I have been to Mr. Pickles on Oakdale Rd. several times now as it is my best friend's favorite spot. The food has always been well crafted, the people behind the counter friendly and engaging and they have ALWAYS had everything I asked for. For a sandwich shop, the ambiance is enjoyable, with seating outside and in, and a mood that makes us want to return. I have included two pictures from the Mr. Pickles website, as I am usually too busy enjoying my friend's conversation and company or eating my meal to remember to take pictures. read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Yes the inside of the shop. Well merchandised. Photo by Steve Holidy. - Sandwiches Near Me - Modesto, California

See all

Ciara & Ness helped me order two lunch combos today. I'm not a picky eater, and like trying new things. They were both very friendly and were happy to provide suggestions which I greatly appreciated. I love Mr. Pickles sandwich shop. Taking the time to share in an effort to help others! read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - CJ's Pastrami & Hot T - Sandwiches Near Me - Modesto, California

A mistake was made on a DoorDash order. I received the incorrect sandwich. I reached out and not only did they remake my sandwich, but also gave me the one that was left behind. They were super busy and my sandwich was ready with some extra treats to say 'sorry' for their mistake. They were quick, so kind, and overall wonderful. Would recommend 10/10. read more

Mr Pickles is the best sandwich shop around the 209! I've been going here since middle school. Freshly baked bread and great choices for meats and cheeses. Everything they have never ceases to amaze me! 10/10 recommend! read more

I tried the Rueben sandwich here. I really enjoyed it, and would have it again, it was a pick up order and was ready on time. I ate it too fast and forgot to take a picture this time. read more

My first time ordering Mr Pickle. Regular My Deli (Sammie) $5 Special + Sandwich Breads: Sourdough Roll (Sammie) + Meat: Turkey Breast + Cheese Choice: Swiss Very impressed! read more

See all

Good food, great customer service. Clean restaurant. No long waits. In and out. Quiet, peaceful cute little restaurant between Modesto and Riverbank. read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Restaurant - Sandwiches Near Me - Modesto, California

First visit to a Mr. Pickles ever, and I was pleasantly surprised. I was looking for a basic Subway vibe, and this was better. Ordered a whole "Got Beef" on Dutch Crunch. Staff were cool, yet wish there was seating to avoid the take out experience. read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Modesto, California

My son ordered a sandwich and it had hair in it. We went back into the restaurant asked for a refund and they said that they could not refund my money because they had to talk to the owners first. They said if I paid cash and they could give me a refund because I use my credit card they were unable to give me my money back What an absolute joke !! Not only that, the price was insanely high $35 for two sandwiches and two waters Don't go here. read more

I previously left a negative review. A couple days ago I met a young employee named Levi who completely changed my view. When I brought up the expired business license he showed me the 2026 date and clarified that it's still current. He also informed me there haven't been any health code violations and when I described the Ness I met, an elderly African American women, he explained that that was just a random lady and not in fact his manager and that if I met her I would love her. Thank you!! And my Mr.Pickle was amazing. read more

Good sandwiches. Nice people. Turkey is good. Dutch bread is good. Woohoo. Thanks read more

Good sandwich, but nothing particularly exceptional. Pricing hurts a little bit but I guess everything is more expensive than it should be these days. Definitely a take-out be dine-in spot. read more

Great location to Mary Groggin Soccer Complex. Less than 5 minutes so good for in between games. Quick and great food as always. The guy running the resister struggled though. Only problem is that there isn't a lot of seating so not great for large groups. 4 five person tables outside. read more

Vanessa it's great customer service Food was delicious Thank you so much! We definitely coming back! read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Mrs Pickle was boom thank you - Sandwiches Near Me - Modesto, California

Went back to hopefully update my review, $30 for 2 sandwiches with not a lot of fillings, even asked for extra mayo and garlic spread and they failed, felt absolutely ripped off. I'd rather drive across town to the Sandwhich shop and get 2 loaded sandwiches for $20- still best place around! read more

Went to Mr. Pickle's on Oakdale Rd. today for their 7.99 special Small sandwich chips and drink. Sounded like a good deal. But, they must be running this special to get rid of stale and very hard bread. The inside ingredients were good we just had to microwave it when we got home to be able to eat it which doesn't really last soft before it gets hard again. This was not a good experience next time I'll pay more to get a better quality bread. Togo's, Jersey Mikes Etc. read more

Worst rudest manager at the Mr Pickles store in Modesto. Would not give her name during my visit today around 325pm, 05/02/25. Worst customer service and this woman should NOT be in her role!!!!!! Is there a corporate phone number to Mr Pickles as she surely wasn't giving it out at the same time??? Try to avoid this business if you can. Super expensive sandwiches, so if you want to pay 16.50 for a lousy sandwich and get bad customer service from said manager, then do so!!!!!!! read more

I don't usually say much about sandwich shops and such but I read that Mr. Pickle's is family owned so I'll chime in. My 92 yr. old mother in-law wants a sandwich, Yelp said the closest one to me is Mr. Pickle's...let's go. One star for each of the employees working. Eye contact and smile go along way with me. They were polite, professional and quick. The fourth star is for the sandwiches, not that great. My pastrami looked like a mustard bomb went off inside it. My mouths on fire! Last words...pass on the mustard. read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Mustard bomb - Sandwiches Near Me - Modesto, California

See all

High prices for small sandwiches, the "medium" was 5". Not much on the sandwiches, bread was stale, disappointing. Customer service excellent, but not enough to justify the mediocre food. I paid over $11 for a 5" pastrami on stale French bread. read more

Great customer service! Been coming here for years. Very very friendly. Great quality food. Jackie and Ness are incredible

OMG they're Italian stallion was bomb! The bread is so good if you love sourdough then you will love it! The prices are a little high, but it's worth it read more

Always great sandwiches at Mr. pickles! Sometimes you have to wait an extra minute or two, but those cookies are worth it!

The service was amazing, she was extremely helpful and made my sandwich perfectly! Would definitely come in and order again :) read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Menu - Sandwiches Near Me - Modesto, California

As someone who works in the food/drink industry I know how annoying it is when a group of people walk in right before we close. My family of 5 went in with only 10 minutes left before closing the two ladies working were so kind and welcoming. If they were annoyed they didn't show it at all. The food was as great as the customer service! read more

This place is amazing! Everyone always has a smile on there face! The garlic sauce is amazing!!! read more

everyone in here always smiles! And the selections are always delicious - we just love coming here!!

Great food! And the owner lady is always so nice when we go there! The listen linda sandwich is my new favorite!!

Awesome staff, great service! And better sandwiches! Best place for sandwiches is town.

Just go to subway these people are slow takes them 15 minutes just to make 1 sandwich

For Mr Pickles as a brand - 5 stars. Menu is excellent, it's one of my favorite things about Modesto. For this specific location - 1 star or 2, max. Some issues: - the plexiglass from Covid had been removed and left dangerously jutting out. I scratched myself accidentally at checkout and drew blood. Told the associate in a nice way, he said owner had tried to remove it but left a jagged edge poking out. I get it, not his job. But kind of shocking in this day and age of litigiousness. - the bread at this specific location is ALWAYS stale. Very strange given the Pelandale location is always amazing. - no real dine in options - no fountain or water options - staff is ok, but not nearly as friendly as Pelandale. Those folks are great. Just leaving this review in the hopes it can help spur actual change, bc Mr Pickles as an overall franchise is fantastic. So much wasted potential at this location. read more

This Mr pickles is my favorite! Super clean inside, service is fast, and the workers are nice and helpful. Definitely recommend this one over any Mr pickles read more

After visiting and frequenting multiple Mr. Pickles shops (Crow Canyon Rd., Pacifica, 5 points Modesto, Pelandale, Turlock, Pleasanton) I can definitively state that the Oakdale Rd. location in Modesto is THE bottom of the pickle barrel. Can you give NO stars?!?! It's bad enough that there are countless Denver Bronco motifs around the shop (shows ownership's lack of insight and helps us understand why the shop runs like a 3rd rate subway imitation - and that's awful because subway sucks) and every time you walk in there are at least 2 staff members aimlessly walking around trying to figure out what to do. After 3 consecutive online orders that were incorrectly prepared (missing additions, including exclusions, on the wrong bread, etc.) I gave one last chance. Ordered online and had order ready time of 1:25pm. Showed up at 1:30 and they say, "we're working on it..." as they begin to prep sandwiches. 2 sandwich artisans stood at the register and line with full trout breathing when I said, "working on it? It's supposed to be ready." I then see 2 more employees wandering aimlessly in the back. Now I must point out there were ZERO customers in the shoppe. And a 5th employee sitting at a table behind a laptop. Not to mention the owner strolling around in his garish Blue and Orange pullover. My first question was then, "how is this order not even started?!?" So I went back out to my car and gave them 10 more minutes to finish the order. Upon returning to the shop there was another customer standing and waiting to be helped. As 3 workers circled in confusion in the visible back of house area, the table-top employee sat looking on with no movement towards the prep areas. There was one lad still finishing my order. So after an additional 3 minutes the order was filled. And the sandwich steward said, "here you go." No apology for delay, no question of "anything else" and no gratitude "thanks and have a nice day" given. This will be the last time. Why? Because when I got home they incorrectly made one of the two sandwiches. How difficult can it be to show a modicum of attention to detail and customer service? I guess it just goes to show that leaders set the tone. And since the owner clearly thinks it's all working well we know why the place is in need of a lot of help. As if the broncos comment earlier didn't already indicate how this place would be run. read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - The sandwich that was ok, but still barely warmed even though just freshly made... - Sandwiches Near Me - Modesto, California

Mr Pickles is one of my favorite go-to sandwich shops. Unfortunately the one closest to me closed over a year ago so now I have to go across town for Mr Pickles read more

First time @ this location amazing staff and the Rueben was probably the best I've ever had.

A $15 sandwich from Mr. Pickles is not worth the money. This deli has changed... Bathrooms were closed 2 hours before store closure. Inside seating area unavailable (again). No fountain drinks (not even water). The quality of ingredients were not premium grade despite the premium price. A full size Mr. Pickles sandwich next to a footlong from Subway is half the size. The customer service is suprisingly poor given their past. Maybe this particular location? There are other deli sandwich options in the area. I suggest pass on Mr. Pickles to pay less money some place else for better quality food and customer service. read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - $15 full size sandwich from Mr. Pickles - Sandwiches Near Me - Modesto, California

So slow.... Each sandwich takes forever. Fountain drinks are behind the counter. Food is consistent.

Great service and very clean. I had the GOAT on Sour and it was good along with spicy dill pickle chips

Really disappointed cant place phone orders, for some jobs they can't take the time to stand in places to have order made. The old mr pickles could always call it in and just walk in for pick up read more

Delicious sandwiches! My fav is the big Jake with turkey avacado and cream cheese! Yum! The Dutch crunch bread is so good!

Vanessa and Ashveen are sandwich angles, their service, smiles and great attitudes keep us coming back!! Their store is always super clean, everything is fresh, and delicious!! We love Vanessa and her crew. read more