Delicious! Ordered a burger with pastrami and a cheeseburger. The woman that took our order was fun, and made my experience a blast! Food was served in 8-10 minutes in a busy Saturday, it was yummy. What a great lunch spot! read more

Fun lil burger spot. With good burgers. Price was a little high for a burger and fry but it's a touristy lil town so about what's expected. Fun patio area, nice staff, and decent place. read more

My Father's Place - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

I rated this a three because I felt it was just your average burger. I had the Sharlie chicken burger and my husband had the Mountaineer that has pastrami. These were good, but the chicken burger lacked seasoning. We also ordered onion rings, these were your typical frozen onion rings was hoping to get something better when this place is highly rated. The service was great, we got our food quick for as busy as they were.. we stood in line longer than it took to get the food!!! The outdoor area had lots of seating and there are a few inside, so make sure it's a nice day when you go so you can enjoy the outside area. It was great to go to once but think I will try a different place next time:) read more

Had to give this place a try since we were in the area- it's super cute, and the service is fast and friendly. They have a decent sized menu and everything came out quickly and was fresh. We enjoyed our burgers and fries, and if we were in the area would probably go back again. We didn't have a milkshake, but that is a speciality there so next time we would try it for sure. Overall it's a cute little place in the heart of town, and we enjoyed it. read more

My Father's Place - Fries - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

The girl who took our order was super nice and helpful. We got our food quickly and we were grateful for some indoor table since we visited on an unusually cold June Saturday. The food was fine- I prefer my hamburgers cooked a little longer, so next time I'd ask for that. Other than that, it was a good visit. Portions are huge. A junior cheeseburger was plenty big. read more

My Father's Place - Large fry, regular tater tot - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

Good food, great service, & the perfect place to be when the weather is nice.. whether it's a deliciously cooked meal, a tropical fruit bowl, or some freshly scooped ice cream.. My Fathers Place has ya covered!! Happy Yelpin Yall read more

See all

I have been here twice now and I seem to enjoy the burgers and atmosphere. Elk burger is really good, the staff were nice and overall good food. read more

What a delicious restaurant. Sometimes the line can be quite long, but the freshness and taste of the food makes it worth it. We have eaten here three or four times and always been 100% satisfied. I would recommend this place to anybody that is visiting McCall and wants a fun place to grab some food. The milkshakes are also very awesome! read more

My Father's Place - Menuuu - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

The burgers and fries were perfect. They state their burgers are cooked medium well, but we asked for medium rare and they delivered. We were able to select from various cheeses and raw or grilled onions. We both had a pilsner that was refreshing and paired well with the meal. We even ordered an unseasoned elk patty for a special treat for our dogs after a long hike. You order at an outside window and get a number to put on your table. It seems there's always a line to order, but that's for good reason. The food is delicious and delivered reasonably quickly considering how busy they are. If you want something to drink or a milkshake, you can go inside and order at a separate register to avoid the long food line. The outside seating is comfortable and seems to turn over fast. It's not fancy, but it's good. Don't let the line discourage you. It won't take as long as you may think and it's well worth it. read more

Great window service, order here! Limited inside seating and bathrooms, outside dining is the rule. Food very good. Pepsi products. Shakes good too. Fast service with service to your table. read more

Wow it's still as good as last time. Love the burger with the ham and cheese. Huge order of fries so watch out. Hope you are hungry. Glad it was open when I was up there. Thanks read more

Great old school burger joint, the mountaineer burger was GREAT! Wife had the bean burger and kiddo the cheeseburger, all were good read more

My Father's Place - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

I'm a big fan. Been in Idaho for 3 years now and let me tell you, the food scene and yelp reviews for places are all overrated, except...this place. This place was legit. We had cheeseburgers and wife had her mushroom cheeseburger as a keto, a few junior cheeseburgers for the kids since they come with the toppings as well as a milk shake. They were all done well. Food was tasty. Definitely worth the stop. Dinning area was small inside with some outdoor seating. It was adequate spacing but could get busy. Service was quick and friendly. read more

Friendly staff, yummy food, and quick service. This place was PACKED when we arrived and we got our food super fast. Bathrooms were clean, especially for it being so busy. Would definitely come back read more

My Father's Place - Menu - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

It's solid food but a bit pricey ($17-20 for sandwich, fries and a drink), and the line took 30 min, then 10 min for food. But food tastes fresh, good portions. It's a vacay meal for sure. read more

We come here often for their shroom burger, onion rings, and chocolate/strawberry shake. Such goodness! The burgers are the best in town. And the staff are all terrific. read more

Holy yum! We popped in for a bite on our way to our camping spot in Ponderosa, and now we must go back EVERY TIME we are in McCall. I don't know what kind of addictive properties they sprinkle on the burgers, but I'm hooked. I had a cheeseburger, my husband had the elk burger...both were amazing. Side of tots, and an 805 beer on tap, perfect lunch. read more

Oh my gosh. I can't speak highly enough about the place or their burgers. Any time you are in McCall this is a must have.

We recently moved from Southern California to the Greater Boise area. We decided to come to McCall for our wedding anniversary. An absolutely beautiful drive up. We decided to have lunch at My Father's Place for lunch. You order, they give you a number, and you find a table. We had burgers, fries, and shakes. I really like that they have so many flavors. I had blackberry. The burgers were juicy and tasty. The fries were good but could have been more well done. The shake did not have as much blackberry flavor as I would have liked, but was still good. The staff are nice, and the location is close to the lake. The inside of the restaurant has a musty, unpleasant smell. However, we will be back. read more

One of the best burgers i've had. Longest line ever tho. Would recommend trying at least once tho read more

My Father's Place - Fire House - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Outstanding everything! The customer service, the tasty burgers to the thick shakes- even the fun music that was playing- everything here was great. We stopped here on our way home to Boise and it did not disappoint! The bacon burger and sweet potato fries were delicious. And my husband had the Heli burger and it had the best blue cheese on it. I highly recommend stopping here if you are even in Mc Call . read more

My Father's Place - Sweet potato fries with multiple choices of dipping sauces. - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

Omg so so yummy ... burgers fries and gluten free options!!! This place is amazing . The service was so friendly too . And I'm just happy we came to eat here as a family read more

Fabulous hamburger, fries, shakes. Be prepared for a line in summer! They handle gluten free needs with gf buns.Its worthy!

Nutella shake is the absolute best!!! The coffee shake didn't have much coffee flavor and the huckleberry was good, just overrated IMO.

Absolutely worth a stop for a burger and fries In a small town. Great food and shakes and sides. Fries are crispy. Onion rings are big and tasty. And nice huckleberry lemonade to wash it all down was great! We were able to sit outside on the patio on a lovely fall day and it was great. read more

The food was good. A little pricey, but you get what you pay for. Quality is really good and you get a decent amount. Service was great, all staff were friendly. Would definitely come back read more

My Father's Place - Shroom burger - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

We came here to try their food based on the good reviews. We waited for one hour in the line for a burger that was nothing special about it! Dirty bathroom and long wait and a ok burger! read more

My Father's Place - Inside - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

Their umbrellas are blue which triggered my epilepsy. And I died and called an ambulance then went to the hospital. To find out the fries gave me food poisoning and I was on the toilet for 5 days straight. Never left it. And then they were all mean to me. Saying I was banned just because I stole probably about $2,000 from their register. So rude. 1 star read more

My Father's Place - Hot dawg - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Enjoyed our visit to My Father's Place. The Sharlie Grilled Chicken Burger with sweet potato fries was delicious. Happy they had fry sauce. The line was long and slow but worth the wait as long as you have a flexible schedule. The soft serve ice cream was rich and creamy. Enjoyed the outdoor seating and small town vibe. Will be back!! read more

My Father's Place - Sharlie Grilled Chicken Burger with Sweet Potato Fries - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

This place has the best shakes I have ever had. I tell you I have had 3 peanut butter Oreo shakes this last month and they are all bomb. The peanut butter to Oreo ratio is perfection. No one else has gotten it right. Also they have a bleu cheese burger that I would die for. Fries also delicious. I love it here, I am depressed on the days they are closed. read more

Fathers is an incredible restaurant that I would definitly recommend! The sweet potato fries are the best, especially paired with the house made fried sauce. Every time I come in I am greeted with smiles by the whole staff. Especially Delilah. She makes the best shakes and has amazing customer service. I will definitely be coming back and haveing some sweet potato fries and an Oreo shake made by delilah. read more

Super yummy burgers! Shakes are not very flavorful, but they're huge. A large fry would easily feed 4 if you're doing burgers and shakes, too. Lots of seating, but it's usually a long wait. We would wait a max of 45 minutes... it's not worth an hour and a half wait. read more

We drove up from Star, Idaho and we were both very hungry by the time we got here. I got the jumbo burger with fries and she got the shroom burger with onion rings. Both burgers were cooked to perfection. Absolutely delicious. We able to sit in the patio with the dog. The service is outstanding. Our food was out very quickly and the entire staff were very friendly. Five out of five read more

This place is on the pricier side to say the least but it was very delicious, I recommend their onion rings for sure! read more

My Father's Place - a mural of a woman driving a pink car - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

The food was amazing the tater tots were perfectly cooked and the grilled cheese was amazing my toddler inhaled it so quickly The staff were so kind and I got the Oreo marshmallow milkshake and it was delicious I also love the style of the restaurant so vintage!! I would come back here in a heartbeat 5 starts would recommend!!! read more

See all

Delicious food and service is very nice! You can eat outside or inside and the place is overall very nice. read more

My Father's Place - My Father's Place tater tots, burger, and mint chocolate chip shake - American Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Outstanding burgers and fries. The menu has lots of everything. We got the Elk burger and fries. Both were tasty and flavorable. The place has a great set up with covid rules. Lines is outside. Seating is also available outside. Enjoy. read more

See all

Every time we have come to McCall this place was packed. We got there just before the lunch rush which was a good thing. The line got really long, really fast. There is no indoor seating and only a few tables had a roof over them. We got lucky and got the last 2 person table and didn't have to sit in the pouring rain or we would have ran back to our car and eaten in there haha. The burgers we got but not amazing and the fries were tasty. The shake was so thick your have to eat it with a spoon. Neat place but get there early if you don't want to wait in line for forever. read more

I have been here a few times now. when I am in mccall I love to stop here for a cheeseburger and a milkshake. they have a stellar milkshake. like, one of the best I have ever had. I know it's not season and I know they have covid restrictions but the place was weird today. there are zero tables inside and 3 tables total outside. there was a constant stream of people coming in and nowhere for anyone to sit. people were eating in their cars. it was a little odd to me because they have 2 large patios and room inside for a few tables but they weren't utilizing any of it. we were lucky and scored a seat outside. I felt guilty as I was sitting there with my family and people were coming out frustrated and giving us dirty looks and sizing up how far along we were with our food. I felt rushed. I decided to get a charbroiled chicken burger and I regret it. the bun and toppings were good but the chicken itself was a little tough and tasted just on the verge of not cooked enough which i'm not a fan of. the fries were good and the tots were even better. my husband got an elk burger and he said it was good. I had a bite and didn't like it. elk is an acquired taste I guess. I got a peanut butter chocolate chip shake today and it was delicious. hubby got a blackberry one. both were as always perfect. I still like this place but i'll get a cheeseburger from now on and not stray. and I will be prepared to eat in my car. read more

See all

Just stopped in on our way through town, was a burger joint that worked perfect for us. Wife got a milkshake and I had a beer with lunch. Food was pretty much what you'd expect. read more