Visited My Favorite Muffun a few days ago, and it was delicious! I got the banana chocolate chip muffin which was decadent, moist and so yummy. I also got a gift box of 2 dozen muffins for my daughter, who I was headed to visit. We used to visit this place pretty frequently in her younger days when she was playing travel volleyball. Glad I had the opportunity to stop in again - great food & sweet memories! read more

Great for office meetings, good variety, I like the muffins size. Do not be fooled, Not a fresh baked muffin. read more

My Favorite Muffin - Great value Good for meetings or office First time trying and they deliver - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Louisville, Kentucky

Coconut cream muffin is so good! All the muffins are but this was by far my favorite!

OMG! I just tried their jumbo muffins.. and by golly, were they massive!!!! The double chocolate chip was ahhhhmazing!!! And the cookie crumble was great too! Definitely going back to try all of them read more

My Favorite Muffin - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Louisville, Kentucky

See all

In my opinion they are the best muffins in the city. Always fresh and tasty. Service is always great as well.

The place was very hospitable with a great selection of muffins at 12:30 on a Sunday. The customer service was prompt and friendly just the way you want it to be. I would definitely go here again as it's a Louisville hidden gem. read more

I love My favorite Muffin. They have the best Muffin variety than any other stores. I wish they had more locations.

Ok...... So I know I'm probably extra late on discovering this place of business....... But.... I did... and yes I heard they been around for years.... who knew... well probably everyone but me. Lol Anywho, this is an amazing little spot to grab some delicious food... and they are more than just muffins... they also have some delicious deli style sandwiches.. a must try 4 sho read more

My favorite muffin is a dessert/pastry shop located off Shelbyville road I. Lousiville Kentucky that specializes in as the name suggest muffins. Recently my wife and her half brother stopped by this shop and bought a massive assorted box of mini muffins to have at there/our family Christmas Eve party in 2021. The muffins had a nice large variety of flavors and packed really good flavor on the few that I tried. My personal favorites I tried were the chocolate and Hanna but muffins. Two of my favorite flavors anyways. So hard for me to not enjoy anyways. Our family and the kids especially enjoyed snacking on them mini muffins throughout the night. So they made for a tasty and unwise holiday snack. Something we will have to keep in mind for future parties or get togethers. read more

My Favorite Muffin - a white box with a red bow - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Louisville, Kentucky

See all

After passing by My Favorite Muffin every day for several years, I finally stopped in. WOW!!! I can't believe what I have been missing! They have an amazing selection (24 varieties!) of both mini and jumbo hand-crafted muffins, as well as bagels, breakfast sandwiches and coffee. There are traditional/common muffin flavors as well as unique and intriguing combinations! I bought a variety of muffins to give as a gift, and the recipient has reported that each of the choices were moist, and delicious. I will definitely return for gift-giving needs in the future. Orders can also be placed online (computer or mobile app). The coffee bar serves up a variety of interesting flavors too! I did taste a muffin and it was absolutely amazing. Because I follow a keto diet (lifestyle), I cannot eat the muffins. I would love to see some keto-friendly options in the future! There are many of us 'keto folks' in Louisville, and to my knowledge, no keto-friendly bakery options are available. Until then, I will be happy to provide these delicious muffins to all of my friends and family! The shop had signage about their covid practices and all staff had on masks. The floor was marked to assist patrons in social distancing while waiting to place an order. Seating is limited to 2 tables that are appropriately distanced. The shop is located on Shelbyville Rd approximately 2 blocks from the intersection of Hurstbourne Parkway. There is plenty of off-street parking. Stop by, you won't be disappointed! read more

See all

This place is great for a quick breakfast snack or gift baskets. I often bring the minis in for the office because everyone loves the muffin flavor selections. The big muffins are very good in size. They are always fresh, and they have plenty of filling (if filled or topped with something). My husband loves the pralines and cream, my daughter like the one like an eclair or Boston cream. My favorite muffin is in the minis...the pineapple cheese. They are delicious and super moist. The only item that I am not crazy about is their actual cream cheese. I find it a little sweet. Otherwise, this place is great!! Caution- they do use nuts in the facility read more

Would be great except the cleaner they use is so strong that I can taste it on the muffins. I think it's fabuloso? Regardless it's overpowering and needs to be mitigated. read more

After dropping my teen for a yard work job, I found my way to nearby My Favorite Muffin. It's been so long since I've been here, & I was delighted to see the full cases of delicious muffin choices...& coffee options. Bagels & breakfast sandwiches are available as well. Clear signage about their business Covid practices, limiting # inside at a time, only two high top tables. Marked floor spots for social distancing while waiting to order. I opted for the Bakers dozen of a variety of mini muffins. The butterscotch are my long time favorite, why is Butterscotch such an under appreciated flavor and so few dessert options highlight it? So yep to the Butterscotch, strawberry, chocolate chip and the 13th bonus mini of a double chocolate. A mocha coffee. Conversation at table with a very Covid careful trusted friend. Extra muffins for the sure to be hungry after yard work gig teen son. read more

See all

MFM is a big win with all my teams at work. I love stopping in to grab a quick dozen or multiple dozen muffins. The mini muffins are perfect for teams. Not too big and gives you some Variety to choose from. They are always a huge hit when I come in with a box of mini muffins. My favorite one is the chocolate cheese. OMG, so delicious! I've been pretty good I usually just pick up to give to others. Love this spot, it's busy in mornings but they usually get you in and out. read more

My Favorite Muffin - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Louisville, Kentucky

See all

10/10 the muffins were soo tasty and beautiful to the eye and priced just right! The lady that helped us was so sweet and patient (there were so many flavors it was hard to choose)! The Ambiance was very cute I loved the mirrors all around and the old school look! I would absolutely recommend! read more

Their minis are amazing and the great customer service makes want to keep coming back.

My Favorite Muffin is an awesome breakfast spot. I pass it every day on my way to work and finally took the time to stop in this morning. Patients used to bring in their mini muffins all the time, and they are delicious! I saw a fellow Yelper post a photo of their Boston Cream muffin, and knew I had to have one for myself. Not only are they amazing, but they are GIGANTIC! I could only finish about half of it in one sitting! The bakery itself is adorable. They have so many kinds of awesome flavors, so there will definitely something for everyone. All different sizes too - the large one that I go was $3.50, which wasn't bad for its portion size. They also have much later hours than most breakfast spots dot, I think until 5 or 6 on weekdays. I really want to go back to try their coffee soon. Try it out if you drive through Middletown in the mornings! read more

My Favorite Muffin - Boston Cream! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Louisville, Kentucky

I'm planning to give My Favorite Muffin another try but I didn't love it. I woke up this morning thinking about coffee but not wanting what I had available. My search for coffee on Yelp reminded me that I'd been wanting to stop by here, so I grabbed my husband and we headed over. The location is located in a shopping center, so it's easy to miss if you're not looking. Walking in, I was surprised at the space and happy to see seating available. The menu was bigger than I expected with large muffins, small muffins, bagels and coffee. Combo meals were offered for a slightly better price than individual prices. We opted for a large muffin each. I got the banana nut and my husband got carrot cake. He said the flavor was good but immediately regretted his choice. With frosting on top he basically ate a huge cupcake for breakfast. I questioned the freshness of my muffin at first - kinda stiff and stuck to the paper but the center was softer. Good, and very filling, but I would've expected better from a muffin made fresh that morning. I've had similar food from a gas station and definitely better food at coffee shops. The regular coffee had decent flavor. It's serve yourself and you can have 1 refill free. Before leaving we our purchased a bakers dozen of smaller muffins for a little over $6. We picked a variety for our 2 boys to try. They were excited when I walked into the house with them but reported they were just "okay, a little dry". Our service experience was mediocre as well. We were checking out the menu and letting the associate know we hadn't been by before. Other than telling us they were out of most bagels, he didn't offer any suggestions or talk about the menu. When someone familiar walked in we were all but forgotten as he and another associate chatted with them while checking us out. It seemed to be a younger staff so I just chalked it up to inexperience with customers. My Favorite Muffin does create boxes and catering platters for times you need breakfast at meetings or the morning after a sleepover. It looked like they offered coffee in bulk as well. I would suggest getting there early for fresher products and more of a variety. read more

My Favorite Muffin - Diving into my banana nut muffin - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Louisville, Kentucky

See all

Visited My Favorite Muffin on Shelbyville RD near the Hurstbourne intersection to purchase cupcakes for my daughter's fiance's birthday 2 weeks ago. There was a large selection of many interesting combinations of ingredients. The cupcakes came in a mini- and traditional larger size. I purchased 6 large ones and they barley fit in the box. I did not partake but the recipients of the 'treasure trove' of delight were quite impressed. A great 'fix' for those with an exceptional sweet tooth. All COVID guidelines were observed by the shop and its staff. Thee is ample parking and I was in/out in 10 minutes tops. You can even place an order on-line to expedite your purchase. read more

My Favorite Muffin - Why 'Let them eat Cake?' - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Louisville, Kentucky

See all

These were brought into work and they are addictive! I do wish they had the website updated to the flavor of the day or include a card of the flavors, we were guessing. They are the perfect bite size breakfast treat! read more

My Favorite Muffin - Muffins - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Louisville, Kentucky

Food and service. Staff took time with me while trying to make decisions on various selections of muffins

I've been coming here since I was a little kid, and I still look forward to getting a box of mini muffins to snack on. They have a variety of flavors-all fresh and tasty. They have my favorite muffins! read more

Fantastic. Great food and so delicious. Very nice people. I recommend going here. Tried to post and yelp said too short, so I am adding fluff. Would probably get yelp a 2 star for not being user friendly. read more

I have no idea what the location is like, but a coworker brought in a box of these moist, flavorful, delightful little muffins and I thoroughly enjoyed too many of them! read more

This is a rather simple review: every single Muffin here is a treasure, they're delish. The strawberry, the marble, the lemon, the cheesecake swirled ones... all amazing. And big! The flip side of this review: My Favorite Muffin has fabulous ham and cheese bagels! But seriously in the five years I've been coming here, EVERY single person that I've ordered a bagel sandwich from has been absolutely rude, outwardly annoyed, and semi-hateful because they don't like taking the time to make the sandwiches. A woman who has been there a long time with dark hair is the most hateful of all, and several years ago she told me to start calling ahead if I wanted a ham and cheese bagel so she could make it ahead. So I started calling ahead. And they all started being hateful and disgruntled with me on the phone about, like loudly sighing and acting annoyed. I've slowly just stopped coming in because of how embarrassed I feel to order a damn bagel. The muffins are great though, I can't deny that. read more

My coworker brings these muffins into work all the time, and they are the best muffins I've ever had. They are the perfect ratio of dense and moist. I don't have a favorite, because everyone that I've tried is top tier. Although I'd recommend the double chocolate and the lemon poppy seed. when someone brings in these muffins to work it really makes my day. read more

Love this place! I stop by here often when I get my allergy shots. They have AMAZING muffins. I try not to always get a muffin and just get one of their healthier breakfast sandwiches instead, but sometimes I cave and get both. Their breakfast sandwiches are great! But they have incredible muffins and a wide selection to choose from. They're large, flavorful, and fresh muffins that you consume instantly and enjoy every bite. If you've not yet stopped by, head there sometime for a fresh muffin and cup of coffee-- you won't be disappointed! read more

BEST Cinnamon muffins in town . Also not afraid to try new recipes. I had a Chocolate Bourbon muffin to celebrate Derby, it was GREAT ! read more

The muffins are to die for. I love this little bakery so much. There is so many memories between getting a "birthday snack" for school or getting breakfast. This place has a special place in my heart read more

I got the blueberry cheesecake, took it home, popped it in the microwave for 10 seconds and was in literal heaven for two days which is how long it took me to finish it......it was HUGE, and full of blueberries. I'm getting the Derby Muffin the second it's available read more

Decent little treat to take to a gathering. I wouldn't drive across town for it but we didn't regret stopping by.

I was literally cruising down the street on a chilled out Sunday and I happened to notice a MUFFIN SHOP!! I had to do a double-take because I've never seen a muffin shop in my life!!! I was like.... hold up muffins! So I did a U-Turn and whipped it into the parking lot a the last minute before closing. I rushed in and saw muffins everywhere I didn't know what I wanted for real. So of course I played it safe and went with my childhood favorite and got the banana nut muffin. It was so good, I told the owner that I was new to the area and he gave me so many complimentary mini muffins to take home. I was so happy! I will be going back again ! read more

Great place to stop in grab a bakers dozen of mini muffins for anything - a gift or yourself. They have large muffins aNd mini muffins. Make sure you go early in the morning to get the best selection. Each month the flavor changes call and check what it is! Only bad thing is the parking lot is ridiculous - I've past it up before on accident and after trying to turn around and maneuver on Shelbyville rd gave up! read more

If you love muffins, and want to ensure you have a large variety from which to choose during your muffin-munching adventures, My Favorite Muffin is the place for you. This national chain offers muffins in both jumbo and mini sizes, in flavors like banana chocolate chip, cherry cheesecake, coconut cream, lemon poppy seed, and Dutch apple. They also have limited seasonal flavors, which during our trip included pumpkin spice and pumpkin cheese cake. In addition to muffins, they sell bagels, breakfast sandwiches, and both hot and cold beverages. Our local store has a frequent buyer punch card program, as well as a specially-priced "muffin of the month," and half-price day-old muffins. My husband and I ordered pumpkin cheesecake (of course) and double chocolate muffins. The crumb is slightly more dense than that of a homemade muffin, but this does allow for maximal muffin moisture. My Favorite Muffin is not an artisan bakery by any means, but they make no claim to be. If you want dependably tasty muffins, you can't really go wrong here. read more

I stopped by today because I was already in the area and hadn't had a muffin in a while. I chose a new flavor, key lime which is still on my desk for later. The other choice was cherry cheesecake. The top had a nice crunchy top with a soft cake texture. Inside was stuffed full of cherries and cheese. Delicious! 2 large muffins were $5.10 read more

My Favorite Muffin - Cherry cheesecake and Key lime muffins - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Louisville, Kentucky

I received a box full of mini muffins as a gift and they were delicious! It had all assorted flavors so I got to try them out and there wasn't a flavor I didn't like. Now I want to go in myself to try the full sized muffins. read more

I only recently came to know about this place and we can't believe we have lived here for so long and missed it. The muffins are ginormous and the flavors are amazing for very reasonable prices. The pineapple cheesecake and coconut creme are our favs but you can't go wrong with anything. They run out late afternoon so I recommend getting their early. This is a great place to get a gift box for someone with a sweet tooth. read more

My Favorite Muffin is a mighty fine establishment. My parents brought me here as a kid and now I make it a point to stop in once a week before work for a bakers dozen of the mini muffins. The staff works in a speedy manner and are all friendly. The shop is cute and clean. My all time favorite flavor muffin is the pineapple cheesecake. I also enjoy the chocolate coffee cake, blueberry, strawberry and cinnamon crumb. One thing I will say is that the coffee drinks (ex: cafe mocha) arent very good so I stick with milk from here. Business leaders - this is the PERFECT place to pick up breakfast / morning treats for your work team! read more

My Favorite Muffin - Half eaten bakers dozen - mini muffins - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Louisville, Kentucky

Fast, easy, and inexpensive. The muffins are moist and rich in flavor. The right amount of sweet. All options are layer out in front of you. You cannot go wrong with any flavor. My favorite is the Orange and Strawberry! Muffins go quick, came in about 3pm and most options were gone. Come early to grab the good ones! Great options for meetings, parties, or just a snack. read more

See all

If you are on a search for coffee in East Louisville that is not the Star$$$, this place has it. They have fresh bakes muffins daily and a coffee of the day. They also sell the coffee that they make by the bag. They do mini muffins by the variety packs if you need treats for your group gathering, or the larger muffins for your individual breakfasts. read more