Cash only. Good sandwiches but a little pricey. God forbid you ask for a substitution or want to omit something from the sandwich that you order! Not only do you get "a look" but you might just get a grumbled comment that you can't understand! It's convenient for me to come here but it isn't my favorite. read more

Great food always made fresh and nice and friendly staff. Food is always consistent and have never gotten a bad sandwich from there

This is my favorite sandwich shop!!! Has simply the basics, which is exactly what I need. Cold cuts are freshly cut in front of you. Bread and fixins are all fresh. Quick service. Just a heads up, its cash only. Stop by grab lunch /dinner then walk a block over and have some ice cream at uncle Louis. read more

Always fresh and staff is friendly. Subs are amazing highly recommend any sub on the menu .

I am specifically talking about Mike's Subway shop just off of Route 35 and New Monmouth Road I went there one time and it was my last first of all there's an older woman with manly features who is short on patience very sarcastic very disparaging and definitely not customer and definitely not customer friendly I went there for first time so naturally I was unfamiliar with the menu when I asked for a moment to familiarize myself with the menu she became irritated and suggested after I made one change on my order that I was killing besides that I felt they were overpriced and h e r e o s we're not put together with much effort interest rather they we're quickly thrown together wrapped up and tossed as opposed to placed in the bag I definitely do not feel the two Heroes and drinks were worth 23 dollars read more

Pretty much your average sub shop. I will say it's super clean and everyone is very friendly. Overall, you can get a good sub there, but it's not anything different that another shop or chain can't match. The bread is good, light and airy, but definitely not made in house and lacked that crunch I was looking for. The meats are good, but they're prepackaged meats, I ordered a roast beef sub and expected/hoped for a homemade roast beef to get sliced up. Cheese options were limited, where's the fresh mooozzzzarella? Fixens are as expected, would have liked yellow banana peppers though. Its a Keyport staple though and I admire anyone that weathered the Sandy Superstorm. read more

The carnivore deep down inside of me, well not that deep down inside is always lurking right around meal time. If you have the same issue come & have it satiated at this sub shop. Sometimes there is just nothing like a good fresh sub to hit the spot especially when you're in need of a quick bite. Mike's is a small family run joint here in Keyport right on the water. Limited seating about 6 small 4 tops. Basic Italian style sub's with most of the ingredients you'd expect from a sub shop and perhaps a little bit less variety unfortunately that you'd expect from a specialty deli. Limited drink options. The "Super" crams 5 different Italian meats on a freshly baked sub roll (only white) along with basic cheese choice, lettuce, tomato, onion and spices. "Oh me amore ma ma," you've died and gone to sub heaven @ $14 for a whole. Not cheap, but not outlandish for a well packed meal. Friendly personable lightning fast service. Clean no frills dining as expected and only inside seating, but you can grab a sammich and walk over to the pier or the many benches upon the water front. Watch the boats come in or catch a few rays or drop a fishing line in while you dine. Located tactfully at the edge of town a walk about to burn some of the calories is always a great idea as well. Cash only, so don't forget to bring some loot. read more

I must say I love their sandwiches. All fresh bread and great service lots of laughs and they pile it on I split a half with my woman. I love the number 3 it's an Italian and the hot peppers are just hot enough but won't burn your mouth. I highly recommend grabbing a sub and sitting by the water and watch the boats. They are closed on Mondays but we all need a break sometime. read more

Not from the area but I was recommended to stop by Mike's Sub Shop if I was looking for a sandwich. I got a pastrami with cheese and onions with peppers and mustard. The sandwich was a little underwhelming, I ask for it hot and it was cold. I never ate a pastrami sandwich cold so it was different for me but it was still pretty good. The real winner for me at this place was the customer service. The whole staff was very friendly and attentive. If it wasn't for the small hiccup on the sandwich this place would be 5 stars! read more

I always get a hankering for this place anytime I'm in keyport. No other sub shop compares in my opinion. The bread! The perfectly thin sliced meats/cheeses! The hot peppers! The sweet peppers! The pickles! The Snapple pink lemonade that I can't find anywhere else! This place is just solid every time, friendly staff, with a quality and care for their product. read more

Great Deli, clean very well lit atmosphere. I have much respect for establishment that has wheel chair access . Now let's talk about the food I ordered a whole sandwich turkey and roast beef it was phenomenal, staff moved quickly and they were pleasant, can't wait to go back to try something else. read more

Better than average subs. There is always a crowd at lunch time which indicates that it is a good quality product/value. The bread is always very fresh I'm partial to the roast beef with lettuce and tomato. Enjoy read more

Best subs around. Bread is perfect!!! You will never find a stale hero roll from here. All the employees there are wonderful to talk with. read more

Best subs anywhere. Keep it simple. Keep it consistent. And focus on what you're good at. Yes, the menu is limited. That's part of their success/secret. They 've been here for something like 50 years. Same owners! If you want a lot of variety, go to a diner. Just about everyone has heard of Whitehouse Subs in AC. Every time I've been there, there's a frigging waiting line out the door. Not knocking them mind you, they're good, but this place has better subs -hands down. read more

Was looking forward to first visit here today but they are closed until Feb 20th. The three other people trying to get subs at the same time as me were as disappointed as I was. One even said that just ruined my day lol. I'll be back. Leaving 3 stars because neither 1 or 5 is fair at this point. read more

Best subs around and extremely friendly staff! My boyfriend and I go here every time we go crabbing off the pier.

Mmmm Mmmm Mmmm. My parents frequent this business but it was my first time. I went with my parents and shared an egg salad sub with my mom. They only had whole wheat bread this day which was perfectly fine for me. The sub was huge and we definitely could have split and half sub instead of the whole. The bread was so soft and the egg salad was just right with tomatoes, onions and lettuce. We placed the order, picked it up and say at a picnic table right down by the water. Weather was perfect for outside eating with a little breeze. I can't comment on the inside of Mike's because I have not been inside. My dad ran in to pick it up, but I would love to try this place again!! read more

Always good, super fresh. This is your classic sub shop, not a lot of options as toppings but this place has everything you need for a fresh sub. Cash only but there's an ATM inside. read more

Mike's Sub Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

Everything you expect from jersey subs, simple toppings, killer quality

No nonsense sub shop. Its not fancy, don't expect millions of options or exotic choices. But if you want a generously portioned neatly made good tasting sub at a good value you found the spot. The place is clean and friendly. Parking is readily available in the lot across the street and you wont wait a long time for help. 1 line review is : Good value, clean, fresh and delicious. Return often. read more

Our hands down favorite sub place in Monmouth county! Not only is it family owned and a great humble place the subs are so delicious and fresh. We take all our family and friends to Mike's when we need something quick and delicious. We also get platters there for our dog's birthday party (don't judge our dogs are awesome). And they are always the first thing gone. read more

Mike's is the best sub shop around. The bread is great and the meat is sliced right in front of you which adds to the taste. They do traditional sandwiches and no hot sandwiches so just know that going in. The only downside is it is cash only and the price is a bit high but it is great and our families favorite! read more

Love today's special! Prices are great! Similar to tastee subs. They were open through out the covid pandemic and we ordered from here often. read more

The chicken parm sandwich was so so. The sauce and bread were good but the chicken was overcooked so it had that nasty crunchy texture. Maybe it would be better if ordered again. It was probably made carelessly by someone. It's okay. read more

Dude i'm not sure where u went to eat but Mikes in Keyport does use boars head.. they must b doing something right!! The place will be celebrating 50 years next month.. despite the opening n closing of several food businesses in town .. the only thing you're right about IS yes the do have amazing tuna.... read more

Second time here. Mind blown. The subs look so basic and boring based on the pictures from past patrons, but don't let the pictures fool you. I'm normally turned off by sub places that don't toast their bread, but I gave it a try anyway to see the hype. This place is AMAZING. I love subs, but unfortunately, most places just can't get it right in NJ. This place is IT! The bread doesn't need toasting because it's so fresh and soft---so good as is!!! The ingredients are high quality and so delicious. The workers are also super neat making your sandwich. I can actually eat the sub without 10,000 napkins. The bread isn't drenched in oil or anything. Just perfectly made! They also can follow instructions and modify as requested. Big bonus! I'm so glad I tried--will be a loyal customer for many more years to come, that's for sure! Their only negative is that it's a cash only place so it may be less convenient at times, but it's fine and worth it. New fave place, yay! read more

Mike's Sub Shop - #3 with turkey added - Sandwiches Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

Craving an italian sub? Great spot to get a killer classic sub.Cash only, and grab a pickle on your way out!!

I came here after a morning at Sand Hook. The ham salami, cappicola, provalone special is on point. Their tomatos are particularly delicious. I've had better but not by much. read more

This is the best place to get a sub in Monmouth County. Even better than the famed White House Subs in Atlantic City (My opinion). I go here often and it never disappoints. If you are looking for a fresh mozzarella, prosciutto with balsamic go somewhere else. This is a straight up Jersey Shore Sub shop. Family owned and an anchor on the Bay Shore. And, if you are having a party try their sub platters which are beautiful to look at and better to eat. My guests devour them! read more

This place is awesome! The sandwiches are really good. The people that work there are very friendly as well. If you get the food to stay you can eat inside and have a decent view. They also have benches and tables across the street. read more

Can't say anything bad about this joint. Fresh meats, bread, and the fixings. It's definitely by far the best Sub iv had to eat and also I found out recently they do serve hot subs iv yet to try one but knowing me that will be very soon lol! read more

Love this place. They are straight, to the point, and make fantastic sandwiches. A while back, I had a wicked food allergy and they would stop everything and clean the one slicer they had, no matter how long the line. Truly a local gem that cannot be replicated! read more

Several of us got 4 subs to go yesterday... a turkey and Swiss, roast beef and Swiss, an Italiian, and a tuna sub. They were all really good. The bread was fresh, good fresh tomatoes (to be expected this time of year, but fresh and perfectly ripe). I've had better subs (therefore four stars), but Mikes is really excellent. read more

Best subs in the area. Sometimes you can smell the oil and vinegar outside the joint and your nose makes you wander inside even if you're not hungry. Every sub I've had here was amazing, all the ingredients were very fresh and the bread was the perfect texture (meaning light and fluffy, not burnt or soggy). Staff is very friendly and the shop is neat and clean. If you're in Keyport you can't leave without coming here for sure! read more

Mikes will always have a place in my heart. I've grown up on these sandwiches and I can say they are and always will be my favorite. The people are some of the best around and care a great deal about their community and the people they serve. Its amazing to see them come back after Sandy better then ever. Everything is fresh and they take pride in that. They have been in town for over 50 years and that says something about the way they run their business. read more

I'll keep this short, if you appreciate good subs/heros, Mike's Sub Shop is the pinnacle. Mike's is family owned and operated and you can literally taste that goodness in the product. I've been going there for over 10 years and never ever had anything other than the best sub there is. My fav is the Italian special, it has the perfect ratio of meat and toppings inside a perfect sub roll. Do yourself a favor and get the large, you'll thank me later. OK so that wasn't very short, but it's because I Iove this place so much it was easy writing. read more

Not even Sandy could stop them! This place is awesome. Everything about their subs are great from the meats, to the bread and the greens! The owners are awesome people and always remember your order, even if you haven't been there in a while. This place is a staple in Keyport and i'm excited for many, many more years of their subs! read more

It was ok. The bread didn't have much taste to it, so I think it could be improved. I noticed the meat slicer guy trying to process two orders simultaneously, the person in front of me and me. I remember thinking, "he's not paying to my order". Then, he was processing my order and the person behind me and I remember thinking again, "he's not paying to my order." Found his multi-tasking to be annoying and I don't think it saved time. Mostly, it gave me the impression that he wasn't focused on the current order. Also, I ordered a sub with capacolla in it. The capacolla they were using looked like regular ham. When I order capacolla, I want the real stuff, the one that shows up near the top of a web search when you search for 'capacolla'. So, my suggestions are: * improve the taste of the bread. * stop trying to multi-task -- it's annoying to customers and it doesn't increase the throughput. * either use the good capacolla or take capacolla out of the menu altogether. read more

i would give this place 5 stars for the sandwich's they make , BUT they are getting 1 star for the service. this staff of all guys are rude and not very friendly. teens who work there who put on the lettuce and condiments are typically some what friendly , men who do the register / meats are rude and give poor service. weird atmosphere when you go inside . i have the same experience each time as a frequent costumer. going to consider jersey mikes instead next time. typically i try and support local business, but i would rather support a chain i think than them read more

Gotta say honestly one of the best sub shops I have eaten at! Been eating there regularly for about 5 years. Always the same consistently good food, clean and friendly service. read more