we live right around the corner, so we are frequent customers…read more the pizza selection is diverse, the knots are delish, and the staff are friendly. the owner is a local guy and is really nice! i recommend this place 100%

I have been wanting to try this place for a few months. The other day I finally was able to make…read morethe time to check it out. I'm so happy I did! Despite the place being small there is definitely good seating availability throughout, whether at the countertop, high top tables, or standard tables. The staff were very pleasant. I ordered two slices. I got the chicken scarp and a margherita. Both were such great choices! The flavors were amazing for both. I'm looking forward to returning and trying other flavors. They also have calzones, pinwheels, garlic knots, and zeppolis. You can also order pies and slices in advance for pick-up and to take-out. If you're in the area, check this place out!

I love this place. I try to go every weekend for a slice. They also have great little chicken…read morecutlet sandwiches with fresh mozzarella and balsamic on garlic knot looking bread. From their salads & grinders to pizza and dinners everything is hand crafted into perfection! Franks and his workers are friendly and quick. This is definitely a neighborhood stable in the community. It's mostly to-go orders although they have 4 tables and I normally eat here. It's at like one big family between the staff and the patrons. It's clean and they normally have sports on the TV. Thanks Frank we appreciate you & your workers and your reasonable prices!

This place is hands‑down one of the most consistently amazing pizza spots around. The ooey‑gooey…read morecheese, the perfectly thin crust, and that special New York sauce you just can't find anywhere else--it all comes together every single time. The ingredients are always fresh and generously piled on, and the slices are absolutely huge. Frank is the owner and takes pride in his creations. Even after moving to Rockland County, I still travel to Westchester/Yonkers just for this pizza. It's my go‑to spot and the standard I compare all other pizza to. Nothing else comes close.

Charging people a minimum of $10 for a debit card is not a legal business practice…read more Store has a $10 minimum for card purchases, including debit cards. Just a heads up that debit cards are not supposed to have a minimum requirement. I understand small businesses have fees, but this policy isn't accurate and creates an inconvenience for customers. Might want to update the policy to follow card guidelines.

I've been coming to this pizza shop for as long as I could eat pizza & I'm 29 years old. It never…read moreloses quality. I'm visiting home from Atlanta and this is always my first stop. The vibe is just your classic New York pizza shop, with great service and the owners remain present and active. Definitely give them a try.

In the evening, if you ask for a slice you get something that's been sitting there all day and…read morenever warmed up properly. The service is lackluster and they tend to treat some people better than others unfortunately. No ambiance at all.

Crosby Pizza fell off. No effort is put into anything they make. Pizza is not the same as years…read moreago. The sause is bitter. The lasagna is gross.

I walked in here for the first time on a early Sunday evening. I was with my 8 year old son. He was…read morejonesing for some pizza, so we decided to try this place after playing some video games at Chucky Cheese in the area. So I ordered a slice for my son and he ate it there and I ordered a large plain cheese pie to go for my family at home. The guy behind the counter was a nice guy. When I also went to order a meatball sub, the nice guy behind the counter said he was the only guy working there and that only pizza was available. There was a menu above the counter offering a lot of other dishes (pasta - salads - etc.) Okay... I get it, you're understaffed. Seems like that night they did not have a variety of slices. And that the only thing you could order fresh was a plain pie. So, we get the reheated slice from the counter for my son and the counter guy offers to cut the slice in two. Much appreciated. My son ate the first half and I took a bite of the second half of the slice. It was mediocre. After approximately 15 minutes our pie is ready. We get in the car and go back home. Pizza is thin, which I like. But overall I'd say the taste is a 6 out of 10. Wife said the sauce had a "sweet" taste to it. Which she didn't care for. It good for a slice if you live in the neighborhood. I'm about 20 minutes by car to get there. Would I make the trip back. No. If I was very very hungry and I randomly happened to be in the neighborhood, I might stop in for another slice. But overall, mediocre. The service was great. The place seemed clean. But I just wouldn't purposely come back to this pizzeria unless I happened to be in the area. Best

Pizza was decent…read more We ordered 2 regular slices, 1 buffalo chicken slice, 3 cans of soda and 2 beef patties with cheese. Price came up to $32 Very pricey in my opinion. I normally pay $24 MAX for the same order I got here.

Great atmosphere and even better pizza! Our server was amazing and super knowledgeable.read more

Seriously everything is so amazing here , kristina is a sweetheart and the food is amazing. My…read morefavorites , chicken buffalo slice , chicken franchese, mozerella sticks , and chicken scaprello, the pizza , marinara sauces are sooo good and everything is super fresh , 10/10

I was starving and ordered large pepperoni and bacon pie, order of wings and a 2 liter soda. Was…read morethe worst $50 I ever spent. First off, wings were not cooked right and I put in the notes well done with a side of ranch. Wings weren't well done and no ranch. Pizza was disgusting, had a weird taste to it. When I finally thought they can't mess up anything else, the 2 liter coke, had no gas in it, so I checked the expiration date and it was expired!!

the owner is incredibly disrespectful was rude to my family basically yelled at us. the food isnt…read moreeven good never again -100/10

The food was just ok, the toppings were expensive but they were hella stingy. All in all there are…read morelots of pizza places in Mount Vernon and I've had better pizza from just about all of them. One star would not recommend and would not return!!

Great customer service, extremely courteous and polite. Elvis was very helpful made great…read morerecommendations. The food was excellent hot and fast. Very tasty. Prices were very reasonable. The restaurant tables were clean and spacious. Everyone who entered was warmly greeted and welcomed. Highly recommended for all occasions. Great for a quick lunchtime meal or a dinner pick up and take home dinner.