We have eaten here twice now. First time was takeout of pizza order was ready on time and hot and was the best pizza we have had in the area. Pizza is larger than domino's and so much cheaper. Second time was eat in. The place was busy all tables full so we sat at the bar. Even though there were only 2 servers on duty we were served in a timely manner. We both had the lasagna special with garlic knots and salad. Omg!! It was delicious. Will definitely go back in fact have a trip planned for tomorrow. All though there were some pretty rowdy tables, when they left it was quite pleasant atmosphere. read more

For a while, this was one of our favorite places for Italian takeout. However, our last two experiences have been so disappointing. Pizza a couple of weeks ago was barely edible. There wasn't enough sauce and pizza was so dry. Cheese was skimpy and crust was hard. Ok, last night we went back to one of our favorites, eggplant parmigiana. Again, a serious disappointment. The eggplant was way over cooked and soggy. The fettuccine was also overcooked and the sauce lacked flavor. Rolls were awful. To top it off, the carrot cake ($7) was tiny and tasted like a box mix. We were not happy. read more

Waited. ...got our own menus. Ordered Hawaiian pizza. Bland, flavorless.. never asked us for refills. Doubtful we will return. Stavaros pizza by far exceeds this restaurant for pizza. read more

We came here on a Thursday evening and there were few cars in the parking lot. Walked in nd was immediately seated with about 4 or 5 other tables occupied. Our waitress, Dayra came over and asked if we wanted drinks. We chose water to start and left us to peruse the menu. It was only two pages, but loaded with options . Dayra explained a few items and warned us that the portions were quite large, but we wanted left overs for tomorrow, so we ordered a sma;; (ya right) calzone and a spaghetti and meatballs (3 large) with an included side salad. Both enteees were good size and could have been shared by two people, but we were glad we had left overs because the tast was great. The marinara sauce on bothe items was splendid and the meatballs were tasty and I know will provide a nice lunch meal tomorrow. And did I say Dayra was attentive, informative ND A NICE SERVER. read more

See all

NY New Jersey quality here in Florida. The pasta dishes are above the rest with portions frequently needing a doggy bag. Stromboli can be custom made. Now to the reason for the name of the place. Coutom 16 inch pizza pie. You can even eat the bones. read more

Tried this place based on reviews. We came with our dining group. We had the meat lovers pizza. Lots and f toppings, good sauce and really good crust. Little crispy with some good chew. Friends had Stromboli and Italian sausage pasta. Both had salad. Nice and crisp. We'd definitely come back again. read more

See all

Being so tired of the chain pizza places we decided to try this place. So glad we did. This is how pizza is supposed to taste! Fresh whole ingredients instead of chips and pieces of veggies. Tasty sauce and cheese. Fresh baked crust! Do yourself a favor and give them a try. You won't be disappointed! read more

I orders the chicken parmigiana. It's served on spaghetti and it was excellent! The restaurant is small, no booths, but a decent number of tables. Server was on top of everything. The only thing I didn't care for were their garlic knots. Even though it came with a bowl of marinara sauce, they were very dry. A huge improvement would be serving them with garlic butter over them and a side bowl of garlic butter. read more

See all

Ordered takeout pizza and it was delicious. It was fresh, ready on time and loaded with toppings. It feels good to support a local place. Staff were really friendly. There is a small extra charge for using credit card so bring cash to save a bit. read more

Had mozzarella sticks as an appetizer, had a good amount of cheese and breading wasn't too thick. Service was quick and efficient straight to the point. Nice environment, not super big (more cozy) so can be a little loud depending on the people but didn't bother us. read more

My Italian Pizza - Supreme 10' pizza - Pizza Near Me - Leesburg, Florida

See all

Always full house. Why? All food is great. I have ordered from this place many many times and every time I've ordered food it has been nothing but great as expected. read more

My Italian Pizza - Me and Chet Atkins - Pizza Near Me - Leesburg, Florida

I recently ordered a cheese pizza from My Italian Pizza and was really impressed. It's so refreshing to find a local pizza place that doesn't taste like it came off an assembly line from one of the big chains. The pizza had that classic, simple flavor you want from a good neighborhood spot -- great crust, good sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. Sometimes a plain cheese pizza is the best test of a place, and they passed. They're new in town and I'm glad I gave them a try. I'm definitely looking forward to trying more items on their menu and maybe even going in for dinner one night. It's always nice to see a new local business doing things right. read more

Best pizza we have had anywhere near The Villages. Atmosphere is quaint and service was prompt.

Yes yes yes. Been here 3 times. Lunch - had hot subs. Next takeout pizza. Then dine in pizza and entrees. The food is consistently excellent. The pizzas - even the large ones - are completely cooked even in the center. The right amount of toppings carefully placed. Nice crispy crust without being a cracker. And the entrees were really good. This is like a really food neighborhood itslian restaurant. Not a fancy place - more like a family place where they really care about the food they serve. It shows. I'll be back!!!! read more

I went to Village Dental for a cleaning of my teeth. My hygienist Joan was very caring . I have Vertigo and she made sure that I was comfortable during my cleaning. She did an excellent job and recommended more procedures to improve the health of my teeth read more

Cozy Italian restaurant with excellent food, service and fair prices. I will definitely be there again.

The pizza was great. Very flavorful and thin crust. Our first time to eat there. Service was good.

Absolutely the best in Leesburg Fla ! Had a Plantation Blvd. Gathering with lady friends! They all enjoyed their pizza no complaints at all ! read more

Too expensive, food is mediocre and they charge for using a credit card to pay. Service was good. read more

The knots were super dry/not fresh, The pizza tased like cardboard and the wings were so over cooked I couldn't eat them and somehow tasted like nothing. Don't waste your time and money here with their so called "fresh ingredients " and fake reviews. Just make the drive to Bella Nona instead. read more

See all

Went there last night and had an absolutely delicious pizza! It is a small, out of the way, business, but has an ambiance that makes it feel very comfortable! Had a large pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms, and also ordered a large Stromboli to go, because the pizza was really good! My friend and I really enjoyed the restaurant and would recommend it too! Enjoy!!! read more

Nice little pizzeria if you're in the area. The staff is attentive and the food was great. I'll be back

The Pizza is very good, and you cannot beat the price. Staff very attentative. First time there, we will be back!

Four of us went for the first time, and one of us had the chicken Parmesan sub which she said was delicious. The eggplant Parmesan was also great! Can't remember the rest, but we were all very happy The dining area was small and the acoustics are horrible. We were seated next to a long table of about 12 people, and they were very loud. I don't think they anticipated such a packed restaurant, so the service could have been a little better. read more

We were there just one time for lunch , the food and service was great . We will be back . read more

First let me begin by saying their waitress,Lindsey is no longer there. She had a great personality and knew her patrons very well. The waitress that we had on Saturday,February 21 sucjed and NO PERSONALITY for this place. We arrived at 2:45 and sat down,she came over never introduced herself took our dink order. We ordered from the lunch menu but when time for the bill she charged from the regular menu price. We questioned and spoke with the Manager and she said we were not there before 3. So now we don't know if or when we will go back there; we will miss the food because it really is very tasty. So if you go there be sure you check the time of order. If it's after 3 the lunch menu should be removed. read more

Prices decent. Sliced sausage. Would have preferred ground pieces.. Service good. Clean in a house.

Good food, good service, reasonable prices - what more do you want ? Friendly wait staff; made good recommendations. Very plain place, but I didn't expect leather booths. read more

We went there yesterday afternoon for lunch and were very impressed with the food. Small, quaint, indoor seating available. Service was great. I had a meatball sub and husband had Hawaiian pizza. Very delicious. Give this place a try for sure. read more

I feel like Jenna and I went to two different restaurants! The pizza is absolutely delicious. Cooked as requested. Fresh ingredients. The meatball appetizer is so good. The meatballs are so tasty and have lots of melted cheese on them. Their sauce is great! If you like NY style pizza give it a try. We have been there 3 times and all 3 meals were great! Our waitress Dayra was very friendly and the service was excellent. read more

Well, unfortunately I have had to downgrade my original review from 5-stars to 2. The past 2 times we've ordered pizza from here, they were both awful. Did you change cooks? Did you change ingredients? OMGosh. We had a large supreme pizza Sunday, July 20, 2025. We ate a piece each & tossed it in the trash! Neither my husband nor myself found it eatable. My 5-star for you is now a 2-star and worse than that.........my search is back on for delicious pizza in the Leesburg/Wildwood area. read more