Mr Pizza is a great place to grab a quick slice of pizza and some bread sticks. The cost of the lunch combo is really cheep at 2$. During lunchtime there can be a long wait because a lot of the high school kids go there for lunch. The pizza is really good! Its really an unbelievable deal for 2$! If you're looking for a small town feel and a quick pizza, this is the place to go. read more

Service was just okay. The establishment although small, was clean. Nothing really to write home about. We ordered the garlic cheese sticks and a large pepperoni, mushroom and olive pizza. Wait time was minimal, but so was the flavor profile. I would describe it as something between a good frozen pizza and hospital cafeteria pizza. I hear they have some great specials making it a budget friendly option, but that's not my wheelhouse. Prices were what you would expect for what we ordered. Owner was nice and did check on us at the end of our meal which was nice. Just a hard market to try and cater to in such a small town and remain budget friendly. Wish them the best. 5.6/10 read more

Mr Pizza - Lg pepperoni, mushroom and olive pizza - Pizza Near Me - Shelley, Idaho

See all

The whole building looked as if it hadnt been cleaned in months, bugs were flying everywhere, there was no AC, the straw holder was just a gallon jug roughly cut in half read more

The breadsticks are addictive! Best owners. Eating here is a must have experience. A southeast Idaho icon.

Amazing pizza! Love this place!! Live in Utah and love to come visit here every time I'm in the area!

Dirt cheap pizza that comes with a drink. The place was dark and dingy. A bucket of white paint could make this place more inviting. I couldn't help but think I was going to get sick while eating there. They didn't tell me the price when I bought the pizza so I was very surprised when it was only 3 dollars. I recommend going but only if you like haunted houses bc this place was weird and spooky. Not the type of place you want to get murdered in but definitely the type of place that someone would bring you to in order to murder you. You could easily film an episode of black mirror in this place and you wouldn't have to change anything. read more

If we are being honest, this place seems like a joke. The ranch and marinara were literal water which somehow translated to the pizza. I walked in and tried to give this place the benefit of the doubt based on its nasty appearance hoping the food would taste remotely good but I was mistaken. I'm bummed we paid before we got the food because we couldn't even eat it. Does the owner even care about this place or is said person dead in the back? read more

Good pizza at a great price! Service was excellent. This is how pizza joints were back in the day. I did take out. Pizza was still hot when I got home. read more

the pizza is good. but slightly dirty and the lunch special with the ranch u can get, is very water like. the lunch special comes with a small pizza and those bread sticks. like i said. its good but slightly dirty. i reccomend going there. read more

Terrible pizza in the most ghetto restaurant, crust was barely cooked through and the ranch is as thick as skim milk.

I have growing up with this restaurant and I love it!!!! The place it's self is a little old, it could use so brightning up,but I love the food!! The ranch, and 2 dollar lunches are my favorite!!! I love the ranch so much, and with the lunch is so good. I hope this place stays open for a long time!!! read more

Best breadsticks around! Pizza subs are amazing. Me and my family stop here every time we're in town.

This is the best pizza place I have ever been to. My favorite is the "hot and spicy" number 4. Seriously has changed my life. I try and go at least once a week. Thank you Mr Pizza for being so amazing. read more

Sure his sauce may be a little watered down, and it may not be top-notch gourmet pizza, but Mr Pizza is definitely the best value for your buck. They've maintained virtually the same prices since 1985 despite inflation, and you can't beat Shannon's (the owner) lunch special. For just $2.00 (tax included) you get a good sized personal pizza, a small order of breadsticks, and a drink. You heard that right all of that is only $2.00. Oh and the service is great! 5 stars all the way read more

First time trying this place, was really excited and hungry. The same person who took my order proceeded imediately to make my pizza with no gloves and without washing his hands. Seeing him spread the toppings was too much. I didnt have the heart to say anything so I walked out without a pizza. PLEASE PLEASE ask your employees to wash thier hands or wear gloves. read more

The worst! Cheap crust, cheap toppings, and 'oh no you didn't'!; watered down ranch! Watered down marinara! We moved to Shelley Idaho 3 years ago. My wife is from Shelley, and she used to eat at Mr Pizza often (in high school) (she made me say that) due to the $2 lunch special. It is clear that the price of the special is indicative of the quality of the product. I really don't want to get into details about the poor quality, but I will say this; if you are accustomed to quality pizza, don't eat at Mr Pizza. You're welcome. P.S. Seriously Mr Pizza, watered down ranch!?, and watered down marinara!? It was like ranch and marinara flavored water! Nope! J read more

We love this pizza! The breadsticks are always delicious and the ranch is thin, but tastes great! The owner is the nicest person and the staff always work so hard to accommodate our needs. We had a family reunion in an off-road location and the delivery driver walked our large order out to our picnic tables. Mr. Pizza is our go-to pizza place when we want a satisfying $2 lunch. read more

Worst pizza I ever had. I don't care if it is only $2 I would not go there again. The place was digusting, dark and dirty. Underneath the tables were dirt, cardboard boxes, and what looked like dirty laundry. The windows were blacked out. Cups felt greasy and the ranch and marinara sauce were watered down significantly to the point where they were essentially unrecognizable. The bread sticks were tough and had no flavor. The pizza was worse than the expired frozen pizza at the 99 cent store. Don't go here unless you enjoyed eating at places that break health code in at least 20 different ways. read more

Cheap, cheap, cheap lunches. And the worst pizza I've ever eaten. There's a reason lunch is so cheap here. I'd rather have lunch at a school cafeteria. Breadsticks aren't any better. But it's dirt cheap! The one time I ate here, the temperature in the restaurant was at least 90 degrees, and my soda came in a tiny plastic cup (you can't take your drink with you if you order your meal to go). If you're looking for decent/good pizza, try Pizza Hut, just a few blocks from here. If you're looking for great pizza, try Lucy's in Idaho Falls. If all you care about is getting food as cheaply as possible, buy a bag of off-brand cold cereal at Broulims. read more

Very cheap but definitely not worth it. The location is filthy, I was grossed out the whole time I was in there. The pizza was very plain and the ranch was like milk. Spend a couple extra bucks and go elsewhere! read more

I have no idea how this business stays open except that it feeds most of the school kids for cheap because the regular pizza is lousy.

Whenever my husband and I are in town we love to come here and get a #2 (2 slice special with garlic bread). I LOVE their garlic bread, it's so cheesy and delicious! And for $4 for both of our meals combined it cant be beat! The building itself leaves quite a bit to be desired, it needs renovation desperately but part of that is lent toward the atmosphere. This building has been erect in Shelley for decades and the pizza parlor was originally a hospital. Very interesting.We love this place! read more

If you are looking for a cheap priced menu this is the place to go visit! I recommend the lunch special. It is simply perfect

Not bad for Idaho. Good toppings and good price for the size. Needed a little more sauce and a few more minutes in the oven.

This man deserves an award or something. Yes its cheap. But thats what's so beautiful about it. For it being $2 its really good.

Clean the soda machine, the pizza pans, the oven and everything else. Moldy soda and black pizza crust are not my idea of a good meal.

The lunch special is probably my favorite thing to eat in Shelley. Very unique dining experience that I enjoy every time I visit this town

A fine establishment. Great place to impress a date and really show them how much you care. Great ambience that really adds to the experience. Must dine -in for the complete experience! 5 Stars! read more

Great pizza subs (calzones) and excellent bread sticks. Awesome customer service and delivery services! Highly reccomend you try!