I remember when I lived down the street I thought this place looked a bit sketchy from the outside. But this is a perfect example of why you shouldn't judge books by their cover. It's one of those hidden gem places that over a wide variety of home cooked food for cheap prices! This place would get a 5 starts for the apple cake alone! read more

I cannot believe it took me so long to actually try this place out. I've heard so much about their famous apple cake! So I finally managed to go try it out and jeez I'm so glad I did. The apple cake is out of this world! I literally have dreams about it. The owner is extremely friendly and always cheerful. You can tell there is so much love that goes into making the food here by the way he talks about it. Also, their salads are delicious but their hummus is the best I've eaten. All in all I'm happy that I finally got to explore this little gem of a place. Next time I'll really need to resist the temptation to enter and grab some apple cake, if I'm walking by the place. read more

Great simple service!! Super reasonably priced! Everything seems fresh and the bread is warm! Get your banana bread immediately!!!

I know this place is really popular for their apple cake and banana bread, but to me, these were good, not the best. BUT, I still recommend this place for their chicken and potato sandwich. For a decent price, it's really filling and the best grab and go meal. read more

The apple cake is quite good, especially when it's fresh made and piping hot! It's moist, not too sweet, beautiful crust (yes I eat the muffin tops off stuff hehe), with generous chunks of juicy apples. Also got a loaf of warm banana bread for the office which was a hit. The owners here really love their creations and are baking up new batches all day long! read more

This is a fantastic place to grab a quick falafel, and Elias (the owner) is half the reason to show up: he will narrate your entire visit, and try to convince you to buy a slice of his famous apple cake (which is also really great). It's a Saturday tradition for my wife and I! read more

This place is legend. Elias is a local personality who makes wraps, awesome apple cake, falafel, and you laugh when you order. More of a takeout place, but they do have some seating. Muffins are good too. read more

This place served me possibly the best pita wrap I have ever had. I had their chicken and potato pita, the flavours of their house dressing, perfectly seasoned cooked potatoes and mouth watering chicken was simply amazing. The medley that happens on your tastebuds must be experienced first hand. The owner is extremely friendly and welcoming. Their business has been ongoing for a whopping 24 years and yet has only just begun offering debit transactions. This is now my go to spot for lunch or dinner whenever I'm in the area! read more

No, the name of this place doesn't refer to Jennifer Love Hewitt's vajazzled vajayjay. I'm not sure how it got its name but that's just one of the many questions I have about this kooky little deli/falafel shop, like: - How can everything be so cheap here? - How do they pay the rent? - Why does the chalkboard menu look like Russell Crowe's conspiracy diagram from A Beautiful Mind? - Does our trash really get sent to Michigan? This place is inconveniently located for me and the food alone wouldn't be a draw but it's the owner, Elias, who I'd travel to see. This guy is a real character. He'll chat you up like you're long-lost friends and tell jokes that'll make even the most PMS-ey Eastern European with jacked-up Brit chompers sport a big toothy grin. Then there's all the writing on the walls. When asked about the "Super Wonita" on the menu, we're told, "Wonita asked for a raise and I said to her: You want a raise or a sandwich named after you? She chose the sandwich." Other little zany gems I found: "Extra toppings cost more unless you bring it from home." "WASTE: Michigan Bound" on the trash bin. "It's a pita we're leaving -- we really falafel." (Huh?)[1] "All above items includes GST - Stories free - Advice - Worth a camel" If you go, get a falafel and throw in some homemade hummus and smushy lentils. It's a massive sandwich that is tasty and filling--but reconsider if you have to sit through a long meeting in the afternoon since the contents are highly legumous. I should also warn you that the optional spice is really spicy. I tried to find out what it was and Elias told me it's LOVE. So, I guess sometimes love hurts. But you really can't get any cheaper than this: a falafel + egg & cheese on a bagel + a bottle of juice came out to $9.50. Since Kat F. brought me as her friend, I was entitled to a free hug but Elias gave us each hugs AND a free slice of apple cake! BOTTOM LINE: You can get some ridiculously cheap eats here but you're really going in order to experience a wack-a-doodle Toronto institution. Elias is a role model for business owners. We could all do with More Quirk and Less Jerk around the city. ==================================== [1] O.M.G. I just got this! read more

This place DOES live up to the hype. On the corner of Richmond and Jarvis, the store front is a place you've always known and passed by, but you never bothered to stop in. I love this hidden gem! I walked in, and immediately Elias asked me if I wanted lunch. The whole experience gets 1 bonus star for him being super friendly and make you feel welcome. I got my delicious falafel with all the fixings. It was $4 including taxes. Crunchy, yummy, and super filling. As a first time customer I got the free slice of apple cake. And he gave me a HUGE chunk too! Yum. He told me about the wall of fame. Buy a t-shirt, proceeds going to the cooking camp he runs every year, take a photo in any place in outside of Ontario, and he'll put it on the wall. For each photo, you'll get a free apple cake, I assume it's a whole one! Or you can just buy this delicious cake - half for $7.99 (more than enough)or whole for $14.99 He also sells moist and yummy banana loafs (blueberry, walnut or chocolate) but he only makes 10 a day (in the morning) or 30 on fridays. But I'm sure you can tell him when you'd pick it up, and he'll make it for you. I actually ended up coming back in the evening to pick up a falafel for my boyfriend because he was drooling hearing about my experience. I got a t-shirt and half a apple cake, and he threw in a banana loaf slice too. Elias makes all the difference with his passion and friendliness, and you get people who want to come back! P.S. they do have muffins read more

Everyone once and blue moon, you have an experience that forever leaves an impression on you. Mystic Muffin was one of those experiences, and the story of the place is amazing. Knowing nothing about this place, I walk in and get a falafel sandwich with a side of chickpeas. Upon going to pay for my meal, they said they only take cash, which I didn't have on me. They said I could stop by the next day and pay them or even later that week.. I stood there dumbfounded... I politely refused this very generous offer and went up the street to an ATM to pay them. After finally digging into my very tasty falafel sandwich, I noticed a few homeless people coming to eat free of charge. It was then clear that place was special and deserving of the praise that it gets on Yelp. After my meal, I was given a piece of apple cake as a parting gift since it was my first time there. It was absolutely delicious to say the very least. I would even go as far as to say it's one of the best things I've ever tasted in my life. This is truly a unique place and I applaud the owners for their sincere effort to help those in the community. The fact that they serve delicious food is only a plus! read more

I did it! I'm a such a yelper! I went to, and am about to review "Mystic Muffin." We went in around 2, and they were low on most things, I gather from how awesome they are they are really busy at lunchtime. We had the falafel plate, a bagel sandwich, beef roll and the infamous apple cake. It was all cheap and delicious. The apple cake was free because it was our first time -- not an urban legend, they actually love giving first-timers free cake. My dining companion thought the food was good, but not as amazing as everyone said. HOWEVER, he said they were the nicest people in the world so he understands the perfect reviews. While we were in there they gave away free coffee and cake to homeless people and knew them by name. Really swell people, really nice lunch, really close to moss park for a picnic. read more

** Mystic Muffin now accepts Interac with a 25 cent surcharge, otherwise bring cash, no credit cards accepted, it's too costly for a tiny place like this.** It's been... 4 years since my last review (sung to the tune of BNL's One Week)... ... and if I could update my review to give Mystic Muffin 10 stars I totally would. Elias, the owner, heart and soul of Mystic Muffin is what makes this tiny shop so great. And now he is a proud papa of a little girl and baby boy with his lovely wife Annie. I think the place should be renamed Mystic Apple Cake because it is mystifyingly amazing! Then there is the huge list of menu choices, I have yet to bring a friend that didn't enjoy a Mystic Muffin pita wrap: Tuna, Chicken salad, Egg salad and Falafel, and then there are the veggie combos, so tasty AND healthy! Everyone ends up finding their favourite - my hubs loves the chicken salad on a pita with cabbage and potatoes, an Elias secret menu special! It can get busy at peak lunch hours, especially on Fridays, but please be patient, your tastebuds will be rewarded! I can't count the number of times I have brought a Mystic Muffin apple cake to a birthday or pot luck type event and everyone assumed I baked it, because it looks and tastes homemade, but I always fess up and tell the truth because I want everyone to visit Mystic Muffin and experience the hilarious and heartwarming service you get from Elias, who works hard, crazy long hours to support his family. And still, after decades in business Best. Apple. Cake. EVER! (Must be legal eating age for a slice!*) *TM: Mysic Muffin wall advertising you can see as you drive along Richmond east of Jarvis. read more

Amazing little gem in downtown Toronto. Very welcoming owner, we arrived late so some of the items were finished, but no worries there's a lot of stuff to choose from! Falafel and tuna pita sandwiches are amazing, fresh soup. Everything is made in house, nothing is processed. Fresh apple cake, that dessert everyone is raving about on here is as good as it claims to be. Lots of love here! read more

I don't come here nearly as often as I should, just because I don't usually walk around in this exact area of town (lame excuse I know). But, would it make up for it if I just DREAM about the apple cakes quite often?? ... No? Ok fine, so that is why I finally brought a MM virgin here for the first time today. Walked in intending to purchase one slice each and maybe a few more for family/friends, but was so shocked to see there were only 2 more slices on display! Then Elias being always prepared, told us he just finished baking a fresh warm batch and showed it to us. He asked if we wanted the whole thing... my wallet, and summer body (yet to work on) said 'no', but my mind and current body screamed, 'hell yeaaahhh'. When it comes to food, I am the biggest sucker! As I was lost in my own world of Apple Cake Heaven, something managed to catch my attention. It was Richard. I have never met or seen Richard before, but apparently he is a homeless, but harmless dude that is known to Elias. He got a free coffee and left. Then another girl (probably homeless too) politely asked Elias if she could get a drink with the wee money she had, and of course, he insisted she goes over to the fridge and helped herself to a drink. This is not the first time he's done this. I recall the last time I was in here, he gave a homeless man (which he also knew by name, but not Richard) free apple cake! Lucky guy! I took the time to enjoy my moist cake encrusted with crunchy sweet crack while I read his menu board, and looked at the pictures on the wall. I noticed he was hosting his (annual?) Kids' Cooking Camp tomorrow and for free... right there at MM!! There are pictures from previous years of the event. I am amazed how Elias gives back to the community! From the outside, it kind of looks like a sketchy convenience store, and I've actually never had anything else here other than a cup of joe and apple cake. This is more of a grab n go or a simple catering place. I really wish there were comfortable seating, music, and maybe some AC. I would be there all the time reading and never getting that summer body. *** He mentioned to us yesterday marked his 19 years of Mystic Muffin. I just want to say, congratulations Elias!! "Make apple cake, not war!"- sign holding by a baby in one of the pictures. (By the way, I gave my share of the fresh apple cake slab to share between a few MM virgins, and they all gave thumbs up!) read more

I feel like I can officially call myself a Yelp Elite now that I've been to Mystic Muffin. I just started school nearby at George Brown College, so I tried this place out my first week there. As promised, Elias is quite a character. It wasn't busy on the Tuesday when I arrived around 1, so he chatted with me, asking what my story was. I ordered a falafel, and was given a free piece of apple cake since it was my first visit. As I was eating, Elias asked me if I eat lentils. When I responded that I don't, he found that unacceptable and fixed me a plate for free. So for under $5, I got a falafel pita, an apple cake, and a place of lentils (that were actually quite tasty, especially considering I didn't think I liked lentils). The food was good, the owners are great, the location is convenient...but it's also sketchy. It's right next door to a homeless shelter, and there was a woman who kept coming in and stealing V8 when I was there. It was a bit of an uncomfortable situation for me, especially when she sat down across from me to eat my leftovers. I don't know if that's a normal experience or if it's more of an exception. Hopefully the latter. All in all, I'll be back for the friendly service and affordable tasty lunch, but I'll probably get it to go next time. read more

How mystic are your muffins? I haven't seen anyone here eat a muffin, but that famous apple cake sure is magical! As a first time customer, they give you a giant slice of warm apple cake. Not too sweet, moist, and pure yumminess! For lunch, I had the combo of the day. It was $6.99 for a hell of a lot of food. Cabbage salad, green salad, lentils, falafel and hummus...and a cookie! The lentils were delicious and all the veggies were crisp and fresh. The falafel was tasty, not the best I've had but still pretty darn good. Elias is one cool cat. Super engaging and friendly with each customer, it's not a surprise that this place is so popular and people keep coming back! ~Elias Quote of the Day~ "The food is hot, like me!" One of the best cheap eats places in the city, guaranteed! =) read more

Because my friends and I were too hungry (and impatient) to scope out the gigantic and extensive menu, we all had the falafel sandwiches, and one of us had the minestrone soup. We didn't see hide nor hair of the owner, so that was a bit of a letdown. The falafels were average - we all had had much better elsewhere (see "Sarah's Shawarma & Falafel", "Falafel World"). Even thought the falafel balls were "nuked", they still weren't hot. The minestrone soup was lukewarm and mediocre. It was the first visit for all of us, so we did receive the free apple cake, and it was very good and much appreciated. Definitely a nice touch, but the disappointing food, and absence of the owner, kept this review at three stars. I may be back to sample other menu items. read more

"So, how is your day so far," says Elias. "Not bad," I say. "So what's your name Jimmy," he smiles. "Andre" "Well Andre, Jaunita who's as hot as my apple cake is going to give you a free slice since I know its your first time in here." And so, I was hooked. I didn't buy any of the bandanda, tshirts (green for St. Paddy's Day) or coffee mugs (free coffee with every mug) but I did smile at the couple who came in with their infant in a Mystic Muffin tshirt...and I smiled at the couple buying a mug to take back to the US (by the way, the owner Elias says the mugs next year on Ebay will be worth $1000). Seriously, the food is fresh and yummy. Sandwiches as far as the eye can see, fresh salads (all kinds) and yumm apple cake. A lunch time paradise. Sit in the window and relax. Say hi to Elias. Bring a friend, get a hug. Bring two, get a soup, bring three and get an apple cake slice. If Elias were here he'd never let me review this without saying "we cater for corporations...I just brought 100 sandwiches and salads to everyone at Scotiabank's trading floor." Go see Elias, for the food, the smile and if you are lucky a hug or a slice of apple cake. Peace! read more

Walking into Mystic Muffin is like walking into a comedy show. Elias and Wonita are quite possibly the funniest restaurant personalities in Toronto. Basically Elias does ALL the talking, and Wonita is the straight "man." I used to work just around the corner and my coworkers and I would go to Mystic Muffin for lunch almost every day. Elias made a point of remembering all of our names (even though he purposely called me something else--I can't remember what, but it was funny). We'd often order the falafel and hummus pita, but the main event was the lentils! They are a must have! The other item of note (you really can't go wrong with anything, though), is the apple cake. Elias claims that it is the best in the world, and he's right. It truly is the best apple cake I've ever tasted. During the Christmas season, Elias often sets a goal for the number of cakes sold. A couple years ago he said that if they reached their goal, Wonita would get a bonus so she could buy a new living room set from The Brick. HA. I know I bought several--that I usually ate all by myself. I hope she ended up getting that new furniture. When the recession hit, Elias offered his customers free meals if they'd lost their jobs--I continue to have TONS of respect for him because of that. I highly recommend a stop by Mystic Muffin for anyone looking for top-notch Lebanese food, amazing prices (did I mention it's dirt cheap?) and a HIGH-lariously good time. read more

We FINALLY made it here today, after several failed attempts. What everyone says is TRUE! This place is the bomb. I can't get over the owner, Elias. Dude is a CHARACTER! He was so chatty that it took awhile to place an order. This guy could do stand up! Note that Saturday is not the best day to go here - Elias told us flat out that it's quiet on Saturdays so he doesn't have everything prepared off the regular menu. Go Monday-Friday. Come prepared with a story - he gives free apple cake to people with good stories. If your story sucks, then you only get a cookie. I had a falafel pita for $4 bucks. Falafel was really fresh as was the hummus. The rumours are true; we got free apple cake. (Elias ensured us a special "Jenny Craig" chip was baked into the cake to prevent weight gain). I really wish this place was close to my home or work, because I'd definitely be a regular. read more

Came in for the first time today to try the popular veggie platter and apple cake! They both lived up to and exceeded my expectations. The serving is huge for what you pay (was able to eat it for two meals) and has so much variety- fresh salad, rice, pasta, chickpeas and more! Like the other reviews said, I got a free slice of apple cake too since it was my first visit, which was just as divine as I was hoping. I now know where to come when I'm craving dessert (the apple cake is sold by half and full sheets too). Elias seems funny too and really well acquainted with the guests, which is refreshing to see in this city! Will definitely be back! :) read more

Mystic Muffin - The veggie platter- delicious falafels, salad, pasta, rice and more! - Sandwiches Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

What's not to love about Mystic Muffin. An institution in Toronto, Elias is so well loved because of his low key love for people and the city. People in need can come here for a free meal. Don't have cash? Elias will spot you if you promise to give it to the next homeless person you see. But peel away the philanthropic element of the owner and his family, and you get really moist and well baked fresh goods that is reminiscent of mums. For me, a visit to my doctors is incomplete without saying hello to Mystic Muffin and rewarding my colleagues with their deliciousness. Spread the love. read more

It's worth all the hype; down to every last ounce of it. The apple cake is THAT GOOD! Fluffy, pillowy, oozing with melt-in-your-mouth apples. They are not shy with the cinnamon either. I love the bits of caramelized brown sugar that form the crust (crispy with the slightest chew!). This stuff is an incredible aromatic and textual experience! I work 5 minutes away from this place and I can't believe I have never visited. This is dangerously close to me and I am hesitantly looking forward to many, many more visits. I had an exceedingly great experience with the owner as well. He went above and beyond for me on my very first visit. I wasn't aware they ONLY ACCEPT CASH and he happily offered me a piece of cake on the house. I went back later that day to pay him and told him he can expect to see a lot of me from here on. This is truly a hidden gem! read more

At first, when I heard people working about going to Mystic Muffin, I thought it was perhaps inappropraite to be discussing "mystic muffins" at work. lol But soon I went to try out this little place, and was blown away. They have a lot of healthy options (try the Lentils and Rice, only available two days of the week, tuna, the eggplant or potato wraps! )All the prices are SUPER cheap. The owner is a chirpy dude, contantly talking to his customers, making them feel welcome, asking about their days, recognizing the regulars. He even has a "recession plan" for regular customers, If you lose your job, you can eat one meal a day at mystic muffin until you find another job! I dont know the fine details, but c'mon! I've never heard of such an offer before. Mystic muffin, is the go-to place for end of the month broke lunches, or just healthy lunch. This is a great little independent place with a BIG shot of personality! read more

For years, we used to make fun of this place because of the name, the sign(s), and the location. We'd drive past and say, "Hey wanna go?" and chuckle as we drove past. And then one day, several years later, I went in. Oh my. For a guy whose favourite joke is "This falafel is making me feel awful," these are the best god damn falafels I've ever eaten in my entire falafel-eating life. The guy that owns the place is hilarious and awesome, and so is his hummus, and so is his damn apple cake that everyone rants about. Last time, I bought a half of an entire cake, a dozen falafels, and probably a quarter litre of hummus, and I don't even have any shame. Guess what it was? AWESOME. And you know what? I'm going back right now. Can't stop salivating. Don't be like me and wait years to walk in. The value you get at this place is rare to come by. read more

I scoped out all the cool places in Toronto to try while I came back from a mini trip and it just seems like there was something so amazing about Mystic muffin -... and then I read it: A.P.P.L.E... C.A.K.E! My eyes lit up. Done deal....Coincidentally, I was a block away from it on Monday afternoon so i wandered the streets until I found this little corner store with a sign with giant bubble letters, something that would not appeal to me at ALL.... walking in, most of the tables were filled, and I saw the lady (in the photo) greet me. Politley, she asked me what I wanted and I excitedly told her I was here for the apple cake.... Not sure who mentioned that first timers get it for free because I certainly paid my $2.00 and thanked her but none the less, it is the best $2.00 you ever spent on a piece of apple cake. The cake was still warm, soft and LOADED... no joke here... LOADED with butter. It seemed like there was some brown sugar crumble on top that was oh so sweet and I could not get enough of. If that platter was in front of me, it would be gone in about 30 minutes and that platter was mighty big. read more

I really wanted to know what made this muffin so mystic, so one day I walked into this low-key storefront. Immediately I felt a wave of good vibes envelop me as Elias greeted me and my partner. He offered us a piece of Apple Cake, and we immediately downed it and bought another. It was probably the best thing I've ever tasted....right now I'm craving another slice (or loaf!) We spent a bit of time giggling at all the cute puns and funny messages written all over his menu while Elias chatted with us. Since that day, whenever I'm in the area I stop by and say hi. Elias is always a total darling, and his witty sense of humour is really a delight. He remembers everyone that comes in, and greets them with a warm welcome. I've seen him turn customer's grumpy faces into big smiles with his positive energy and silly jokes. The falafels are amazing, as is the lentil soup, the baked goods, and probably everything else. Food cooked with love and good intentions always tastes better, and this is one place where you can really tell that the chef is putting his heart into each plate. Elias' Mystic Muffin is a much needed ray of sunshine in this seedy area. This man is truly an inspiration, and that apple cake is iconic. read more

A four star middle-eastern inspired lunch place elevated to five stars by great atmosphere, amazing apple cake, and the coolest owner ever. Mystic Muffin has your typical falafel joint options plus things like egg salad and tuna sandwiches. True to the name they also have a small selection of baked goods: muffins, cookies, and the world's best apple cake. Apart from the apple cake, which is an easy 5 stars, this is four star food; very good but not the best. I had the falafel plate for $6.99 and it was a ton of delicious food. What makes Mystic Muffin is the experience. This is a real neighbourhood joint and the guy that runs it seems to know everyone and he is the most fun, friendly, and zany dude ever. He prepares each dish or sandwich to order in front of you and he chats and jokes the whole time. He immediately asked me my name and where I worked and he, and his helper Wonita, referred to me by name for the rest of my visit. Because it was my first visit he hooked me up with a free slice of his famous apple cake. The whole experience just left me so much more happy than when I came in and that alone is worth 5 stars. read more

The falafels are amazing. Seriously. The muffins are too. Screw Tim Horton's and Richtree, you need a peach muffin from Mystic. The place looks like a dive but the muffins are truly gourmet. The apple cake is really unique and fantastic. It's a soft, fluffy, spiced slab cake with a topping of apple slices and crunchy melted brown sugar. For years as a student in Toronto heading out of town for long weekends on the Coach Canada bus, I rode past this place and saw the signs for the World's Best Apple Cake. Now I work down the street from Mystic and I believe it. I'm not sure why it's marked as wheelchair accessible. There's a step up through a narrow door to get in. read more

I finally got a chance to check out Mystic Muffin yesterday for the first time, and like most- I was impressed. I got the full Elias treatment which was wonderful- he made sure to ask my name, where I worked, and told me about the restaurant, including pictures on the walls and child cooking classes. I picked up a hummus to go, and it was very, very good. The free first-timer apple cake is everything you've heard and then some- moist and amazing. What a great place that lives up to the hype- good food and lovely people. read more

This place is unique. The interesting phrases add to the character of this place. The owner is similarly unique and nice. I only tried the $2 CAD Apple Cake. For two dollars (or a Twooie, as I'm told they're called) I think you'll be hard pressed to find a better Apple Cake. If I ever find myself in Toronto on Jarivis between the hours of 6:30am to 5pm, I'll be sure to try some other stuff. read more

Ahhh maaa gaaad! I'm in love...like the real thing this time. Oh ya, I got it bad for this Mystic Muffin! (Hmm...questionable phrase) I'll keep it short since the 5 stars says it all: 1) APPLEE CAAAAAKE! 2) Don't even read the menu, just let Elias take care of you - and that he shall! 3) Sandwich, soup/salad/whatever, dessert, drink under $10 (CASH) Healthy, unique flavours, and service to boot! read more

I live down the street from this funky bakery, but it took me about two years to finally venture inside and I tell you it was worth it! Yes, it's called Mystic Muffin, but muffins are definitely an after-thought; apple cake is the confection of choice. Be sure to converse with the friendly, quirky owner, Elias, and let him know it's your first time here. You'll score a free slice of apple cake that is sure not to disappoint! This is a great lunch spot since it has a wide selection of sandwiches, salads and soups. The falafel is the most delicious, filling lunch you'll get for under $5. I've also ventured here close to closing time and scored some discounted, baked loaves that are great with butter and/or jam for breakfast. I have yet to try the muffins... My only complaint is the hours - the place is closed after 5pm on weekdays, after 3pm on Sat and completely closed Sun. I kinda wish it was open later on weekdays so that I could stop by after work. What say you, Elias? Will you fulfill my apple cake fantasy?! read more

I've eaten enough Mystic Muffin to give an honest review. I use Elias for alot of catering at work and I've sampled alot of the food he has on the menu. It's true about the apple cake. It is unreal. I've eaten it countless times and it always tastes amazing. The falalfel is great and the sandwiches are excellent. If possible, try the potato and egg plant wrap. Sounds weird but its an amazing vegetarian dish. On a final note, the owner Elias is a hard working and amazing individual. He always has orders on time, and is such a nice person. He is passionate, jokes around and is always in good spirits. Great price, fresh food and an amazing owner. Mystic Muffin is worth the visit. read more

Mystic Muffin is an office worker's oasis downtown. Independently run and maintained with lots of love, this quirky take out joint serves up falafels, wraps, soups, salads and baked goods all at amazing down to earth prices. Walk in and you'll be astounded by the chalkboard menu, it is literally crammed with items, prices and little phrases such as 'trust me, it's good' or 'recycle!'. The wraps are delicious and cheap here and they also have a special 'better life' combo which is stacked with all the good stuff: lentils, cabbage, falafel balls and salad. Service is friendly and efficient, if you are a newcomer you'll be entitled to a free slice of their famous apple cake. Which is scrumptious. Goodbye Subway....hello mystic muffin. read more

This small bakery just east of Toronto's busy Financial District makes a really tasty Apple Cake! After trying a slice in-store, the Apple Cake earned a featured appearance at my family's Canadian Thanksgiving celebration. Must thank my buddy Bahi K. for introducing me to this low profile neighbourhood gem. I didn't get a chance to try the rest of the menu which includes nutritious meals, especially helpful for a bite on the run. Oddly, despite the small space with limited seating, Mystic Muffin creates its own personality that's well reflected in the jovial servers that make you glad you visited. The wall is covered with photos of people all over the world in front of famous landmarks wearing Mystic Muffin T-shirts. I wonder if I snag a picture wearing such a shirt, if I too can join the wall of fame? All said, a great distraction with delicious treats, well worth trying while strolling through this rapidly up and coming yuppie part of town. read more

Mystic Muffins are five stars for two reasons: The food and the service. Look, the famed apple cake is great. It's soft. Easy to take apart and tastes like an apple pillow in your mouth. A friend thought it was even better. I still have a chicken samosa and banana bread to eat too. I'm sure it won't disappoint. But the beauty of this place is the owner. He's a gem. When I first came in on about to get busy morning, I ordered the apple cake before realizing it was cash only. I was in Toronto on business. I didn't have singles of American dollars, let alone loonies. He told me to just take it and go. I'll be back, he told me. He was right. I returned in an hour to pay off my debt. He simply why I was back so soon. I then paid for the cake, bought two more things and sat down to eat. A few minutes later I heard him yelling "Johnny, Johnny." He meant me. I turned around and he flung a piece of banana bread at me. On the house. "Johnny is what I call somebody if I don't know their name," he said. I never caught Johnny's name but I can thank him here and urge you to check out the place. It's really good. read more

Mystic Muffin is not a restaurant or brunch place. Seating is very limited and there are no tables. Had a chance to go there numerous times to grab a quick bagel before work or a tuna wrap during lunch time. These are good quality but you will get fed up very soon - the menu is extremely limited. I had the tuna wrap & falafel over and over, and in the end I just felt fed up and dying for something new. The owners are friendly when they see that you are first time customer - they are chatty and will offer you a piece of "famous, must be legal eating age" apple pie for free, (which is nothing special by the way), however if you keep coming back, once they remember you they will start to harass you to buy a slice of pie every time - I got the impression that it's not really a big seller, but on the contrary they are trying to get rid of it by all means, especially if it's a holiday season. They will ask you "if your wife is making an apple pie and that you should by all means buy theirs instead". Don't get me wrong - the owner's "humor" is well intended - however it's over the top, trying in vain to be funny by all means, which is not really my cup of tea. The only good original joke is the "Michigan bound" on the trash bin. Oh, and did I mention the location of the place is shady, and avoid the park around it that some of the reviewers mentioned, since you will be harassed to give a change every five seconds or so.... read more

Stopped in here for a weekday lunch, and ordered a falafel pita with a side of spicy potatoes and a piece of apple cake. The pita was just alright. However, the side dish of spicy potatoes was great, as was the moist delicious apple cake. Despite my lack of love for the pita, I have to admit that lunch was a good value at $8.50. If I lived or worked in the area I would probably become a regular, but it is not something I would go out of my way for. read more