So this is no place to come and sit for hours as most of the milk bar is just 4 boards of menu, however, it's cute to come in and grab something quickly. And that's easily done as everything (well the cakes & cookies) are already pre-packaged with a list of ingredients on the packaging (which I LOVE). As for the treats themselves: -Cereal Milk Soft Serve: certainly tastes like milk after you've had cornflakes--if you are into that, get this. I for one was happy with my two bites of the sample. -Compost cookie (chocolate chips, butterscotch chips, graham crumbs, pretzels, potato chips): it's a bit crunchy because of the ingredients (instead of smooth and gooey like how I like my cookies). In fact there are so many ingredients all of them kind of mesh together and create just a sweet taste that's nothing memorable. If I could actually taste the individual ingredients I would eat it but it's just not worth the calories, nor the disgusting ingredients that are used in this. High fructose corn syrup, riboflavin--like what even is that? What happened to cookies being flour, eggs, butter and natural ingredients??? -Crack pie: pretty good. Somewhat salty, somewhat sweet caramel/smoky flavored. The insides are perfectly smooth--like a key lime pie texture. The crust is harder because it has the nuts and glaze. My first bite I was like, okay this is fine, but I ended up devouring it--sort of. I like it but wouldn't have to have it again. FINAL VERDICT: Nothing blew me away enough to try again, but I would come back to try their candy bar pie and blueberry & cream cookie, but I'll read the ingredients first. Just because you call yourself compost and crack whatever doesn't mean you have to use unnatural ingredients! read more

Milk Bar has gone from the most glorious dessert shop on earth located in the East Village to a bit of a mediocre machine. Can't believe I'm saying this, don't want to blaspheme, but my cookies were just OK. Of course, my grievances go way, way back to the discontinuation of my cake slices, and their subsequent adulteration into truffles, but who's keeping track. Oh, right, me. Anyway, not as fresh, and the compost, was - gasp - a bit hard from what I'm used to. Which is softer. Yes, I like them fresh and soft. read more

Order the salted pretzel cake if you want to taste a salted bag of meat. Exceptionally horrible. Surprisingly disgusting. Threw the ice cream under the BQE if you want to taste. read more

Don't really get the fuss about Milk Bar. I've tried the crack pie and the cereal milk ice cream and although they were pretty good, it was nothing spectacular. But glad they have a Brooklyn spot. There are no tables inside though, just a small bench. So if you're coming here on a hot day, don't expect to eat the ice cream in a/c. read more

Milk Bar - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

CRACK PIE. That's it. Nothing else to see here folks, move along and head to your nearest Momo to get some CRACK PIE! If you are feeling really adventurous add some cereal milk ice cream to your CRACK PIE! But whatever you do.... Don't leave w/o your CRACK PIE!!!!! read more

My husband and I both love Milk Bar but the service at this location absolutely sucks! We have been to this location numerous times since it's more convenient than the city and it's the same unfriendly person at the counter which is fine, until you mess up my dessert that I have been looking forward to all week. We got the Crack Pie Milk Quake like we always do and all the toppings and pie were at the very bottom, not mixed in at all and ruining my ice cream. Please get better employees!!! read more

I had been hearing about this place LITERALLY every single day I had spent in New York. "Milk bar", "milk bar", "milk bar" people kept telling me to go. One day I FINALLY got around to catching up with a friend, and thought that sure, it's weird to grab dessert rather than drinks, but so what? We met up at the tiny tiny storefront in West Village. I had no clue what I was in for. Initially, the wrapping (I thought everything would be fresh, aka sliced from the whole pie) was a bit offputting, especially the name "crack pie". Hands down though, one of the best dessert places I have been to. Don't bother wasting your time with the cereal milk ice cream or creamsicle ice cream. Go straight to the crack pie. I loved this place so much that on my way back to California, I bought a box of cookies, one of each flavor, so that my brother and I could have a cookie tasting week--one for each weekday. Best week of my life! I'm the type to have a distinct favorite. This was the first time when I couldn't decide on which was the best cookie. Can't go wrong with the cookies, COMPLETELY worth the commute, the wait, the price, whatever it takes! read more

So effing good. The cereal milk ice cream with corn flakes is out of this world. Do yourself a favor and just grab a couple pints. I think I have had every cookie from here and they are all amazing. Favorites in this order are the corn (you won't regret it), chocolate chip cornflake and the blueberries and cream - tastes just like the best bites of a blueberry muffin! I stopped in recently and had the huckleberry cheesecake ice cream - equally as amazing as cereal milk. Also, milk bar is on point for delivery - I was skeptical about ordering ice cream for delivery (I don't like it melted) and it was still fully frozen when it arrived. The crack pie is so good as well - tastes like a stick of butter and brown sugar. Delish! I still want to try the candy bar pie, truffles and breads. Definitely favorite novelty dessert shop in Manhattan and Williamsburg! read more

I already know that I LOVE Momofuku Milk Bar. I've been to the one in the city and finally got the chance to try this one. The thing is... I only really like the cereal milk soft serve with the cornflake crunch. It's what I always order when I'm there. The crack pie is meh..but I already knew that prior to coming to this one. The only reason I don't go as often is because that the one in the city is crazy and the line is down the street. This one is actually a reasonable wait (and much bigger than the one in the city). When I got there, the line actually started inside the place which made me happy :D Since I moved close by, I'm happy that I can go and grab my ice cream without rethinking it because of all the tourist craziness. Another plus about this place is that they have a bigger selection and alcoholic shakes - which I didn't get to try yet but it sounds cool. read more

3 for $5 cookies?! Yes, please! I was so happy to finally have stumbled upon Milk Bar and have the ability to try the famous composte cookie -- which was delicious, by the way. I still have yet to try the other two I purchased (I am coveting them fiendishly), but I have only the highest of expectations. And to make it even better?! They take credit cards! This is great for you cash-starved folks out there who just want your cookie, no questions asked and no ATMs. My only wish is that they didn't pre-package these -- they would be even better if they were served warm and gooey straight out of the oven without any kind of plastic wrap; it kind of cheapens the experience. Next time I'm going in for the cereal milk softserve stuff. read more

I stopped by to see what was good. I was surprised the shop was so tight. I only tried the cereal milk ice cream and the salted pretzel (I think). It was ok, I won't be rushing back. read more

Milk Bar - Williamsburg Food: 8/10 I have to admit, when I first tried the Cereal Milk (at the East Village Location) I wasn't a big fan. But as more of my friends visiting wanted to try it out, and I ordered one each time anyways, it kind of gets addicting. It's exactly what you expect your milk to taste like after you've snuck in a bit of frosted flakes with your cornflakes and try to pass it off as anything remotely healthy. Their ice cream comes out in these little small capuccino cups that are really adorable! Another thing you have to try are their cookies! Their cookies are so soft and sweet and just simply amazing! The "compost cookie" sounds funny, especially when you read the description, but I say GO FOR IT. Unless youre not a fan of that sweet & savory combo, then don't try it! Service: 7/10 Good service, when I came to this location, not much of a wait! Staff are friendly and the service is fine. Nothing out of the ordinary. Overall: 8/10 Additional Notes: A good "staple" NY ice cream place now, in my opinion. I love that I can get it in Williamsburg as well as out in the city. read more

Milk Bar - Cereal Milk!!! - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Maybe I expected too much. I thought I was going to get something baked the same day, or close. I didn't realize I was going to get something in a package, shipped from who knows where, made who knows when. Husband and I got the crack pie, cereal milkshake and chocolate truffle balls. Crack pie and truffle balls were all served in wrapping, definitely not made even remotely close to where I was standing. Is it so wrong to expect a slice of pie from an actual pie? It tasted okay, kinda like a pecan pie filling, without the pecans. Definitely not worthy of the name crack pie. Truffle balls were pretty disgusting. Heavy and not very tasty. Cereal milkshake tasted like chemically enhanced milk. And did I mention it wasn't even thick, like a milkshake should be? Yuck. read more

One of the most overrated places to eat in the city, Milk Bar thrives on the reputation of David Chang's other successful businesses and an audience of people in their 20's and 30's with too many dollars in their pockets, who are nostalgic for a childhood filled with dreams of drinking cereal milk without the cereal or putting potato chips in chocolate chip cookies. The truth is that were one to judge the product without the brand, one would be incredibly disappointed. The hot chocolate is always weak and flimsy, with only a tease of chocolate flavor. The cookies are all overly sweet and flavorless with too much butter. The compost cookie, as I described above, is meant to be some kind of childhood dream, but turns out to be an adulthood nightmare. And all of this is expensive. So if it seems like your kind of place, enjoy! But after 4 or 5 attempts, you won't see me there again. read more

I have absolutely NO idea what all the hype is about. I am giving this place 2 stars- 1 star because I received good service- 1 star because they stay open late. So I was very excited to go to Milk Bar -Finally- I had been dying to try it so I bought : -Corn Cookie: Ewh after taste much! -Cereal Milk soft serve: What! umm hmm...I don't know what to say other than it tasted like cereal milk- that can be a good or bad thing depending on the person -Chocolate Cookie- It was good until the weird during and after taste hit- what! -The famous Crack Pie- You could possibly die from the the mountains of sugar but I liked it because I am a sugar addict. I hate pecan pie because it has pecans in it. This taste like pecan pie without pecans so SCORE! BUT considering that it taste just like pecan pie it shouldn't receive so much praise -it's not like it's some sort of original recipe I will never go back. Done. read more

On my first and only visit thus far, I bought all three things that I have heard people rave about: the cereal milk Ice cream, the birthday cake truffles, and the crack pie. The birthday cake truffles were moist, but overall, I wasn't in love. The crack pie though was SO good and it's so obvious why there are recipes to mimic it at home. I definitely recommend it, 10/10. My FAVORITE thing though is the cereal milk ice cream with the corn flakes. It seriously tastes like cereal milk, and it blows my mind. Absolutely AMAZING. It's really refreshing, in my opinion, too. The place itself did not look the way I expected. It's pretty small, but it definitely gets the job done. It is cozy and cute. The woman working there was super friendly and patient while my friend and I took our sweet time trying to figure out what we should try first. It is another one of those places that you should definitely try AT LEAST once. read more

Milk Bar - Cereal milk ice cream with cornflakes...amazing!!! - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Went in here to try their cereal milk soft serve.. This place might be too grown up for me. -sarcasm- They don't do soft serve in cones. I apparently needed to be civilized and eat with their wooden mini-shovel. That didn't occur to me after I was handed my overpriced "emperor's new clothes soft serve" in a thin paper cup with "said wooden mini-shovel" which I haphazardly threw away. The soft serve has a melting point of "when your foot touches the pavement outside the store". By the time I was at the end of the block, I had to lick faster than the drip rate onto my clothes. Taste-wise, after a few minutes, I got bored. Demoralizing soft serve experience. read more

Cute place to stop in for dessert. The cashiers were friendly and quick and the soft serve was great! It was way more filling than I expected it to be so maybe consider sharing if you've had a big dinner! If you get crunch cereal, they place it on the top and bottom of the ice cream so you definitely don't have to worry about running out. read more

Milk Bar - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

My first experience with Milk was with their cookies, specifically the corn cookie. That surprised me the most with its sweetness, buttery-ness and texture - it tasted and felt good. The rest of the cookies are all unique and delicious in their own way - especially the composte cookie. It doesnt have the most appetizing name but I'm glad it makes up for it. If it's your first time here, you can't go wrong with a basic staple - the cereal milk soft serve. Pair it with a cookie and you're set! read more

Definitely an A-OK spot, the milk bar is tiny but this particular location does offer cake classes, which is unique. We were lucky enough to sneak into (technically we didn't sneak, they let us walk in WITH hairnets on of course!) the back factory as a new cake-making group was entering. That was a particular highlight of the visit. We were able to see treats in the making and the staff was very friendly--although no, they didn't let us taste anything! I did appreciate that the coffee shop had dairy free options (soy and almond milk) and the almond latte was tasty. We also tried the b-day truffles, which were pretty lack-luster. Overall, small shop, standing room only aside from one bench inside (no tables) and two benches outside. Christina wasn't hiding in the back (I know that for a fact, because the five-year-old asked--FYI: Christina is her role model!) but isn't something I would recommend as a 'must visit spot'. read more

Milk Bar - Almond milk latte. - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Came in for dessert, ordered a slice crack pie which was a gooey, buttery and delicious. Also tried the birthday cake shake, it was very sweet (But hey its a milkshake), the shake had pieces of cake inside and overall was very good. read more

Milk Bar - Birthday Cake Shake and a crack pie - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

We came to this area in search of crack but only found crack pie. Kidding about the first part but serious about the second. Had the crack pie but it wasn't "like crack" at all. "Just keep adding sugar and it will taste great" seems to be the theme here. It's just another one of these cutesy novelty bakeries that seem to be sprouting up like wildfire. I applaud the effort in trying to be unique by offering a small variety of sweets you won't find anywhere else, but the sweets I had were kind of forgettable. A lot of people seem to go nuts over the crack pie but it was basically a sugar cookie in pie form. Nothing too special. It's not like you would have to employ NASA scientists to try to decipher the sheer genius of the ingredients there. We also tried some kind of cereal shake that involved alcohol. Although it might seem like a huge draw for a drunken late night snack, I had one sober and as tasty as it was, I just didn't get it. I don't know if it was the combo of the flavoring or the alcohol but it gave a hint of a spoiled milk taste. I thought it was rather funny that the workers wouldn't allow us leave the premises because the drink was alcoholic, therefore being unlawful to drink on the street. It would be equivalent to being arrested for having a rum cake in your possession. It just feels like this place is trying a little too hard to be different. This is for people that find a regular chocolate chip cookie to be boring. As long as the sweets I eat are delicious, I don't really need one that thinks out of the box. I'm sure that this is the type of place where an NY transplant would take their friends to when they come up for a visit. Unfortunately, I doubt this joint will give them something to write home about. read more

A great place to stop for a sweet snack! Service is prompt and efficient. There isn't much space to sit so it's better suited for on-the-go snacking. I had a soft-serve cereal milk with fudge. It was good and the only reason why not 5/5 is that it's pricier than I think it's worth. read more

I don't understand what all the hype is about with Momofuku, I have visited their noodle bar and now their Milk Bar and I was unimpressed on both occasions. Yes their Carck Pie was good but it wasent something amazing like everybody raves about. The Cereal Milk shake was also good but again it wasent something unique or memorable. The prices are a bit steep in my opinion, I wouldn't return, it wasn't memorable or something I would crave. read more

This review is just for their soft serve, no baked goods- and I was pretty disappointed. I really wanted to try the crack pie soft serve, but unfortunately they were sold out. Cereal milk soft serve with cornflakes it is. And it was just...ok? It didn't even really taste like cereal milk, just a mildly sweet and kind of bland. I'm not really sure what everyone here is raving about. The cornflakes were nice for texture, but I didn't think it was anything special. I still want to try their other sweet treats, but for now, I'll pass on the basic flavors. read more

In one trip, I just about tried everything on the menu. This place is the shizzy. I recently went to NY for a weekend and ate here three times. The cake truffles are so delicious I wanted to cry. Of course, I had to try the cereal milk ice cream and ... it tastes exactly like cereal milk: no better, no worse, no sweeter, just the same. I don't know what I was expecting, but it was not what I had anticipated. It was interesting, not bad, I'm glad I tried it, but I enjoyed the strawberry sesame ice cream more. This place is teensy! So don't expect to bring a big crowd and hang out. But the stuff is superb and totally unique. read more

Honestly, there isn't really anything special about the dessert here! I stopped by because I was in the neighborhood and got three of their homemade cookies. The texture was kinda different and it was really sweet. Nothing memorable and I love desserts, so for me to say it was average, then this place was really just average. I got the cornflake chocolate chip marshmallow cookie, corn cookie, and blueberry and cream cookie. Nothing special about them, the cornflake has a really weird texture and left a weird taste in my mouth! Drinks here are overpriced and don't bother with that. I won't come back here, would I suggest others to come here ? Not really! There isn't really anything in the neighborhood except traif which I love but I wouldn't take the trip all the way to l Brooklyn just for this place. read more

Cereal milk ice cream. Need I say more? Everything is delicious and worth a few bites. It's mildy expensive for what it is but that's also Williamsburg for you. The birthday truffle cake is to die for. read more

Milk Bar - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

OMG. Crack pie is as addictive as it sounds like. It had better be, given how they make it (first, make cookies from scratch, then crumble them up to make the crust). Sugary, buttery goodness. Just don't eat more than one slice or it might be heart attack pie. Tried the cereal milk ice cream too. Definitely get the corn-flake topping on this one. The salty-sweet crunch adds good counterpoint to the sweet ice cream, which does indeed taste exactly like the milk left over when you're done eating sugary cereal. Well done, Milk Bar. I'll have to come back next time I'm in NYC. read more

Inventive flavors, but I was just not all that impressed. We had the espresso shake (cereal milk soft serve + Stumptown espresso, $7) and the strawberry sesame soft serve ($4.50). While I enjoyed the shake more, it was nothing extraordinary especially for the price. I should probably go back to try the crack pie and the pork buns (and probably one of the alcoholic shakes), but otherwise this isn't an establishment that I'm itching to go back to. read more

The corn cookies still hit the spot. I can't recreate the corn or compost cookies even w the tosi cookbook so I always stop when I'm in town. Quick pork bun lunch on the run too. Love as always. The girls had issues w the register but got it back up and running in a few mins. read more

This is actually the location where they make all the Milk Bar desserts that go out to the East Village location (and to Midtown). The entrance is right next to Saltie though it's not too obvious - the double green doors are usually closed and you may have to ring the bell. They only sell in bulk... meaning prepackaged cookies by the dozen or entire cakes and pies. I'm not sure if the prices are any cheaper than the one in East Village ($20 for a dozen cookies) but they do sometimes have samples of the cookies there. No soft serve, milks, or special breads either. read more

You are better off buying whole milk from the local supermarket and adding cornflakes on top.

Okay so I have been hearing about this place for a long time and was in the area and decided to stop by! I've heard most via online and social media about their 'crack pie' . I purchased a slice of the crack pie & two other things Incase the crack pie flopped! And indeed in my opinion it FLOPPED! I'm not saying it wasn't good . However it tasted like a gooey granola bar and the goo filling being overly sweet! It was also not warm but the cashier said it should be eaten as such! Eeeh, I wouldn't go back for it or recommend it either. Now next up was the birthday cake truffles. They were cool . Tasted like birthday cake cookie dough. And last but not least the Corn Cookie! Now that was delicious. Reminded me of the corn bread batter that my cousins and I would fight to lick the bowl when my grandmother was making cornbread! Very good. So overall Milk was a cute spot but less than impressed by the 'crack pie' which was what I originally went for. read more

See all

First time I went to Milk Bar didn't even know there was one by my job. I decided to come in here to try their ice cream that everyone was talking about. Not as good as I thought it was going to be. It was $7.08 for a pint of ice cream with the topping of crunch. Very upsetting to eat this. I was excepting it to be really good. So expensive for a pint. Once was enough. read more

Milk Bar - $7.08 - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Everything they have to offer at this place has been hand-crafted by angels... The Cereal Milk soft serve ice cream with Corn Flake crunch, to die for. The Compost cookie, Chocolate Chocolate cookie and Blueberry & Cream cookie, heavenly. I plan to try the Strawberry Sesame ice cream, all of the cake truffles and the Pretzel Milk in the near future. These sweets are a little on the pricy side, but absolutely worth it. I can totally see myself becoming addicted to this stuff. Too good for my own good. read more

I stumbled in here while waiting for Foodswings to open, thinking I would have my dessert before dinner. Naturally, I had to try the much-raved-about Crack Pie. Sadly, Crack Pie = pecan pie without the pecans. The crust is below average. It in no way, shape, or form, resembles anything worthy of the name "Crack Pie." While not bad, it's not amazing. "Meh" is the best way I can describe it. Also, the pie isn't fresh (it's served in a refrigerated cardboard box) and the portion is ridiculously tiny. For nearly $6, I expect something made on the premises. Now on to the beverages: I forked over $9 for a cereal milk white russian. White russians are nice, cereal milk is delicious, a no-fail combo, right? Wrong. The portion was ridiculously tiny for a milkshake (think less than 10 oz) and tasted spectacularly awful. It tasted of...styrofoam? I'm not sure how to describe it, but it tasted extremely synthetic and not at all like the delicious heaven left in the bowl after breakfast. In fact, it was so bad I couldn't even finish half of it. *Note: I've had cereal-milk inspired dessert before (mmm creme brulee), but this completely missed the mark. Service was average. I was thinking of trying the veggie bun, but I don't think I can bring myself to go back. Save your money and time, if you're in the mood for syrupy pie, I suggest heading over to Hill Country BBQ for bourbon pecan pie a la mode (with Blue Bell ice cream). At least their pie is fresh and has pecans. read more

This is a review for just the cookies and pies. They come in pre-made boxed containers and were mediocre at best. I had the crack pie and it was cold like it had been sitting in a fridge for a few days, and very firm. I like my pies with texture and this one was more of a cookie because it was so dense. It was also very small and for 5.50, I was expecting way more presentation and tastiness which it both lacked. The cashier was nice though. read more

this is just a review for the cornflake chocolate chip marshmellow cookie. I LOVE IT. one of the best cookies ever. didn't want it to end. read more

Milk Bar - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Really just all around terrible. $9 for their absolutely atrocious cereal shake. Tastes like salty milk. I hate this place and everyone in it. You are better off eating the dog treats they offer in the front. read more