Madisons Pizza

First time here, and absolutely nothing but great things to say all around. The staff was friendly,…read morecommunicative, and got through the lines quickly. Best wings I've had in a while, and the nachbros and slaw were really good too! It's clean and there's a decent amount of seating, indoor and some outdoor tables to enjoy the weather. We will absolutely be back!

They don't prepare veggie burgers as advertised on their website. Their cook staff serve rock hard…read moreunripened avocado im the vegan bowls. Disapppointing. No ambiance to speak of.

BROS wings tossed in Tangy Steakhouse Buffalo!

Tuna Po'Boy

See all

House Salad with Fresh Grilled Chicken

BROS Burgers & Shakes

4.1(66 reviews)

4.9 mi

BLUF: Solid food that is ready quickly and consistently friendly service…read more Bros is such a good addition to Nags Head. They have a menu consisting of salads, burgers, wings, sandwiches and such. No matter what I order, I usually steer towards their fresh tuna because it's always excellent. I have a mixed bag of items from Bros over the years - tuna po boy, burger, cali chicken sandwich, salads, etc. and it's all been salad. Also, the employees are friendly. Food comes up fast and parking is easy. You can eat in or take it to go. Very consistent.

Food was delicious! Smoked buffalo wings and Sweet Thai Chili sauce were excellent. Got mine extra…read morecrispy. Fish sandwich was a hit as well. Friendly staff and nice location in the Nags Head Outlets.

Sample menu

Chicken Philly and side salad.

See all

Storefront

McGrath’s Burger Shack

3.6(48 reviews)

2.8 mi

This is the kind of "hole in the wall" joint I love to find in a strip mall --uniformly delicious…read morefood and the server was super nice and attentive despite being busy. The Irish Beer Cheese Burger was well seasoned with just the right amount of beer cheese to top it off -- and it was a juicy, perfect medium-well doneness! Fish and chips and the McGrath Dog were also quite good.

It was a sunday evening and naturally every other restaurant in nags head was full. This place was…read moreempty. It was dark and everything was sticky, the tables, the floor, the chairs. They were accommodating for a large party so that was a plus. Ordering took about 30 mins to get out our food, there was a mix up with the ticketing but it was resolved. My order was unimpressive, it was like a small paddy sitting in cheezewhiz, my bun was burnt, and fries were greasy soggy, the other order was the fish, and that was probably the best thing to order, it was crispy and tasteful. the wings were decent, a little light on the sauce but palatable. they only had diet drinks in, and had very few choices. i really felt the price was not justified for the price and service. Our server was polite but slow, and 3 of the other orders were forgotten because the cook thought they were the same... that's what we were told, so it took a while longer for the rest of the order to come out. Most likely won't be coming back.

Burger top (really good, did not taste burnt)

See all

Irish Beer Cheese Burger

Just Wings

4.0(18 reviews)

40.3 mi

We ordered the sweet and spicy chili and chipotle citrus. Well cooked and flavorful…read more Size of pieces from the boneless wings to the bone in (traditional wings) are beyond great compared to majority of the places around here that give tiny pieces and charge more with crappy service on top of that. We enjoy ordeing from here for the wings. Orders have always been a good experience for us and correct as we have ordered from door dash with no issues. We have not dined in yet. This is definitely our go to spot in the area. We love getting wings from here!

Wings needed to be cooked longer. But the thing that got the low rating is i order pizza and it was…read moreold pizza reheated up with a little bit of cheese just melted on it. It ended up in the trash!

Order station and dessert display.

Window seating and entrance.

See all

Store front.

Chicken Coop Country Diner

4.4(108 reviews)

26.4 mi

Breakfast at Chicken Coop was excellent. The biscuits were 10/10, the bacon perfectly crispy, and…read morethe sunny side up eggs cooked just right. The baked apples are perfectly seasoned, tender and delicious. Service was great! Would recommend for breakfast.

tl;dr: stick with a chicken dish and you will be very happy…read more Interesting little place, connected to a gas station. As you walk in you note the feel of it being a converted diner made to look like a country place. You grab your own menu, seat yourself, and walk up to the bar/register when ready to order. If the first time, you need a minute to get your bearings. Food ordered (3% fee is not using the cash "discount" FYI, pretty common around here and absurd given these OBX prices). Drinks are self serve. Some coke products and excellent tea. This was the end of breakfast around 10:30/11, so it was empty. Service was pretty quick. (they bring it to the table). I thought the breakfast pricing was fair. Shrimp and grits for $12, etc. Especially for the portion sizes. Two things I didn't care for. -The ceilling tiles were crazy dirty and stained and the flor light bulbs were uncovered. -The shrimp and grits needs a re-do. It's huge, with a base of grits, ladels of bacon gravy, and about 5 shrimp and cheddar cheese. It's more like a shrimp, grits, gravy, cheese casserole. I would have much rather had a base of grits, the gravy scooped in the middle with shrimp stuck in it, and topped with cheese. Even with all that you'd think there would be flavor. It was kind of bland minus the occasionally greasy/burnt bacon piece. Also, the shrimp were flavorful but over-cooked and tail on, which is traditional--but in the casserole were a pain in the butt to get the tail off/cut. I know they can do good flavors and plates. My spouse's chicken biscut...omg the hand-breaded chicken was fantastic! My son's baked apples were to die for. You Philly visitors will be happy to see scrapples on the menu - yuck. All in, I would repeat and stick to chicken and the chicken coop.

Interior

Meat loaf, mashed potatoes, green beans, biscuit

See all

Interior

WingsWay

4.3(162 reviews)

64.1 mi

Definitely have to give this little mom and pop wing stop a try. Food was FRESH and the wings were…read moredelicious. and the owners were so sweet! I tried them both regular crispy and with the buffalo sauce and both were sooo good. We got the 10 shrimp and 10 wings + fries special for like $28 and it was a big old tray of food. Can't wait to go back and try more sauces.

Wings better then any chain wing place. Meaty wings and good. Kinda remind me of wings I got when…read moreJapan.

15. Buffalo wings and fries.

See all

Wiseguys Pies

4.4(51 reviews)

22.0 mi

Service is quick and everyone is friendly! No frills, basic tables and chairs if you decide to eat…read morein. Great pizza. we pick up a pie at least every other week.! Huge salads!

Best pizza around!!!!! Only wish they had delivery service and some specials every weekread more

White pizza!

Wiseguys

See all

Sorellas Pizza & Pasta

4.3(52 reviews)

62.7 mi

Craving Pizza on the Island? Sorella's is a Must-Try!…read more While visiting the island, I found myself in the mood for some good pizza, so I decided to check out Sorella's for dinner--and I'm so glad I did! With its reputation for hearty, flavor-packed dishes, it was the perfect spot to satisfy my cravings. What We Ordered: * BBQ Pizza * Big Daddy Pizza * Stromboli BBQ PIZZA This pizza was a savory-sweet masterpiece! The olive oil base paired beautifully with the barbecue chicken, caramelized onions, and smoky bacon. The addition of jalapeños brought the perfect kick, while the cheddar and mozzarella created a rich, melty layer of cheesy goodness. Topped with a barbecue swirl, every bite was packed with bold flavors that balanced sweetness and spice perfectly. It was a creative twist on classic pizza flavors, and it didn't disappoint. BIG DADDY PIZZA If you're a fan of the classics, this one's for you. The Big Daddy Pizza was piled high with red sauce, beef, sausage, pepperoni, green peppers, red onions, mushrooms, and mozzarella cheese. Each ingredient brought something special to the table: the meats were perfectly seasoned, the vegetables added a satisfying crunch, and the mozzarella held it all together with a gooey, cheesy blanket. This pizza is a hearty, crowd-pleasing option for anyone who loves a fully loaded slice. STROMBOLI This was the showstopper for me! Stuffed with red sauce, pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, red onions, mushrooms, and mozzarella, the Stromboli was simply heavenly. The crust was golden and perfectly baked, with just the right balance of crispness and chewiness. The filling was indulgent, packed with meat and cheese, making it a dream for any meat lover. Every bite felt comforting and decadent--a must-try if you visit Sorella's. We opted for takeout and enjoyed our meal during a cozy movie night at our rental. The pizzas and Stromboli held up beautifully, still warm and fresh when we dug in. Sorella's proved to be the perfect blend of convenience and quality for a relaxed evening in. Sorella's nailed it on every level--flavor, portion sizes, and variety. Whether you're in the mood for a creative take on pizza like the BBQ Pizza, a classic loaded option like the Big Daddy, or the indulgent Stromboli, you're bound to find something to love here. If you're ever on the island and craving pizza, Sorella's is the place to go. I'll definitely be back for more!

We ordered two pizzas to go and they were ready within 25 minutes! They were delicious! We'll…read moredefinitely order again!

Stromboli

See all

Big Daddy

Nags Head Pizza Company

4.4(404 reviews)

1.7 mi

Pizza was great. Dont forget to order the cheese bread its the best. Fast and friendly service!!!read more

Don't go anywhere else for your pizza in the area. Seriously, you want pizza, you're in Nags Head,…read moreyou have to order from only here. It is delicious. We ordered well ahead of time online, that way it would be ready for pick up as we passed by. After ordering, you will get an estimated time of when it will be ready. We were given a time and then made a stop before coming here. However, they are quicker than the estimated time. Which is a great thing, less waiting when you pull up, but not good if you get stuck elsewhere beforehand. Pulled in, right up to the window, let them know I had an order. Within seconds, my order was in my hands. The hardest part about this was the enticing smell in your vehicle back to your house. Totally takes over and your stomach starts grumbling. When we got back, we immediately opened up those boxes so the aroma filtered through the house. Each pizza was amazing. The garlic bread was amazing. The right amount of garlic that doesn't overpower. Then the pizza itself blows you away. Perfect crust, perfect amount of sauce, perfect amount of toppings. Made you go back for a slice over and over again. Then it doesn't hurt that there are personal touches to each box with a message. Each box has a message when you open. A nice touch from such an amazing place to grab a slice.

See more unrecommended reviews

Trifecta - Supreme, cheese and garlic bread

Cheese Box Quote

See all

Sign

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

24 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Mark E.

0

1

0

4 years ago

Maybe I am missing something, but I do not see how a pizza shop can prosper when it is closed half the time! The lone owner and employee is hostile and rude with no problem of telling you to leave his shop if you ask too many questions. The owner, I think his name is Brian, has people issues like I have never seen and I feel takes little pride in his work. So pizza lovers beware, Madison's Pizza may not be for you unless you enjoy overcooked pizza. This critique is based on a July 4th. holiday experience I will not soon forget. The foul language and poor sanitary practices aside, anger management is certainly in order for a young man who needs it! I do not see Madison's Pizza in business much longer with this owner/ sole employee at the helm. Former victim of Madison's Pizza Nags Head, N.C Mark E. read more

Richard C.

0

2

0

3 years ago

The boss got her haircut next door at Sun Daze with Sierra. I sent her next door to Madison's for an Italian sub and wings for dinner. Every bite was a plethora of excellence. The wings are tPugh to beat on the island. The subs are always the best. Didn't have pizza this time but know it is always the best. Love this place. Great job once again! read more

Joe F.

0

1

0

3 years ago

this fool is all over Facebook complaining about a person who posted a low review. he has a horrible attitude and is flat out rude. who cares if the pizza is good, this dude is psycho! won't catch me in this place. see their Facebook page for his rant dated 4/15/23. read more

Joni L.

0

4

3

4 years ago

Absolutely delicious and great service! The pepperoni pizza is amazing. We stayed a few nights coming from New York heading to Atlanta and had many pizzas on the way, The wings were also spot on! this is definitely worth the try! read more

Maria M.

0

1

0

1 year ago

Food was amazing! We got wings, tenders, hawaiian, and the meatball pizza. All of it was great! The owner was a great storyteller and kept us laughing while we were waiting! Great experience overall read more

Magen L.

0

2

0

5 years ago

We live in Salvo and have never tried Madison's before. Great food! I enjoyed the Spinach and Garlic pizza loaded with fresh veggies and flavor. My husband had the pepperoni/sausage pizza. read more

Brandon C.

0

1

0

3 years ago

The guy is a total piece of shit! Rudest person I've ever met in my life. No customer service. Told me to fuck off and said my order was bullshit. This guy does not deserve a business! read more

Lory P.

1

25

0

2 years ago

Horrible attitude for a business owner! I would never support any biz whose owner is so rude and ignorant; too many other places with really nice, courteous, respectful owners! read more

Joseph D.

0

1

0

4 years ago

madison pretty good pizza for north carolina nice guy at counter crispy crust one if the better pies i have had here my other favorite is colington pizza read more

Jen D.

0

2

0

3 years ago

Owner is foul. Hard pass. Too many other good places to spend my money in. He should hire someone else to deal with people while he makes pizza. read more

Ron T.

30

15

0

1 year ago

This place sucks the owner needs serious mental health help and hire more help if you can't handle it and you health board rating is terrible ! read more

Mike H.

0

1

0

5 years ago

Pizza place is awful, it needs to be shut down. People avoid this POS place at all cost! . You will be better off buying pizza from Walmart!

Patty M.

0

1

0

2 years ago

Excellent subs. Philly steak sub best I've had in OBX, and I have lived here 27 years. Very clean. Highly recommend. Plenty of parking.

Madison W.

0

1

0

6 years ago

the BEST chicken tenders i've ever had, that crisp... heaven sent; super nice owner too. really cute joint i loved the atmosphere

Molly B.

0

2

0

2 years ago

Speaking strictly regarding the owner and who you would be giving business to: he trolls and harasses women online.

Joe

0

2

0

1 year ago

Best pizza in nags head and the owner is awesome. The restaurant is busy, so know what your doing when you call

J L.

0

2

0

2 years ago

The pizza was delicious, the man who took our order was super nice and friendly! 10/10, highly recommend!

Troy B.

0

3

0

2 years ago

Great food - taco pizza is awesome this a must for us when we are in the outer banks - owner is great

Zofia M.

0

1

0

1 year ago

Very kind and hard working owner with delicious food! Pizza, wings, and tenders were all a hit!

Cara W.

0

1

0

3 years ago

Fantastic food! Best pizza. Service and price is good. Entire familys new favorite pizza joint.

Madisons Pizza - chicken_wings - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Madisons Pizza also viewed

Village Pizza Nags Head

4.6

(203 reviews)

I stopped by this spot when I was hungry while shopping at the Nags Head outlet. They had a deal on…read more2 slices of cheese and a drink which I ordered. My slices came out fast and were brought to my table. The slices were large with lots of cheese. Drink was your choice from the fountain and free refills. The restaurant has a view of the water, so it's a nice break from shopping in the heat.

The pizza was awesome and the owners were great. Incredible crust and fresh toppings. Could have…read moreused more cheese on the pizza. Cheese sticks were large and yummy! Very generous portions as well. Ambiance inside 5, outside 8. I would love to give them a 5 star review but I can't due to their pricing. 1 appetizer, 1 salad and 2 small pizzas, 3 sodas plus tip - $85. Pure insanity.

Southern Shores Pizza & Deli

4.2

(295 reviews)

Fast. Cheap. $4.30 for a slice of sausage pizza with extra sausage. The sauce was fantastic…read more If you are headed to the escape room this is a nice place to pre or post visit. Technically my son gave it a 7.5 out of 10 but he loved the price and said the sausage was especially good. I think the extra sausage for $0.50 is the way to go

After seeing a few Instagram posts about this place, it was on my list to try during our time at…read moreKitty Hawk! And this place didn't disappoint at all! We ordered a large, hand tossed pizza and it was delicious! The toppings were plentiful and tasty. The pizza was hot and fresh. The dough was soft and delicious. Truly no complaints with the hand tossed pizza but a recommendation to order it well done so the pizza has a a bit more structure to support the toppings. (It was OK for us because we knew we wanted to have leftovers for lunch at beach.) Highly recommend!

Pizza Stop

4.1

(116 reviews)

Ordered online and the food came hot and fresh! We lived the gluten free options! We ordered at…read more4:30pm on a Saturday and it got here around 5pm and we are staying in Southern Shores.

Hunger drove us to stop for a quick bit and Pizza Stop delivered! We each had the special allow us…read moreto try 4 different pizza types (plus 2 drinks) for just $16! We selected pizza from the case and they were warmed in the oven. Our slices: Cheese: Classic hot and delicious with just enough sauce Pepperoni: Highly recommend the pepperonis were even a little crispy Spinach, ricotta, tomato and garlic: Wonderful combinations and very little grease! ‍ Pepperoni and mushroom: Good

Nags Head Pizza Company

4.4

(404 reviews)

Pizza was great. Dont forget to order the cheese bread its the best. Fast and friendly service!!!read more

Don't go anywhere else for your pizza in the area. Seriously, you want pizza, you're in Nags Head,…read moreyou have to order from only here. It is delicious. We ordered well ahead of time online, that way it would be ready for pick up as we passed by. After ordering, you will get an estimated time of when it will be ready. We were given a time and then made a stop before coming here. However, they are quicker than the estimated time. Which is a great thing, less waiting when you pull up, but not good if you get stuck elsewhere beforehand. Pulled in, right up to the window, let them know I had an order. Within seconds, my order was in my hands. The hardest part about this was the enticing smell in your vehicle back to your house. Totally takes over and your stomach starts grumbling. When we got back, we immediately opened up those boxes so the aroma filtered through the house. Each pizza was amazing. The garlic bread was amazing. The right amount of garlic that doesn't overpower. Then the pizza itself blows you away. Perfect crust, perfect amount of sauce, perfect amount of toppings. Made you go back for a slice over and over again. Then it doesn't hurt that there are personal touches to each box with a message. Each box has a message when you open. A nice touch from such an amazing place to grab a slice.

Slice Pizzeria

4.1

(445 reviews)

best pizza in town! We go there every year the night we get into town! We normally just buy slices…read morebut have also ordered pizzas to go!

Good pizza - cheese and pepperoni are solid choices. Great chicken wings. Wish it was open more…read moredays.

Sal's New York Pizza

4.1

(169 reviews)

Pretty solid spot. Tried a sausage and pepperoni pizza. I'd get it again for sure. Check it out!read more

Great place to order pizza to bring back to your hotel. The order was ready right on time and the…read morequality was quite good. Was it NY style? No, based on this Brooklyn native's experience. But the crust was well done while still having sufficient flop. The sauce was savory and there were plenty of toppings.

Pizzazz Pizza

3.1

(123 reviews)

Excellent pizza and customer service. Flavorful sauces, I recommend the buffalo chicken pizza. We…read moreordered online and then walked over to pick it up. Pizzazz is located in a shopping center with ample parking. Our order was ready upon arrival and accurate.

This place is amazing! We came to OBX 15 years ago and my husband still talked about it. We were…read morepassing through and got pizza and wings. Everything was just as good as we remembered it! I ordered online and was ready in less than 20 min! Whenever we're in OBX, this will be our pizza place!

Duck Pizza

3.4

(236 reviews)

Pizza is overcooked. Hard and dry. Maybe turn the over down by 10 degrees? Or speed up the conveyer…read morebelt by 10 seconds?

Well bless its heart--this little coastal pizza joint ain't tryin' to impress nobody with fancy…read morefrills. She's got a good ol' black-and-white checkered floor that's seen more flip-flops than a beach boardwalk, basic tables and chairs that wobble just enough to keep you humble, and décor so sparse it practically whistles when the door opens. The walls don't tell stories, but the air sure does--salty, warm, and heavy with the promise of hot pizza and cold drinks. It's the kind of place where the ambiance is "sit down, hush up, and eat," and honestly, that's all she needs. Cheers!

Colington Pizza, Beer and Grill

3.5

(8 reviews)

Just picked up a large meaty pizza, awesome! Lots of meat on the pizza and staff were very…read moresociable. Will go there again next month for a sit down dinner and listen to music on Friday and Saturday nights. Rod, Suffolk, Va

Colington is rated "Best Pizza on the Beach" and our first experience was delicious. We ordered a…read moresupreme pizza and a Greek salad. Both were fabulous. The supreme pizza has sliced meatballs and red onion on it -- tasty touches. The salad dressing for the Greek salad was an outstanding vinaigrette that seemed to be homemade. We ordered online and our food was ready in twenty minutes. When we walked in to pick it up, our food was waiting for us and the staff was very friendly. Colington offers some really great food!!

Cosmo's Pizzeria Southern Shores at the Market Place

4.0

(133 reviews)