Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mr Gatti's Pizza

    2.1 (7 reviews)

    Order Mr Gatti's Pizza Takeout or Delivery

    Mr Gatti's Pizza Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Mr Gatti's Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    11 months ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 2
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Sam S.
    0
    28
    1

    10 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    11 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Don't waste your time or money 30 minutes and the pizza bar was empty ended up just eating a salad and pasta

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Mr Gatti's Pizza

    You might also consider

    Valenti’s

    Valenti’s

    4.2
    (30 reviews)
    1.4 mi

    The people are nice there fast the food is great it better than the restaurant in Vass the food is…read morea little bit high price for what you get but I got gluten-free pasta and salad and they charge more for gluten free but it is good I got water and the bread was nice the service was great and will if you got a little car that's to small the parking lot is hard to get into but getting out is ok I will go back to that one I will never go back to the one in Vass because the one in Vass is to slow and the bread is good and the food is not good and the people are not nice so...

    This is a gem in the heart of Sanford. It's the perfect spot for a special occasion, date night or…read morejust to treat yourself. Place is well decorated. Seating is ample and spacious. Make sure you make reservations because they're usually very busy. As for the food, I think that this is one of the better Italian restaurants I've tried in NC. The Parmagiano Crab Dip is absolutely to die for...especially when served with their freshly baked flat bread. The pasta all'Ortolana was very well seasoned and filled with veggies. I judge an Italian restaurant by their sauce & meatballs which honestly didn't disappoint. Portion sized are generous...everyone was leaving with takeout containers. The service we had was impeccable! Our server, Madison, was amazingly attentive and efficient! This will be one of our favorite haunts.

    Photos
    Pasta all'Ortolana with chicken
    Pasta all'Ortolana with chicken
    This crab dip is to die for!!
    This crab dip is to die for!!
    Half portion of spaghetti & meatballs

    See all

    Half portion of spaghetti & meatballs
    Bubba's Subs and Pizza

    Bubba's Subs and Pizza

    4.0
    (71 reviews)
    1.9 mi
    $

    We drove an hour to just eat here. The drive was most definitely worth it. The food here is amazing…read moreas so is the all the staff. Inside the restaurant is clean and spacious. Be sure to try them out.

    Worst pizzas I've ever seen made by a restaurant! Stay away from this place at all cost. Pizza…read morecrust was either premade or the flour didn't rise. The crust was very hard and the top of the pizza was orange from all the grease it had on it. Some of the slices didn't even have cheese or pepperoni on them. Got home and noticed this. I called back and the shift supervisor told me I would need to drive 20 minutes back to get another 2 pizzas made. Instead of offering to make them again when I'm back that way or a refund, she wanted me to turn back around and drive another 20 minutes back with the original pizzas for their mistake. I offered to send her pictures and she declined. She said the flour probably didn't rise on the pizza and that's why it was hard. If so, why still serve it if it's visible that it's not going to be good? What's the excuse for the rest of the pizza? As much as they cost, you're better off going to a pizza joint to get a better tasting one. Another thing to add, they have at least 10 employees working in a cramped up kitchen constantly talking so be prepared to eat spit from them talking over your food while being made. As many years as I've been going there before it was bubbas subs, I definitely will not be going back. Ever since the original owners stepped down, this place pretty much kicked the bucket. You know the food isn't great when they had a sign at one point on the counter saying to check your food before you leave to make sure it's right. I'll spend my hard earned money elsewhere that takes pride in the food they make!

    Photos
    Sign
    Sign
    Barely any cheese, meat and mayo  and where's the lettuce and tomato!????
    Barely any cheese, meat and mayo and where's the lettuce and tomato!????
    A meatball sub with a dollop of cheese

    See all

    A meatball sub with a dollop of cheese
    Cafe Vesuvio

    Cafe Vesuvio

    3.5
    (82 reviews)
    2.0 mi
    $$

    Cafe Vesuvio is a long standing Italian family tradition in Sanford. The shop was recently…read morerenovated and looks really nice inside! Last night we had a Cafe Vesuvio Special pizza as appetizer, two side salads, garlic knots, the special "MamaMia" chicken penne with vodka sauce and a bottle of Montepulciano wine. All was excellent!!! My wife and I spent several weeks in Italy this past fall and tried some amazing food that isn't served in most US Italian restaurants, so it's hard to make a good side by side comparison to Vesuvio's! The Vesuvio pizza is better than the majority of pies we had in Italy. The chicken Marsala and Sorrento are fantastic too. Our server, Brittany was friendly efficient and knew her product. She could actually talk about the food options, family who owns the restaurant (sweet friendly people) and the different wine offerings. It is amazing how much a competent and attentive server can impact a dining experience. Probably the only thing that we'd change about Cafe Vesuvio, would be a nice canopied outdoor dining area to take advantage the beautiful spring and fall weather we get in Sanford. But please don't let that keep you from giving Cafe Vesuvio a try. FYI we frequent Valenti's and La Dolce Vita and all three have standouts in their food and servers!!! We sit at the bar often... Cheyanne at Valenti's is a sweetheart and I think made the recommendation that we try Montepulciano wine for the first time. You should go visit her too!!!

    Situated in an unassuming old strip mall, I wasn't sure what to expect. Cafe Vesuvio was a…read moresurprise! The interior was generic Italian restaurant with lots of comfortable booth seating. Service was friendly & efficient. Food was very good...reminded me of neighborhood places up in NY/ NJ with nonna cooking in the kitchen. This is a nice little gem in Sanford if you're in the hunt for Italian food.

    Photos
    Portobello mushroom ravioli with Marsala Cream a sauce - special
    Portobello mushroom ravioli with Marsala Cream a sauce - special
    Farfalle Bella Donna
    Farfalle Bella Donna
    Gnocchi with meatballs

    See all

    Gnocchi with meatballs
    Hawkins Grill & Pizzeria

    Hawkins Grill & Pizzeria

    3.6
    (27 reviews)
    4.3 mi
    $

    We called in a carry out pizza order for pepperoni and double mushrooms. Do you know how hard it is…read moreto actually get a pizza where you feel like they put double mushrooms on it? Well Hawkins Grill delivered!! There were plenty of mushrooms so we didn't feel like we were getting short changed and the sauce was very tasty. We liked the crisp, chewiness of the crust as well. We both agreed that next pizza will be from Hawkins Grill to confirm they know pizza! (Wish we would have gotten a photo.) The order was a carry out but from the time we called to the drive to pick up, the service was great and not a long wait at all. We have eaten in before and the atmosphere was easy going and service good. When we ate in, it wasn't super busy but the night we picked up the pizza it was so I'm impressed in their ability to serve as quickly as well a great product when they were so busy. Would recommend and we'll be back! Thank you!!

    The service is iffy depending on who is on duty and the food is marginal. The young man that waits…read moretables seems to be best suited for a behind the house position. The young lady server is awesome. If your crew is craving Italian a visit to Elizabeth's will be your best bet. The cost of mediocre food from Hawkins Grill is incredibly high.

    Photos
    Ham & cheese calzone- lunch
    Ham & cheese calzone- lunch
    That's garlic bread... that's garlic bread? Theres literally drops of garlic no garlic at all.
    That's garlic bread... that's garlic bread? Theres literally drops of garlic no garlic at all.
    The menu!

    See all

    The menu!

    Mr Gatti's Pizza - pizza - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...