very clean and organized!! They were very friendly and paid attention to everything I neededread more

Visiting Buttercooky Bakery on 6/25 and 6/28 brought about an increase in stars and better…read moreexperience. Stepping inside of this magnificent dessert emporium I became perplexed by the variety of desserts and pastries that were very desirable and readily available. In the words of Vinnie Barbarino, I'm so confused (IYKYK). It's a different setup that causes the line to move faster than it used to, I see the improvement. The ordering is done in one place and cashing out is next to it, in the same area. You still walk in and head straight to the display cases where you pick you pleasure. I did not pick my names sake only because it slipped my mind due to me being focused on breakfast. No, I don't eat cakes for breakfast. I picked up a couple croissants, apple turnover, a couple of cheese Danishes, and an almond croissant. Service was prompt and the employees were attentive as well as pleasant. I like how they approach the counter and inquire about your status versus staring at you letting you try to figure out if someone is going to help you or not. At the check out, there's the coffee station or tea. I ordered 2 French Vanilla coffees, to say the least the French vanilla flavor seemed distant to none. On the second trip it was exact same coffee request with the same results. An improvement needed is to have different sweetners for the coffee. Not everyone wants white sugar or sweet n low. Since the vanilla syrup is not sweet enough, another liquid sweetener can work. Nonetheless this was such a sweet experience! Inspire more, Yelp more!

12/31/25. Specially stopped by to get a slice of their Hungarian cheesecake ($5). Other favorites…read moreare the large pretzels ($7.50) and Irish soda bread. Crumb cake doesn't have enough crumbs. Service was better today than previous visits. 3.5 because some items are still a miss.

Definitely mid and not the best bakery in the area. We got this cake in the shape of a lamb for…read moreEaster which, while undeniable cute, was pretty much one-note and flavorless. Also was a bit hard and stale.

My family and I love the Salted Caramel Cake. We buy it for many occasions and it's always…read moreavailable.... Can't get much better than that!

This place has horrible customer service. I ordered cupcakes on uber eats. They are buy 1 get 1…read morefree. I only received the 1 cupcake. Why should I have to add 2 if they are buy 1 get 1 I should have received the free cupcake automatically. I will no longer patronize this business.

I had a custom cake made here in 2016 in the shape of a guitar. I think the owner at the time was…read morethe one who created that cake for me. The design, detail and precision were so incredible. This is what made me come back and order again this year. Unfortunately my expectations were not met this time around. The cake was nothing of what I expected when I went through the design when I first placed the order. The digital art that was placed on the cake and the fondant job were not neatly done. I'm afraid of what the cake would have looked like had I not supplied them with some decorations. Needless to say I was disappointed and will not be using them again for any custom cake jobs. I definitely did not get my money's worth.

Very good service and very good baked goodies! it's highly recommended! They're always fresh for…read morethe day. i told my friends to go here for the best and freshest! I love their raisin bread, danishes, and muffins the most. Oh, I don't wanna firget their apple strudel, the best! Parking is easy and close to supermarket, veggie shop and pharmacy. so accessible.

If you're looking for a baker that will cater to your style, look no further. I have been using…read moretheir business and everything they do comes out superb. Not only are the cakes aesthetically pleasing but also moist and decadent. We had wanted as special cake for our daughter. They patiently worked with me to replicate our birthday theme into a beautiful and delicious cake. Our 1 year old's cake was a two tiered cake with lemon blueberry cake with cream cheese frosting for the first tier. The other tier was a churro cake with cinnamon cake and dulce de lèche. I highly recommend them for your next event.

I've loved the cannolis and rainbow cookies from here since I used to hang out in Elmont 20 years…read moreago and would stop here often. Recently I've gotten back into going here and I'm so glad I did. The staff is always very friendly. It's a small bakery but with a very good selection. I've gotten a few too good to go boxes from here within the last couple of months and they are extremely generous with the portions they give for those boxes. The first time they gave me a large box full of pastries, a box with four large cupcakes and two loaves of semolina. Went again last night and recieved a box with 8 large cannolis and a large apple crumb pie. The parking lot is very small and in front of the store, so if they're busy you may not be able to find a spot as there are definitely less than 10 parking spots.

I ordered 1lb of rainbow cookies like I ordered the week before. I received way less cookies so I…read moreweighed it. They shorted me a good amount of cookies. When I called they argued with me and the employee told me they dont measure in ounces (although 16 oz is 1lb which I informed her of). The manager of store was very rude and told me to place a new order on Uber Eats and they would give me "free" cookies. They essentially shorted me, offered nothing and argued with me. WEIGH YOUR STUFF FOLKS. They can't don't know math

Worst Italian cookies I ever had. Expensive too... no flavor, strange texture... never again.read more

I've been stopping in during the holidays for several years. This past Easter I was scolded for not…read moreordering in advance with such a large order. My order was $180 and only two people waiting after my order was already underway. It was the owner too which is disappointing. You'd think they appreciate business and check the attitude. Oh well. Lost a customer.

I made a stop at this bakeshop after doing my shopping at this neighborhood. Cute little spot. It…read morehas a small dining area. I believe it is more popular for take outs, I see in and out traffic. I enjoyed looking on its displays specially of their fruit designed pastries. A unique presentation of each flavor. It's quite a pricey item but worth the try. Cakes on display cabinet has better pricing than my regular bakeshop. I may try to get one on my next visit and make a comparison if worth getting. So far, I enjoyed my visit here.

What a beautiful array of holiday pastries. These things look amazing and the taste was pretty…read moregood. These Mango one had little bits of mango in the center and that was a surprise and a pleasant one for some. The staff here is friendly and know their pastries so they can help you with any questions. The place itself is nice and cozy as well.

Amazing!!!!!! My husband has celiac disease, so for the last 13 years I've been eating mostly…read moregluten free with him, and this is by far the BEST gluten free cake I have ever had- it literally tasted like the birthday cakes I remember eating when I was a little girl. My husband said that everyone working here could not have been nicer or friendlier (he called a few times to make sure he gave all the right details!), and we are overall thrilled with our experience. This was our first time getting a cake here, but it definitely will not be the last! Thank you so much for making it such a happy birthday!

It is not easy to find gluten-free cakes, let me tell you, but this place has them. And for that,…read moremy wife and I are extremely thankful. They cost a pretty penny, but I'm able to present my lovely wife, who has a gluten allergy, with a cake for her birthday every year now. This bakery caters to pretty much every dietary restriction actually. We're just lucky to have such an accommodating place so close to our home. Service is great, staff is friendly. They let you put down a deposit and show you the completed cake before you walk out with it. We've already bought 3. Was pleased with every one. If you're a baked good lover with a food allergy or dietary requirement, definitely check this place out.

I tried this place for the first time and their cannoli was amazing!…read more They had so much varieties of pastries that it was hard to decide, but I decided to try their chocolate covered cannoli and their mini cream puffs (tiramisu and regular cream). All tasted really good, especially the cannoli! Their cannoli cream is not too sweet, just perfect! The cream puffs were good too! I definitely want to try other ones as well! They also had cakes, cookies and more and the price was great too! The large cannoli was $5 and the cream puffs were $16 per pound (I paid around $2 for two cream puffs). This place is small so you can take out and try! I'll definitely come back for cannoli and other pastries!!

I stopped by to get a bday cake. Lots of variety, everything looked delicious. Nice variety of…read morecakes, cookies, pastries, etc. I chose the French cheesecake which is lighter than the usual. The lady in the store was very nice. She wrote a beautiful birthday message on a chocolate piece to be placed on top of the cheesecake.