Pros: -Huge menu…read more-Good, consistent food -Servers have always been nice -Quick seating when not a special day (Mother's/Father's Day/etc.) Cons: -Crowded on special days There are a few things on this menu that have never let me down (knock on wood) and they are: Turkey Avocado BLT - the homemade focaccia hoagie brings this home in a big way! Great Morning Wrap - always has the right ratio of ingredients so you get a little of everything in each bite. PRO TIP: ask for an extra side of the chipotle mayo. Other things that we have tried and enjoyed: Chicken Dumpling Soup -- always recommended by those who have tried it. Steak and Eggs - good portion for the price and well seasoned. Eggs Benedict - really rich hollandaise sauce, and the fresh arugala balances well against that richness. This is one of my wife's favs. Biscuits & Gravy - this definitely ranges, better sometimes vs. others,but that range is great (4.5*) to good (3.5*). It just depends on the day that you go I have probably eaten at Maxim's 12-15 times and have never had an unsatisfying experience. I am sure that they will treat you right too!

Adorable restaurant located in a building that is adjacent to the railroad in Oconomowoc. Decorated…read morewith railway decor. We were seated immediately, and service was good. We ordered a few different things for lunch. The French onion soup was very salty, but the brisket sandwich that they had on the menu was amazing. The brisket was like butter. I had a large Cobb salad, which some of the things in it tasted very chemical like. The lettuce and the cucumbers, especially had some strange chemical taste. Slightly acidic. I can't put my finger on it. I would not recommend. All in all, if you're looking for a place for brunch while you're in Oconomowoc, you might wanna stop in here just for an experience once. I don't know that we will be back, but you never know. I will say there is a large variety across three menus. So somebody should be able to find something that they like.

Pine Cone is a classic no-frills roadside diner with large portions and a fantastic bakery case. It…read morecan get busy and loud inside but the tables are spaced out pretty well. Service was quick and the waitstaff was super friendly. The location makes it a great spot to catch up with friends between the Madison and Milwaukee areas. Parking is easy and it is right off the interstate. The food was good and portions were massive, you'll definitely get your money's worth here. Everyone took food home. The bakery is the true star of the show. The cases are packed with tons of options. They had cream puffs and eclairs the size of my head. Everyone raves about the cinnamon rolls and I have to agree. It was huge, fluffy, and perfect for sharing.

Second time visiting the pine cone. This has become a great little pit stop for us. I still can't…read moreget over how we can eat for 2 for under $20 and still eat good! The waitress's are always so sweet and the food comes out quick, hot and fresh!

Great breakfast place! Seated as soon as we walked in. Hot coffee and water before we even looked…read moreat the menu. Not fancy but very comfortable setting, we felt like we were in someone's kitchen. I had 2 eggs medium, toast and home fries. Eggs were cooked perfectly and the home fries were amazing! The staff was super friendly and we felt like they could be family. 10/10

Top notch service and food to match! We've had breakfast here several times and the experience is…read moreconsistently great!

Nostalgic interior and familiar, the best milk makes the best ice cream. Tin roof sundaes the way…read moreit's supposed to be. I do miss my sign about asking about free ice cream yesterday, but still like the idea 20 degrees below zero outside and you get a free scoop! Friendly staff, always a stop in Watertown. Priced perfectly for a day trip in rural Wisconsin.

I've been here a few times throughout my time living in this area. The ice cream is always good (if…read moreyou like Malts, their chocolate malts are delicious) and I absolutely love the environment of the shop. They have good outdoor seating as well during the summer time. The only downside is that there isn't a lot of space inside but it's a small town so it's to be expected. The service is always pretty decent, nothing to note on that! The food on the other hand hasn't ever been my favorite. The Mac and cheese is basically glorified under seasoned Kraft mac and cheese. I tried a burger recently and it had too much ketchup and mustard on it which made it was hard to eat. The cheese curds are okay but aren't very crispy. Overall, everything is pretty overpriced. It costed me over $16 for a chocolate Malt and a small burger with no side or anything in a small town. Overall, it's definitely a fun spot for a sweet treat with friends but if you're looking for a good bite to eat, I would suggest heading 12 minutes away to Johnson Creek and go to Pinecone or to the Diner downtown if it's open.

This restaurant has a cozy bar and a couch by the entrance. A second home for early-bird-drinkers…read moreand folks looking to cure a hangover. The food and beverages are ok. I specially liked that they provided a carafe of coffee (this is how it should always be). My husband didn't like the iced tea. He said that it tasted like it was made the day before. It looked funny, too. The service was good. We'll be happy to give it another try.

Stopped in for lunch on Friday. Their menu drew me in with creative entrees and the fact they have…read morea full bar (which is hard to find at times at breakfast places). I sat at the bar which sits in the middle of two dining areas. Since it was lunch, I opted for a reuben and a cup of chowder. In retrospect, I should've went with a breakfast entree as the sandwich was just ok. I felt the chowder was lacking of any clams and depth of flavor. My server was super friendly which raises the review by a star. Definitely will be back as I like the menu-here's to hoping a better meal will be had.

Sherwood Family Restaurant is a small place right next to the McDonald's and across the street from…read morethe Piggly Wiggly. It looks a bit worn down, but the food was good and the prices were great. My wife, daughter and I had breakfast for $26 before tip. The servers were friendly too.

i ordered an blt rap and there was a hair inside of it... no big deal but cmon, are you not using…read morehair nets??

I grew up going to first watch in another state, so having one so close to home is so exciting. We…read morehave been there twice now and it's so good! The food is delish, the staff is kind and efficient, the coffee is great. The only negative is a long wait at times or and the small parking lot during peak hours.

I picked up a to go order last Sunday afternoon & their system forced a minimum of 18% gratuity as…read moreif I were dining in the restaurant which is absurd, I typically tip 5-8% for a to go order since they aren't doing anything for me except bagging it & shouldn't be forced to tip considering they're doing nothing but bagging it after the paid chef team cooks it. Food was good but much smaller portions than other local breakfast places. I had a Bloody Mary while waiting & that was delicious. I didn't mind the forced 18% minimum tip on my drink because he served me there. I definitely will never go back for takeout unless they remove the minimum tip of 18% on carry out orders.

Stopped here last night on a motorcycle ride cuz I'd heard nothing but good things about the place…read more I was SORELY disappointed! First, the place is cash only...had to find an ATM nearby before we could even order. We couldn't order at the counter ourselves, and had to wait for a one of the car hop girls to take our order. It was busy, so we expected to wait a bit. Ordered a cheeseburger with ketchup, brat, 2 orders of fries, a vanilla shake and a chocolate shake. Food shows up after 15 minutes, and the bill is just over $28. They forgot the brat, the burger was only as thick as the slice of unmelted cheese on it, and was drenched in ketchup...slid apart as soon as I picked it up. Fries were okay, shakes were pretty good. All said and done, nothing to get excited about. We'll probably never be back. Overpriced, not great food. Save your money and go someplace else.

I think the vanilla frozen custard is some of the best I've ever had. It tastes like they use…read morevanilla bean instead of just vanilla. It was thick and creamy (and dreamy)! My flurry was huuuuge--just how I like it. The deluxe sundaes were extremely large, and absolutely picture perfect. We stopped in about 20 minutes to close and they were happy to serve us still. (Given, we were only looking for custard and not a full meal.) The service was fast and friendly. They did turn the lights off about 10 minutes after close. The place itself is super cute. The menu seems pretty varied. I can't wait to go back!