Middleboro Pizza Pirate

We ordered pizza from Stoney's on a Friday night and was told the pizza would be ready in about 35…read moreminutes, which it was. We ordered cheese, pepperoni and chicken broccoli Alfredo pizza. All three were good, but I think the pepperoni was our favorite. We will likely order here again.

This is one of those places that has a unique style or pizza. This is a hole in the wall type of…read moreplace the locals know, but it is hidden out of the way. I recommend going in with an open mind and stepping outside your comfort zone of what you consider pizza. The food is prepared timely, and service is always friendly. Its Middleboro's own version of a townie "cheers". My recommendation is to try their pot roast pizza. It tastes great, and is a good change up from the usual. You won't be disappointed. Prices are fair and reasonable. I would recommend this place as the type of place to go when you want a cold beer, and you just got off of work and want to head out with the team.

2 cheese pizzas, pepperoni & onion and a bacon & tomato

Chicken Bacon

See all

Outside view of the memorial business

Central Cafe

3.6(94 reviews)

0.3 mi

Lacey hooked it up! She suggested a Strawberry banana lemonade drink that was super sweet and…read morerefreshing. Also, she sent us home with a few extra blue cheeses and was great to chat with. Thanks Lacey! Nestled on the outskirts of the downtown area. Small town charm inside. Felt like a typical New England breakfast place (the layout.) We went with the potato pie and the buffalo blue (of course laced and well done) Let me tell you- THE CRISP and flavor they get on their crust is what bad bar pie's dream to be! (Even as leftover's the crisp is where it's at.) Now I wish I had tried a traditional pie but I guess that's why we visit places we like twice! They serve hearty pies. Thick, filling. The potato pie... I like what's happening here but I feel like it needs some garlic in those potatoes and need to be mashed more. Kind of chunky. And a little cream helps. The Buffalo blue- this had to the best buffalo pizza I have ever had. Hear me out: I am not a huge buffalo sauce fan. Sometimes it can be too much for me. This was the perfect marriage of cheese to buffalo sauce that it's not overwhelming. Pro tip- dunk it in a little of their blue cheese.

For decades my husband and his family were loyal patrons of Middleboro's, most popular pizza…read morerestaurant, Central Cafe. However, for the past 2 to 3 years, whenever we've visited my husband's hometown, Central Cafe has not lived up to those glorious memories of family dining. In the past year on at least five separate occasions, we have had one bad experience after another ordering from Central Cafe. We've experienced burnt pizzas, stale sub sandwich bread, Caesar salad with NO Caesar dressing available (???), and now the latest order with French fries that tasted as if they'd been sitting in the car for a week!! On top of the downhill trajectory of Central Cafe's food quality, in the past 5 years, their prices have skyrocketed, with some menu items, like their "Meat Lovers" pizza increasing more than 50% in price! On top of the price changes, for more than a year, with their new menu prices in full effect, Central Cafe refused to supply menus to customers that requested them. When my husband asked for a new menu, he was told that they only had the laminated ones available to those ordering from inside the restaurant. On this last occasion, my husband planned to take a picture of the menu when he went to pick up our order, but he was told that "so many people complained that [they] brought [the paper menus] back". As if the doubly-priced subpar food wasn't enough of an insult to its legacy, Central Cafe charges an additional $3.00 "takeout fee", a hidden fee added to all takeout orders that nobody mentions until you question why your total is so high. And if you order "plain chicken fingers", an employee will kindly ask "mild or hot?" in reference to the buffalo sauce (that you did not order) that they charge an extra 75¢ for. For a burnt meatball sub in stale bread comes with soggy fries, an order of chicken fingers, and 2 orders of soggy sweet potato fries, the total of our takeout order was $55 and some change. After calling to confirm the order was correct, that is when we were able to take the 75¢ sauce off of the order, and I decided that $9.00 was just too much for sweet potato fries, especially once we realized they were stale and l most ikely reheated in a microwave. Needless to say, today's visit to Central Cafe is our last. Our previous visit would have been our last, but because of our last visit's lousy food, we were given a gift certificate for the next. In the end, the food we received today wasn't worth the money we paid even with the $25 gift certificate reduction off the total. Longtime patrons of Central Cafe are aging and I would be surprised if they are gaining any new ones. It's time to make a change or they are doomed to fail.

Greek chicken wrap with no chicken

See all

Strawberry banana lemonade

Pachinis Pizza

3.7(31 reviews)

0.1 mi

Food is always delicious, they also give you a pizza when you spend over 50 which I thought was coolread more

Pachinis, chinis, cheenieweenies. These are all the nicknames I call one of the best pizza places…read moreI've ever been to. Most pizza has ingredients you can decipher from each other. Cheens? Cheens is different. With Cheens the flavors all mix together to become heaven in ya mouth. The quintessential bite. I feel like if God made pizza; you could find it at pacheeniss. Dare I say Cheesus Christ? Probably shouldn't. It's bussin tho. You can tell the chefs know what they're doing because they don't say a word. They're too busy making an other worldly pie. I don't even want Dave portnoy to come here. What a true gem. Thank you Pachinis.

Back of menu

See all

Pizzaiolo Italian Eatery

4.4(80 reviews)

5.3 mi

Yesterday was my second time eating at Pizzaiolo... both times I got 2 slices of cheese pizza, and…read moreboth times it was superb! Friendly service too, and everything is hot and fresh! Thank you! -Greg in E. Weymouth

Great food, great place to have a cocktail, and the wait staff, bartenders and the owners wrap up…read morethe 5 stars. Great selections of scotches, whiskeys, and bourbons. Keep up the great work.

Chicken Marsala over capellini

See all

Buffalo chicken pizza

The Hideaway

3.4(48 reviews)

0.5 mi

Very cute place. The upstairs patio is very nice. There is a bar on both floors . There were 4 of…read moreus for dinner and drinks. Food was very good and reasonably priced. It's nice to have a restaurant with an outside dining area.

First time there ! It was great... service and food were great. Unfortunately they were out of the…read moreprime rib which was our dinner plans but we ordered the steak which was very good ! Definitely planning to return!

Phenomenally decorated ceiling

Greek salad with added salmon

See all

The Cabin

4.1(306 reviews)

1.5 mi

The Cabin in Middleboro holds a legendary status for a reason. I don't know what kind of magic they…read moreare working behind the scenes, but their cheese pizza is hands-down the best pizza I have ever had in my entire life. Whenever I come home to visit, stopping by isn't just an option--it is an absolute requirement. Even though I'm usually only home for about four days at a time, I end up eating there at least twice every single trip. It might sound like a lot, but once you taste it, you completely understand. The combination of their incredible, perfectly seasoned sauce and high-quality cheese creates a flavor profile that no one else can match. Couple that with their fire oven, which churns out an impeccably crispy, perfectly charred crust every single time, and you get pure perfection. They've been consistently serving up unbelievable food since I was a kid, and decades later, they still haven't missed a beat. If you haven't been, you're missing out!

We were greeted by John the owner he was very friendly and it's a bonus that the owner takes time…read moreto talk to new guests. They were four of us. One ordered the Reuben which got great marks. One ordered the fried clams which also got great marks. My son ordered the lobster roll which was lobster salad, not big pieces of fresh lobster but probably from a can. He enjoyed it anyway. I got the surf and turf and the steak tips were overdone and tough. The four shrimp I believe were already breaded frozen not fresh. Our waitress Amanda was very efficient and friendly without buzzing over the table. We also had nachos and stuffed potato skins and the bill for four was only 260. Will be a little bit more careful with the menu exploring different dishes next time but we will be back. Thank you John and Amanda

View of pizza oven from the bar

Fish

See all

Drink Menu

Smitty's Pub and Pizza

4.5(54 reviews)

10.0 mi

I was looking for something different today for my dad and my brother. I come across Smitty's pub…read moreand pizza so we gave it a try. Great selections of specialty pizzas. It was hard to choose. Since I live in CA now, I am drawn to the linguisa selections. Today, we got a taco pizza, the veggie pizza and the one resembling a Big Mac pizza. All were incredible! The place was busy and I see why. The pizza were the standard bar size (10 inch). On top of being so delicious, they were surprisingly hearty. We could only finish half. The owner served us and was very pleasant. Service was prompt and kept the drinks full. I would highly recommend take out or in restaurant, but it might be hard to find a seat for good reason. Great job, and a 5-star recommendation. We made sure the owner and the person who made our pizzas knew how we felt when we finished.

Still the best for local pizza IMO. Love the chicken wings and tenders. Small menu, but they do…read moreit very well. Great service and vibe!!

See all

Our takeout lineup! Pepperoni, sausage pep onion, chicken Mozambique, Big Mac!

Baldie's Craft Pizzeria

3.3(136 reviews)

1.7 mi

The best pizza in the area All wood fired pizza…read more Just a cool place to hang Great apps ..good food Wont break the bank

Great relaxed atmosphere with the best wood fired pizzas around. Music trivia bingo on Tuesday…read morenight added to the great family vibes. Ellie, our server, and Ryan, the bartender, made the experience even better!!

Pumpkin martini

Fried Crispy Chicken Sandwich

See all

Smash Burger

Fire & Stone Trattoria and Pizza Bar

4.5(97 reviews)

15.6 mi

Absolutely our favorite pizza! Hands down. Only take out..but it is always ready when we get there…read more It is always consistent. They use the finest ingredients. Pepperoni is to die for. Stuffed red peppers are delightful. Love, love, love this pizza.

Food is great. The pizza is fantastic great variety. The burgers are out of this world…read more Call your order in before you leave to pick it up. The place is busy.

MARGHERITA

Big Koa burger

See all

Harry's Bar and Grille

4.2(294 reviews)

2.1 mi

Harry's is wicked mental. This joint represents the apogee of the tavern bar n' grill experience…read more Virtually everything is mental here and on point from service, food, drinks, vibe, cleanliness, efficiency, etc. I wanna emphasize that normally I hhhh-h-haaaate the "tavern" scene but Harry's has no negatives AT ALL. Food is HOT n' FRESH AF. Everything is cooked to order and prices are wicked reasonable and there are specials to be had each day. The staff is VERY efficient and friendly as hell. Menu selection is diverse and best of all has no tree-hugger "healthy option" gluten-free vegan crap. This is serious food for level-three hangry eaters who welcome thunder thighs and kankles. The vibe is great and the wooden construction attenuates sound wicked good and makes it acoustically sensible. My One and I have been going here for quite some time. We have never had anything a SNAFU. Drinks are great and Devin was our waitress last night and she is absolutely wonderful. Be confident that the owners and staff clearly take pride in this establishment and always aim to please in all ways. The drink menu is fun and extensive with variants on margs and 'teenys, etc. All food and drinks are scrump AF. They also give you gigantor hot n' wet handcloth towels after the sowdown as the coup de gras. It's like being on JetBlue :) Peep it out! And yes, they have KEEN-O and scratch tix.

I frequently eat at this restaurant because it belongs to the Fischer family of restaurants, they…read morejust know what they're doing when it comes to pub food. Anything on the menu is good the staff is always on point and the bar is fun when you can get a seat. If you feel like grabbing something on a weekday or weekend you can't go wrong here. At Harry's the theme is planes. Get there early on a Tuesday and get the wings. They're huge and priced right. You won't be disappointed. I just like the atmosphere and feel of the place. Townie but friendly which makes it fun. Keep up the good work Fischer family. See you at the bar.

Airplane that where hanging from bar area

Onion rings

See all

Civil aircraft

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

6 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Sam M.

364

5

0

5 years ago

I called a week ahead to ask questions about their sheet pizzas and was told they didn't need any time upfront to order before. I called 24 hours in advance and paid ahead of time because I was ordering 3 sheet pizzas. I was told that my requested delivery time of 11:30-11:40a would work. At 11:55 I called because the pizza had not been delivered and I hadn't heard from them. They said it was on its way out. At 12:20 we still had not received the pizza or a phone call so I called back and was put on hold for over 5 mins before I hung up and called back. They told me the pizza was still sitting there. I had to send someone to go pickup the pizza. There was no sincere apology or even warning that the pizza would be late. We will not be ordering from here again. read more

Tim B.

0

1

0

10 years ago

My new favorite place! Visited the first day they opened and they did not disappoint! The pizza is great, tasty sauce, great crunch crust with more than enough toppings. Very pleased, will come back again! read more

Angela A.

74

2

1

6 years ago

First time ordering. Not impressed. This is a huge letdown after a 1 hour wait for delivery. Driver had us come out, long wait, insufficient substance. Won't be ordering again :( read more

Donna V.

0

6

0

10 years ago

Pizza was tasty and salad was fresh! Restaurant was clean. I will return next time I'm in the area.

Ben J.

0

2

1

2 years ago

Where is the pirate i wanted a pirate i was promised a pirate with PIZZA what rven is this

Oh M.

0

1

0

8 years ago

ordered a Honey Dijon roll up and there was barely any honey dijon

Middleboro Pizza Pirate - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Middleboro Pizza Pirate also viewed

Santoros Pizza & Subs

3.8

(39 reviews)

My pickup order was ready on time, but the taste of my sub sandwich was not at all good. This was…read moremy first time there and I see no reason to ever go back.

Great service and food is great. Cheese pizza one of the cheapest around at only 14 dollars for a…read morelarge. Also my favorite pizza. The employees are awesome and down to earth and owners are even better. My wife loves the manicotti from there and salads are great as well.

Christo’s Royal Pizza

3.3

(32 reviews)

Saw Christos ad for his Greek salad pizza with chicken, but we decided to switch it up and go with…read morelamb (gyro) instead...and wow, SO glad we did! Absolutely delicious. He even gave us his cucumber sauce to drizzle on top, which was a perfect compliment. I liked that it was just a really different type of pizza. My husband and I were seriously impressed....this pizza was loaded with toppings (they definitely don't skimp!). I've been trying to eat healthier, and this totally hit the mark while still feeling like a treat. We'll 100% be ordering this again. Thank you, Christos Royal Pizzas Lakeville! Wish I had taken a pic before we dug in!!!!

Great place! We love the Italian & Chicken Parm subs. Always great service and nice people.read more

Pizza Tyme

4.0

(73 reviews)

Great food Love there bar style pies Buffalo chicken is the…read morebest with ranch and blue cheese sauce

No frills place. There are three tables inside if you choose to eat in…read more Folks are super friendly here. Steady stream of take out as we ate. Pizza was very good bar pizza. Nice crust and good flavor. We got a few apps- wing sings and onion rings. Very good. Took about 25 minutes for the pizza. They come in own size- but very well and tasty. The price was around $12-13 for a pizza but in this day and age you'd pay that at McDonald's- and it was so much better!!

Tomato And Basil

3.1

(28 reviews)

food was cold and really not appetizing. place is run down and filthy. Guys working there seemed ok…read morebut they definetly need a cleaner. wood on steps is dry rotted so be careful walking.

I haven't been here since the place opened 3 years ago- we live 5 minutes away, but our first two…read moretimes were not good experiences (I always give a new place a second chance). Came back today for lunch as I've seen some positive feedback on facebook. I am glad we did. Fish and chips were fantastic. We both got fish and chips. It was really fresh fish- I asked and they said the seafood is all fresh and they get delivery 3 times a week. It's a order at the counter type of place- no wait staff. That's fine. There is a bar but doesn't appear to be open anymore. Food is really good. The next test will be the pizza... we will defiantly be back to try that so stay tuned....

Buddy's Union Villa

3.7

(113 reviews)

Excellent bar pizza, Greek salads were large with fresh ingredients. Feta and grilled chicken was…read moregreat. Dressing is a little different than traditional Greek dressing. Plenty of booths and tables, large bar as well. Servers are nice and orders get to the table quick.

STILL one of the top 5 places for excellent bar pizza…read more Every time I get to go back to my hometown I remember how lucky I am growing up eating Buddys pizza. Mmmmm

South Meadow Pizza

3.4

(12 reviews)

The pizza is my number one favorite. It's always so fragrant and delicious. I've got some now!…read moreTheir Greek Salad is the best too

Love this place. Great Greek style pizza. Great sandwiches…read moreand salads too Highly recommended

Whittenton House of Pizza

3.7

(30 reviews)

Great place for Greek style pan pizza and fries. Been going here off and on over 22 years and…read morealways good quality

Be careful of pizza cook. Good food and usually great service but (owner) with mustache can be very…read morerude. I've limited my business because of him. Lots of people left here so ask for well done or you can possibly get a pizza looking like a crime scene with cheese everywhere. Guessing the training isn't the best.

Cappy's House of Pizza

3.3

(33 reviews)

Fantastic food! Pizza is delicious and the staff are always friendly. Hidden gem for sure. A…read moremust try and definitely check out their speciality pizzas!

We ordered for the first time. The pizza was delicious! The service was great. We will be back.read more

A3

3.8

(114 reviews)

Everything went well, I got the "angry pizza". It tasted very well. The bussers were very…read moreattentive, giving constant water refills. Service was also exception

The food is great, particularly the pizza,- if you can get it. Several times, the last one on a…read moreThursday night at 730pm, they were "out of pizza". I'm sorry but I just don't get that. Parking is tough also.

Marc Anthony's La Pizzeria

3.3

(323 reviews)