Mitchell's Mex is emphatically and unapologetically *not* Taco Rico. If you're looking for camarones a la diabla or menudo, Mitchell's Mex is not for you. If, on the other hand, you'd like some really well-put-together Mexican *fusion* fast food... Mitchell's does an outstanding job. Crispy wraps with just the right proportions of veggies and meat, crispy fish tacos... yum. Heat is limited to jalapeno level (salsa picante? wuzzat?..), but it all works. Decor, for a fast food place, is tasteful and modern. Front-of-store staff clearly believe in what they do, and after my first (likely of many) visits there, so do I. read more

I had been waiting months for Mitchell's Mex to open, and after my first visit today I can say that it definitely exceeded my expectations. The building is unique, both inside and out. The menu is unique, and it is only the soft opening menu. The extremely friendly explained that the real menu will be twice as big. I ordered a Grilled Frito Burrito with queso and dang sauce, and a side of queso and chips. The burrito was huge, and stuffed with tasty ingredients. Queso was smooth and just a little spicy, and the texture was just right- not too thin or too thick. Every item on the menu can be prepared vegetarian or vegan. The interior was very attractive, with bright colors and interesting decor. There were several tvs with sports on some and cartoons on the other. Large floor-to-ceiling windows provided natural light. The employees were all extremely friendly and helpful. How refreshing to find employees who truly care about their customers and ensure that they provide a good experience. The restaurant was very busy at 3 pm, so I am guessing it is packed at lunch and dinner time. There will be a drive thru but it doesn't appear to be open yet. Planning to return soon. It will take some time to work my way through even the temporary "soft open " menu. read more

See all

Great quick Mexican place! The food is excellently seasoned and the portion sizes are on point for the price. Service is quick and friendly. read more

I love this location so much. As a vegetarian there are lots of yummy options!! Shout out to the employees!! I wish I knew their names, because every time I go to the drive-thru the girls are always so sweet to me. They are always so quick to correct any mistakes with your order too. read more

Great food and friendly employees, best Pepsi in town. We eat there at least once a week.

I've driven by here several times, but today I finally went inside. Everything looked clean & squared away, inside & out. There is a good selection on the menu & the prices aren't bad. The staff was friendly & knowledgable as well. I got the wet burrito with shrimp. It was outstanding! One of the best I've had in a long time! It was filled with ingredients & the hot stuff was hot & cold stuff was cold! That actually surprised me because most places it seems that everything is just warm. It was covered with a really good portion of queso, too. I am really glad that I finally stopped here & will definitely be back!! read more

We love Mitchell's Mex! The service, the food is always fantastic! The chili lime salad and the steak quesadilla are my favorites!!

We love Mitchell's! I like the atmosphere in Lafayette as well. Queso burrito and dang quesadillas are favs

I've never posted a third update but this most recent visit demands this one star upgrade. Finally I have found a menu item to get excited about. The Queso Frito Crunch Salad. Shredded lettuce topped with diced tomatoes, corn, black beans, queso, and Chili Fritos. I choose the house made avocado ranch dressing that is creamy and flavorful. I ordered mine with chicken and it was somewhat lost in the salad. There should have been more for the price. Besides that misstep the salad is delicious and left me wanting more. read more

Mitchell's Mex - Interesting exterior design includes cacti! - Tex-Mex Near Me - Lafayette, Indiana

See all

Initial reaction - do not love the menu/the design/the options/the fonts. It's messy and and we'll organized. We ordered kids meals, nachos, one burrito, guac and drinks. And it was pretty expensive. The burrito was small but had good flavors. The guac was good but also very small. Kids meals are a good deal and kids enjoyed it. The wraps looked pretty good. I'm interested in trying that next time. I would have recommended them to include chips and salsa with all their meals. read more

Mitchell's Mex - Mugs burrito - Tex-Mex Near Me - Lafayette, Indiana

See all

I was impressed with the use of Fresh ingredients meats veggie and tortillas. Quick service and friendly staff enhanced this experience would try again read more

This restaurant will advertise to you by grabbing your email from the name on your credit card. You don't even have to give them your name or email, they will find it through their SquareSpace vendor and harass you with emails and advertisements. Plus, the food is over-priced, over salted, and takes too long to come out. I wish they'd put up a Moe's or even a Chipotle instead. At least then the food would be better quality and even cheaper, surprisingly. read more

I'm a big fan of Mitchell's. It's not cheap, but the food is always fresh and good quality. Check out the menu before you go, as it can be very overwhelming. Ate inside today and it was very clean, cute, and they even checked on us. Overall, give this place a shot. Expect good Tex Mex with an Indiana flair. read more

Mitchell's Mex - Bowl with sauces on side. Dang sauce is a must! - Tex-Mex Near Me - Lafayette, Indiana

See all

We absolutely love Mitchells!! The dang and original queso are two of our favorites!! The ambiance is great! The customer service is the best!!! read more

The Grilled Frito burrito is HUGE. I ordered a medium salsa and chips. Went through the drive thru, it's open now and set up kind of like chick fil a drive thru. Checked my order and they charged me for a queso instead of salsa. And gave me queso. I let them know at the window that I ordered salsa, not queso. And they gave me a refund for the queso. The manager Josh gave me free ice cream for the inconvenience and they gave me the salsa I ordered. Food was great. Couldn't finish it all. But my favorite thing was the customer service. Can't wait to keep coming back. read more

Mitchell's Mex - Medium salsa - Tex-Mex Near Me - Lafayette, Indiana

A $7 burrito not much bigger than a soft taco is absurd. Parking is difficult with a weird parking layout and congested entrance. Flavors decent but quantity for price is out of line. Tried one of their wet burritos to go in the past and was like paste by the time I ate it which was just 5 minutes after it was picked up. This is fast food at better dining prices. read more

Absolutely not. My first visit and they mess up my order. I was given chicken instead of cheese for my quesadilla, and chicken instead of beef for my burrito. Went back to get the order fixed. Upon receiving my order for the 2nd time, they did not give me the sour cream that's supposed to come with my quesadilla. The chips I got were stale as well. The beef had way too much seasoning in my opinion. Saying they can replace anything to make it gluten free is a bit of a stretch. I ordered a gluten free burrito which turned into 3 corn tortilla tacos. My gluten free quesadilla was 3 tiny corn tortilla quesadillas (which that was ok.) The only thing that tasted good was the queso, but my stomach hurt very quickly after eating. The only reason I'm giving a second star is because the manager was kind and understanding with my husband when he did the food swap. If I try this place again, I hope they do much better. read more

Mitchell's Mex - Quesadilla - Tex-Mex Near Me - Lafayette, Indiana

See all

Huge let down. Food was barely warm had no flavor. I'm from Texas and this is not Tex Mex. We shared a quesadilla and I had a chicken burrito while my wife had the quesso burrito and she said it was decent. That's the only reason it's not a 1 out of 5. read more

See all

I now understand why all the surrounding fast food establishments hold such negative customer service reviews; everyone with great customer service skills works at Mitchell's. The ambiance is welcoming and spacious, the food was diligently prepared in accordance with my requests, I received it in an incredibly timely manner considering the location was packed. Mitchell's has become a staple to Lafayette in record-breaking time for good reason! read more

I had a wrap and it was good but the inside was cold. It's supposed to be a hot wrap.

Get the muggs burrito! It was delicious, especially with beans and rice both. Cassidy took our order and had so much patience as we figured out what we wanted. She had great recommendations too. We will definitely be back!!! read more

This was the first time I have ever came here. My friend and I decided to get lunch together and try this place, since it's directly across from campus. We were greeted with a smile from Josh, who we found out later is the front end manager. We asked his suggestions and he gave several! We actually decided to go with the ones he suggested and it was SO YUMMY (ground beef incredibowl). As we were periodically eating and doing an assignment, Josh came by to refill our drinks and throw our trash away- I thought that was so sweet. He really was a great example of customer service. I hope his superiors see this and reward him accordingly. We will definitely be back again! read more

So we didn't know what to expect. Would it be like Moe's, Chipotle, or Qdoba? Nope, it's unique. I would say it has 3 differences: 1) they don't make the food in front of you 2) it's like a fast food full service restaurant as they give you a buzzer and bring the food to you. 3) it's high quality, lots of options, I would guess there are a million possible options! That means that you can choose meat, sauce, type of cheese, etc. and the menu has a lot of choices! The ambience and seating is upscale fast food, maybe like Wendy's or Arby's? For those who don't like spicy, the chicken ranch wrap was delicious! The dang sauce was pretty good, hard to describe, a brownish sweet sriracha maybe? Everything was good read more

I worked in Delphi for years and enjoyed the original Mitchell's hut downtown. After leaving that job I sadly missed out on my almost daily Mitchell's run. My wife and I were in town and I remembered a new location opened so I zipped over and grabbed my favorite (and now wife's favorite) CBR wrap! It was as good as I remember and potentially better than before! Service is always 5 stars. read more

Mitchell's Mex - Tex-Mex Near Me - Lafayette, Indiana

Great service and quick wait for food! Definitely trying again :) Glad to see a great local option for quick lunch or dinner read more

first, this does Not taste the same as the Delphi location. I was so excited for them to becoming to Lafayette permanently but was kinda disappointed. Got the spicy mitchi like normal but wasn't hot, no sauce, and no tostada. Same with the second one we ordered. Then, we orders chips and queso. Didn't get that in the order. Sad day. Hopefully this is the new open blues. Probably will stick to the Delphi location only. :( read more

First time trying the new Mitchell's. Large menu, lots to choose from. Prices seemed a bit steep. I ordered a taco salad. All ingredients were present as advertised, however it was 91% lettuce, the other 9% made up the cheese, tomatoes, chips, and ground beef. The tomatoes were a tiny pile in the middle of the salad and the ground beef had to be dug for to find it's existence. It comes with either sour cream, dressing, OR salsa. I ordered the dressing but asked for salsa as well (it is a "taco" "salad" ). I was disappointed to learn that the mini 2 oz cup of salsa that was just over half full was an additional .75. Won't make that mistake again. Staff was nice. Food taste was average but would I ever get the taco salad again? ..never, not even for 1/2 the price. Will I ever eat here again? At this point, will wait for some better reviews. read more

I ordered a chicken and cheese quesadilla with rice on the side, and it was really good!! I would definitely order it again.

Food was so yummy. Portion size was very large, even have enough for another meal. Service was remarkable. Josh was extremely helpful and courteous. Will be back for sure. read more

As "authentic " as Taco Bell but three times as expensive. Staff is polite and professional. The rest of Lafayette could learn from their work standard. read more

Ok food but I have never been to a Mexican restaurant that charges for taco sauce and water.

First time going to this place and the service is outstanding. Drove in to pick up a lemonade and they were just going to open, the gentleman who took my order was all smiles and very pleasant. He didn't care he had to fill the lemonade dispenser to grab my drink. I'm just saying it felt good to be served with a smile right at start up. read more

The food tasted like expensive taco bell, but not as good as Taco Bell. The flavors are not balanced and all mush together. The items purchased were the sriracha mitchi (chicken) which was advertised as a "favorite" and "best seller". It tasted like it was all sauce and rice. The shrimp tacos had mushy shrimp and only 3 pieces per taco. The speaker didn't work, so after staff tried to ring us up outside, they couldn't get a connection and we had to be re-rung up at the window. They also ask for a tip on the screen for having placed a drive-through order. read more

I ordered the nachos plate, and according to the drive through order taker it's the big one. It was tiny and was 90 percent beans. To top it off, the order taker guilted me into a tip for her 30 seconds of helping me. And I had to tell her three times not to put rice on it. The food is horrible, the service is horrible and I paid 12.50 (no drink) for something that I could have gotten at taco bell for half the price. I will never visit this place again. read more