Tiffany makes the best OREO cake! Ever since we sampled her cake at a wedding vendor event, we knew we had to hire her to do our wedding cake. She created a beautiful 3-tiered cake with oreo and strawberry flavors for our big day. The guests were so impressed by how delicious the cake tasted! read more

MiGoodies BakeSale - a white wedding cake with flowers - Bakeries Near Me

See all

With Shelter In Place I needed my sweet tooth craving to be fulfilled. I follow Tiffany on Instagram and i saw she had cookie dough for sale. I had to give in! She delivered it straight to my door and was super accommodating to my hours. She was also super responsive to my questions and included instructions on how to bake the cookies. The cookies smelled so delicious when it was baking and it came out so beautiful! i love how it had just the right amount of chocolate in it and it wasn't too sweet. I will definitely order again! Thank you Tiffany! read more

See all

We were so glad to find Tiffany and MiGoodies BakeSale. We tried various Bay Area cake vendors and all were either too sweet, too pricy, or apparently too good to respond back to. Her tasting box was delicious and the flexibility in mix and matching cake and filling flavors were great. Tiffany is very creative, talented, and honest. My husband and I are indecisive people, so it was great getting her honest feedback and clarifying questions to make sure every detail was on point. She pretty much created the ultimate wedding cake to the point where we got compliments the entire night on how gorgeous it was AND it tasted great too! Our guests were so surprised how delicious the cake was to the point that people were making it a mission to try all 3 of the flavors we chose. If you're on the fence about having a wedding cake because you see all those posts on how guests don't like cake or that it's a waste of money...then you're missing out if you don't choose Tiffany aka MiGoodies Bakesale read more

MiGoodies BakeSale - a wedding cake with roses - Bakeries Near Me

Tiffany baked the cake and cupcakes for our wedding over the summer, and they turned out great. She makes everything from scratch and doesn't add artificial ingredients, so the final product is high quality. Her decorations on the cake were meticulous, and the cupcakes were simple but cute. Note that she doesn't work with fondant, only buttercream, so certain kinds of decorations aren't really possible. For example, we wanted to do ruffles with an ombré color scheme on the cake, but those are both difficult with buttercream. So she essentially did a few different shades and then did her best to blend them at the edges, and we skipped the ruffles and went with a gold stencil instead. She was able to do a faux tier for us as well, so we had two real tiers plus one faux tier. We also added flowers from our florist and a cake topper that we made ourselves from polymer clay. Due to the pandemic, we needed to pick up a to-go box for our tasting, which cost $50 and unfortunately didn't apply to our final balance (unlike most of the other bakers we considered). The box included 8 flavors, including a variety of classics as well as a few less traditional options. Many of the samples tasted great, but a few seemed like the recipe needed a bit of tweaking. We ended up choosing one flavor per cake tier plus 3 flavors for the cupcakes. Our package also includes a 5" anniversary cake that we're looking forward to enjoying next summer! Overall, Tiffany does a good job and we would recommend her. She is very detail-oriented and professional and is quite good at baking and decorating. read more

See all

We selected Tiffany to bake the cake for our wedding and were very pleased with result. We had a consultation with her where we sampled the cakes and they were all delicious. In the end we selected a three tier with two layers being lemon and one being strawberry. We liked that her cakes were different than your typical wedding cake and were also not overly sweet. On the day of the wedding Tiffany dropped off the cake and worked with our florist for flower arrangements, and setting up our cake topper. She did the decorations herself and it turned out beautifully. The cake was delicious and many guests complimented us on it. Our only regret is that we wish we got more, so we could keep the top! read more

Tiffany did an absolutely wonderful job on our wedding cake. It was so gorgeous and tasted amazing! Our guests were impressed and so was my hubby. She even added some real roses to match my bouquet which made for some fantastic photos. I can't recommend her enough to other brides looking for a truly beautiful and delicious cake for their big day. read more

MiGoodies BakeSale - Gorgeous!! - Bakeries Near Me

See all

Ordered a custom 2 tier CoCo cake for my sons first birthday party. Oreo flavor was so good last time we decided to go with it again. Everything was perfect! Cake was ready right on time, no hiccups at all. I still swear by her beautiful and tasty cakes. read more

MiGoodies BakeSale - Bakeries Near Me

First off, I may be biased because I went to elementary school with the "Head" baker. However, the fact that I cheated on my 7 week transformation program for a few days because I couldn't get enough of my cake. It was a process of creating a design and selecting the flavors. It came out great. Pistachio is my favorite and although she never made one before, it was mouth watering. I tried the other layer, oreo cookie, and I had a hard time of deciding which i loved the best. Maybe next time we can just combine them so I can have all the sweet goodness in one bite. The design was more than I had hoped as far as the design. Its inexpiable when your imagination is brought to life and is beyond you expectations. Thanks Tiff, our family has a few "BIg" bday's this year and if I say so myself...You Are Booked!!!!! read more

MiGoodies BakeSale - Top layer is Pistashio, butter cream with gold leaf detail. Bottom is oreo cookie with black fondant ruffles and a wafer paper flower. - Bakeries Near Me

Best cake ever!! The owner is so kind and very accommodating. She fulfilled all the request for my order. The Oreo cake is like none other! Folks were blown away and fighting over the last slice. Made with the very best ingredients. Worth every dollar spent. They only regret was not ordering a larger cake. read more

MiGoodies BakeSale - The inside details of the Oreo Cake! - Bakeries Near Me

See all

We thought we didn't want cake at our wedding, but changed our minds a few weeks before the big day. Tiffany was very accommodating and was able to make the photo ideas I sent come to life on short notice. Everyone raved about the red velvet and Oreo cakes she made. She even delivered an anniversary cake a year later, which was a very thoughtful touch. Highly recommended and easy to work with! read more

See all

Let me just start with saying the lemon bars are AMAZINGLY DELICIOUS!!!! Hands down the best lemon bars I've had in my life!!!!! They taste so refreshing and sweet! I have been craving lemon bars during quarantine but I didn't know any places that make good ones, the ones I've had in the past are whatever so I went on yelp and typed "best lemon bars near me" and thankfully MiGoodies BakeSale was the first thing that popped up for me. I went to check out her ig page and to my surprise tons of my friends on instagram followed her. So I reached out and placed my order through email! Since this craving was so spontaneous I wasn't really expecting to be able to get an order this week but Tiffany worked her magic and was able to have an order of this delicious lemon bars ready for me by today when I placed the order on Tuesday! I went to pick them up and zoomed home so I could get a taste already and they are the best lemon bars! They were sooooooo good and lemony! (Is that a word) anyways So happy I placed this order and will definitely be ordering more in the future! read more

MiGoodies BakeSale - Lemon Bars - Bakeries Near Me

Tiffany's treats are the best! I've ordered from her several times - a baby shower cake and cupcakes, dessert catering for 50+ people and most recently, quarantine cookies! She is really talented and everything she makes is DELICIOUS! read more

See all

I use MiGoodies for all my baking needs. The Nutella cupcakes are the best I've ever had! The German chocolate cake was not too rich and I loved the chunky pecans in the frosting. But I think the pecan bars are still my favorite. read more

MiGoodies BakeSale - German Chocolate Cake - Bakeries Near Me

Nothing but good things to say about Tiffany and MiGoodies Bake Sale! Ordering was easy. No fuss. She made a minimalist, elegant chocolate birthday cake with edible gold accent that was as delicious as it looked. We will definitely request an order again in the future! read more

The oreo cake I ordered was delicious. She did everything I wanted, I showed her a picture and it turned out great. I would definitely order from her again. read more

MiGoodies BakeSale - Bakeries Near Me

delicious cookies! Only 1 dollar each and pretty decent size! I used tiffany for my wedding and didn't regret it. It was only $108 for 108 cookies plus $1 per sample cookie. I had 6 samples. (FYI they charge for samples so be mindful of what you try. They are not free) read more

Everything about this business is amazing. Tiffany is a true master at what she does. Everything was smooth from placing the order to choosing flavors to pick up and finally showing off the master piece and tasting it. Never disappointed. Customer service: 5 stars Appearance: 5 stars Taste: 5 stars We had nutella, carrot cake, red velvet, and coconut cupcakes The cake was a banana cake with chocolate ganache caramel drizzle and vanilla meringue. read more

MiGoodies BakeSale - Bakeries Near Me

I had a great experience working with Tiffany. We wanted a simple and small cake for a cake-cutting ceremony at our wedding and Tiffany did a fantastic job! Her cake was delicious, decorated beautifully with fresh flowers and delivered on time to the restaurant with no issues. I highly recommend her services! read more

The first person I thought of to make my sons 2 year old birthday cake was Tiffany of Migoodies. I showed her a picture of exactly what I wanted and she made it even more beautiful than I expected. Best part is, not only did it look cute and very professionally put together, it tasted great! She delivered in a very timely manner on the day of the party. It was a big focus of the party for sure. Didn't want to cut into it. But I'm glad i did. Highly recommend! I totally trust her with flavor recommendations. We had a vanilla Oreo buttercream cake. Now I have to find another occasion to order from Migoodies! read more

MiGoodies BakeSale - Bakeries Near Me

See all

Tiffany is wonderful and easy too work with. We found her on Yelp for our wedding cake and scheduled a tasting. We tried her lemon cake, chocolate genache, and strawberry cake - we went with the lemon. They were all so good! We went over details of the wedding day and she was so patient answering our questions. She was fast at responding to emails and made suggestions for adding her pretty wafer flowers and making a little base for our cake topper. The day of went by so fast. I saw her for a split second setting up our cake while we were getting family photos done. Next thing you know I turnaround and the finished cake was perfect - simple and elegant with our Lego cake topper. I had signed up for her newsletter and received one announcing pies!! We ordered a pecan pie and an apple pie and coordinated pick ups instead of delivery. The crust on the apple pie was my favorite. read more

Tiffany is the BEST! I've gotten 2 cakes made by her so far and both a success! A SnickerDoodle Cake w Cream Cheese Frosting and Pirouettes. The second cake was a Nutella Cake w Fresh Strawberries inside & Strawberry Macaroons on top!! She has been so open and helpful to my ideas and last but not least PATIENT!! My new go-to gal for cakes!!!! read more

MiGoodies BakeSale - My SnickerDoodle Birthday Cake w Cream Cheese Frosting & Hazelnut Pirouettes! Was sooooo good!!! - Bakeries Near Me

See all

When I started looking for a place to make my gender reveal cake I researched a bunch of bakeries all around the Bay Area. I am so glad I found Tiffany. She is super sweet and professional and was always very prompt when responding to all of my questions and concerns. Not only that, I paid only half of what I was quoted by some other bakeries. I ordered an 8" round Oreo cake which was really yummy (especially the thick layer of Oreo chocolatiness in the middle). It was a huge hit with everyone and really made the big reveal special. I was a little worried that an 8" cake wouldn't be enough for everyone at the party but it actually ended up being way more than enough since it was so tall. I will definitely be coming back again. Thanks Tiffany!!! read more

MiGoodies BakeSale - 8" Oreo Gender Reveal Cake - Bakeries Near Me

See all

We ordered our wedding cake from MiGoodies BakeSale and we are so glad that we did! When we did our cake tasting with Tiffany, it was clear that whatever we ordered would be absolutely delicious (and it was!) We couldn't decide between red velvet with cream cheese filling and vanilla cake with raspberry filling, so Tiffany designed a cake that included both. Tiffany was super responsive leading up to the wedding (even when I was distracted by other wedding planning and life in general!) Closer to the wedding, Tiffany worked directly with our florist to incorporate some of the same flowers used in my bouquet to decorate our cake. The result a cake that beautifully fit with our romantic, outdoor theme and was delicious to boot (kid and adult approved!) Tiffany even had a beautiful wooden cake stand that we were able to rent to display our beautiful cake in style in a way that was consistent with our other decor. I couldn't be happier with our cake and all of Tiffany's help leading up to our big day! Thank you so much!!! read more

All I can say, is Tiffany has the golden touch when it comes to her goodies! Have ordered the Oreo cake, triple chocolate cake, strawberry cake, and pecan tart, all were deliciously whimsical! Definitely will be a loyal customer for life. You have to try her baked goods, she won't disappoint. read more

See all

I LOVE MiGoodies! Pie are maybe my favorite food group. I had Tiffany's peach and apple pies, and they're kind of perfect. The crust has a nice texture and some browning on top (I don't like overly soft crusts). And her fruit is perfectly cooked with the right amount of sweetness. I wish I could eat them everyday! All my family members are getting Birthday Pies now instead of Birthday Cakes. All day everyday! So yummy! read more

The homemade touch makes it all the better! I first had MiGoodies before she made this a career. From the cookies to cupcakes, cakes to cheesecake I have yet to be disappointed! I ordered coconut cupcakes for my birthday which she delivered to the venue and then I ordered caramel cheesecake to me for Easter! She's my go to for all my baking needs! read more

Tiffany's custom cakes are delicious as they are imaginative. She was able to accommodate my request a week and half before my son's bday for a thomas themed cake when no one else was able to! read more

MiGoodies BakeSale - Thomas the train themed cake - Bakeries Near Me

See all

The sportsthemed cake I ordered for my 2 year old son turned out amazing! Originally I wanted an all fondant cake, but the buttercream was just as eye catching and beautiful. I loved the design, it was exactly like the ideas I showed her. The cookies and cream/Oreo flavor center was the best I've had anywhere. The cake was moist and soo delicious! Ordering was an easy process, I received quick responses and overall Tiffany was very friendly, she showed confidence and assured me that she could make the cake I wanted. I would order again from her! read more

MiGoodies BakeSale - Bakeries Near Me

Omg, Tiffany's cake is one of the best cakes I have ever had. Ever. (And I have told her multiple times now haha) Tiffany is quick and prompt in response and very willing to listen to your ideas and work with them. I saw on her instagram that she had a green tea cake and my family/friends LOVES green tea! She gave me different options for frostings for the cake and in the end, we opted for vanilla buttercream. The cake is AMAZING. It's dense (just how we like it) but not overpowering or heavy and most importantly, so full of flavor. Each bite was a little piece of green tea heaven. She also added a little matcha green tea powder on the outside of the cake, which added a little oomph to the flavor of each bite we had with the buttercream outside. Too perfect! She also delivered the cake and texted me when she was on her way. It was so easy to work with her and I can't wait to have another cake of hers (which btw, will be VERY soon). Definitely try MiGoodies, you won't regret it!! read more

I really wanted to update my review and add my 2 cents about my favorite item from MiGoodies. My ALL time favorite is the French Toast Bacon Cupcake. What a great treat. Each bite tastes like French toast with bacon. The icing is not too sweet and does not steal the show. There is bacon in the cupcake as well as on top. You can't go wrong with this unique flavor combo! read more

We used migoodies for our wedding dessert bar. Tiffany made us mini apple pies, black bottom cupcakes, sweet potato tarts, and allergy free Rice Krispies. The desserts were amazing and a big hit for all of our guests. Tiffany made our day stress free- everything was delivered on time and she worked well with our coordinator. We will definitely continue to use Tiffany for our events!!! read more

MiGoodies BakeSale - Bakeries Near Me

I hired MiGoodies to make our wedding cake and cupcakes and I cannot say enough good things about my experience. I found MiGoodies after the first baker I contacted dropped our very mediocre wedding cake tasting off a day late. After that experience, I was feeling pretty down about wedding cakes, until Tiffany came to do our tasting. She brought three amazing mini cakes to our home and gave us the royal treatment while we tried them. They were all so delicious we couldn't pick just one, so we ordered cupcakes to get all three flavors (carrot, red velvet, and Oreo). Things only got better on wedding day. I'll let my photos speak for themselves on the beauty of the desserts, but I'll just add that while at most weddings, eating the cake tends to be the least exciting part of the reception, our guests gobbled all of ours up. Gorgeous, delicious, and amazing service. What more could you want? read more

See all

Ordered a custom made (wolverine theme) cake from Tiffany! Best cake ever! Superb customer service. My son was very happy to see his cake! Definitely recommend. read more

MiGoodies BakeSale - Bakeries Near Me

See all

We booked Tiffany for our engagement party and she did amazing!!! She is so easy to work with and very professional. I emailed her with an inquiry for cake and cupcakes and she responded the same day. I wasn't sure exactly how much or what type of cake I was looking for, so Tiffany was very helpful with providing direction and ideas. For design, I sent her the theme colors for the party and a few cake designs and let her customize the cake and she did not disappoint! The cake was beautiful and delicious! All our guests loved it to the point where only a few slices of the three tier cake were left and all the cupcakes were gone. Do yourself a favor and book her for your next event! You will not be disappointed! read more

Tiffany was outstanding! Not only was our wedding cake everything we asked for, but it was so yummy! The design was made exactly as we had requested and delivery was on time and everything was structured beautifully with the layout of the flowers as well. Thank you again for everything! read more

Loved the cake we had made for my nephew's birthday! We actually picked up the cake because we were heading an hour away so delivery was not necessary. The taste was the best part of the cake (oreo!) and my 1 year old nephew LOVED his name written on it. My only slight concern was we ordered the largest size and the box it came in barely fit the cake. By the time my husband got home from picking up (5 miles away), the letters had smeared because the upper inside flap of the box rubbed with the top of the cake a good deal. Kind of a bummer but luckily I was able to fix it to some extent. All in all, I would definitely order from her again. Great customer service, fantastic flavor and beautiful design. read more

MiGoodies AMAZING! I used them for two separate events in one week. First, she baked the most beautiful and delicious German chocolate cake for the hubs' 40th birthday party. Sadly, I don't eat coconut, but when I heard everyone raving about it, I knew I had to order again for my besties baby shower. I ordered one dozen red velvet cupcakes and one dozen vanilla cupcakes with strawberry buttercream frosting. The red velvet were so delicious, but the vanilla with strawberry buttercream were INCREDIBLE. I'm pretty sure Tiffany uses fresh strawberries for the buttercream. The cupcakes were perfectly decorated for the baby shower. Both orders were very reasonably priced and Tiffany was so accommodating with pick up times. I highly recommend using MiGoodies for your baked goods! You won't regret it! read more

I tried MiGoodies numerous times and never had the opportunity to share how yummy their baked goods are. We had the delicious fresh apple pie over Thanksgiving and it was a hit. Lots of fresh apples! I ordered over a dozen lemon bars for Mother's day, and it was moist and had just the right amount of tartness. For my son's high school graduation party, MiGoodies packaged giveaway party favors that consisted of 3 cookies in a clear cellophane bag. They were mint chocolate chip cookies- my son's favorite. Not only were the cookies delicious, but Tiffany went the extra step and printed labels and tied each packet with ribbons of my son's school color. Wow, that's what i call service! I didn't have to worry about party favors and who can resist fresh baked goods. Not only are her baked goods delicious but Tiffany is so personable , flexible , creative and easy to work with . Most importantly, her goods are always delivered when and as promised. read more

What a fantastic local bakery! I ordered an apple and a pumpkin pie for Thanksgiving, and both exceeded my expectations. It's hard to believe that such a talented baker is also such a friendly, organized business owner. I am very picky about pies. The crust needs to be flaky and light without being over-baked. The filling needs to be the perfect combo of sweet and flavorful. The pie filling also needs to be moist without making the crust too mushy. These pies fit the bill! The crust is some of the best I've tasted, the filling flavor and texture was excellent, and the pies looked as lovely as the photos on Yelp. I was very impressed that Tiffany delivered the pies to my home in Redwood City the night before Thanksgiving (at no extra cost). She was also very clear about how her business operates, so it was easy to make the order and pay her online. MiGoodies clearly sells a wide variety of baked goods, so I can't wait for an excuse to try another delicious and beautiful item. Thank you, Tiffany! read more

We ordered a cookies and cream birthday cake for a large party and it was three layer of perfection. So delicious and well crafted. Yum. Better than any bakery that I know of. I'd definitely order again. read more