Dear Yelp, While…read morestaying at the hotel, we Decided to pop in for a drink. Every time we looked in the place was packed. After dinner, we were able to find a spot on the side of the room. Within a minute, two seats opened up at the bar. We sat there for an hour. The female bartender was amazing. We enjoyed our drinks and the piano player. Great experience! Love, Nicole

Perfection in a hotel bar! Has everything you want- great live entertainment, dim and vibey…read moreatmosphere and of course, delicious cocktails. Staff was definitely working overtime with such a crowded bar, but we were able to get our drinks. I highly recommend the Brown Room!

I went to the Boiler room recently, and I had a wonderful experience. Michele was my server. I had…read morean espresso martini and the truffle wedges and a truffle brick oven pizza. Michele was so fun and cool and friendly. The food was great. The atmosphere was really lovely. I would recommend this place for a chill night for drinks and a quick bite. I was very happy with my service. It made all the difference! Thanks!

So cute fun and good! Went out with the girls on a Friday. Live music was fun and the atmosphere…read morewas great. Loved the pizza and salads too

I was looking forward to stopping by Port Marina during my Cape May visit for a waterfront meal…read more According to the posted hours online, the restaurant appeared to be open, but when I arrived I was informed they were closed and that the online hours had not been updated. I unfortunately wasn't able to experience the food or atmosphere, but I wanted to share this in case other visitors are planning a trip and relying on the listed hours. Hopefully the information can be updated to avoid confusion. I'd still love to return in the future and give it a proper visit.

Love the vibe and views from Port!! Came here as our first stop on the way to cape May and stopped…read morein for a drink. I can't speak to the food, but the service was friendly at the bar and the atmosphere was perfection! Will be back to try more

This was our third time dining here, and it definitely won't be our last! The food was delicious,…read morethe décor creates a great atmosphere, and the presentation and service were outstanding. From the moment we walked in, the hosts made us feel welcome, and our server, Cassidy C., was absolutely fantastic, friendly, attentive, and made our dining experience even better. We highly recommend this place and are already looking forward to coming back!

Amazing location - we sat on the second floor balcony of this beautiful restaurant overlooking the…read moreCape May Beach. The server was Trevor and very nice. He had his hands full with several tables but handled everything really well. The food and drinks were terrific. My only criticism would be the cheese dip didn't have much flavor. It needed a little spice or something. We had the Tijuana Street Fries and Classic Taco Sampler. Both were terrific and huge portions for the cost. I would definitely eat here again if given the opportunity

Excellent service and food Casual atmosphere with…read moreentertainment Thoroughly enjoyed and highly recommend

Bartender was excellent. Rooftop waitress was straight-up racist. I've never felt so unwelcome at a…read morerestaurant. Her attitude and treatment toward our table were completely unacceptable.

My husband and I looked this place up and saw it had good reviews so we went to have a drink. We…read moresat at the bar for about 10 minutes and there were two bartenders. Neither of which said "hello" or "can I help you". It wasn't busy. But another guest came up and was served right away so we ended up leaving. Terrible experience. We love Cape May and vacation here every summer but wouldn't recommend this place to anyone due to the bad experience we just had.

One of my favorite formerly hidden spots. Anita makes the best drinks and if you want the local…read morenews this is the place to be. Live music and the Thursday ramble is a mainstay for us. Friendliest bartender around.

We had a great time at Carney's. We had a very warm welcome from the hostess. Our server Michele…read morewas delightful. So warm & friendly. She explained the menu to us. There were four of us. We all ordered something different & we all loved our meals. Can't wait to return. The atmosphere, friendliness of all staff and excellent food just can't be beat!

I see three stars and I just don't get it. Maybe it was from the previous owners but this place was…read moreawesome. Twenty of us for dinner. No problem for them. The staff were attentive and helpful. Ava was our server she was awesome. Atmosphere was perfect for a big family with kids. Also trivia night so that was pretty cool. The food was delicious from the fresh fish tacos to the best French dip sandwich I've ever had.Everything top notch. If you're looking for good pub food in an awesome atmosphere this is your place. This will now be one of our go to places to stop while visiting Cape May.

We had been here before and recall a good experience, so we went again on the Sunday of Memorial…read moreDay weekend around 4:30. First, we were seated in the back where the wait station and door to kitchen was located and staff was just standing around. We asked to move to one of the empty booths and was told they were all for reservations coming in. They were able to move us to the back room. Server was nice and attentive and our food (just appetizers) were good. The issue we had was the overly aggressive bussers who kept trying to take our plates away even when it was apparent that we were not finished. This happened several times. We dislike when dirty dishes are left in front of us but this was over the top and intrusive. With so many options around town, we likely won't be back.

The food has consistently been good, though in my opinion it's a bit overpriced--but that's become…read morepretty common since COVID. The beer selection is always impressive, with plenty of options to satisfy just about every taste. Service can be hit or miss depending on when you visit and who's working, but that's often the case at busy shore destinations. My family stops here on almost every trip to our home on the Cape May Bay, so we've experienced it at its best and busiest. The atmosphere is exactly what you'd expect from a popular shore restaurant. And yes, if you know about the bathroom situation, you know--it really deserves a permanent fix rather than another temporary patch. The menu offers something for everyone. The pizzas are consistently good, the bar food delivers exactly what you'd expect, and there are several signature dishes that are always reliable and full of flavor. When the restaurant gets crowded, you'll definitely notice it in both the service and the overall vibe, but that's just part of the shore experience. Overall, I'd recommend giving it a try. Go in with realistic expectations during peak times, and chances are you'll have a great meal. We almost always do, and I think you will too.