Food quality / price (value) rating 9. The atmosphere is a small, nicely remodeled antique diner. We've been here probably a dozen times and it has always been good. Today, I had the banana pecan pancakes with real maple syrup, and ham. Both of them were high quality. The wife had a tuna salad sandwich that had a generous portion of tuna. The coffee was strong and the service was excellent. read more

See all

We had an amazing breakfast at the Millbrook diner. They have sidewalk seating for the great weather we've been getting. Our waitress made sure we had everything we needed and were happy with our meal. We will be back! read more

Millbrook Diner - Sidewalk seating - Diners Near Me - Millbrook, New York

See all

Amazing little diner, incredible food and service, eggs were perfectly scrambled, sausage was salty and delicious, and the home fries were on another level, soft and savory. The interior of the diner was in very good condition, mostly original from 1952, and was well decorated and festive for the Christmas season. Recommended. read more

See all

The food was good the service was not good didn't get water after we asked a couple times

Nothing special,lovely small restaurant with great views .Right in the middle of town, which you Could stop by and take a break from locally owned shops. read more

Everything I ate was delicious and tasted fresh. My table mates raves about the milkshakes. Our waitress was competent, friendly and had a great sense of humor. I loved how the diner seemed to transport us back in time. I would have given this diner 5 stars except: 1)The tables are too close together. 2) I saw the kitchen staff participating in unsanitary practices. read more

See all

My son claimed that his banana/chocolate chip pancakes were the best he eaten for a long time. My experience was somewhat different. First my order was mixed up: instead of grilled chicken Greek salad wrap I was given a buffalo chicken wrap. It was bad: the inside was basically a somewhat spicy soup of ingredients with not real texture or taste. You guys need to go easy of liquid and worry more about ingredients. read more

A fun place to eat; a classic Hudson Valley diner. The staff is friendly, yet for two meals (afternoon French fries snack and New Year's Day breakfast), the young male waiter had no sense of when we were done and repeatedly and intrusively asked to clear the plates before I put my fork down. The fries are amazingly delicious; crunchy, firm golden outside with moist inside. The morning French toast was a beauty to behold but mushy and not fully cooked in the center of the slice. The marbled rye was perfectly toasted for the patty melt, but the tuna had too much mayonnaise. And with the bulging tuna, the sandwich needed another slice of cheese. I'll appreciated the double entry of prices for cash or credit, the latter requiring a 4% increase in price. I'll be back because the ambiance is lovely, and I'll try the spinach pie, which is highly recommended. read more

See all

The food was great the service is great the old style looks nice and friendly atmisphere William booth age 8 read more

Millbrook Diner - Diners Near Me - Millbrook, New York

This was pretty disgusting I found a dead bug in my food. I don't know how this happens but I am extremely grossed out and would like this resolved. read more

Millbrook Diner - I found a bug squashed in my chicken ceased wrap - Diners Near Me - Millbrook, New York

Met a customer here, what a great spot! Charming inside, the food was very good. Out server was en pointe, attentive, not overly... I had the chicken souvlaki, lots of chopped chicken and fresh veggies in a pita. Top notch side Greek salad. The zucchini fries will be something I think about, a lot!! Perfect size and batter ratio. Still some snap. Great tzatziki! I'll be back! read more

Delicious food and cute ambiance! Service was fast and seating was ample despite being busy. read more

Millbrook Diner - Western omelette with side of toast & fruit - Diners Near Me - Millbrook, New York

I have eaten here before and been very happy with the food, service, and the cute originality of the diner. My second visit was disappointing, with just okay food, adequate service and the same quaint atmosphere. We were charged for hot water. I eat out a lot, including other diners, and never have I been charged for hot water. We were not informed by the waiter that there would be a charge for it. Also, the food was not as good this visit as the first time. So on to another place that isn't nickel and diming me for water. read more

There's a wild price discrepancy between their online menu prices and the printed menu in the diner. That aside, the food is only mediocre. They don't believe in cooking with salt. Mysteriously, my card was charged about 1.25 more than their terminal showed me, including the tip I added. So it looks like they might have a hidden credit card processing fee. For such a cute and iconic plate, I've gotta say, I will never be back again. read more

Stepping in here to the old fashion atmosphere definitely adds the vibe. We've been dining here for a couple of years on occasions, and happened to stop here with my family and friends. A weekday vs. weekend can play a role in how crowded it can be, but when we visited on a weekday for a late lunch, not many customers. The food we ordered came out within 15 minutes, while everything tasted as we expected. I'm really impressed with the fries as it's not just crispy, but instead providing a load of flavor on the potato. With a return visit, it seemed to me that some of the prices have gone up a bit, no fuse though. This is one of the places to come to when having a get-together, offering many interesting history and food. read more

I really liked this place. It was clean and comfortable. Our waitress was better than most. The food was ok. Still, for some reason, I enjoyed it more than most diners. There are intangibles that lift mediocre to good and good to great. This sweet little spot has a bunch of them; oh, they buttered my toast. Stuff like that. Check it out. read more

I gotta say I've eaten here probably 30 times minimum. Foods always consistent but the service is getting worse and worse and worse and the prices are going up and up. Not worth it. read more

+Pluses 1. Vintage diner, not many of these left. Great mini jukes on the table- super rare to find. 2. Lots of parking. -Negatives 1. Very crowded and noisy on the weekend. 2. Major mismatch of prices online vs. reality. Owner should fix this asap. 3. Burgers grossly overcooked; medium orders came out well done. 4. Inattentive service from our waiter, who was busy talking with his regulars. 5. Mediocre food. If you are into vintage diners, this one is it. If not, stay home. read more

I am always attracted to these old beautiful diners. the staff attentive, the place clean, the menu overwhelming, it was busy and loud (that's to be expected) the prices did seem to be a bit high, but iF the food is good it really is not an issue.. so here we go after much looking and looking again at this bible of food listings I was able to choose, THE GREEK SPECIALTIES now this has to be tops I think, ordered spinach pie (alias spanakopita) or so I thought, it was accompanied by a Greek salad , the pie was drained frozen spinach in a filo wrapper, dry and flavorless , not even salted, the dough soggy, OMG the specialties, the salad was well made and topped with lots of feta. my friend opted for breakfast (it is now 12 PM ish) I thinking bad move this late in the day, a cheese omelette (cant go wrong) it looked like a yellow closed cell sponge color and texture(maybe frozen or prepacked egg mix) dry and over cooked, it was filled with plenty of cheese, it came with some potatoes that were translucent, greasy, brittle. we were so disappointed after all our expectations. I suggest that you do try this wonderful icon of history, maybe ask some of the locals what to order. read more

Our absolute go to! Greek salad is the best in the area. Everything is good and the service is friendly and speedy! We love the Millbrook Diner. Thank you! read more

Waiter ruined the experience. inattentive and just plan rude. Food has been going downhill in the last years too. My girlfriend and I ordered the exact same sandwich. Hers was full of stuff mine was to slices of bread with hardly anything in it. I ordered mine without fries she ordered fries. Check came and they were the same price! I questioned the waiter why would it be the same price without the fries. Got a nasty attitude after he already was inattentive the whole meal. Its a real shame because I'm a local and had been coming for years. The owners are such nice people also. read more

A real old-fashioned diner with excellent food. Something you see out of a 1950s movie. You expect to see Danny and Sandy and their friends hanging out inside! Really good burgers and salads. It's small inside but I love how it is authentic and original fixtures and design. Right in the heart of Millbrook New York. I've been here several timesI never have been disappointed. My favorite is the Millbrook Cobb salad. Take out is just as good as dining there. read more

Millbrook Diner - Diners Near Me - Millbrook, New York

Nice location , Clean tables, Looks cool and interesting from the outside. Booths and tables to close to each other, it's so close your having conversations with the people 3 tables in each direction when you don't even know the other customers. The service is horrible especially the young Hispanic waitress and American young man waiter with blonde hair and glasses. The Tattoo waitress was the best waitress ever she got everything the other two couldn't handle. There were no free refills on soda that wasn't explained to us until the cool tattoo waitress came over to let us know why. They serve French fries with hamburgers and cups and bowls of Chili but couldn't figure out how to make chili fries when I asked if they had any. The Latina waitress couldn't figure out what I was asking since it wasn't on the menu. The Tattoo waitress had to explain I would have to buy the fries and the bowl of chili separately and mix it together myself. I said if I have to do it myself it wasn't worth it they could have done it for me and charged me for 1/2 cup of chili. They can't handle special orders off the menu. Hamburger was good but same issue if I wanted Mustard Ketchup and onions instead of lettuce and tomatoes it was an issue because it was an off menu item. I'll go back as a last resort but there are plenty of other places around that can do much better even the local dive bar. read more

The Millbrook Diner is worth travelling a few miles from the Taconic on your way to wherever. It is clean, friendly, and has the best pie in six states. Aside from your regular diner stuff, the pies are worth the visit. Actually, the waitstaff is pretty funny. A great place to visit, and a greater place to have a meal. We'll be back. read more

Great service and great food. Very family friendly. A nice place to stop just of the Taconic highway

5 Paws. My pup was treated like royalty receiving a fresh dog bowl of cold water on arrival. The two humans also enjoyed the food, beverages, hospitality and the waiter who needs to get into the voice over business. A good menu with choices for everyone. read more

Millbrook Diner - a dog on a leash - Diners Near Me - Millbrook, New York

I have never felt so discriminated against as in this place, I don't know if that person who served us was just having a bad day but he was very rude to us, he was so angry that he was practically throwing plates of food at us (very bad Food I have to add) a place I will not return to and will not recommend. read more

Great food, and portion size! Friendly staff, highly recommend for all. The food is very fresh, and filling. If you are in the area, and is looking for a quick bite to eat or brunch, this is the place! read more

Millbrook Diner - Greek omelette - Diners Near Me - Millbrook, New York

It's a diner. I very much enjoyed my omelette and the atmosphere. Nothing over the top amazing, but just what you're looking for on a Sunday for brunch read more

Millbrook Diner - a plate of food on a table - Diners Near Me - Millbrook, New York

Millbrook is one of my parents' favorite towns and a place I visited a few times growing up, so when a recent road trip took my wife and I past Millbrook, we knew we had to stop for lunch, and the place that my Mom recommended stopping was the Millbrook Diner. We arrived just in time for brunch and were excited to give this place a shot. As you pull into the parking lot, it's easy to tell that not much has changed with this diner over the years, and that's a good thing in this case! The diner's appearance alone makes you feel like you've stepped back a few decades into small town America. It's small and charming, and there are still those old-fashioned music players at every booth (I'm sad that so many diners around Long Island have taken these out, even if nobody ever uses them). When we walked inside, the servers let us know that we could sit anywhere we like (there are maybe around a dozen booths and some counter seats available) and handed us some menus. My wife ordered some stuffed mushrooms while I decided on some pancakes with local maple syrup (an extra $3, but you get to take the bottle home) and a side of eggs. We both went simple on the drinks and just got some waters. Honestly, the food was really good! The quality of the eggs and pancakes were both excellent (what you'd expect from a diner but maybe slightly better). My wife really enjoyed her stuffed mushrooms as well. And I have to say that the local maple syrup was a terrific choice! If you come here and order pancakes, french toast, or waffles, I'd recommend you do the same. From the small town charm to the delicious food and the friendly service, Millbrook Diner will make you feel like you've stepped back into a simpler time. Worth the visit if you're in the area! read more

See all

Yesterday we ate a mid-afternoon main meal there and it was a very positive experience. It's a "classic" diner and it opened way back in 1929. The current owner - who was very friendly - has owned the diner since 1991. The food was delicious (I ordered the vegetarian lasagna, which came with either a small salad or a cup of soup [I chose the Manhattan clam chowder and it was the best I've ever tasted; it was wonderfully creamy] and my husband ordered something called Debbie's avocado melt [which included turkey]). Extra points because the Millbrook had bread pudding (my "obsession" dessert) and it was very tasty. The prices were reasonable (especially the lasagna, which was a bargain) - and everything was very clean, including the restrooms. Our server was rather perfunctory, although not unfriendly. read more

Great diner -- locals, visitors all welcome. Gyros are first rate , zucchini fries to die for. Any excuse to go, though not calorie friendly, you should go! read more

Love this breakfast dishes, the Greek salad, & the milkshakes. Great ambiance. The staff is wonderful too.

So many choices and each dish is delicious. Friendly and efficient staff....very accommodating to all who go there. Recommend you try it

Just ok. Service nothing special. Eggs and pancakes average. I cannot recommend. Coffee not special and a wait if you want a refill. read more

Classic Diner plus. Great food and service. Soups homemade. As John Cougar Mellencamp says "Ain't that America " read more

See all

Millbrook Diner is a charming throwback to the diners of yesteryear; a gleaming metallic tube smack dab in the middle of the main drag, with cheerfully-painted Christmas and holiday cartoons happily glazing the windows. Nostalgia is instantaneous upon looking at it. This is definitely an "it is what it is" diner when it comes to the quality of the food served. I was not expecting thick-cut, wood-smoked bacon served with organic beefsteak tomatoes, organic romaine, and a chili-garlic-lemon-thyme aioli served on 384-grain ciabatta bread when I ordered my BLT. It was lettuce, tomato, bacon, and a smidgen of mayo served on toasted whole wheat bread. It filled me up, along with a side of delightfully greasy fries. I was full and content. I don't go to diners expecting a five-star meal. I go to eat. I did. I was happy. I was charmed. I will come back. read more

Millbrook Diner - Millbrook Diner (11/23/11) - Diners Near Me - Millbrook, New York

See all

"When you need an Anchor for your gut from late night partying, come to the Mill brook Diner!" Warning: If you ask for cheese on your eggs, it will be a Square or two! read more

Always had a nice meal there. Every time I go it makes me think of my father-in-law. He loved it their.

Overpriced, average food. I just paid over 15 bucks for a not terribly big, not terribly fresh greek salad with chicken to go. Unfortunately this is probably my favorite greek salad anywhere around here, so they've got me. Can't say much about the remainder of the food. The fries are good, the rest of what I have tried is uneventful. The staff are always nice and responsive. read more

Millbrook Diner - Not so fresh - Diners Near Me - Millbrook, New York