The Hamptons are a challenging place to run a business. Seasonal, workers shortages etc . This…read morestore was run so well for a long , long time. Now it has lost its charm and sense of what good quality is. I don't know who bought it but it is no longer clean and delivering what a high quality fish store could. The service is below past standard and just the presentation is less appealing. Please up your game. I miss the old Stuart's.

It was fabulous! We got 2 lobster dinners 2 lb each. It came everything! And it was delicious…read more All of the fish looked awesome. We will be back for sure.

Great food; Great owner! Our favourite place for seafood. Amazing lobster salad, scallop ceviche,…read moresea bass and blue fish paté!

Perhaps you've sampled the rest, but Mike's Amagansett Seafood is clearly the best. Yes there are…read morecheaper... but none I've ever encountered sells fish and seafood as fresh as what Mike offers. His blarney is a hallmark, as are his prepared seafoods, including lobster salad, both a house made coleslaw and potato salad that is light and flavorful plus one of the finest tuna fish salads that's made with just the lightest touch of mayo. It's so good I freeze it for the winter months when Mike is closed. With a couple of hours notice, Mike will also custom prepare steamed lobsters, one of the best lobster rolls on the East End or shellfish platters that are to die for. This is definitely a place to come for seafood and english sports on the telly.

I don't even want to tell people this place is good because it really is THAT GOOD. And forget the…read morelobster rolls! Get in that freezer and try any one of those desserts! The chocolate mousse is something you'll never stop thinking about... Don't go here if you don't want the memories plaguing your mind all day and cause you to think how an hour drive really isn't THAT BAD..

I found this hidden gem thanks to a recommendation from the staff at the Montauk Sound View. They…read moretold me Bennett Shellfish is a local, family-run seafood spot and, although it isn't a traditional sit-down restaurant, it's the place to go for a fresh lobster roll. It was less than a 10-minute drive from where we were staying, and going there was the best decision! They were offering two lobster rolls for $41, and they were worth every penny. Each roll was generously filled with large chunks of fresh lobster, a little diced celery, and just the right amount of mayo. They weren't overly dressed or packed with unnecessary fillers--the lobster was definitely the star. One roll filled me up, so I packed the second one in a cooler and brought it home to my dad in Nassau County. He loved it and gave it a 5/5 too! They also sell baked goods, and the chocolate chip cookies were delicious. Just keep in mind that there is no seating and you cannot eat on the premises because it's an active driveway. Everything is to go, but the beach is only a short drive away and makes the perfect place to enjoy your food. If you're looking for fresh local seafood, generous lobster rolls, and a no-frills hidden gem, Bennett Shellfish is absolutely worth the visit!

So delicious the lobster rolls are amazing the service is great just all around great place to…read moreeat

When in Rome, or Montauk, this is a must have! The Lobster is fresh, delicious and flavorful :)…read more This place has a shack off the highway vibe with friendly and knowledgeable staff that are quick to serve! Fried food up the wazoo and plentiful alcohol beverage selections. See for yourself!

The place of the institutions is totally unhygienic, especially in the deli area, that is the…read moredirtiest place in the iga. Not to mention that there are many employees who are totally rude and disrespectful, they treat customers badly, they treated me badly and I wanted to talk to their manager and it was a rude person who ended up yelling at me, everything was in the checkout area the employee's name is Yolanda. That day both the employee and her manager ended up yelling at me and treating me badly, I'll never buy in that disgusting place again, it's not worth it. A tip for those who are going to buy is to check the expiration dates of the products, since they never check the employees and we as customers end up buying products in bad condition.

It beats starving. Not lots of options on the east end for…read moreshopping. I typically bring most everything I need from the city. But there are times I am forced to buy something out here. This store has a bad selection, the workers have a bad attitude and overall it's a bad customer experience, plus I feel like I'm getting robbed when I pay. Now that I see they had that "Merry Christmas" sign it tells me they're red necks and probably Tr mpsters. Never again.

Very busy even on a Monday. Go early or expect to wait, but if you are not in a rush, it is worth…read moreit. The service is very friendly and accommodating. The setting is casual and the food is excellent! Fresh and well made and with many menu options. A must stop in the east end!

Went to try a hot lobster roll and also sampled the calamari. The calamari was perfect - crispy,…read morenot too heavy of a batter, well salted, and piping hot. The tartar sauce and marinara paired well too. The lobster meat was chunked rather than shredded (which I prefer) and really piled on generously. It was disappointed that the meat was super dry and not tender. Kind of disappointing for a $36 lobster roll when you expect the chunks to melt in your mouth and be succulent. We did ask for a side of butter to dip the pieces in and it did improve it slightly. I needed to also salt the meat since it was cooked in unsalted butter. Bun was a tad too toasted but otherwise held up well and was both crispy and fluffy. Side of fries were well crisped and salted. Service was great - our waitress was attentive and quick to address our needs while managing a very busy bar. Food came out fast. Had no wait when opting to sit at the bar (2 people) though a table wait would have been about 15 minutes.

Overrated to say the least. I was so excited to stop by Round Swamp Farm with the number of…read moreinfluencers that fave about it. I tried the chicken salad and it was honestly pretty bland. My friend had the turkey sandwich and it was nothing special. Someone else had an Asian chicken salad which they said was pretty flavorful. We all split the chicken tenders and I will just say- not worth the price. The workers were great and I loved the vibes of the place. A lot of great options for prepared foods. Overall just did not live up to my expectations!

Omg what isn't good here! This place looks small and the parking car be tight. The guacamole, tuna…read moreand chicken salad are amazing. Also got fresh mozzarella that's room temperature which makes it great to serve right away with their amazing produce. The chicken wontons were excellent with a spicy sauce. The dot cake and campfire cookies are amazing! This store is quality!

Amazing food, service, and ambiance! Staff is so nice and helpful especially Daniel. Favorite spot…read morein Montauk!

Love love love. Amazing ambience. Friendly service from staff. Great and consistent food. We always…read moreorder the lobster Cobb salad, love the dressing! The menu says the lobster salad serves 2 to 3 but it always seems to serve 4 to 5. The portions are generous. They were out of steam muscles so we ordered a different seafood instead dish, which was the clam Bucatini --it was excellent. The fries are absolutely extraordinary. They are thin and crispy. Fill out your order at your table, take it up to the window to pay, wait for food to be delivered to your table. With a bottle of rosé and a beautiful views, what is not to love here?? We come back as often as we can (post Labor Day weekend to skip the lines!)

So I needed a 4lb salmon to make gravlax and The Seafood Shop was amazing. We picked out the lucky…read moresalmon, I examined it closely, it was fresh and organic and a good price. The young man who trimmed it gave me a piece exactly 4lbs and packaged it in a heavy duty disposable tray that I will be able to cook in and throw away. So, in summation: service treats you like a valued new friend; checkout staff are knowledgeable and helpful; store doesn't smell of seafood, truly a testament to the freshness of their products. It is a sham that they have removed the fresh vegetables from the store, but I understand. In addition, all customers were given a big slice of their homemade jalapeño cheese cornbread. Not to be missed. I'll be back.

Absolutely terrible customer service. They did not pick up the phone, hung up once we finally…read moreestablished contact, and failed to meet a delivery time by 3 hours.

I came here for a brand takeover at this space and gladly, food from the menu was available. The…read morestaff was accommodating, friendly, and laid back. The space itself was an outdoor eatery with an old school, clam shanty vibe. I had a Arnold Palmer in a cute bucket (not too sweet, very refreshing), fries (okay, very crunchy), 1/2 sized lobster rolls (fresh, cool, & light). I'd check them out if im in the area during the warmer months.

The worst experience we've had in Montauk. Avoid at all…read morecosts! Tourist trap. Do not waste your money and time here. Make sure to ask what MP is because we were charged $45 for the worst lobster roll of our life. Do not get the hot lobster roll--it was absolutely bland. Tasted like old, rubber lobster. Zero seasoning. Zero redeeming features. It doesn't even come with fries. Came with a tiny, sauce sized container of the stalest, blandest slaw we've ever had. All the "bowls" of soup are served in tiny paper cups. $10 clam chowder and $12 lobster corn bisque were not good. Too many thickening agents in both gave a very strong, off taste. Chowder was slightly better than bisque. Bisque had zero lobster meat in it. All corn and potatoes. Do not get. Very disappointing. Service was non existent. Waitstaff looked like they were in pain from having to be there. This is a shack on the road with prices of a reputable establishment. Spend your money on countless other good options in Montauk.