Pizza is decent, nothing I would write home about but it does the job in a pinch. I do like their two slices and a drink deal for 7 bucks and the customer service is good. The wing dings are hit or miss and the cheesesteak is just okay. read more

The lunch specials are the best in town... Not to mention the food tastes so much better than fast food. With the variety of pizza they offer you're sure to find something pleasing into your taste buds Check them out read more

Love mystic wings! I never tried their pizza but we always order their wings here since it's so good! The workers are always nice here, despite being busy. The place has few sitting inside and outside but we always did take out! Try their wings, it won't disappoint! read more

Overall- 4/5 Food- 4/5 Quick lunch. Taste and quick bite for a Friday afternoon treat. Had a slice of tomato pie which was good. Made in house daily. Steak sandwich was good. Meat was seasoned which is sometimes a miss on steak sandwiches. Wings were solid. Service- 5/5 Quick and pleasant. Owner worked the counter which is always a treat. He even knew a couple of regulars by name. It's always a good sign when you have 'regulars' Ambiance- 3/5 Casual and a bit dated. It's a true local faithful pizza shop. read more

See all

Consistency is key and I know that I will get a well made pizza every time I order. I don't explore the menu much because I'm so happy with their plan pizza and cheesesteaks. My favorite side are mozzarella sticks and they have a perfect dipping sauce for them. Everyone is always friendly and there are plenty of seats if you want to stay and eat. read more

Disappointed last two orders were wrong.asked for chicken cheese steak got regular cheese steak. Ordered chicken cheese steak with fried onions and mushrooms , got neither. Last 6 months foods has changed so has service read more

I only ate in there one time the guy at the counter wasn't very receptive towards me at all for just ordering a slice. That said having delivery over 15 years or so from there place has been consistent. Nice delivery drivers who got to know me and I got to know them, I've probably 100 times I ordered there only twice that I have an issue one time the pizza was blonde on the bottom was barely cooked, but it also was a Friday night so I can understand why. Go there you definitely will not be disappointed. read more

Had takeout for the first time tonight & I knew by the smell of the restaurant that it was going to be good! The dining area & counter were clean. The staff were extremely pleasant & friendly. We ordered a plain pizza, cheesesteak & French fries cooked well done. Everything was delicious and the fries were still crispy 20 minutes later. I recommend Mystic & will return. read more

They were extremely busy on Christmas eve Party of 3 dined in. Staff were attentive and kind. Waited patiently for us to pick and order. My family liked it but it was bit oily/greasy for me. read more

This isn't my typical go-to place for pizza or for burgers fries or anything of that sort. This was my first time here. I came here, because it was close to the area, I was visiting. Ambiance: The vicinity, itself, was ok. The design of the place didn't encourage me to want to sit and eat there. My order: I ordered two slices of vegetable pizza, and one slice of cheese pizza, a cheeseburger with mayo, lettuce, tomato, and onions, with french fries. The Service: The servers overall was average. I wasn't greeted, with salutation. As I walked in, the front guy thought that I'd ordered food online. I said no, but would like to order please. Still he didn't follow with, "Hello how are you"? or "Good evening." But everyone who walked in was greeted with stars and banners. I guess that only applies to their regular customers. I'm just pointing out that he wasn't consistent, across the board, with his interactions. Also, there was a woman and little girl standing, at the counter, the entire time, with a little child, talking to the guy the whole time I was there. I would say I was there for, about 15-18minutes. The man is working. I didn't think of it, initially, didn't care, but I'm pointing this out, because my order was wrong. I walked to my car excited to try the pizza, and it wasn't what I ordered. He was distracted. I had to walk back in and get what I ordered. It was corrected, of course, and the gentleman behind the counter was apologetic. Pizza Rating: I did not like the pizza at all. It was very dry and just not very pizza-ry. I know that's not a real word, but that's what we're going to go with right now. First of all, I have never in my life seen or ordered a vegetable pizza were the only vegetables on the pizza were; onions and bell peppers. When I asked him if I can get a vegetable sliced and he said yes, not a problem. I listed the vegetables I would like on the pizza. I said everything except for olives; so bell peppers, onions, tomato, etc., whatever they have, except olives. When I walk to my car, opened the pizza box, it was literally just onions and not square onions, like they were sliced big on the pizza w/ green peppers. I didn't like that at all. I didn't eat it. I wish I took a picture of it to upload here. It was dark at night, so I didn't think to take a picture. Burger & Fries: The burger and fries was delicious. However, there weren't any napkins inside the bag, a fork to eat with the coleslaw, or enough ketchup. I didn't know coleslaw came with the meal, but it would've been nice to have a fork to eat it. Payment: My food came up to $19. It's what I was verbally told. However, when I went over my account days later, I saw that I was charged $21. Is that a gigantic significant difference, numerically, no, however, if I am told that something cost a particular dollar amount, then that is what I am expecting to see you on my bank statement. Overall, I most likely will not be visiting this place again in the future. read more

Delicous chopped beef and cheese with onions on a soft hoagie roll. Tastes delicious! read more

Mystic Restaurant - Cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Montgomeryville, Pennsylvania

Wow! We recently moved to the area and weren't sure where to get good pizza after great NYC style in places we previously lived! Not only does mystic have great traditional pizza pie with plenty of cheese but they have a other menu options too! Tonite we ordered their ziti with sauce, excellent! Sauce isn't too sweet. I ordered ziti with olive oil and asked for broccoli added. Ziti arrived with plenty of broccoli and olive oil had sautéed garlic! Yum!! And everything was still hot! Thank you for a delish dinner!!! read more

Just tried Mystic again this evening and the food was much better. The pizza was evenly cooked, toppings tasted good. Very happy with the service and quality of the food. We'll be back for sure. read more

Mystic is a well known local family owned classic pizza place. I love the lunch specials and the serve it very quickly. I mainly recommend their pizza, hoagies, cheesesteaks and salads. Wouldn't recommend platters, ordered the chick Parmesan once and was disappointed. This place isn't fancy and doesn't have anything that I would say " must try" but if you are local it's a great option for lunch or dinner! read more

My coworkers and I absolutely love it here! The food is always great and the customer service is the best. Highly recommend. read more

Mystic Restaurant - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Montgomeryville, Pennsylvania

1st time ordering delivery from this place. Came highly recommended from the residents at Abraham's Center for Jewish Life. My significant other is currently a resident there. Ordered a pizza, mozzarella sticks and extra sauce estimated delivery was 602-617pm, when I placed the order I indicated where we were located so there was no mistake in location. After several text messages and calls the food arrived at 645pm COLD and MISSING the extra sauce. Ok I get the address was entered wrong but it took them 40 minutes to contact me and verify where we were located!! I don't know anyone who would be happy paying over $40 for COLD soggy disgusting food!! No credit or refund was issued no I am sorry for the delay NOTHING!! Mind you the delivery driver called and asked if we were at the Abrham's Center because he knew exactly where that was since his own father is a resident there!!! Mystic sucks and 1 star is too many for these losers. Justify $40 for 1 pizza, mozzarella sticks, soda.. I don't make a ton of money and this was a pre holiday treat for my ailing boyfriend. Mystic is not worth my money and I will never order from them again. At the very least a credit should have been given!!! read more

Mystic Restaurant - Crappy Mystic Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Montgomeryville, Pennsylvania

the wings here are one of the best I have gotten. I didn't get to try the pizza because the wings here captivated my taste buds. they way it is fried; it is freaking to die for. I did get to try the chicken parm which was pretty good but nothing too special. I would go back to try the pizza to see how it is but I feel like if I go back, I would just order the wings again. the place is small and not very fancy. the atmosphere is a bit bland. the staff is friendly; they treat you to free soda if you order enough and they're just very lax about how they approach things which to me is fine. read more

Mystic Restaurant - I wings and more wings - Pizza Near Me - Montgomeryville, Pennsylvania

I recommend this place the food there is good the pizza was alright i only had it once do idk and the place is good I recommend

Mystic Pizza is a local pizzeria in the Village Plaza that turns out beautiful pizzas and delicious sandwiches. They have a homey dining room with lots of seating, and images of Europe on the walls. If you like, you can phone in orders (like we usually do), and pick up your pies within the hour. Staff are friendly and gave us free pens last we were there. Try Mystic's pizza with sausages and green peppers. Thin crust, cheesy cheese, and generous toppings (plus the perfect amount of grease) made us happy diners. Their sandwiches are bueno too: try the turkey hoagie with oil, or go for their soda and cheesesteak special. read more

Mystic Restaurant - Italian hoagie - Pizza Near Me - Montgomeryville, Pennsylvania

Food is awesome, staff is friendly and the place is clean. It's my new go-to lunch spot. Thanks guys!

I have been going to Mystic Pizza for about 20 years, recently i have been noticing food quality going down and the prices are going up eg. had a pepperoni pizza burger with no pizza sauce (GRRRR) and over cooked burger!! and a soda for $16.00 ridiculous, i wont be going back EVER!! pizza sucks NOW!! Ill be going too Montgomeryville Pizza from now on!! Mystic SUCKS!! read more

Asked to give credit card number to reserve table. When we had to cancel due to illness we were charged 100.00. If this is the policy of the restaurant that's fine but customers should be told up front a 50.00 per head charge for canceled appt. read more

Mystics has, and always will, hold a place in my heart. This modest pizzeria is quaint and rustic, and has a warm homely vibe to it. They have a smaller old fashion TV atop the few refrigerators filled with beverages. The staff is incredibly friendly and try to get to know you, and they'll even hook you up with a free drink if you order enough. They allowed eating in, as well as take out and delivery. The food is always on point. They're affordable and cozy. However, the main selling point are their wings. These wings are INSANE. They're fried to perfection, and these crispy bundles of joy are the best foods in the world. They're like little crack wings that fell from heaven. My girlfriend and I chose to celebrate monthiversaries here just because of the wings. I highly recommend any wing lovers to try these wings. read more

Mystic Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Montgomeryville, Pennsylvania

This was the smallest, most OKAY pizza I've experienced out of New York with a pricey price tag to go along with it. Are you serious? When my gal pal had said this was there go-to place in PA for pizza, I really felt sorry for her. The place looked like it was stuck in time of a classic old looking pizzeria from my childhood days. The dirty counter, the dim lights, and the slide in booths - ahh nostalgia! The pizza box was small, but DAMN was the pizza even smaller! I easily could have split this thing with just my husband and I, but this was for feeding four people. The disappointment is still hanging in the air even today. I don't quite get the hype, but I would order more than usual if you want to remain full for longer than an hour. read more

Excellent customer service . I tried their buffalo pizza ranch and I have to admit it's worth the penny. Very kind people who care a lot about the customer. I absolutely recommend this place not just for the food but the customer importance. read more

Gave this place a try for takeout - pizza was good, everything else average: Hoagie - didn't include oil and vinegar even though I asked, and why do I have to ask? Cheesesteak - dry, not enough cheese and bearable if you had ketchup. Chicken wings - just okay, dry. Shrimp - not great. read more

Just had a fabulous vegetable pizza on Saturday. I've been driving past this place for 25 years because I live on the same street, but for some reason never stopped in. This is going to be my new favorite pizza and Italian food place. And they deliver for $1! read more

I don't care what else you read. I eat here often. The owners are friendly. Food is great and is made quickly. Don't let them push the pineapple Fanta on you. It's good though lol. read more

Doesn't look like much when you walk in, but past that everything was perfect. I was super hunger so called in to order tomato pie and fries. Loved both of them. I would highly recommend it. read more

Driving through Montgomeryville last night, I searched Yelp for pizza shops, and Mystic Pizza seemed to be pretty much the only game in town so I gave it a try. It did not disappoint. Their pizza is fantastic. It has good crust, appropriately thin under the cheese, and crispy with a very slight chewiness at the edges. They use good, cheesy cheese. The kind of real mozzarella that leaves strings coming off every which way if you cut it when it's piping hot, but that has a fresh natural flavor and gives just the touch of greasiness that a pizza needs. The sauce tasted fresh and was well seasoned. And the quality of the toppings was top notch. Mine had prosciutto (an interesting topping option that really worked), black olives, and mushrooms, all of which were good, no slimy canned stuffed or anything like that. I also tried their cheesesteak. It was above average. I wouldn't put it on my best cheesesteaks list, but it had the right meat, the right amount of cheese, the right amount of freshly friend onions, and a pretty good roll. It's a basic order-at-the-counter, plastic-lettered menu board kind of place, the furniture, flooring and light fixtures are a little mismatched. It seems clean, and the dine-in area is comfortable, though. And the service was great. The employees were really friendly and were on the ball. And, the prices are good. Taking it all together, if I lived closer, I would be happy to have it as my regular pizza place, and I definitely expect to be back on the not-infrequent occasions that I'm in Montgomeryville on a Friday evening. read more

Ordered a pizza with bacon, got charged for a pizza with bacon, no bacon on the pizza. On top of it all, the pizza is inedibly subpar... I'd avoid unless you want your order messed up read more

1st time caller. Yes, needed delivery. Ordered mozzarella cheese calzones, Steak with fried onions. Grease was flying out & calzones were empty. Won't be ordering again. DISAPPOINTED!!! read more

Friendly staff and always have had my order ready when I expected them to. Food tastes fine but have had some issues with some orders. One time my pizza was too wet and couldn't pick up any slices without them falling apart. Another time the bottom of my Stromboli was burnt. I want to like them but have not have good experiences with the quality of their food. read more

Mystic Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Montgomeryville, Pennsylvania

Hey! I haven't been in the area long. I had my old faves in my old neighborhood. I took a chance tonite and ordered a cheesesteak stromboli with extra cheese. This was the BEST stromboli I have ever had! This restaurant has won me over!!! Absolutely delicious!!! read more

The best pizza and cheesesteaks around and family owned. If you're looking for a take out spot during this quarantine look no further!!!

This is a family friendly, order at the counter and clean up after yourself kind of place. The type of food served here is pretty all-American basic food for the soul: pizza, sandwiches, wings...etc. I've never had their pizza, but their breaded wings are amazing. It's super simple, just breaded, deep fried and comes with a side of hot sauce, but yet so satisfying. The breading has the perfect level of crispiness and is well seasoned. The meat on the inside is perfectly cooked, not dried up. If you're in the mood for some simple breaded wings, this is the go to place. read more

Mystic Restaurant - Breaded wings and onion rings - Pizza Near Me - Montgomeryville, Pennsylvania

I have already reviewed this place two or three times because this is my favorite local biz and it deserves all the accolades, but YELP keeps hiding it and taking it down. Great food, pizza is quality thin crust and I love the unique pizzas they come up with from time to time! If you are lucky enough, try the focaccia slice... it won't disappoint! The place is clean, quaint and comfy. The staff is awesome, super helpful and really feels like the family owned and operated biz it has been for over 20 years! Don't delete my review... go try them! read more

-One of the best local places around. It's family owned and has been a staple of the local community for a long while, everyone here is super friendly! -I'm a fan of their pizza but pretty much everything is great on their menu, I've had many parties catered through them and they always deliver on quality! -If you're in the the area or even thinking about getting a slice, look no further than Mystic! read more

The pizza here is decent with plenty of cheese and a perfectly greasy, thin crust. It's great for those nights when you are craving some good old-fashioned takeout pies, although the cheesesteak pie with garlic sauce is a family favorite, too. It's a great pick if you can't decide between a cheesesteak and a pizza. Staff here are very friendly and they always have our food ready when we pick it up. read more

Order take out from here at least once a week cause My kids love the food that much . The pizza is by far the Best in the area . Perfect balance of cheese and grease lol Cheesesteaks and gyros are on point as well.. Staff is always friendly and delivery Is always prompt and more Importantly the order is correct . Glad to have a go to spot When cooking at home isn't an option. read more