No complaints. It's always top shelf. The food. The service. The atmosphere. Love it! You can't go wrong with any menu item. All appetizers are a must try. If I need something from my childhood, the now "humble" hand grenade is a personal fav. Jackie's Favorite is one of my favorites also. If you're in the mood for a thick steak, please, come sit down. And to my friends that like to seafood and then to eat it and yes, I said that on purpose, then you must come try this place. read more

Well we are in from Illinois for work with a major corporation and decided to try this place out! Let's just say 15 minutes of the 4 of us sitting at a bar without taking our order for drinks. When the bartender showed up she took our order and another 10 MINUTES GOES BY. We got up and left. With our 14 crews of 150 employees they will know NOT TO GO TO THIS DIVE! Work customer service ever in 43 states . They were NOT BUSY AT ALL! 2 other waitresses just stared at us! Epic failure!! read more

I have never had a bad meal at Mike's. Lunch was Fish and Fries basket. The Panko crusted Cod was light and not greasy at all. The fish was tender and flavorful. Great French fries!! The Geman Chocolate Pie was Fabulous!! read more

Mikes Penn Avenue Grille - German Chocolate Pie was rich and delicious. - Seafood Near Me - Salem, Ohio

Every time I go to lunch or dinner at Mikes it's always delicious! I've tried many menu items and nothing has disappointed. The staff are awesome and always treat you like family. Wait times are rarely an issue and food is brought out quick. They have daily lunch and dinner specials that can be found on their Facebook page everyday. Mikes is a must stop if you are in town and looking for good food at a very fair price. Highly recommend! read more

Food was horrible, the appetizer we ordered was the most disgusting thing I've ever been served. Which I noticed isn't even on the menu anymore. read more

What happened to my old review and pictures? Is this one of those Yelp issues where a single restaurant has multiple entries? Oh well... Stopped in for lunch, I got the beer battered cod. It was excellent. Fries were homemade, the cod was freshly battered. But, was not beer batter as I am used to having. Was more a thin batter. But it came out hot and good. Tossed in a pic. I really love their prime rib. They do that Friday and Saturday. Used to have it Sunday too, hadn't been here in awhile, but menu said prime rib Friday and Saturday. Wife had some lunch special. Baked fish on home fries with a raspberry vinaigrette. It was ok. She liked it. I said "eh". I have never been disappointed by the food at Mikes PENN Grille. Always good, sometimes exceptional. Beats heck out of that place down the street... read more

Mikes Penn Avenue Grille - Beer battered fish. It was very good. - Seafood Near Me - Salem, Ohio

I was craving a steak salad, and it was the best in town. I would recommend this place to anyone.

Food & service are both over the top. Great menu selection too! If anyone has never been there you need to go!

Had a carry out order with 2 items. The grilled chicken salad was missing items which were stated. Called & left message for the manager to call. She texted back & was going to call but never did. No resolution in the situation. read more

We've been going here for as long as I can remember, and it's a definite go to. The peppers in oil are the absolute best I've ever had. I wish they'd sell them!!! Everything else is always delicious. You won't be disappointed, give them a try. read more

I can not wait until this restaurant opens back up!! The food is consistently delicious and the specials are always great! If Mike is working he is great with gluten free suggestions! read more

Probably the worst meal I did not eat. The Italian sampler is frozen fried food at best. I had a sirloin and scallops. The meat was overcooked and tasted old, didn't eat it. My son had the Rib eye which was so undercooked it was uneatable. The Walley fish was an appetizer size, the scallop's were eatable. The wait was forever and the waitress didn't even bother to ask why both meats sat on the plate. Never again! read more

After hearing great things about their steak salads, we decided to try. We got our salads and are very surprised at how small they were. The dressings were fantastic. But we did have to ask for a side of bread because the small salads, intended as meals, were not satisfying. Really sorry for the 2 star. Staff was friendly and helpful. But very disappointed in portion size. read more

1st time stop. We had great steaks, scallops and shrimp. Everything grilled perfect. Salad greens had a home grown flavor and asparagus tender. read more

First time there in almost 5 years! I ordered ribeye topped with crab meat (fake Krab). First off, I wasn't told the krab meat was fake, then we ordered scallop appetizer that were terribly cleaned, sand still in scallops! My ribeye was cut up, almost like roast beef.... the only reason I'm giving 2 stars is because our waiter was good! read more

Good food. Had a nice evening with my gf. She had a Reuben and onion rings. I got chicken tenders with poppy seed sweet and sour sauce.

Menu looked great. Prices kinda high but it seems to specialize in steaks and seafood. Red headed bartender was a sweet heart. That's the good. Today was my first time there. Place was warm. Had two window AC units that weren't helping much. Only had a few Coke's and the fried greens and that was all I could order. The digestive discomfort almost started immediately after taking a bite of the greens. Did not finish them. Sat there with friends watching World Cup finale just praying for it to end fast. Hint, soccer does not end fast. By the time I made it home the level of discomfort was a ten. After about 40 minutes of throne time I felt some relief. I tried getting some gardening done, Unfortunately it was short lived as the discomfort returned. I ignored it too long this time and did not make it to the throne room in time. So to wrap it up, I feel like Mike owes me new shorts. read more

Mike's was recommended to us and we drove along ways to get there. Sadly we were pretty disappointed. The menu looked good but didn't pay off. We waited forever to get served 40 minutes. We ordered our dinners including a salad for my husband and soup for me which should have come out before the dinner. Instead they came with our dinners. The wedding soup was pretty awful. Very very salty and much too thick for a wedding soup. I ordered the stuffed ribeye. The ribeye was extremely fatty and part of it was raw even though I requested medium well. I'm not sure what was in the crab topping. The taste was decent but I suspect it was a lot of stuffing and little crab. My baked potato was small and gummy I'm pretty certain it was cooked in the microwave. I sent the first one back and the second one wasn't much better. Didn't have the flavor of a good baked potato. We ordered a red velvet cheesecake which was in fact a red velvet cake with cream cheese topping. It was tasty but not what it was listed to be. Disappointed that we can't give a bravo review! We were hoping this might be one of our newFavorite getaway restaurants read more

Well..... no bueno. Food not worth . Took very very long 2 1/2 hours. Comes in courses. You know , salad, main coarse , then my side never came with fish. Um. We where in a group but........ my wife and daughters fish where sub par. First yelp post ever and unfortunately was not because of an awesome service or food. read more