Loved the traffic light system! You have to wait outside until the light is green. The building is smaller so this definitely helped to create a nicer less rushed relaxing experience inside of what would otherwise be tight uncomfortable conditions. The ice cream itself was delightful! I loved the variety of flavors and cone options. Parking is tight but just a street over is tons of public parking available. The staff were friendly and efficient. The decor was cute and fun. We would absolutely come back! There's an awesome restaurant on the side (porch we didn't try the other one) and a boutique across the street! read more

Moo Cow is a must-stop on St. Simons Island! The ice cream is incredible--honestly, there isn't a flavor you won't like. Fun vibe and friendly staff make it even better. The shop is tiny inside, so be sure to wait until the entrance light turns green before going in. Perfect after the beach or a walk through the village. We'll definitely be back! read more

See all

I went here on a Friday night. at first, I was kind of surprised that they were only letting one person in at a time and they had a traffic light at the door. The menu was outside. I decided on red velvet ice cream. when I went inside, it looked better than I expected. I got served quick by the staff. The ice cream tasted great much better than expected. Huge chunks of red velvet cake. seating options were great parking was very easy to find. The staff were very, very friendly. read more

Moo Cow Cream - Red Velvet ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Simons Island, Georgia

Overpriced ice cream. It's supposed to be homemade but doesn't taste like it. Ice cream is average. I tried the cookie dough ice cream and it was not creamy or milky at all. I wish it had a more vanilla and cream flavor. Service was average. The shoppe is small and only a few people fit inside. read more

Cute little place. Not a lot of options and a little pricey. But the service was great and friendly. Ice cream was tasty... just nothing out of the ordinary. read more

Moo Cow Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Simons Island, Georgia

See all

Had the apple strudel in a waffle cone. Very good. There was a long line but the red light where the line starts has the menu posted so you can start thinking about what you want before you get inside the (small) business. read more

I'm trying to look for a positive in this review to start with. I would say it's conveniently located after a beach day. The outside seating is ample, but other than that...This shop caters to one customer at a time. You have to wait for the light to turn green before entering. You need to know your order by the time you walk in, which would be helpful with better signage. The scoopers expect you to know your order and quickly -and I mean quickly move on. The small chalkboard outside was hard to read and confusing. The ice cream options are limited, they ran out of the one I wanted and most of the tubs had freezer burn on them. I opted for a raspberry sorbet because of it. Want a cone? Expect to pay $1.50 on top of your single scoop price of $5! Definitely overpriced for what you get. Also, I'm still not sure what's homemade and what's not. read more

Great ice cream! There was a line out the door with a cute traffic light to signal when people could enter the small store. The Insta Graham flavor was great and everyone in my group enjoyed their ice cream. This shop is a great complement to the many restaurants in the area read more

Yummy experience, but maybe not worth the price? 3 ice creams for $22 was quite the shock to pay, but I'm always down to shell out good money for a quality item. While yummy, it definitely wasn't the best ice cream I've ever had. But hey, I still say give it a go! They did have some interesting "in house" flavors in addition to their regular menu, like curry and a lavender flavor. Be prepared for long lines! Thankfully, we went right on the cusp of a thunderstorm, so we only had about 3 groups in front of us. They utilize a stoplight method to let you know when you can enter inside to order, as it's pretty tiny overall. read more

I loved this cut ice cream shop, it was delicious and they had funny signs all over the place.

I didn't take any pictures because it would've melted way too fast! I didn't give it five stars just because they only allow one group inside at a time because it's a very small place. I want to say I can understand, but when people are standing outside in the heat, waiting to get in side, they should have a better system instead of using that garage area that they have open for junk, maybe people could wait inside there with fans running or something. There was a group that must've stayed inside eating leaving several people outside waiting g because all of them came out with half of their cones. As far as the ice cream, I wanted to get the Mojito that was listed under the homemade flavors, but I didn't get much of a flavor from it from the sample he gave me. My husband and I both got the chocolate pecan (also a homemade flavor), which was an extremely tasty chocolate, completely packed with nicely sized pecans. The kid working inside was great and keeping up with all the people and having a great attitude. read more

My friends and I visited after eating dinner at Porch next door. There was a line at the door, so we waited for the light in front of the shop to turn green so it would be our turn to enter the shop. There is a menu outside of the shop with a list of flavors and other items they offer besides ice cream. When we were able to enter the small shop, we ordered what we wanted before paying. I chose a small cup of salted caramel ice cream, which was plenty of ice cream for me. It was easy to pay with my phone and go back outside to sit down at one of the many tables. We ate our ice cream and watched lots of people come to eat ice cream after dinner. You could hear live music in the distance, and kids were running around playing. It was a festive and relaxing atmosphere. I'm glad we visited! The ice cream was delicious, creamy, and full of flavor. read more

Stopped by this past Sunday around 2:00 PM & we didn't have to wait thankfully. Ice cream was good, but not wow or the best. Didn't taste homemade but it was still good to enjoy on a hot day! Prices are okayish, I paid $5ish for a small cup which I think is a bit overpriced. read more

Moo Cow Cream - Outside sign - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Simons Island, Georgia

Their servings are huge! This photo is a kiddie cup. The single scoop is massive and all the flavors are delish! read more

Moo Cow Cream - I got mint chocolate chip - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Simons Island, Georgia

We love this little ice cream shop. We stop by once every couple weeks for a quick little dessert after dinner. The staff are always super cordial and nice. They also have a pretty decent variety of flavors. The best place in town for a little treat. read more

It's really small area you walk in order and leave. It was raining so they were nice enough to have a tent over the door so we didn't get wet. They only allowed one party in at a time which was fine but I got a double lemon sorbet and I didn't think it was worth the $7 price tag read more

See all

Best ice cream on St. Simons, always go to Moo Cow when there. Really good creamy. Great flavors. Little tiny place with great big ice cream. Sometimes you will find a line but that just tells you how good the ice cream is. read more

Service - 5/5 Service was prompt and person was friendly. I was able to get samples of ice cream I've never had before. (Rosewater). Ice cream is hand made. Food - 5/5 Food was amazing and hit the spot on a hot summer day. Options are more limited compared to other ice cream places. Allergy - there is a sign posted that they can't guarantee that food may come in contact with allergens. Environment / Ambiance - 3/5 they only have outside seating some shaded. Space is somewhat confined inside. LGBTQ+ Rating - 2/5 There is no safe place sticker or support materials at this location. Me and my partner had no issues at this location. Would Be Back / Would Recommend I would definitely go back and recommend to others. read more

So very overpriced. And no indoor seating. And no ambience. Ice cream is so-so sadly. If you are looking for a cute ice cream parlour, keep looking. Also I think the cheapest ice cream is about $7 read more

The ice cream is PHENOMENAL. we had the rose saffron, honey lavender, fireball and chocolate. Omg. I want to drive back just to get more of it! read more

Will be a bit of a line . Worth it for a fresh waffle cone with crazy cookie dough flavor ( cake batter base w sugar cookie dough ) and a scoop of Cookie Monster ( lotta cookies colored blue like Cookie obv!) so yummy read more

Cute place, very small - need to wait outside for each group. Ice cream was good, we also had Savannah Pops which was a nice option for gluten free (some) and nut free. read more

As I entered, the employee told me that I had to wait outside until the group she was serving left. It was literally 90 degrees outside and no shade in sight. I don't want ice cream that badly. read more

Ice cream and sorbet were delicious, efficient service as patrons wait their turn for ordering. Only suggestion would be to have more nondairy options. As hot as it is, the heavy cream can be difficult. read more

Moo Cow Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Simons Island, Georgia

See all

Delicious ice cream! We got the cookies and cream, and the espresso chip on sugar cones. Yummmm.

Honey lavender and Georgia peach ice cream. Remember,ndessert goes to the heart, not the stomach since ice cream cheers you up when feeling you're up and down. Moo Cow Cream https://yelp.to/EGPixeheBpb #Brunswick #Georgia read more

Moo Cow Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Simons Island, Georgia

See all

Definitely some of the best ice cream you can get in the area. We went twice while we were in town which accounted for 50% of our days. There was a line both nights and it's odd that they only let one group at a time in the store but it's worth the wait. The sea turtle was extremely popular. They also had a side of odd flavors which we did not try. I had the birthday cake with sugar cookie dough in it one night and cookie dough the second night. Both excellent. Definitely a must stop by if you are in the area. read more

Yummy ice cream... just the line was super long when we went. Price is little pricey. read more

If you have a sweet tooth this is the ice cream shop for you. A lot of fun flavors (my favorite is salted caramel brownie) and the most generous scoops I've ever seen read more

Stopped by for a little dessert. I'm a traditionalist, so of course I ordered the hot fudge sundae! The ice-cream was good, and it was well made. The young lady behind the counter was very friendly. There are picnic tables outside, so good for families. read more

Moo Cow Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Simons Island, Georgia

Wife and I just had dinner and we were looking for a place to go for our sweet tooth. This place is close to the main area in SSI so we decided to stop on by. It was saturday night, so the lone was out the door(this place is fairly small) After waiting for about 15-20 minutes we finally get inside... we are surprised because there was only one person working that night! Younger kid behind the counter working his butt off to get ice cream to all these people. He told us that the other person that was supposed to he there with him was a no show... poor kid! He did a great job, however, and he was still upbeat and not stressing out. 5 stars goes out to this young man. Oh.... the ice cream was really good too! read more

Really good home made tasting ice cream. They have all your favorites and some wacky flavors that change all the time. Today when I went they have chocolate diablo, apple jack, and others. They seem to always be busy but the line moves fast. The is no indoor seating but plenty on benches, and tables outside. read more

Moo Cow Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Simons Island, Georgia

Overpriced and weird employees. Their ice cream is so generic and overpriced. It's literally the generic Mayfield kind. Not even homemade. The ice cream costs about $5 including tax which is a total rip-off for a small cup of nasty cream. The employees are really passive aggressive, and not even wearing masks or enforcing social distancing during a pandemic. Stay away. read more

Moo Cow Cream - Outside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Simons Island, Georgia

Came in today and they have lots of strange flavors plus the usuals. The lady that served us was very nice and they are following Covid guidelines at this time. I went with the spumoni and my boyfriend got the Butter Pecan. There are tables outside to sit at. read more

See all

Nice small ice cream shop. Excellent hand made ice cream. I had strawberry which was delicious. Outdoor seating. Parking available.

Each time I've visited SSI, I've passed by this place and have always told myself I'd stop by. Well it finally happened and I went two nights in a row because it was just that good. It's a simple little shop win at least 15 different flavor options and they also sell King of Pops here too. They have good ol vanilla, cookie butter, superman, chocolate, pistachio, and a few other specialty flavors like honey lavender. Of course you sample them but my mind was set on just simple vanilla. One scoop (which I believe was $4.95) is actually a ginormous amount of ice cream and it just tastes delicious. It's super creamy and I actually enjoyed it better than some ice cream sold at grocery stores. They also have toppings available (a little expensive but it's $1.50 per topping) and even the extra charge of toppings didn't stop me from getting sprinkles and crumbled Oreos on top. They also have milkshakes for $8 if that's your style. Oh and there isn't an indoor seating area but there are plenty of picnic style tables out front because who wouldn't want to enjoy a nice treat in this beautiful weather???? read more

Moo Cow Cream - Sooooo I had already ate like half before I took the pic. Vanilla, sprinkles, and crumbled Oreos. Heavenly! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Simons Island, Georgia

Delicious! We stopped in right before closing for some post-dinner dessert. We were the last guests of the evening. Employees were very friendly and helpful. The home-churned Berry Jam was out of this world. My fiancé had the honey lavender, and loved it. (Note: I found it to be pretty good but didn't love that one, so be sure it fits your taste!) Will absolutely come back as often as we are back on the island! read more

There isn't much I can add in support of this gem of a "hole in the wall" ice cream shop other than I wished I had discovered Moo Cow before today. My husband and I were the only people - other than the counterperson - in the shop when we visited (mid-day, Wednesday after Labor Day). We felt very safe - we were all "masked" and we were able to sit outside to enjoy our ice cream. We visited the Georgia Sea Turtle Hospital earlier so I could not resist trying the Sea Turtle Ice Cream - very creamy with a taste like butter pecan with a touch of caramel. Delicious! We were told Sea Turtle is their # 1 seller. My husband had a cherry vanilla waffle cone which he said was incredibly good. I am already looking forward to my next visit to both the Island and Moo Cow Ice Cream! read more

Moo Cow Cream - Adorable! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Simons Island, Georgia

See all

Love their unusual flavors and the low key location. We've had all the ice cream in the village, and this is our favorite.

Really good ice cream and friendly people. The guy working 8/31 at closing was super sweet and they closed down but he saw an older couple walk up to the door right when they closed and the guy walked over and opened up the door and told to them to come and they would serve them. Awesome people read more