Located behind the Xfinity store on 3rd Street at the Golden Plaza in Williamsport since 2004, this establishment serves the ultimate treat any time of the year but especially during the holidays as a Christmas brunch or dessert. My partner and I came today for takeout. We first discovered Mr. Sticky's after a friend brought some sweet delights of sticky buns. Cinnamon rolls flipped once they came out of the oven. Brown sugar mixture on the bottom of the pan melts into a smooth and silky cap that coats and cascades down the finished batch of rolls. Baked from scratch daily, they only make five versions of buns/rolls: the regular Mr. Sticky, plain cinnamon roll, walnut sticky bun, peanut butter cinnamon roll, and cream cheese cinnamon roll. Beside the star of the show, they also serve homemade soups, salads, and sandwiches served on their homemade rolls. We decided and called this morning an order for a dozen each of the regular Mr. Sticky buns and walnut sticky buns. Greeted by the staff upon entering, our order was ready for pickup in two large cartons. They were still hot arriving at our final destination. After biting through chewy, sticky rolls, you taste a blast of mouth-watering cinnamon and crusty bits of brown sugar. These are very big and can easily be shared and/or eaten over a few days. The pricing was reasonable at $52. It's worthy of a close to 4-hour drive, which we can recommend. read more

See all

Finger licking good. Worth a stop, just off highway. Walnut sticky buns and Cinnamon Rolls. Cream cheese topping is too sweet for my liking but will order it without next time. read more

Their sticky buns are to die for! We ordered the day prior and they were ready for us. Every time we go back to the Little League World Series, we make sure to seek out locally owned businesses and Mr. Sticky's is always on the top of our list. They are busy, but we never have to wait long. They are worth a stop! read more

Obviously the sticky buns are the star of the show but don't sleep on their breakfast sandwiches and lunch menu! Always fresh and very reasonable prices. Call ahead if you're in a hurry and you can zoom thru the drive thru! read more

Open until 3 and arrived at 2:20 employees just pointed at a sign in window stating SOLD OUT! Very unprofessional and what kind of food sales sells out of full menu. I'm saying one with LAZY employees.. if I wouldn't about the tickets for a fundraiser, I don't think I'd ever go back read more

We've had their wonderfully delicious sticky buns when we lived in PA and miss them! We will order some in the near future to share.

Don't come to Mr. Sticky unless you're looking for a reason to break your fast. The house made sticky buns in this place are divine. We picked up a six-pack with two peanut butter iced (my personal favorite), one cream cheese, two original sticky buns (hub's favorite), and one walnut sticky bun. That peanut butter icing should be illegal. If you're grabbing them to go, they kindly put the icings in individual tubs. Make sure you refrigerate them or toss them in your cooler if you decide to grab some on your way out of town. We brought these down to our friends in Ohio. They're now also addicted to Mr. Sticky. Service is swift, and there's plenty of space to sit and enjoy your sticky bun if you want. Sometimes it's just worth the calories. read more

See all

Fantastic warm sticky bun, perfect to share -- next time we will skip the other (mediocre) local spots and have lunch there!

Best sticky buns I've ever had. Took some home and great reheated. Definitely worth the trip. I my area they would be $5+ and only $3 there. Nice to get something good and not pay a fortune for it. read more

These sticky buns are TO DIE FOR! They are the perfect blend of stick sweet syrup and soft chewy dough. I wish I knew how they made their dough the perfect texture! My friend and I shared the walnut sticky bun (definitely get this if you like candied nuts) and a cinnamon roll with cream cheese frosting. Both were amazing, however we did like the sticky bun just the tiniest bit better. The buns themselves are quite large so I would recommend splitting them with a friend. The store itself has a drive-thru which makes it super easy to order and get your food, but I believe they also allow for ordering inside. I also had a buffalo chicken wrap and while the fried chicken was good, I found that the amount of buffalo sauce inside the wrap was a little overpowering. Overall, I highly recommend dropping by to try out their sticky buns, just be prepared for a food coma after all that sugary goodness! read more

Mr Sticky's - walnut sticky bun and cinnamon roll with cream cheese frosting - Bakeries Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

Very good. Must visit when in Williamsport. Took a box home back to Texas. Best when super fresh and warm but a minute in the microwave you are good! read more

Mr Sticky's - Bakeries Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

See all

RUN, don't walk, okay, maybe sprint so you don't hurt yourself - and find a Mr. Sticky's Fair Stand near you or drive to Williamsport, PA to their Headquarters to enjoy the BEST STICKY BUNS you will EVER have in your life! I am not kidding. When the sticky bun cuts with a FORK and pulls apart like pulling apart a cotton ball with that gooey brown sugar and cinnamon wrapped around the dough...you know you are in Sticky Bun Heaven. Want to know how GREAT these are? I shipped a dozen to my husband and I in NJ. Yea, they are THAT good and reheat very well. You won't be disappointed. Their logo is "extremely addictive" - and I think based on my review you'll agree I'm addicted. They serve great coffee and made a wonderful Cafe Latte for us (at the headquarters). Perfect pairing for a fresh sticky bun. In addition to a plain sticky bun, you can get one topped with nuts, a cinnamon bun (plain, cream cheese icing or peanut butter icing) and so much more. Enjoy! read more

See all

Amazing sticky buns! We Went through the drive through on the way up to the lake because this place was highly recommended. Great recommendation. Highly recommend! read more

The best ever sticky buns. A thing of beauty for sure. If you are in the area you really must go. There is indoor seating but the real star is the food. There is also a drive up window. They have sandwiches and coffee as well. read more

I was there at the end of October for my son's birthday. Was told about sticky buns so I went there and bought a half a dozen and brought them back to Chattanooga Tennessee. I took them out of the box and wrap them individually in wax paper and put them in the freezer. I take them out of the freezer let them thaw then put them in the microwave to heat them. They are absolutely delicious. I've never had anything like it before and I would recommend them to anyone who is in the Williamsport area to go by and try them if they haven't already. I will be making a order to have ship to me so that I have more on hand. I have already ran out of them. I'm hooked on them so that's the reason I need to order some to be shipped to me. read more

OMG! So good. I can not say enough good things about the chewy, crusty and gooey buns in addition the cashier was super patient with me while I read the menu. My tip would be when ordering ask for separate boxes for individual buns, because they freeze so well and also order a side of the icing. read more

Mr Sticky's - Bakeries Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

This place is sticky bun heaven. I was in town for the LLWS and found this place on Yelp. It's kind of tucked behind another building but is definitely worth any effort needed to locate. I ordered the Walnut Sticky Bun and a cup of the (very good) house coffee and was completely blown away. Hands down the best sticky bun I've ever had. I brought some home for the family to experience and they're now big fans of Mr Sticky's too. I will definitely be taking advantage of their nationwide shipping. read more

Amazing sticky buns and food. Their burgers are also a hidden treasure here in my opinion. I will say my only qualm is them running out before they close. A business who has been running as long as they have should not have this happen. We came about 30 minutes before close on Saturday (again a popular day where u should have more than enough)I had just bought fundraising coupons from my nephew. We live in Virginia so I figured I would get the buns before leaving the next morning at 4am (hence we tried to get them saturday) and the girl at the window said they were out. Imagine the frustration lol Thankfully the tickets have no expiration and we will use them on our next visit- but nevertheless annoying! read more

Excellent service along with excellent food. The sticky buns are out of this world. If you are in the area be sure to stop in and get one or a dozen. The location is a little hidden but most of the best things are. Be sure to get the cream cheese frosting because it is yummy. read more

Mr Sticky's - Bakeries Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

I rate restaurants based on their over all goal. For example, you can't expect Michelin standards from a Chinese take out but still rate it 5 starts because it hit all its goals. This place makes sticky buns and rolls as well as breakfast sandwiches. We ordered americano and expresso coffee. Decent. We order a sticky bun and roll. WAY sweet but they should be I suppose. The breakfast sandwiches were okay too. Bottom line we ate a bunch for under $25.00 For Williamsport the place is a hit. read more

I don't think I have ever said no to a Mr. Sticky. These stickies are always a good treat. I have never had of their 'normal food' but why would I when I can enjoy a homemade sticky bun!? Christians own the place and love the community. read more

Wow...Mr. Sticky's Buns are to die for... probably some of the best sweet rolls I have devoured! Found Mr. Sticky's by reading reviews on Yelp! Check out their menu! Wait staff was so accommodating! Will do a repeat visit every time I pass thru Williamsport! Try them... you won't be disappointed! So yummy! read more

I never even liked sticky buns until I had a Mr. Sticky and now I can't get enough! You haven't lived until you've had a sticky! They are to delicious to even put in words, but you must try them! read more

This is the ultimate calorie splurge! Not for any who are on the keto diet,low carb, worried about sugar or any of that... This is an indulgence and a delectable one! I cannot rave about how simply wonderful these sticky, cinnamon rolls are... with or without the delicious cream cheese icing. You know how if you see cinnamon rolls in the bakery at the grocery store, they look good, you get them, and when you get home and bite into one, it's so disappointing?? NOT THESE. It's best to only buy one. Okay, two. Because you really are in ecstasy, in absolute delight, and will eat ALL OF THEM. The only ones better than these are homemade. At least my homemade ones-- but heck, they take two days, thankfully, which is a deterrent, and keeps me from being an extremely out of shape mess. These are... otherworldly good. They also have other menu items that are very good too... their burgers are excellent. But these cinnamon rolls... Hallelujah!! read more

The chicken sandwich was great. I would definitely recommend it. The chicken was crispy and cooked to perfection. The salad was okay. I really loved the cream cheese topping that I put on the sticky bun. read more

Mr Sticky's - Bakeries Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

See all

Food is delicious, it is a warm welcoming environment, and the service is fantastic. Really made me and my daughters day.

Heaven. Pure amazingness. I cant wait to return! I stopped here for a quick bite to eat before a long road trip for work and it was the best decision ever. There was no wait and I quickly placed my order to eat at the reataurant and for a half dozen to go. I chose the original sticky and it was fantastic! Warm, melted in my mouth, and sweet. By the time I finished up, the line was about 8 customers deep and the drive thru was backing up. 5 stars! read more

Mr Sticky's - Original sticky - Bakeries Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

Fabulous as always. We come from North Carolina to visit family and always make it a point to stop by. Kendra was so sweet and accommodating. I hope this super "sweet" institution never changes. read more

I'm in love with this place!!! The food is so good and fresh. I'll be returning very soon. read more

Mr Sticky's - Smokehouse chicken and the best fries ever!!!! - Bakeries Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

See all

I haven't tried anything other than the sticky buns and cinnamon rolls but they are so amazingly good! We like to get ours with the icing on the side so we can make our own, half cream cheese/half peanut butter combo! read more

Best sweets around! Friendly staff. Been coming here for years passing through for work and I feel like it gets better every time I have it. The Original Sticky read more

Perfect way to start the day! Mr Sticky does it right, my favorite is the bun with peanut butter icing but you definitely can't go wrong with any of their special sticky buns! read more

Mr Sticky's - Signature sticky buns, walnut, original, and peanut butter icing! - Bakeries Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

If anyone has ever been to Williamsport and not gotten a walnut sticky bun from Mr. Stickey, then shame on you for 6 weeks, cause you don't know what you're missing! My out of town family always requests a variety pack of sweets for me to bring them anytime I leave town to come and visit. Anytime out-of-towners come to visit, I make sure to take them here. Just don't expect any friendliness to the waistline that's for sure! These things probably add up to my monthly sugar allowance, but man are they worth it. If you've never been, just get in the car now and go do yourself a favor. Just as long as it's not on a Sunday... read more

Best comfort food in Williamsport. Never had sticky buns or whoopie pies THIS good. Great sandwiches and fries too! If you're in need of comfort and carbs, this is the place to go. Try the peanut butter icing on the sticky buns while you're at it read more

Prior to two nights ago, I had never heard of Mr. Sticky's, but I realize I was missing out! My husband's grandparents live in Williamsport and my in-laws go up to visit every month. They brought some sticky buns home and put them in their freezer. They offered me one, insisting they were better than Fleck's of Bucks Co. I didn't believe they could be better than a hometown favorite, but I would never turn down a sticky bun. After taking a bite, I was solddddd. Oh my gosh. The dough is so soft and light, not dense or dry. The gooey butter sugar mix perfectly coated every square inch of the bun. My MIL had microwaved the bun, which elevated the flavor and texture. The smell? Heavenly. She then proceeded to tell me that it had been frozen for 6 months. S I X MONTHS. Yet, somehow, it tasted like it had been baked that very morning! So my suggestion? Call Marcy at Mr. Sticky's and get a dozen delivered to your door via FedEx. They ship across the US and I believe they're 100% worth it! The price, size, and FLAVOR cannot be beat! read more

Mr Sticky's - Sticky with walnuts - Bakeries Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

Food was crap. Salty, lack of flavor. Fries were soft and not seasoned. Go for the sticky bun and don't get anything else. Sticky bun was quite good, so that helped redeem our visit. read more

Employees And customers not wearing face masks so I just walked back out. Clearly owners don't care about customer or employees health during this pandemic. They only care about themselves. I will never be going back until they follow governor orders and protocols. read more

I thought Mr Stickys was fairly good, we stopped by for breakfast after our trip. We ordered breakfast special, which was a sandwich, coffee & hash brown for under 4 dollars. We also took some of the famous sticky buns, which everyone had told us about. (They are Extremely Addicting) They serve breakfast & lunch there, including soups, salads & sides. There is a drive-thru, so that makes it nice if you're in a hurry. Ample parking, cash, visa & mastercard. read more

See all

Grabbed a box for the family. Half peanut butter half cream cheese on an original is perfection.

If you're looking for something along the lines of a Five Guys, this is probably the closest you'll get in the Williamsport area. We go there when we want a burger that's better than fast food but not quite the price of a Friday's. Service isn't as speedy as fast food, but it's definitely worth it. Expect to pay a little under $15 for two people. The big draw, though, is the sticky buns (obviously). They're huge and incredibly tasty. read more