This place was great. The bacon egg cheese was so amazing. Both bagels were steaming hot when we unpackaged them. There was so much bacon on bacon, egg and cheese, no skimping. The cheese bagel was so great. I don't know why that's not a staple more often in bagel shops. Time was a little long. read more

Myrtle Ave. Bagels - Cheese bagel with jalapeno Asiago - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Im not the bagel expert, but today I was delighted by a Lox Super Bagel, for $13.00 that could have easily fed two people. It was delicious and filling and I'm a big guy. My teen age kids had to save half of theirs because it was so filling. Strongly recommend this Brooklyn classic. You will not be disappointed read more

Bageltastic! Wowza. Couldn't ask for a more enjoyable experience. Was served quickly, and the bagels were good. The bagels were not warm, just the ingredients inside, and there was a lot of egg inside the bagel. Still quite good. I got the bacon egg and cheese with Asiago jalapeño cream cheese on an everything bagel, and the wife got the sausage egg and cheese on an everything bagel. I'm walking here! The ambiance was nice, we sat against the window and eavesdropped on some real estate bros as they chatted and bragged about just how humble they are. Great for people watching! read more

Myrtle Ave. Bagels - Sausage egg and cheese. Duh. - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Excellent service excellent bagel. Must try cucumber dill spread on an everything bagel. The everything bagel chips and ask for the cream cheese spreads on the side for a little snack. read more

Myrtle Ave. Bagels - Everything bagel with cucumber dill spread - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Myrtle Bagel is a solid bagel shop in Fort Greene. The shop is standard with a few tables and counter to order. My first visit, I bought a few bagels to go and were impressed by how big each bagel was for the price. Definitely getting your money's worth! The second visit, I decided to get the lox bagel sandwich and was not too impressed. The everything bagel was dense and there was nothing that stood out eating this sandwich. It had all the fixings but didn't deliver. The price however is very good, I believe around $12-$13?, but maybe I'd rather pay more for a better quality lox bagel. read more

Having the Clinton in Paris bagel right now, so good. 10/10. Boyfriend had the Brooklynite sandwich. Also 10/10. Super friendly service, feels homey. read more

Absolutely obsessed! The blueberry cream cheese was unexpectedly amazing--so flavorful and fresh. This place has officially become my new go-to spot in Brooklyn. Can't wait to come back! read more

Myrtle Ave. Bagels - Bagel with blueberry cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Solid bagel- love the BEC. Super clean and great service. However, they must go directly to food jail for serving this hot sauce. Terrible, flavorless, and red dye???? Cmon. read more

Myrtle Ave. Bagels - Terrible hot sauce- please bring more options. Tabasco would be better than this. - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I only stop in here to grab bagels to go, so can't speak to any of the other items, but the bagels are awesome. The price is definitely affordable, and the staff hustle to get everything done. No complaints from me if you want a solid bagel. read more

This was my first time coming here to get a breakfast sandwich. I got one of the egg white special sandwiches with added turkey and I have to say it was good maybe too much cheese in it but overall it was good and I would come back to try other things. The place looks nice and there's plenty of things to choose from. My next choice would obviously be what the place is named after which is a bagel! They also seem to have a very nice selection of different cream cheese. read more

Myrtle Ave. Bagels - Main case - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Great bagel -- the cucumber dill cream cheese is so unique and so delicious. I'm sold on this place. New owners, great branding. You can't go wrong. Plus the vibe is great. read more

Looks like they're under new ownership, and it shows - I mean that in a good way. They're doing some refreshing to the space, and both the food and the service are significantly improved compared to when I was here last. read more

Pretty solid bagel sandwich. I got a Whole wheat everything with tofu cream cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion. I'm glad they have vegan cream cheese options so everyone can find something they like. read more

Myrtle Ave. Bagels - Whole wheat everything with tofu cream cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I ordered a sandwich and they bagel was completely burnt. How could they even send something so bad out read more

Myrtle Ave. Bagels - Burnt bagel was delivered. I can't believe that they would even send this out to anyone - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This was one of the only places in the area open on Thanksgiving. They had a lot of options on the menu, but after all of us decided what we wanted to order they told us the grill was off and they wouldn't be able to make most of what we wanted (?!) - we came in the afternoon so maybe it's only on in the mornings, but it was still pretty strange and they should have mentioned that first. Then after ordering a few bagels and a sandwich, the wait time was pretty long, and it was cold inside while we waited - the tables are right by the door so it's not a great place to eat in the colder months. But the main reason for 4 stars: I finally ended up getting my eggplant sandwich and took it to-go, and it was DELICIOUS (but oily, as expected) - I've been craving it ever since. read more

Myrtle Ave. Bagels - eggplant sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Placed an order today and I'm very disappointed with the quality and quantity of a dry bagel sandwich. Home fries were disgusting the cook should honestly taste his own food before serving raw potatoes to customer. A very mediocre breakfast spot where they will serve you a burnt sandwich. Forget about getting good customer service here, cashier is very unpleasant and rude. Owner should train his employees in providing welcoming service to his customers. Wouldn't recommend this bagel shop to anyone. read more

I used to go to this spot often. One day the owner (Asian guy) didn't fill up my spread properly in the cup. I asked him to fill it up and he made a big stint and was very unprofessional. Instead of being grateful he has a steady customer, he made it seem like I was doing him a favor. I suggest going to Bergen Bagels a few blocks away on 536 Myrtle. They give you the proper portions, have better prices and appreciate your business. read more

Myrtle Ave. Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

So yesterday I thought I'd be all adventurous and try another new bagel shop. ::sigh:: Sometimes its better to stick with what you know is good. No complaints about the location, the decor or even the staff working. The food was the disappointment here. First up was the Chicken Cordon Bleu on a roll. Good amount of chicken... even though I thought it was weird that they cut it into little strips rather than leaving it as a cutlet. Nice pile of ham on top of the chicken and swiss melted over everything. Sadly though the sandwich needed more honey mustard. I think there was only one bite where I actually tasted it. Also picked up a black and white cookie... in a word: EW!! Do not order one of these cookies. I've had such great b/w cookies at other bagel shops... not this one. This b/w tasted chemically, ugh, I'd like my money back on this one please. Also picked up a couple bagels for the morning. Large. Doughy. All around nice bagel. One star for the sandwich, one star for the bagels, and I guess one star for the establishment itself... like I said - no complaints there. I'll give it another try again but I'm stay far away from that dessert case. read more

Myrtle Ave. Bagels - chicken cordon bleu sandwich. - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I have been trying to avoid going to this place because every time I go or order something is wrong with my order. It's so frustrating because they're almost never that busy so it's just laziness?? Bagel world is a couple blocks up but they're food is so much better and they're so much nicer. I suggest going there instead for breakfast. read more

I come in for one small coffee light and sweet nothing more nothing less. They mess up that simple order I get to work without checking my coffee and it's black. Morning not ruined but definitely annoying. I saved the coffee and brought it back 2 hours later. I tell them the situation and albeit it's not the biggest situation but the nice girl in the front looked at me like i was wrong. She then took my order and says "Ok we won't charge you"... I wasn't paying for a second coffee in general. Listen i've been going here since I started college nearby 6,7 years ago. It's not the biggest issue in the world clearly it's the fact that if you can't get a simple order like that right it's super discouraging as a customer to want to go back. Be on your p's and qi's if you give a fuck and if you don't go do something you care about. the second coffee was good, thank you read more

Bought chicken salad on a bagel for takeout. Chicken salad was rancid. Won't bother with this establishment again.

Bagel is a pretty standard specimen. Ordered an everything bagel with less cream as the standard amount is usually overwhelming. The bagel itself was dense with a closed crumb. Not particularly chewy. The exterior was somewhat crisp and reading pulled into small pieces. The bottom had a small amount of semolina and was bordering on overdone. The flavor overall of the bread was flat and starchy. Needed more development. The everything topping had this vegetative onion flavor which I find off putting. The balance was okay, though more poppy seeds and salt would have been preferred. The cream cheese was standard commercial stuff, lacking the creamy richness of more quality products. Would I eat this bagel again? Only without other options. read more

Myrtle Ave. Bagels - Everything bagel with cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This place is wholly inconsistent, and has been for years. They often get orders wrong and about 75% of the time their bagels are hard as rocks. I was inspired to post this review, though, after getting two bagels, with visible mold growing on them. read more

Myrtle Bagel is your typical NYC bagel joint and very reminiscent of La Bagel Delite. With a huge case of spreads, baskets of delicious carbs, sandwiches, and coffee, you can't really go too wrong here. This location has seats for 10, so not big enough for a restroom. They make sandwiches, hot and cold, as well as the typical bagel with specialty cream cheeses. They also cater and do big platters if that's something you ever need. I ordered a #3 - an avocado, bacon, cheese on a bagel with a small coffee. The bagel is NYC standard - chewy outside, fluffy inside, and generously coated with sesame seeds. Like other La Bagel Delight's, the bagel is a bit taller than other places so you get a really generous amount of carbs and a sometimes difficult sandwich to eat. The bacon was crisp, the American cheese warm and oozy, and the avocado green and fresh. All tasty, well executed deliciousness, but not a bagel to write home about. The coffee, light and sweet, was standard deli level coffee and not too heavy handed on the milk or sugar. Everything was affordable, service was average, and the tables are clean. A okay by me! read more

Breakfast is Great, Sandwiches Great, Their Muffins are fresh always soft still warm upon arrival (delivery) so extra warm when in person. Staff and Atmosphere is always welcoming. Best known for their spreads and Bagels, but all other things are great as well. read more

How do you give zero stars?? I asked for an everything bagel, SCOOPED out, toasted with veggie cream cheese. The bread is stale. Half was scooped out. A dash of cream cheese. $7 down the drain that could've been used at Bergen Bagels which isn't even that much better. Horrible!!!!!!!! read more

Myrtle Ave. Bagels - Stale - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Come here for lunch on occasion since it's opened up a few months ago as it's near where I work and need a change from my normal lunch spots. Nice and clean inside with ample seating. Price-wise, not the cheapest place in Clinton Hill to get a sandwich and a tad higher than what I like to spend on lunch, but not the most expensive either. I've tried both the Cubano hero and the Italian Chicken hero, which were both tasty and a good size so it felt worth the $6.99. 3.5 stars, but I'll give them 4 for the benefit of the doubt and will update later when I get more chances to visit. Can't comment on the bagels, but will try them for breakfast one day. Hard to compete with Bergen Bagel, but they seem to have a good selection of cream cheeses. read more

Myrtle Ave. Bagels - Italian Chicken hero ($6.99) - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This is my go to bagel place, mainly because it's the closest shop to my apt. But, the bagels are very tasty and they give you an insane amount of cream cheese. I might even say it's a bit too much, sometimes I get an extra plain bagel and save some of the cream cheese for the next day and I'm not mad at that. read more

I wanted to love you, but it just isn't meant to be... I agree with the other reviewers, the bagels are doughy and heavy. There's absolutely no beautiful golden color and crisp outside that is indicative of a real New York bagel, in fact they're more like giant hard rolls than they are bagels. I was generous with the two stars because the staff is very nice and attentive and the cream cheeses are actually really good, but the bagels are awful (picture included), it's expensive for what it is, and the baked goods are actually made elsewhere (though the lemon bars are quite good). Fingers crossed that their bagels will change...completely. read more

See all

Good bagels, try to order in the store since they jack up their prices waaaaayyyyyy high on Seamless (like up to $3.50 for a lox bagel). Some (most?) of the staff were not wearing masks which is a little concerning. read more

Pretty good bagels in the area and they deliver!! I always get the everything bagel with bacon herb cream cheese. It's great and they put plenty of cream cheese on the bagel. They also have a variety of baked goods -delicious brownies! read more

There are a millions bagel shops in New York, each neighborhood has their own. My bagel shop is Myrtle Bagel. The bagels are fantastic, everything you want in a New York bagel. The coffee is my favorite, it's a great price and they have hazelnut coffee and not the syrup kind. But the real reason I love Myrtle Bagel is the staff. I come in 2-3 times a week and they know me and my order and are friendly and kind, it doesn't matter if the line is out the door, they always know how to make me feel valued and I love supporting a local business where I feel like part of the community. Especially when it's coffee, it's setting the tone for my day. :) read more

I have been ordering from them for a while now and it has certainly gone down hill. I live in the neighborhood and work on the corner of Myrtle and Vanderbilt (so like 30 steps away) and when I order delivery, there are issues 90% of the time. I often have to call and check up on my order: things will be missing, won't be on time, etc. I order delivery because I don't have time to walk out and pick it up but I thought maybe this would be faster... Today, I made an order at 11:30am for pick up (to be ready at 11:45am-11:55am). When I arrived to pick up my order at 12pm (to be sure it would be ready!), it was not ready. They did not have sun dried tomato cream cheese, which I completely understand. They could have called me and offered me an alternative? The girl at the front proceeded to hand mix cream cheese and whole sun dried tomatoes in a tub in front of me :/ Although I appreciate the effort, if I'm already standing right there, why not just let me know the SDT is out and offer me something different that is already made? I'm already waiting... I would have been happy to choose something else than have this unblended mess. The situation was made worse when I told said girl at the register, that I wish someone had contacted me and her answer was "I wasn't here". Ok, but this is a business. Do better, as a team! I personally always preferred their bagels vs Bergen Bagels because Myrtle's has a softer texture. I want to continue supporting neighborhood small businesses so I guess now I have to settle for tougher Bergen, even if they are much farther down the street. read more

Service was absolutely terrible i called to place a order they did not ask for name or phone number and when i show up their they say they do not have such a order i try and confirm with my order and phone number and they were clueless and said they have no order and it was the wrong place, until i call again to double check and they say they have my order and it was the right place. I have never encountered such ignorant adults who do not know how to do such a simple job as giving me my bagels. Very disappointed to say the least. read more

Great bagels, just wish they had a little more variety. I got the bacon egg and cheese on an everything bagel & it was great! Very easy to walk to, and super friendly staff. read more

I am writing the same review as I did on google. I don't normally write reviews but today, the customer service was mediocre. I made the mistake by ordering the "lox spectacular" instead of the "lox ruby red spectacular" by mistake. when I notice this, I called the store back and told them that I ordered the lox spectacular and wanted to know if I can bring it back. I never yelled or caught an attitude with them or anything, I knew it was my fault. so when I showed up, the black girl who I normally see when she takes people's orders, was pretty stingy and had a childish attitude behavior about it. All I ask for the correct order and I never accused them of anything knowing it was my fault, but her attitude was a bit off. Customer service should be 100% on point. So when the girl hands me my order, she said a smart remark saying "next time say lox ruby red spectacular not lox spectacular" with a smirk on her face, as if I don't know what the difference is. Let me remind you I always order the lox ruby red bagel, and I normally see the same girl. But the way she handle the situation today was rude. she even went to go on and laugh with her coworkers in the back as if I can't hear see what they are saying. I am a regular customer to this bagel shop. I have been going here for 2 years now, I will think twice about coming here ever again if customer service is not up to par. read more

Glad I waited over an hour for a sandwich less original than Joe Biden's campaign. I can fry a chicken cutlet better on the sidewalk of the Kentucky Derby. Less seasoned than a Vietnamese militia man. Beverage? Sure I'd love some coffee with my milk. Thanks a Latte read more

Used to be my fav bagel place. Fresh bagels and yummy cream cheese. Today I bought a lox and cream cheese bagel. The lox was slightly browning and didn't seem 100 percent fresh. The girl with dark hair who waited on me wasn't friendly at all. And another annoying factor ....the price listed says 7.50. She charged me 8. When I mentioned it she said this is the new price. If you are going to raise your price ...fine ...but take the time to change your board to reflect it. The bagel tasted slightly stale too. Maybe it's best to come early in the morning when products are fresh and service is better. read more

Was staying at an Airbnb down the street and this place came up. Decided to try it out and got the turkey melt which was really good. Cool, clean place with lots of varieties. read more

See all

I love this spot. I get the everything bagel with strawberry cream cheese twice a week. The bagels are so fresh! The cream cheese is slathered on heavily and what makes this place even more of a gem? 3.76$ is the cost of my delicious bagel with flavored cream cheese. They sell more than just bagels. They sell deli items using all boars head meats and delicious bakery items .. like b/w cookies and cupcakes and brownie bars .. they have an extensive coffee menu. Delicious by the way.. I've tried everything on there. The customer service there is amazing too. I always get greeted with a smile. The prices are great too! read more

Myrtle Ave. Bagels - Everything Bagel with Strawberry Cream-cheese - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York