Every time I eat here I have a great time the food is perfect and its always consistent ive never had a bad Mac.

All I have to say is OMGGGGGG!! Best Mac and Cheese I have ever had.. We ordered The Crazy Whitey and Philly Cheesesteak.. Full of flavor and cheesy goodness!! Also got the Bacon Balls... Yummmmm!!! Service was fast and friendly. We will definitely be back to try out the other flavors!! read more

First time here and definitely will come back!Awesome Mac &cheese. Very satisfied and cute atmosphere

Excellent service and the best mac ricotta balls around. Nice place to sit and eat inside or outside.

Awesome gf food. Service is always decent if not very good. However easily gets backed up at time and runs very behind

i love the mac and cheese here but please get better employees. the girl at the counter: name on ticket was Hall, was incredibly rude and refused to give me a discount that i had earned (10% off, like seriously you're going to make it an issue to not give me $1 off my mac balls?) after i ordered she and her coworker (a larger sized blonde girl) were pointing and looking at me in the back the whole time i ate. will be looking elsewhere before coming here again only due to the service up front. however, management was helpful when i let them know about this incident and was prompt in their response. thank you for that. read more

Awesome mac and cheese! Tons of options and a super friendly staff. Its kind of pricey and the wait time is kind of crappy. They might tell you 10 minutes when ive found myself waiting a half hour....but i always keep coming back anyway. Its really good. read more

The scampi mac is my fav! Love coming here when I'm craving mac & cheese. It's a little bit of a wait but it's only because it's a small space and they are so popular. The food is fresh and so good. read more

Food lacked flavor with limited seating. Too similar and a rip off of the already established s'mac restaurant in east village and first ave. I just figured if you were going to do a repeat of a restaurant they would have some nice recipe's and food, but I was extremely disappointed. Food sucked and idea unoriginal leads to a bad score and a non returning customer. P.S.I don't know what these other people are on because stouffers mac n cheese tastes better than this. So if you want to a better tasting mac and cheese with a better price just pick up some at the grocery store and mix what ever you want in it you'll save more money that way. I wish they had refunds for crap food.:( read more

If you are craving Mac n Cheese, this is the place to go. I enjoyed it. I really liked the Mac n Cheese balls with cranberry. However, if you don't want Mac n Cheese, then of course this is not the place for you. read more

The fried mac n cheese balls are a great snack with a nice, tangy sauce (ask for extra as it's crucial to the flavor profile). The actual mac and cheese is interesting to experiment with the various flavors but won't replace any good family recipes anytime soon. read more

This place is amazing!!! From the fried mac balls to the Mac and cheese to there salads!!!

I tried this place out yesterday and was pleasantly surprised. It's a relatively new addition to the area and I must say, a very welcome and unique one. We ordered the fried mac & cheese to start. It was fantastic: wonderfully cheesy, tasty and crunchy. The tomato cream sauce it comes with was a great compliment to the fried mac & cheese but it's not absolutely necessary--it stands up just great on its own. I decided to create my own mac n' cheese combination with chicken cutlet, mozzarella, broccoli and parmesan. It was just the right amount of flavor and gooeyness--the ingredients went really well together and it was the perfect comfort food for a Saturday afternoon. It comes with breadcrumbs on top (I think all the combinations do?) which added to the crunch factor, but next time I think I might ask for them on the side so I can add (or not add) them myself. I didn't realize til we got home that they have dessert options, so next time I'll definitely save room for that. I can't wait to go back and try out the rest of the menu. I hope this place sticks around! read more

OMG delish!! Hot creamy gooey perfection!! A satisfying lunch for a chilly day!! I did the Mix it your way with American Cheddar, broccoli, cauliflower & shrimp -- will definitely be back!! read more

Best place in n Orange County for mac & cheese. Whenever we are in Middletown this is our "go to" place. Everything is always delicious and we have never had anything off the menu that we have not enjoyed. Great good, friendly staff and always worth the 30 minute drive! read more

Love the mac and cheese! The only thing that makes me not want to come back is the countdown to Obama leaving office counter. I know that will make some people really happy, however, you will lose people as well. Businesses should know better than to offend people with personal feelings about politics, that is business 101. read more

Just happened to see a coupon for this place in the local Clipper magazine, and contacted a friend about it who confirmed just how good it is (surprised I hadn't heard about it by now, as it's been open well over a year). Took another friend from out of town to Mix N Mac over the weekend, and we both really enjoyed it. I HUGE variety of different mac n cheese recipes, plus a 'mix & make your own' selection, all reasonably priced and served in large portions. You can even take any of the recipes and have them make a 'melt' for you, which is basically the cheese and the rest of the ingredients (sans the pasta) in a grilled cheese format-I had this with the shrimp scampi...quite tasty, and comes with a tomato cream dipping sauce. My friend had the Cuban mac n cheese special, which was loaded with raost pork, ham, different kinds of cheeses, and a touch of mustard. Yes, it tasted like a Cuban sandwich, only it was mac n cheese! We also had some bacon cheesy balls (little mac n cheese balls with bacon, breaded and deep friend) which were delicious. It's a lot of food, and not on the light side, but for something off the beaten path and quite tasty, it was $25 well spent and I'll be back for sure. read more

My rating is solely based on customer service. In my opinion, the way one is treated by the business owner, is equally, if not more important to the quality of food in a restaurant experience. read more

friendly, clean, great menu, mouthwatering mac-n-cheese options... the owner is (at times) making the food for you.. i mean really? you get that at McDonald's?? Middletown could use a few- no a lot more places like this. oh-- they also have Joe's Tea!! i loved it. I already recommended it to a few friends and i will go back SOON. Thanks Michelle. read more

This place is amazing!! I am a student away at school and my first stop when I get home is Mix N Mac. They have so many options and every single one is delicious. I never leave disappointed! I wish they had more locations! read more

Definitely get the Mac and cheese balls. They're so delicious. You also have the choice of mixing them up. I highly recommend the bacon and cheese balls. They are so tasty and full of flavor. The cranberry balls were alright. I wish there were more cranberry taste to it because the tomato sauce and cheese overpowered the berry taste. If they used a cranberry flavored cheese, it would be perfect. read more

Discovered this gem this afternoon. Many delicious variations on macaroni and cheese. They also have gluten free pasta available -- such a treat! And the mac and cheese balls, super yummy. read more

Great Mac and cheese varieties. 15 or so different kinds plus specials and pick your own. Mexi is a favorite. Spicy but not too much. Kids love it too as expected. Plan to wait about 10 minutes while it bakes. Enjoy! read more

Went with my family, 5 people, spent $60. Way too much cheese on top, but good overall flavor. Would recommend the spinach/artichoke. But also had the regular "American" mac and cheese with bacon and it was awful. Think something was "off". Staff offered to make a new one and were very pleasant but we didn't want to take our chances. read more

The Buffalo Chicken Mac is amazing. Went there for during a lunch break a few month back and Loved the food so much

It is good Mac & Cheese. Then again, how hard is it to make Mac & Cheese? I make it at home just as good, maybe better for a lot less money. I feel sorry for those who never knew what Mac & Cheese is SUPPOSED to taste like! Middletown needs some cooking lessons! read more

Now this is the place to eat in Middletown! Everything I've had has been delicious. Insanely amazing Mac n cheese!

My wife and I were up in Middletown visiting friends the other day and we were drawn to Mix n Mac partly due to unique name and us being fiends for some mac and cheese . We were both blown away by the experience . I had the pepperoni mac balls and buffalo mac and cheese plate, my wife had the veggie mac and cheese plate. Needless to say we were very happy with our choice. We recommended our friends to go to Mix n Mac and they loved it too! The aura in Mix n Mac is warm and laid back. We will be visiting our friends again very soon, because we want more Mix n Mac! I hope the owners open a Mix n Mac in Westchester County. read more

The mac n cheese options here are incredible. They have a wide variety of ingredients and you can even build your own mac n cheese. They also have gluten free, vegetarian and whole grain options. The staff also made for a great dining experience. read more

So glad I finally tried this place. I never knew mac and cheese could come in so many varieties and be so delicious. Everything is made fresh every day and the owners are genuine, nice people. My new favorite restaurant, I tell everyone to go try it. read more

I'm not one to leave reviews. In fact this might be the first review I've ever left a company and created a yelp account just to do so. Me and my boyfriend were came in from out of town for the weekend and after a long day we were tired and didn't really feel like going out for dinner. Saw this place on yelp, and wow is it amazing! Quick delivery and the food taste great! Definitely recommend. The Sriracha Honey Mac is so good! read more

Delicious!!!! Always creative creations! Love the quality of the food and the friendly fun atmosphere!!!

Innovative! Concept is great. Would like a bit more bang on the flavor profiles. We had cheeseburger and shrimp scampi. Would try other flavors and balls in the future. read more

i went there twice wirh a. Friend the food was really good the second time we went we. both had gotten sick from it a huge disappointment for a. Mac and cheese lover read more

The Mac N' Cheese is really tasty, and the options are great and everything tastes freshly made. The price is quite expensive for take out Mac N' Cheese which is the reason for the 3-star rating. Expect to pay $50+ to feed a family of five. read more

I love this place!!!! I go at least once a week. I love the different varieties of ingredients and flavors they incorporate. I also love the fact that they have so many different drinks I've never seen before and the Iced Teas are great. read more

Its alright i've ate here a few times and my complain is that my food is never hot enough. service is alright and prices are a little high.

Amazing food for the price. I've had the Chipotle Chicken meal numerous times (as both a mac and a melt), and I'll order it again the next time I go. The staff is always friendly, the place is always at a nice temperature, and there is always some good music playing. This will most likely be the best mac and cheese you've ever eaten! read more

The food blew me away! I ordered shrimp scampi m&c and it was fabulous - creamy, cheesy, tasty, lots of shrimp and whole wheat pasta (much prefer that to white flour). Pleased to see gluten-free available for those who require it. My daughter ordered the bacon ranch and it was also great. Went during a quiet time (1:30pm Tues. afternoon) and had fun chatting with the friendly owners and their son. The decor leaves a bit to be desired, but hey - this isn't fine dining, it's mac and cheese! Can't wait to go back. read more

Went here for the first time today and got the cheese burger Mac and cheese and it was great! Will come back for sure!