Everything was perfect! I forgot just how much I loved Mikey's Late Night Slice. Been having a craving for a while so I ordered us a pie on the Toast Local app for carry out. Love the vibe inside though I had a date with my couch after this long week and decided on a carryout. Ordered the Mushroom w/Roasted Garlic and added Sausage. It was a great combination and these pies are huge. Service was amazing and carry out order was ready when promised. I even found princess parking right out front. Awesome experience all around and always recommend grabbing a slice or a whole pie from Mikey's. Best part is we have leftovers for tomorrow. Helpful hint - pies come cut in 6 super large slices. We got ours cut in 8 which was perfect and there is a 12 slice option as well. read more

See all

Great atmosphere, I love the dark ambiance! We ordered the meathead and regular pepperoni (not pictured because we ate it so fast lol) They have a really cool sauce bar with about 6 different types of sauces. Jalepenos, banana peppers and a variation of Parmesan cheese and red pepper flakes. We also tried this stuff called "pizza crack" Delicious! It was a mixture of Parmesan cheese, red pepper flakes, oregano and garlic! Brock was a fantastic bartender who made the drinks extremely fresh and yummy! I will be back! read more

See all

10/10. Best pizza I've had in a while! The ladies working had great energy and were very welcoming. I love that they have a pepper/sauce/parmesan cheese mix topping bar to add to your pizza. I got the Spicy Ass Pepperoni slice and Cheezy Breadsticks. I'd hold the marinara but that's just me. They have so many sauces to dip/drizzle on your pizza you shouldn't miss it. It wasn't busy inside but they have plenty of seating. And they have a bar. Solid pizza spot! read more

See all

If you haven't had Mikey's newest pizza of the week, The Birds & The Bees (and the Bacon!), make sure you do asap! This slice is the real deal! @mikeshothoney, Hot Honey-tossed Chicken, Crispy Bacon & a Pink Sauce Base makes for a game changing piece of pie you need to try! If you want to experience this fire slice, make sure you do by this weekend, March 1st is the last day you can grab one! read more

See all

This review should be a 3.5 stars. We came here around 9:00 to eat a slice of pizza, have a drink, and people watch. It seemed odd to us that when we walked in we were the only people there. Throughout the next two hours, about 20 people came in. The pizza was good not great but after some drinks the pizza I bet would be the best! We loved all the options and the funny logo and cups. read more

See all

One of the best pizza spots in columbus. Loved their vegan pepperoni pizza and garlic dip. read more

See all

Yum Yum Yum! Since I'm from NYC, I'm always down to check out some pizza that looks like it could resemble the real deal. We were at the arcade next door and were hungry after they closed so I decided to take a chance here. Upon walking in, the pizza scent was divine! It honestly took me back to growing up in NYC with that amazing aroma. I really have not experienced that since moving out of NY so I was excited to try Mikey's. Since it was late, there was not a lot of variety in choices. The staff greeted us and offered us to order. We ordered the Plain Ass Slice, the Vegan Pepperoni, the Plain Ass Pepperoni, and Unicorn sauce. We ordered it to go and we did not wait long to have it heated up. We decided to eat it back at our hotel room since it was a short walk. I am most sure if I was starving but damn, that pizza hit the friggin spot! And the unicorn sauce was a good addition too! I didn't realize until later that they have several locations. Hopefully I will be able to grab a slice when traveling through in the future. read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Slice Vegan Pepperoni, regular slice, Slice Plain Ass Pepperoni, and unicorn sauce - Bars Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Best place ever it's so fun. Margarita and Shawn are the best. I had the best time and the drinks were great.

Kinda obsessed with Mikey's, use to come here all the time years ago and I'm very happy to say they haven't changed!!! The customer service has always and still is immaculate! the ambiance full of fun and music! Feels carefree in a way that says "aaaayyyyeeeee" like the Fonzie. The pizza!!! oh myyyy!!! The pizza is always perfectly done, full of favor, nice n toasty and delicious! never ever have I had a bad experience at a 'Late night Slice' This restaurant is a staple and a comfort, welcoming all with a warm embrace and yummy pizza dipping sauce. the walls hold many stores and memories of exiting nights and happy days! ~Will continue coming here forever~ read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Slice of Plain-Ass Pepperoni* - Bars Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Tried out a slice of the Plain Ass Pepperoni and it didn't disappoint. If you are looking for a big cheese pull this isn't your slice, but if you want a thin slice with great flavor this is it. When I came in and shared that I was new to Mikey's they took time explain all of the slice options that were available and I had to fight the temptation to try one of each. The atmosphere was casual dinning experience with music playing in the background. I would suggest you give them a try. read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Slice of Plain-Ass Pepperoni* - Bars Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Really good vegan pizza and they don't upcharge you for their vegan pizza like some other places read more

See all

Good food and games Nice place to hangout with friends and family Decent games for kids - table tennis. Arcade games. read more

See all

Perfect spot to grab a slice and go or you can sit down and enjoy the pizza and sauces.

It just wasn't my cup of tea!The ambience wasn't too friendly of service!!!!! I was tired anyway it put me to sleep! My friend woke me up when it was time for the pizza! read more

Worst location ever. Cashier yelled at the line the entire time and clearly hated his job. I didnt want to give him my business considering his attitude was horrible before we even made it to the front of the line but my party was hungry. This guy is awful and if you want pizza I suggest choosing a different location. Let me add a picture of the employee who needs a new job. read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Bars Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

First stop when I got to town. Cashier was friendly, welcoming, and helpful for a first timer. He answered my questions and offered advice to help decide. I went with the special mushroom Kingdom pie Togo which was an absolute banger. The sauce was delicious, good meaty Mushrooms, good flavor, well cooked crust! Over all a delicious well made pie. As an out of towner not knowing what to expect they certainly set the bar high for the rest of the restaurants I'll visit while in town. read more

See all

Incredible pizza. Brock and the rest of the staff were incredibly warm and friendly. They gave us another order of breadsticks because the first was little burnt even though we didn't mind. Great people. Great Pizza. Mikey's. read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Breadsticks - Bars Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

My friend and I stopped here early this morning at approximately 1am. We just so happened to stumble across it on Google as we were looking for late night food spots after a long night out & I am so happy we did. For it to be a late night spot, I was really impressed by the service and how friendly everyone was. It was a very chill environment with a bar feel. We got the Date Night special which included 2 slices of pizza, breadsticks, 2 drinks & a unicorn bar. The wait time was about 10 minutes. They were all out of cheese pizza so I had to get the spicy a** pepperoni (that's the name of it haha). It came with pepperoni & banana peppers & sooooo good. The dough was soft & everything was hot to temperature. I dipped mine in the spicy unicorn sauce *chef's kiss* & complimented the pizza well. You could also order drinks. The drinks were just okay but the bartender was very friendly. I was also told they have a speakeasy. We didn't check it out because we had already had a long day but I would go back the next time I'm in Columbus & need a late night bite to eat. read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Unicorn Bar*** - Bars Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Went on a date here during the day it was not a lot of people there. I heard there's a secret bar, but I don't drink so still cool . The pizza was good. I'd say that the pizza crust could've been a little butteryer good night read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Slice of Spicy-Ass Pepperoni* - Bars Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Surprised by the bad reviews but this was one of my favorite slices when I still lived in Columbus. The slices are comparable to any New York style slice you'd get in the city. For two slices at about $10, these aren't fancy slices but there are definitely quality. The slices are put on basic paper plates, thin, and packed with flavor. The unicorn sauce still hits and so do the slices. The area of this one is great because it's right by 16 Bit and Dirty Frank's which also deserve a visit. read more

Great place for the munchies! The pizza slice was big and crust was thin and crispy. Server was quick and friendly! The prices were not bad too! read more

Left my ID at home. Came to get a slice at 10:30 and was rejected by security at the door because of an ID policy that must be newer. I just went to the high st location and they took care of me, but I was fully prepared to go to Goodfellas. read more

This is a review of the service mostly. The pizza in its quality was fine but this location messed up the order and caused my wife to be sick to her stomach for hours. My wife has a dairy allergy which I explicitly mentioned numerous times when I ordered and asked for dairy free cheese. One bite in and my wife knew it wasn't dairy free by the flavor. I called the store and the lady who took my order said it was dairy free. I then asked to talk to someone else and that person said it wasn't dairy free. Poor training and unknowledgeable staff turned our weekend getaway into a night on the hotel bathroom floor. read more

The food comes out fast. No service provided. Great looking drive bar. Loved the place. I'd go again and again. 10/10. read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Whole pie. Whole Mushroom w/ Roasted Garlic This was 10/10. Good crunch. Lots of flop though. Crust flavor was so good. - Bars Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I thought New York had the best pizza but who would have thought that Columbus, Ohio had the best pizza?! Let me tell yall something...that mushroom slice is the greatest slice I've ever had in my life. I live in Texas and I will now think about this pizza all the time... read more

Staff was pleasant, pep was extra delicious! Will be back my experience was seamless and fast

I went after a concert where I was in the pit, and it had a very nice vibe to it and it was a great way to wind down. Food was great, but I can't say anything about the service since a friend was the one who ordered while I got us a table. The only reason this review doesn't have five stars was because of a print of batman and robin (robin is very underage and, you know, batman's legally adopted son) kissing on the way to the bathroom. Like, full on kissing. Kind of threw me off. read more

Visiting from California, I did not know that I needed this pizza until I had it, this oversized, greasy, cheesy pizza with the garlic sauce. Definitely get the garlic sauce. We tend to have more artisanal style pizzas back home, rare to see any that sell by the slice, and if I wanted garlic sauce, I'd have to order pizza from Dominos or another big chain. It's healthier but sometimes you just want to take a chance with your cholesterol levels and Mikey's Late Night Slice delivered that! Love the decor. It's fun, funny (check out "the bathroom"), and reflective of the funky vibe of the place. The service was also really quick when we went around lunchtime on a Saturday. We didn't really see many people out and about either so perhaps Columbus itself just doesn't get crowded even on the weekends. Overall, a great stop. read more

See all

Passed by this place while walking to short north and got a few slices to go. Pepperoni was the best one and would leave without their mushroom pizza as well. We also had a bbq chicken slice that was good too. Great ambiance with fun decor and perfect for a late night bite. Service was fast. Great pizza by the slice for a night in downtown Columbus. read more

See all

Great experience today at Mikey's Late Night Slice. I popped in for a quick bite after leaving an event. They now have a daily crazy hour EVERY day from 4-5 pm where items are 50% off. My pizza slice was half off and was ordered a drink by the bartender Melissa as well. She recommended the punch which I cannot remember the name of. It was super good but I'm glad she told me that it was dangerous as it's super good and you can't tell you're drinking alcohol. For my pizza slice, I got the Plain- Ass Pepperoni which is Pepperoni, sprinkled with Parmesan cheese. It's so good!! You really can't go wrong with any of the pizzas. They also have a signature sauce called the Unicorn Sauce. Unicorn Sauce is a delicious tangy, smokey, spicy, sweet flavor. It's amazing!! Can't wait to come back to get more punch when I'm not driving. read more

Great bar service! Tessa is awesome! Gave a great tasting! Also looking forward to see the expansion of the Mikey's Hooch!

the service was exceptional i ordered the vegan chicken bbq, cheese & basil, and 2 plain pepperoni slices and lastly cinnamon stix bbq chicken 7/10 cheese & basil 8/10 plain pep 8.3/10 cinnamon stix 5/10 a little hard due to being reheated im assuming so get fresh if you can they have a bar area thats really nice as well with a nice selection open seating and nice music selection ambiance is low lit with comfortable lounge chairs with a music selection of late 90s to modern day overall i enjoyed myself read more

This place was highly recommended.. And I was surprised by how great the pizza was !! It was very fresh and delicious!! The spicy pepperoni had a nice kick to it but not uncomfortable hot .. The mushroom and garlic pizza was amazing with that nice fresh mushroom taste !! The crust was thin and soft !! A must try pizza place if in the Columbus area !! read more

See all

This place saved us. We got into Columbus late so we thought there would be some late night eats. Yeah for some reason the food scene in downtown Columbus is dead and deserted. Total ghost town. At like 1:30 am, we arrived and were immediately greeted by the staff. They told us how to order. We got cheese with basil, mushroom with roasted garlic, and plain ass pepperoni. Pizza tasted delicious at 1:30 am. Prices were fair. Free refills on drinks. Food was hot and fresh. read more

See all

This review can be summed up with one thing: $6 for one slice of pizza (or $30 for the whole thing). I know inflation has been increasing, but dang!! That just seems crazy expensive for a reheated piece of pizza. Yes, reheated because just like a typical NY pizza joint, the pizzas sit in a glass case at the front until a slice is ordered and then tossed back in the oven. I tried the specialty pizza which was touted as a 'Hot Chicken' with fried chicken and mac and cheese. Comes with ranch and some pickles. It wasn't spicy, but the chicken and mac and cheese part was tasty and the ranch was really good. However, given the price I doubt I will frequent any Mikey's locations unless it is literally the only thing open. read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Inside - Bars Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Do you really need more pics of Mikey's? Good NyC style slices for a pinch after the club or for lunch. The rotation of types is a plus and I appreciate the vegan options. This was my first pizza in Columbus when I moved and it continues to be my go to when in a hurry. The unicorn sauce is so tangy and good, they sell it in the stores now! The service is always consistent though the people change. And the area is a mix of old school pizza parlor, rock punk bar, and if you go to the speakeasy one- cozy hangout... always some type of vibe. I appreciate the marketing team figuring out cost effective meal deals like two slices and a drink under $20 etc.! It speeds up the lines and helps the daters as well. Good business and on! I would like to see more creative options for the non meat folks though. Pizza on! read more

Maybe it was TOO late at night, but the cheese with "fresh" basil was anything but fresh. Stale crust, cheese dried out, and basil was a few tiny bits and dried out completely almost to barely visible specs. Definitely couldn't taste the basil at all. I was very disappointed. This was probably the worst slice of pizza I've had in a very long time. read more

Tastes like home and nights to remember! Every time I visit Columbus, I make sure to stop by one of the locations for a slice (or a few)! The ambiance cannot be beat for any occasion of whether you're out on a date, with friends, or even by yourself. The staff are always friendly and their service is top notch. 100/10. read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Mikey's Slice of Plain Ass Pepperoni Side Spicy Unicorn Sauce Side of Parmesan Cheese - Bars Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This place has Great service. Great pizza. Local beer on tap. What else can you ask for?

Only had 30 minutes, so jumped in and had two quick slices. Service was quick and the flavor and crust was spot on and what I was looking for, Awesome! read more

Mikey's Late Night Slice - Bars Near Me - Columbus, Ohio