What a pleasure it was to stop in to this place. The pizza was delicious and reasonably priced, we got the cream cheese specialty one. The ice cream was so good and soft, I got the sorbet. The owner was very friendly and seemed really passionate about what he was doing in his pizzeria. Very much a hidden gem, would stop in Random Lake just for this place. read more

Random Lake Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Random Lake, Wisconsin

We have ordered delivery several times and never been disappointed. Today I actually went to the pizzeria to pick up my order. The two men working were so kind! He offered me a water while I waited. The atmosphere was eclectic and exactly what I look for in dives. To my pleasant surprise they have a full service bar, AND homemade ice cream. I left with a pint obviously... and it's so good! Pizza is phenomenal, the atmosphere was wonderful and the service was great. Loved this gem! Will be coming back again and again. read more

See all

A great mom and pop restaurant. Great pizza, great service, They offer a gluten free pizza crust and this was also delicious They make their own ice cream and ice t was really creamy and delicious too. Definitely will be back. read more

Food sucked Puked up my calzone Horrible food great service tho good atmosphere ,....., read more

Greatest pizza ever, great friendly people working there too, great booze too if you need one of those too...lol....we really liked their bloody mary's too! read more

Best Pizza in Wisconsin. The nicecream it out of this world! Tommy's the best! Had my wedding here because we met there. read more

Great Pizza and very customer friendly staff and owner. Homemade ice cream for desert was excellent! read more

Went here for dinner with a large group of friends and ordered the Gyro Salad and Calzone. The gyro meat on the salad was nicely sized, extremely tender, and very well seasoned. The salad mix that came with it was well proportioned, and both tasted just as good the next day as leftovers. The breadstick was dense, warm, and incredibly delicious. You can tell the dough is handmade. The sausage calzone was not too big, and the handmade dough here did not soften or get soggy on the bottom. After reheating the next day, the crust held its firmness, and the calzone was just as flavorful. The interior of this place is pretty eclectic, with lots to draw your attention to. It's family orientated, and the wait staff is incredible. Tom was fast, extremely patient, and friendly. He was kind enough to grant our requests for separate checks and took the time to socialize with us. This is a great spot with great food and good people. read more

See all

everything is great, the food, the service and the atmosphere. I highly recommend the pizzeria.

We had takeout from here! Order was hot, delicious, and not a leftover to be had. Yum!

Food is AMAZING. Staff is super friendly and the atmosphere is very calming and welcoming.

I was at a bonfire in Richfield and people were talking about great pizza they raved at how good this pizza was and I had to agree just happen to be around the area visiting an old classmate Tim S. Tommy, the owner seems to have dialed into what people want in a fresh, quality pizza restaurant. The place was packed on a Saturday afternoon crowd. The whole restaurant had a total of two seats available at the bar. Drink orders were quick. A few of the people getting home made ice cream to go while some got take out pizza and many were dining in. I found a great selection of craft beers. The owner is always onsite, a guarantee for great service. This place is decorated part man and she cave. The kids are allowed to decorate the walls with their own hands and name. It has a family feel. They have a WC Ramp for restroom access and outside has a bar with occasional live music out by the tracks. And yes I plan to have a few more visits before snowfall. 8/2019 Food 5 no canned mushrooms thank god Ambiance 5 Service 5 Location 5 Value 5 read more

Random Lake Pizzeria - S&M. - Pizza Near Me - Random Lake, Wisconsin

This place is a gem! The staff is so friendly, the food is delicious, the decor is interesting, and they play great tunes. We shared a yummy cheesy crust app (try it with the spicy dipping sauce!) I had a half gyro-half muskie pizza, my son had the spaghetti (huge portion), and my husband had his usual: pepperoni, green olive, and onion. At the end of our meal, the power went out in Random Lake. The staff handled it like absolute pros, trying to accommodate a large party that had just come in. All of the guests seemed to take it in stride because the pizzeria team was so easygoing about the situation. We left with nice cream cones, full bellies, and smiles on our faces. We'll definitely be back! read more

I have to say I was pleasantly surprised that Random Lake is where I would find some great pizza! They have unique pizza options and I encourage trying one of the specialties. We tried a plain sausage and the spaghetti and meatballs. Hands down everyone in our group was obsessed with the spaghetti and meatballs. It was buttery, noodley, saucy, meat goodness!! The breadsticks were also really good. Fun and unique pizzas. The staff was really friendly and polite. We will be ordering from here regularly while at the lake. read more

Such a beautiful family place. Best pizza crust I've ever had. Delicious homemade ice cream. Menu is extremely interesting. The bartender is super cool. Clean kitchen. The owner is focused and loves his job. He is friendly to the customers. I'll have to go back a second time before I decide if it's a five star. read more

See all

My first pizza dine in experience since all the coo is craziness. They have a nice patio for outdoor dining. Sadly it was raining so we headed in door. There were only three other groups here and we were all pretty spaced out. They have a wild assortment of pizza creations! Seriously check out the pic of their menu! I found the creations to be fun and creative! Since this was my first trip I decide to go more traditional, so I ordered the Landmark. Sausage, pepperoni, onions, peppers, mushrooms and black olives. It was served steaming hot from the oven. The crust was a Milwaukee style cracker thin crust.. had plenty of topping and they were delicious. A solid classic Milwaukee style pizza. I cannot wait to go back and try some less traditional pizzas. Their whole menu looked delicious! I want to try almost everything and I love the fun man mes for their dishes. Worth mentioning they have a pretty good selection of beer. Great for washing down all the pizza! This place is very casual but in a comfy cozy way. read more

Random Lake Pizzeria - Pizzas!!! - Pizza Near Me - Random Lake, Wisconsin

See all

We everything about this place, amazing food, awesome beer on tap, homemade ice cream & friendly/laid back atmosphere. BUT this spaghetti & meatball pizza is seriously the BEST from the crispy crust to the big meatballs and two veggies (we like garlic & mushrooms). Get it with cream cheese & the zesty (spicy) sauce. And it's awesome reheated in the air fryer! read more

Random Lake Pizzeria - Spaghetti & Meatball Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Random Lake, Wisconsin

this place is great! I recommend it without hesitation. tom does a wonderful job. please check it out

Random Lake Pizzeria is a great find! It's always delicious and there are so many choices. The pizza is unique and full of flavor! Try the spaghetti and meatball pizza, you won't be disappointed! Don't forget to leave room for homemade ice cream! read more

Random Lake Pizzeria - Cheese ring! - Pizza Near Me - Random Lake, Wisconsin

See all

As we drove through the small town of Random Lake, we wondered where all the locals were. Turned into the packed gravel parking lot along side the rail tracks and sand volleyball court and had our answer: they were all at the best pizza shop for miles and miles! We shared a philly ring - DELICIOUS! The crust alone is worth 5-stars, but the perfectly cooked onion and green pepper, the right amount of cheese, and a slightly spicy red sauce made this a good choice! The great balls of fire weren't what we expected but still very good. More closely related to a calzone smothered in spicy red sauce, what we had hoped for were fist sized meatballs wrapped in cheese and all ensconced in a baked dough. Ahh, well. We'd still order it again. Great pricing, super friendly staff, and predictably random decor. What more could you ask for? read more

This is the place you want to go for pizza you have never experienced. Some of our favs are spaghetti and meatball, Chicago style hotdog, and BLT. The menu is insane and the beer is always cold and unique! The owner is cool and laidback and is welcoming! You feel like family when you eat here. Do not just stop at pizza Tommy makes his ice cream homemade and the flavors are as unique as the pizza! read more

Random Lake Pizzeria - The owner had a magician in for his birthday! Kids loved it! - Pizza Near Me - Random Lake, Wisconsin

Crust taste like cardboard. Owner is a bit strange, seems to be a little kilter. Nice decor

Cheese ring....whew that sums it up with two words. Get the cheese ring...don't forget because it will change your world. There are many different types but since I was with the nieces they wanted a plain one which was still outstanding. The crust on the pizza is super thin and cracker like which is the way I like pizza done. We had a few different varieties like the classic, Tommie's Special and the T & T Special. The pesto is NUT free so the two people with nut allergies were super stoked about allergen free pesto. When the pies arrived they were perfectly done with a crispy crust that wasn't over filled with too many toppings. Since it is a small shop the pies came out one at a time which was great to space out the eating. After we were completely stuffed the homemade ice cream was served. I didn't indulge but everyone said the vanilla ice cream had a very unique good taste which resulted from using local honey. Again score! Did I also mention that the owner is super friendly and hosts a very big selection of beers on tap? Cheese rings, killer pizza, homemade ice cream and booze to finish it off - what more can you expect. PS - A guy from Chicago was in there eating and I overhead him say that it was the best pizza he had ever eaten. Take that deep dish! read more

NEVER AGAIN!! NEVER HAVE I REGRETED BUYING A GIFT CERTIFICATE. Ordered food to go. Got home pizza was uncut, ok fine. My pasta was dry and sauce less. Like eating spaghetti noodles with Italian seasoning dumped on top. Awful. read more

Worth the trip. Looking forward to coming back. We had a 16" pizza with half cheese for the boys. Also ordered a side salad and cheese sticks with marinara. For dessert the boys had some homemade ice cream. Everything was great. There were no leftovers. We will be back for the cheese rings and more pizza. Awesome spot for a family. Patio outside for a nice night. Friendly staff and clean. read more

Random Lake Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Random Lake, Wisconsin

Tommy and the guys knock pizza out of the park!!!!! Super unique and unheard combination will leave you mind blown and 100% satisfied. (They serve the normal stuff too). Worth the drive from Milwaukee for a great meal is a super casual environment for sure! Homemade ice cream is the hidden gem of the show! Again, unique flavors will delight everyone in your group! We have tried many of the pizzas but the spaghetti and meatballs is our fave! Great joint-you won't regret eating here! read more

Random Lake Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Random Lake, Wisconsin

Looking to support some small businesses in my area during the COVID crisis, I decided to finally try Random Lake Pizzeria. I'm usually a traditional pizza girl but I think COVID cabin fever was getting to me so, on a whim, I ordered the cheeseburger pizza. I like pizza. I like cheeseburgers. So.... Driving home smelling it it from the backseat was torture. Oh. My. Gosh. Soooooo good. The right amount of every ingredient balanced with a great crust made it just what I was jonesing for. Love the pickles. And their small is a perfect size for one person. A good meal and some leftovers. There are many other intriguing specialty pizzas that I'll be back to try. If I can get past the cheeseburger pizza next time. read more

It is just so nice and it is truely just amazing. The person that was working was so polite and funny. Everything was clean and Very welcoming! when I visit random lake again I will come back! read more

An amazing family owned pizza joint. Super family friendly. Great food, good beer on tap, & homemade ice cream. If u like hot stuff try the habanero poppers they are the real deal! read more

I never expected a place with so much character and excellent pizza and beer in Random. Another bar or supper club? Sure. But quality ingredients, creative combination of toppings, the cheese ring appetizers, freshly made iced cream, along with craft beers? Surprise! Plus, you're surrounded by sweet sounds of rare 70's classic live sets, Kilimanjaro memorabilia, a huge aquarium, and your friend Tommy? What more could you want. This is my happy place. read more

The environment is super friendly and welcoming staff is great, owner is very friendly and the food is amazing.

Food is delicious with fresh ingredients. service is great with friendly attentive staff and fun decor to look at.

Love this place! -For many reasons, and their epic pizza is at the top of the list of them. Also on the list, a choice selection of suds, sodas, sundaes, and other sip-ables. The other (huge) draw for me is the atmosphere and chill vibe the owners/employees got going on, and the clientele that is drawn to hang out there reflects that. Good place to hang out in the summer time too! read more

Always good!! Great pizza and more, including homemade ice cream! Yum! Eclectic, fun atmosphere!

All kinds of ways to use their thin crust. Poppers, Cheese Rings, Great Balls of Fire. Find your way there. Worth the trek. read more

Random Lake Pizzeria - Cheese Ring! Poppers! Pizza! Beer! #AllGood - Pizza Near Me - Random Lake, Wisconsin

Hands down! This is the BEST pizza I have had in Wisconsin, and I've lived here for over 4 decades!! Highly recommend the Muskie, Reggie White or BLT! Breadsticks are out of this world!! read more

Such a great homey atmosphere. Very kid friendly and clean. Pizza is amazing, along with their ice cream

LOVED IT.... The cheese ring was fantastic, the pizza was as great or even beats any place in Sheboygan. We live in Cedar Grove and wanted something closer. Should have gone to this place ages ago!!!! Great super relaxed atmosphere, excellent bar, and fantastic food. Can't go wrong. read more

What an adorable little find in Random Lake! Fit for families and adults, locals and visitors alike. This pizzeria seemingly does it all - apps, pizzas, sandwiches, salads, homemade ice cream, a killer craft beer selection on draft and in bottles + a full bar... need I go on? Probably not, but I will anyways and raise you these two words: CHEESE RING Don't not get the cheese ring, you guys. I wanted the gyro one but was outvoted... the artichoke/kalamata/cauliflower ring was the jam though, so I'm glad I was shot down. This thing... don't sleep on this thing. The pizza is beyond solid (love that thin, crispy crust!) and the ice cream was great... I didn't even think I had room until it showed up, turns out I *did* have room for chocolate dream ice cream. I don't understand this town but I think I like it: the lake is indeed random, the people are friendly and the pizza is stellar. You're as good as it gets, Random Lake Pizzeria! read more

Every time I visit my parents, we have to go to Random Lake Pizzeria. The pizza is some of the best I've ever had. The crust isn't really thick or thin - just right. All the toppings I've tried were great. Honestly, I'm not sure what makes it taste so good. It just does. The owner and his staff are nice people. They keep an ever-changing selection of micro-brews and imports. And!! Last but not least.... they have the old skool table-top Ms. Pac Man. Beat that! Bottom line, if you're driving up Highway 57, pull of into little Random Lake for some great pizza. read more