. The pizza was good but on the greasy side. read more

Favorite pizza place in west bend. The friendliness of the staff could be a little better.

1st to review? Wow West Bend, just wow. You are a clicky frickin' community, but nobody has reviewed Sal's? Fine. Well 5 stars then, pizza is way too greasy for those faint of heart, but it's open late and between the two best bars. Now I did move South one-stop before Milwaukee where I encountered Cedarburg Sal's... no way, not as good. Where both places have put my order in late, I was able to go back to the bar in West Bend, and Cedarburg just blows. It's thinner and greasier than CB and their kitchen is like 20 times better for better faster fresher stronger pizzas! =) Big Ass Slices, and you can even put Big Ass Ham on it if you like... It's your life, you do what you want! And now, as far as NY Za goes... I'm not from NY, I don't heart NY, nor did I eat pizza there; the best representation I had of it was actually in L.A. so don't quote me boy cause I ain't said, oh, and you can also usually catch Pay-per-View boxing matches here too. Be there, be live! read more

Sal's Pizza is so good it has me thinking of moving to West Bend to be nearer. , Either that or I'm going to franchise Sal's Pizza and open one in Wauwatosa, where it's sorely needed. Who'd of thunk one could get a New York style slice in West Bend? Not me, but now that I know it, next time I'll save myself the $400 airfare, $100 cab ride, and $200 per night hotel and just drive to West Bend to satisfy my craving for a genuine New York slice! read more

We happened to be in West Bend over the weekend for a little league tournament. I'd never been there before. My husband and I ventured downtown for a bite as we had some time to kill. We stopped into Sal's for a slice and now I'm sad.... Sad that West Bend is 90 min. away from Madison because that was some seriously fabulous pizza, damn good in fact!!! I ordered a calzone-like slice that had a thin top crust in addition to the bottom crust with a filling that consisted of mozzarella, ricotta, sausage and pepperoni. SO amazing - creamy and crisp and chewy and salty and full of flavor! Dare I say, it was practically perfect! My slice was accompanied by a bright flavored and garlicky marinara for dipping that was so good it just drove the awesomeness factor through the roof! Hear me now and believe me later. Drop in for a slice when you're in the area or just stopping through on your way to somewhere else. You will be happy and satiated and so very glad you did!!! read more

Might have hit this place on a bad night, but pizza was on par with frozen. We drove about 20 mins and the pizza was ready and hot when we arrived. Service was friendly, and the pizza was okay, but I will try another place next time. read more

As are most people, I am totally in love with the garlic knots!! The pizza is incredible, too. I have been bummed the last couple times, when they are out of the garlic knots, though! Never have I been disappointed with the staff. Go visit them!! read more

It's been a very long time since I've been here. I am so glad I stopped in for a slice! I know this is a bit out of the ordinary but I went for a macaroni and cheese slice and it's really freaking good! The slice came with a little roll which was really good too! Only $5 for the slice and a soda. Definitely worth it, I'll be back! read more

We got delivery, so I can't speak to the experience in the restaurant itself. However, the guy on the phone was very friendly and they had no issues with delivering to our location on the outskirts of town. We ordered one of their stuffed pizzas and some cannolis. The large pizza was massive; I think we gnawed on it for four days afterward. It was very good and arrived hot with marinara on the side for dipping (no sauce actually inside the pizza). The cannolis were fabulous; they tasted like they were about 1000 calories each-- I don't want to know how close they really were! Given the option of these guys or the chain pizza delivery, I'll take Sal's any day. Will definitely have to try the normal pizzas next time. read more

Excellent local pizza place. New York style slices and garlic knots worth dying for. My favorite flavor is the margarine, other specialty flavors tends to be too much topping and makes the middle part of the pizza soggy. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - West Bend, Wisconsin

See all

The food is very good but one blonde haired lady at the register Is very disrespectful, as in she rolls her eyes at you talks in a very rude tone also so that is why I wouldn't give the restaurant a 4 or five stars. read more

The best Za' in West Bend! This is what pizza is supposed to be like, growing up out east, we know pizza! Not the lump of dough or cardboard with sauce and sparsely topped chain crap. If you want true N.Y. style pizza's then Sal's is it. Very reasonable prices and a great value. read more