Okay, Pie Hole might have ruined other pizza in town for me. The slices were packed with flavor, and since you order by the slice, they've somehow mastered the very important art of making sure your slice comes out piping hot. None of that sad, lukewarm pizza that looks like it's been contemplating life under a heat lamp for three hours. Big flavor, New York-style crust, hot slices, and you can grab exactly as much--or, realistically, as much as you think you need before ordering another slice. I'm going to say it: this might be the best pizza in town. Definitely coming back! read more

We ordered pizza here tonight. We had to take all the sun-dried tomato off the pizza because they were burned to a crisp There were no clean tables. Workers made no effort to clean a table for us. Floors were dirty enough that I could feel the dirt under my sandals. Unfortunately, I can't recommend this place. read more

I was hopeful about this place. I was cool with the vibe and was looking for a good local pizza place but the pizza was marginal.

The potato pizza was incredible. Awesome staff, fun vibes, reasonably priced. They had some unique flavors like Mac and cheese and Thai chicken. read more

See all

Oh man! We're from Cali and we came here for our first time and boy was it some really delicious pizzas! Very reasonable in pricing as well! Def def recommend this place if you're in Idaho craving pizza! They also sell by the slice! read more

Pie Hole - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Idaho Falls, Idaho

See all

Was traveling and the two locations is planned to go where closed on Sunday. Visited based on reviews. One of the best pizzas I've had in a very long time g time. Can highly recommend the Pie Hole Supreme. read more

Fast and delicious slices of pizza. Always changes the by the slice. Good prices too.

There aren't many restaurants opened on a Sunday in Idaho Falls. We were right in the historic downtown and stumbled upon Pie Hole, one of the only few places even open! The restaurant is very casual, and counter order. There are a few tables in there for dining, but the place isn't large. Service was kind, and the food was great. I was pleasantly surprised at how good the pizzas were! I had the classic pepperoni pizza and sausage + green peppers. read more

YUMMM!!! Delicious, ginormous pizza slices! Nice, thin crust that is foldable like East Coast pizza. I HIGHLY recommend this place and will definitely eat here again!! read more

Pie Hole - Pepperoni and Dill Pickle ginormous pizza slices - Pizza Near Me - Idaho Falls, Idaho

This establishment is dirty. I like when when I go to a restaurant that it is clean and welcoming. But this place is the opposite. Imagine your food being prepared in a dirty kitchen, so gross. That is what you get here. As for the food. It is below average. Just not much flavor , very bland. They are slow too. Wait times get long. So if u want slow bland food prepared in a dirty environment, this is the place for u. read more

Huckleberry pie was the best! Crust was very good and filling not too sweet. Would definitely come again. The lunch food smelled and looked delicious read more

The food here is always reliable. I love that there's always new pizza to try. The people who work here are always very kind. Chill atmosphere and cool decor. I love pie hole. read more

The pizza was great! I will be returning for sure. The customer service was also great:) also the music inside was fun

Oh no! What could improve? Attitude. Giving a crap about your job. Happy that you have a job. If you not ordering a full pizza, which I would recommend later in the post, you order slices of premade pies. What I wanted was two slices with sausage and meatball. I guarantee it was not already made. Which is fine. They could just add the toppings to the cheese slices. The server looked at the press and picked two slices and said they were it.... They were not it. The slices had two pieces of sausage, that's real skimpy. No meatballs, and some onions. I'll give the some credit, the pizza was good but it's not what I asked for. The server was too lazy to take two slices of cheese pizza and separately add sausage and meatball, And heat them up. Of course this stroner also asked for a tip...sheesh. read more

I decided to try this place at Lunchtime this week to see if the pizza quality was any better than my other past visits. I'm convinced that unless you're standing by as they take it out fresh from the oven, it will always just be "OK" at best. I've tried other locations and it's always the same quality. I would like to say that sometimes"OK" is all you may want or need at the time. If that's the case be prepared to be marginally satisfied here if you don't expect fresh or flavorful. It's not something to avoid completely, but if you want to get your Pizza Itch scratched and it's close to midnight or your nearby at a bar, you should explore other options. read more

We were driving through Idaho and wanted a quick lunch. Stopped by to grab some pizzas and ordered ahead and was told they would be ready in 45mins. We decided to try the Thai Chicken Pizza and Pesto Veggie pizzas, and cheesy garlic bread as a side. When we arrived, the place was empty so we were able to seat our large group. Thai Chicken pizza was good, thin crust, 19" but nothing to write home about. The Pesto Veggie pizza came with chicken added on, though we had not requested any .....so the vegetarians in the group stuck to cheese garlic bread. Shame since this was better tasting than the Thai chicken pizza. They offered to make a fresh pizza for us without chicken, but we were on a time crunch and could not afford to wait another 45mins for a vegetarian pizza. read more

See all

Good pizza. Bread sticks were awesome. 1 size. Yuge. Price was good. Recommend if your in Idaho Falls read more

Pie Hole - Jalapeños Canadian bacon and sausage - Pizza Near Me - Idaho Falls, Idaho

I've eaten at Poe hole several times and last week myself and a couple co-workers went there for late lunch and it was delicious!! I had forgotten how good they are. Fast and great employees. Definitely a greats top in downtown read more

Josh is the best - food was great, amazing service & good vibes! He was so welcoming and kind :)

Pizza was amazing! We wanted to try the bbq pulled pork but they didn't have all the ingredients, they recommended the drunken candy and it was so good! We only waited like 15-20 min well worth it! The ambiance was cool I liked the music! read more

Pie Hole - Drunk Candy Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Idaho Falls, Idaho

Not gonna lie, at first glance, the pizza doesn't look appetizing. They have about 5-6 pizzas sitting behind the glass, not sure how long it's been sitting there but it definitely looks cold. I ordered 2 slices: Thai Chicken and BBQ Chicken. As I was getting ready to pay, they placed the pizzas in the oven to heat it up. The verdict: These large, thin sliced pizzas were SOLID. The Thai Chicken Pizza had a peanut base, with sliced green onions, cilantro and chicken on top. It was actually really good. The BBQ Chicken was tasty as well. My friend ordered the Potato Bacon Pizza, which was really unique but also delicious. I left satisfied. Highly recommend checking out Pie Hole if you're in the area! read more

Pie Hole - Top: Thai Chicken Pizza | Bottom: BBQ Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Idaho Falls, Idaho

I LOVE their potato bacon pizza. Always stop in for a slice whenever I'm in town. One time I stopped in and they didn't have my fave so I took two slices of pepperoni to go. Didn't notice until I was eating it on the road how burned it was underneath. A one-off miss for me, but I'll be back! read more

We stayed in Idaho Falls during our summer road trip. We got into town late, it was one of the few places open. Excellent pizza, took a little longer than expected considering I had called in my order 50 mins prior, but it was worth it. read more

It is exactly what it needs to be! Standard pizza, drinks and service. Perfect for a quick bite.

Great pizza. Stopped in with our large group of vegetarians (12 of us) and the staff was quick to accommodate us. We enjoyed the cheese pizza and veggie pesto pizza. Seating was limited but we came in when there weren't too many people. But there's also benches outside to sit. Great service and great food. read more

Very good pizza and service!! Accommodating staff that thanked us for coming on our arrival and when we left. The crust on the slices I had were excellent.... Crispy and flavorful ... toppings were generous and delicious. It was a plus to see a great beer selection in Idaho Falls! The pepperoni pizza was a standout with every inch of the pie covered in thin slices of high quality Pepperoni ! I have been a Papa Toms fan for decades and this pizza meets or possibly exceeds their standards in my opinion! Wonderful find in downtown Idaho Falls!! read more

Delicious pizza by the slice. Cool vibe on the inside. Friendly service. Just wish there was a little more sauce.

We were traveling through on our way home and we're tired and didn't want to go out so we ordered pizza. We got the pepperoni with extra cheese, extra pepperoni and it was smothered with pepperoni and very delicious. Our friends got a veggie with pepperoni and ham it was delicious too. we had to order delivery using this app called Sliwhich I never had before, but it was easy and delivered on time. read more

Pie Hole - Our pepperoni pizza with extra pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Idaho Falls, Idaho

After midnight-baked potato bacon pizza hits the spot. Drank enough for hiccups-get a pice of drunkcandy pizza. Any other ailments ask the maitre d' and he'll point you in the right direction. Jackets available at the door read more

Definitely 4.5 stars! Good product, soft delicious light crust, easily folded into a pizza sandwich! Very reasonably priced for the quality of product. Great experience! read more

WOW. The Thai Chicken Pizza! Love a good Asian-inspired pizza. My husband and I have VERY different tastes when it comes to pizza so I was so glad they could they could accommodate half and half. Ordered takeout here on a Tuesday night to bring back to our hotel and it was a great comfort meal on a cold night. Note that they just have one size (8 large slices). I called at 7:45pm and they said it'd be ready at 8:15pm. Arrived there at 8:15pm and it was another 15mins for it to be ready, but they were apologetic. Overall a solid pizza option in Idaho Falls. Parking out front. Appreciated the TMNT drawing on the box! read more

See all

Ordered two pizzas. I added red peppers to one of them but they must have been out of red peppers because they substituted jalapenos instead. Not cool. A little pricey for two pizzas as well and it took an hour to have them ready for pick up. read more

We stopped by Pie Hole on our way back west from Wyoming. With the number of US covid cases breaking records during our time here, I was glad to see that all the employees were masked up properly (over the nose, not touching their masks, etc) which we did not see in many establishments during our trip. We felt safe ordering from them and glad that we stopped by as the pizza was delicious and the ingredients tasted fresh. Loved the Thai chicken flavor and the potato bacon flavor was really unique and helped us satisfy our potato craving while in Idaho. Highly recommend trying if you pass by here. read more

Pie Hole - Thai Chicken Pizza Potato and Bacon Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Idaho Falls, Idaho

Walked by here after getting drunk at the bar next door, and took it back to my hotel room across the river. Decided it would be a good idea to get some food in my stomach. I got a piece of Hawaiian, and a pepperoni. It was delicious!! Great price, guys inside were cool. Will definitely come back! read more

Order on the app an hour ahead if you want a whole pie but it's pretty good the sauce has flavor the pepperoni has kick

I'm not going to get overly wordy here. Let's keep it simple. Vibe: Modern. Inner-city. A little loud. Price: Good value considering the excellent quality of their food. Diversity: No gluten-free options for allergies. :-( That doesn't impact my personal experience, but it does limit some of my friends. Customer Service: Excellent. Friendly. Helpful. Food: AWESOME!!!! The crust is delicious. The CHEESE!!!!! Oh the cheese....chewy, gooey, delightful! I had a different favorite pizza place in town before Pie Hole opened...now THIS is my absolute favorite. Hours: Every day of the week and well into the night!!! This is a HUGE plus for Idaho Falls! Other places don't have late night or Sunday options. They sell whole pizza pies or pizza by the slice. Great great great. read more

Pie Hole - Best pizza pie ever - Pizza Near Me - Idaho Falls, Idaho

See all

Driving through Idaho Falls to Jackson, we stopped overnight and stayed at local hotel and found late night craving for pizza. Yelped what's best and the Pie Hole was at the top of the list! Love the name and open late till midnight. Even better, we can order by the slice. Yum! Quick and cheap eats also sitting outside as we had our with us read more

Always good! stop here often for a slice of pizza before a bike ride. Good good good. Kid loves it. read more

Fantastic! We are visiting from California, so of course we had to try the Potato & Bacon pizza. So worth it. read more

Ordered take out and it was awesome! Always the best service and delivery. So delicious I almost forgot to save some for my hun. You guys rock! No soggy crust and extra grease. Made my dining experience a joy! 5 stars! read more