WOW, I'll apologize for failing to take substantial pics. The place is small, no seating inside, it's plain, nothing too fancy with a Snapple cooler on the right and a small ice cream cooler on the left. We ordered 2 lobster rolls and a turkey sub. I ordered a Maine lobster - lobster meat and mayo. My daughter got the LBI roll - lobster meat, avocado, tomato and mayo. My wife ordered the west coast turkey - turkey, Swiss, avocado and citrus mayo All sandwiches were loaded w meat. They were fresh and tasty. The amount of meat in the turkey sandwich was ridiculous. Service was quick and friendly. If I have any suggestion, there needs to be a side with the lobster rolls aside from cole slaw. A bag of chips or a side of fries would be nice. Overall we enjoyed the food and I'm a bit concerned that this place is walking distance from my house. read more

Mystic Lobster Rolls - 1/2 west coast turkey sandwich. That thing is diesel. - Seafood Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

This is probably the 5th or 6th time my husband & I went to Mystic. Initially it was a 5 star review-- otherwise we wouldn't have gone back. It's pricey for sure, but it was worth the occasional splurge.... Then they changed their menu-- which at first was great. We had liked their subs, but when we saw the change earlier this summer, the guy working the counter said the change was to focus more on lobster creations. That was pretty much their social media tag line. The first time with the new menu it was pretty great & I enjoyed their tacos. My go-to roll was the Deep South. I'm sure you're wondering-- wait, she said it was great so why the 1 star? Well, we went back this afternoon, after not being back since the day after their menu change. So it's been a few weeks. And omg they have gone downhill fast. I ordered a Deep South roll; my husband got the Beach Haven and we figured we were in for the long haul, so we got an order of Costal Tacos to share, along with an order of what were supposed to be the brined yukon gold potatoes. All of these we've ordered before. None of them were the same as when we got them a few weeks ago. The potatoes weren't brined-- or weren't brined to the same level as they were before. When the menu was changed, the potatoes were addictive & really like nothing we've had before. Now? They were a few flaccid potatoes swimming in some oily muck. Before, they were tossed in a seasoning (bay or rosemary herb). Now? The Bay seasoning was clumped to the bottom of the container & there was the aforementioned pool of muck. Yuck. My husband had no complaints about his roll. It looked appetizing. Mine? Which I've had more than a few times-- was overpowering with a mayo that tasted more like Bay seasoning than chipotle. It was NOT what I had before, which was spicy, but not swimming in mayo. You could see and taste the lobster, which came in large chunks-- so good tail & claw meat. Not the shredded garbage that I had today, which was swimming in this bay flavored mayo. And NO CANDIED JALAPENOS!-- which are the maker of this roll. At $20.99 the roll should have been perfect. Not this garbage roll. The final insult-- the Costal Taco. Brown avocado. No Key Lime Jelly. Overwhelming with coarsely chopped red onion-- which I can still taste 6 hours later. Very light on the lobster. Very heavy on the greens, which were wilted. And several pieces of shell. I thought this was my go-to Lobster place. No longer. Changing their menu sounded like a good idea IF they were going to focus on producing the best lobster roll around. Now, with the increased prices what we were served today was just insulting. DON'T WASTE YOUR MONEY. read more

Mystic Lobster Rolls - Bay flavored mayo & no candied jalapeños. :( - Seafood Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Been wanting to try this place for a long time since it recently opened and I love supporting local businesses. They have a great variety of sandwiches and the Angry Roast Beef sandwich with roast beef, pepper jack, hot cherry pepper spread and chipotle mayo sounded amazing. However the only good thing about the sandwich was that it was big. The "meat" was processed and rubbery. Some of it was discolored and inedible. Was unable to eat any of it. The only reason why it gets two stars is because my Moms Italian sun was Atleast edible. Will try the lobster eventually but I'm scared too. Not to mention we heard complaining workers while waiting for our food. Disappointing to say the least. read more

Mystic Lobster Rolls - Horrible processed roast beef. - Seafood Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

Everything from Mystic Subs and Lobster Rolls was everything I expected, delicious and fresh. Ordered over the phone for takeout and went to pick up, inside it's kind of small so you can't really eat inside there maybe after Covid they will add tables. Ordered two rolls and the lobster mac & cheese and lobster bisque. The mac & cheese was so creamy and delicious and there was so much lobster. The Maine roll was fresh and filled with lobster. The surf and turf roll was very tender and filling. The bisque was creamy and worth the price. Can't wait to come back. read more

See all

Not worth the $$$ Lobster roll was fine but nothing to write home about just average and small sizes 5/10 from me read more

Great lobster roll and lobster bisque! Super sweet owner that made sure we got everything we needed read more

Mystic Lobster Rolls - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Great food, even greater owner! The owner really took care of us -- lobster rolls filled with delicious lobster, generous portions, and amazing conversation at the end of our day! Our group tried multiple types of rolls, the sliders, lobster bisque, & key lime pie -- all hit the spot! read more

Disappointed. Pictures speak for themselves. Small portions, no lobster pieces in lobster bisque, watery mac n cheese, over cooked filet, store bought yucky coleslaw. People were very nice though. read more

See all

We only checked the Google reviews, and thank god we skipped the currently-meh Yelp reviews. The lobster rolls were great and the service was amazing. We didn't get her name, but the owner, who seemed to be doing everything, was super friendly and brought us free key lime pie and lobster bisque, even after the restaurant was past closing time. Strongly recommend. read more

Kind service, delicious food! Was not sure what to expect but was blown away. We came close to closing, and were treated to extra soups and pie! Felt well taken care of--the perfect end to a long day and week. read more

Fresh and delicious lobster! Excellent cold cuts on the subs and loaded too!! This place is a must try!!! read more

Mystic Lobster Rolls - Wow!! The lobster is fresh and delicious!! The subs are loaded with good cold cuts! Everything is excellent!! It's a must try!! - Seafood Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

You could drive all the way to Maine and not get a lobster roll as good as theirs. I was extremely excited to try them and they didn't disappoint. A little expensive but you get what you pay for. They load the lobster in! Try the Connecticut. It's the best! read more

My friends and I were looking for a new lobster roll to try closer than Point Lobster. Mystic is a counter order place with tables to sit at outside. My friends all tried the lobster roll and thought it was great. I had the California tacos which were very generous. We also tried the lobster bisque, the shrimp and corn chowder, and the key lime pie. Everything was great! Best of all, the woman who works there, who also owns it, was extremely nice. We didn't catch her name, but she did everything herself and yet there wasn't a long wait. She was so enthusiastic about her food and is clearly doing what she loves. read more

The portion was small... It was served on a hotdog roll! My order which was different than my boyfriends came out same thing.. very expensive!! Lobster roll better at other places too read more

I love this place! The lobster rolls are delicious and the subs are HUGE portions! If you haven't tried the lobster bisque or lobster mac n cheese, give them a go. They're a perfect side for any lobster roll. read more