Don't go anywhere else for your pizza in the area. Seriously, you want pizza, you're in Nags Head, you have to order from only here. It is delicious. We ordered well ahead of time online, that way it would be ready for pick up as we passed by. After ordering, you will get an estimated time of when it will be ready. We were given a time and then made a stop before coming here. However, they are quicker than the estimated time. Which is a great thing, less waiting when you pull up, but not good if you get stuck elsewhere beforehand. Pulled in, right up to the window, let them know I had an order. Within seconds, my order was in my hands. The hardest part about this was the enticing smell in your vehicle back to your house. Totally takes over and your stomach starts grumbling. When we got back, we immediately opened up those boxes so the aroma filtered through the house. Each pizza was amazing. The garlic bread was amazing. The right amount of garlic that doesn't overpower. Then the pizza itself blows you away. Perfect crust, perfect amount of sauce, perfect amount of toppings. Made you go back for a slice over and over again. Then it doesn't hurt that there are personal touches to each box with a message. Each box has a message when you open. A nice touch from such an amazing place to grab a slice. read more

See all

So many options here. Both of the pizzas we had were so good. It's take out only but totally worth it! everything is fresh and fast! read more

See all

Pizza was great. Dont forget to order the cheese bread its the best. Fast and friendly service!!!

First day down at the Outer Banks and we ate here. I had heard a lot about this place and we decided to go ahead and try it. We got a Margarita pizza and a Supreme pizza and they did not disappoint. The margarita pizza is one of the best pizzas I've ever had. The only reason I'm giving it four stars is because the packed atmosphere and small parking lot. The service was also well and the woman at the counter was very kind. Overall a great pizza place to eat. read more

It took us a minute to find this little gem because it dies not look like a restaurant. As we arrived, there was a line of customers picking up to go orders so we presumed it was take-out service only. We placed an order for a pizza tailored to our personal preferences and waited. For a resort town, we thought the prices were reasonable. Our pizza was delicious. The crust was thin as requested. The Italian sausage they use was flavorful. The sauce was just right. We noticed that other patrons were picking up as many as 10 pizzas at a time. We thoroughly enjoyed our pizza and will make a stop at this small pizza spot on future visits. read more

Easy to use on line ordering system. Great menu and excellent food especially the pizza. Small business, family owned with such a friendly staff. Always my number one choice when we decide to order pizza! read more

This is some of the best pizza I've had ANYWHERE. It's DELICIOUS. The ingredients are fresh. They followed the takeout order instructions to the T. The crust is perfection, there's a DELIGHTFUL pillowy doughiness, a light crisp. I can't even tell you how wonderful this pizza is. I'll dream of it. I recommend extra mozzarella cheese -- the Milky Way + tomatoes + extra mozarella is everything you could ever want in a white pizza. Get this pizza immediately! read more

Nags Head Pizza Company - Milky Way Pizza + extra mozzarella + tomatoes BYO pepperoni + extra mozzarella + red onion + black olives - Pizza Near Me - Nags Head, North Carolina

Pizza was mediocre but staff is friendly! I would like to try more pizza places in the area

Price is what it is. This is some great pizza with creative pies! Ordered online and it was done in 15 minutes. Very friendly staff. The Hulk Smash with pesto, homemade meatball and roasted mushrooms was fantastic. They don't overdue the crust but that cornmeal crust make it sturdy and crispy. Go! read more

Had the hulk smash pizza and it was not cooked enough. Ingredients were average. We make better pizza at home. Won't be returning

Delicious cheese pizza and bbq chicken pizza that me and all my friends enjoyed! Food was out quick and the staff was very friendly and was quick to offer paper plates, utensils, and seasonings! read more

Placed an order on a Tuesday night around 5:45 pm expecting a wait time of an hour for pickup. We used their online ordering through Toast, which was quick and easy, and were pleasantly surprised to see the wait time as only being 25 minutes. Headed out to pick it up (we opted for pickup in 25 minutes over delivery in about an hour due to our proximity to the restaurant), and got a text message on the way that it was ready. Pickup went quick and easy, though do note that their parking lot is a bit tight to navigate. There is a bit of outdoor seating (no indoor seating) and a pickup window. Very no frills, but nice enough. Now, to the food. We ordered a cheese, a supreme, and a buffalo chicken (each 16"), along with a family sized house salad. It was a good amount for dinner that night with leftovers for lunch the next day for 3 adults and 3 kids. Do note, however, that the family sized salad is enough for probably four adults to share as sides. Pizzas were perfectly good, though I wouldn't say exceptional. I prefer a slightly darker bake than what they serve, but to each their own. Overall, good pizza and great, simple service. read more

A great pizza spot to try! We ordered ahead on the phone to pick up and take home. They have outdoor seating. Few notes about ordering- ordering on the app isn't as easy if you plan to customize, or do half pizza toppings. We decided to call and had no issue getting whatever we wanted. The line to pick up orders can take a bit of a while because of people ordering at the window. Now for the food- we ordered family size salads - the Mediterranean and the caprese. Both were so good and lots to go around. We also ordered two large pizzas, each half different. Three were speciality pizzas from the venue and one was a custom by us. The group favorite was the cottage pie- a bit simple but just done so well. We got two pizza rolls but didn't seem as fresh as the pizza, so will give those another go next time. It's basically a cinnamon roll but made with pizza ingredients. We will be back! Also, the quotes in the boxes are a sweet touch. read more

Vegan pizza! It wasn't the best I've ever had, but was very good, and in a location with limited vegan options. I'd come back! read more

See all

This was hands down some of the best pizza I've ever had! We ordered five for 14 of us and we could've put down at least 2-3 more pizzas. They were amazing! They also write the sweetest quotes on the boxes, such a thoughtful touch. Support this local business!!! read more

Very friendly staff Pizza was delicious and a few unique kind of pizzas. We loved the paia bay pizza, it was amazing! Definitely recommend going and grabbing a pizza here! Quick and easy ordering and pick up read more

We had (2) BYO a meat and a vegetable. Both were prepared just as ordered and tasted fantastic. Fabulous crust. Plenty of toppings tasty sauce Staff was helpful and friendly Ready just as I arrived hot Great OBX pizza place read more

Pretty good generic American style pizza (I don't say that as an insult, just that the pizza doesn't conform to any particular region's specialty pizza). I will put in big letters though THEY DON'T HAVE INDOOR SEATING and their tables are not handicap accessible, at best someone in a wheelchair might be able to sit in one of the adirondack chairs on the patio. If you have a big group or someone with mobility issues or the weather is shitty, plan for takeout. We ordered a bunch of pizzas, they were ready pretty quickly, and folks enjoyed them well enough but it's not a must-visit when in town kind of place. I would recommend ordering extra sauce and extra cheese if you do go because neither was abundant. My favorite was the all meats one (Manmaker), I also liked the Sausage Parmesan - I couldn't eat any of the others that people ordered because they were all loaded with fresh basil which most people would like but would put me in the hospital. My vegan friend particularly enjoyed his Haley's Comet though, said it was one of the best pizzas he's had since going vegan. The pizzas are thin crust, and the crust is chewy and not doughy, but I didn't find it super filling. I normally eat two pieces of pizza tops, I ate three large slices and was still a bit hungry. Prices are a bit on the high side like everything else in the area. So - go for takeout or patio dining and if you just want some pretty decent pizza (and aren't super picky) or are vegan, don't go if you want indoor seating or true best-in-class pizza that you'll be talking about after your vacation is over. read more

10/10 pizza and salad! We're from NJ so we're always pretty skeptical when it comes to pizza but this place was awesome! Very cute outdoor seating area as well! Staff was great and order was made super fast! read more

Nags Head Pizza Company - Plain 16" pie and custom salad - Pizza Near Me - Nags Head, North Carolina

Great quality and on time delivery. Would use them again on our next visit to the Outer Banks.

The pesto chicken pizza is without flavor but so much potential. It tastes like they baked then shredded plain chicken breast. The pesto sauce tasted like nothing or else they just didn't use very much to be able to notice any of the basil and olive oil flavor profiles. The crust is weak too. There's tons of pizza dough recipes online on Reddit and YouTube you'd think a restaurant would find one that was actually good and use it. read more

Husband and I stopped in for dinner and didn't have to wait long at all for our pizza. Glad we picked a clear night because the only seating is outside. We split the Farmers Market veganized with vegan cheese. It had just enough cheese and the lightest touch of red sauce. If you love a lot of sauce, ask for extra. We also added the vegan pepperoni. It was a nice medium thick crust with tons of veggies. Only complaint is that they wasted a box for use dining in rather than using a reusable tray. read more

Nags Head Pizza Company - Farmers Market with vegan cheese and added vegan pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Nags Head, North Carolina

Great pizza, fast and friendly service! We ordered carry out. While the first place we called on a Sunday night was an hour and a half wait for carry out pizza, it was a reasonable twenty minutes for this place. And the pizza was perfect! read more

Wasn't sure about this place when we first drove up! Never had pizza as an outdoor picnic place but you order at the window and can either eat it at the tables or take it to go! We took it back to our AirbBnB - it was still piping hot and the grandkids couldn't eat it fast enough! Our grandson doesn't even like pizza! The staff was very friendly read more

Very good pizza. We got the Pesto chicken pizza and a family size Caesar salad, which is easily enough for 4-5 people. Just an fyi there is no indoor seating. They have a few picnic tables but if you are coming here due to the rain be forewarned. read more

Had the BEST Gluten and Dairy free pizza! Makes me want to move here! Cute message on the inside of the box, great experience ordering online and then picking up the order! read more

We ordered pizza for our first night of our vacation: a 12" with pepperoni and green onions. It was perfect! The outside eating area was quiet and well-kept, and the servers at the window were very kind! read more

Not being from the area I check yelp for guidance, this spot was on the top. I don't think I was led astray. I ordered half pepperoni half sausage, a cheese pizza and a Little Dipper (cheesy bread). The pizza was tasty from sauce to crust. Pepperoni wasn't limp, the sausage had flavor, each slice had an ample amount of toppings. They have a pickup up window with a little bell if no one is there when you walk up. I also noticed a quaint outdoor eating area as I was driving off. As for staff, if everyone is like the young lady who helped me they are awesome! Added bonus they have merch, cool stickers and if you had a bad day their pizza box quotes are sure to bring a smile to your face. If you're in Nags Head and craving pizza go check them out. read more

See all

It's ok. The best you're gonna get down here. Watch out on the weekend. It takes forever.

Bottom Line: Fresh, quality pizza with a new location at MP 12.5 on the beach road. Nags Head Pizza Co. has been my family's favorite pizza spot in Nags Head for several years. We like that they serve thin crust pizzas with high quality toppings. My favorite pizza is the NHPC BLT specialty pizza with mozzarella cheese, roma tomatoes, bacon, fresh arugula and balsamic glaze.​ In addition to a variety of speciality pizzas they also have classic pizzas. NHPC's menu includes salads and vegan and vegetarian options. NHPC's new location is a pretty beachy aqua building with a quaint front porch and a convenient pick up window. There is also seating indoors and out back. read more

Nags Head Pizza Company - Nags Head Pizza's new location in 2022 - Pizza Near Me - Nags Head, North Carolina

4.5 Stars for this Pizza spot. Girl that took our order was super helpful as we were indecisive, but we ended up with: Ultimate - we added banana peppers and it all came together nicely Margherita - Was not what we expected. It was little tomatoes over a bed of cheese pizza and sprinkles of basil. Pepperoni Nice soft dough. Service on a weeknight dinner was good. I did enjoy the hand-written inspirational/motivational cute quotes written on the top inside of the boxes. Hands down: Nags Head Pizza Company over Southern Shore Pizza & Deli read more

Nags Head Pizza Company - The Ultimate Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nags Head, North Carolina

See all

I got the vegan cheese and regular pepperoni pizza. My boyfriend had extra cheese and pepperoni. Both were absolutely delicious. Very hard to get dairy free cheese options when I travel so this was very appreciated! I also loved that they draw on the boxes with cute little notes. read more

I had the chicken pesto pizza. It was mediocre at best. The people were nice enough, but at the end of taking our order, they ask for a gratuity. A gratuity for what? Yelling our names when the food is done because you got her phone number wrong? It's tacky. read more

Love these pies so much we've had one for a takeout supper two of the four nights we've been in Nags Head. Our favorite things: the fresh ingredients, creative options (we chose half Farmer's Market/half BBQ Chicken), friendly staff, and the corn hole out back to pass the time while your pizza bakes. read more

Nags Head Pizza Company - 16-inch Half Farmer's Market vegetarian and half BBQ Chicken (Four big slices of each) - Pizza Near Me - Nags Head, North Carolina

Tasty pizza. We also enjoyed the chicken bites. The salad was just OK Prompt delivery overall no complaints. I would eat their food again.

Really yummy pizza and the walk up pick up window is great. We added jalapeños to our Hawaiian Pizza and the amount they added was substantial. Yay. Just the right amount of sauce and a tad of grease to feel like a NY pizza! read more

Delicious Pizza during our Beach Trip, also very nice people. Nice outside, dog friendly area to eat just a walk from the Beach. read more

Nags Head Pizza Company - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nags Head, North Carolina

We ordered pizza and salad after a long day at the beach. Both items were delicious! The order took about 25 minutes but it was worth it! The only compliant I would have is that there's only one window open so when our food was ready, we had to wait until people ordering were finished. Overall, a great experience though! read more

Food was great, the ambience is laid back and fun. They had local beer that was recommended to us.

I had their pizza delivered-they told me 25-30 minutes. I think I had it in 20. It was super hot and one of the best pizzas I've ever had. The pepperoni rolls ere amazing too. Very impressed! Tried to order it last weekend but they weren't open for the season yet. read more