Marina del Rey has no shortage of good restaurants, and Dear Jane's certainly belongs in the…read moreconversation. Perched right on the marina, it offers a beautiful waterfront setting and, if you get the right seat, terrific views of the boats.
Parking is easy enough: valet is $12, or you can use the public lot farther down Panay Way for a little less.
Walking in, the restaurant immediately has personality. The host area almost feels like a mini art gallery, with eclectic paintings scattered around, while the bar to the right has a great, dark, old-school ambience. They also have a GREAT Happy Hour, a fact we were reminded of no fewer than three times! It runs Tuesday through Saturday from 5:30-7:00 p.m.
The main dining room continues the moody, slightly quirky seafood-house feel, with the real star being the wall of windows overlooking the marina.
Unfortunately, I enjoyed almost none of that view.
Our table was at the bottom of the entrance ramp, and I willingly took the worst seat, leaving me with a terrific view of the front door and the backs of other diners. Sometimes being the gentleman has consequences.
One completely unnecessary observation: I was not a fan of the waiter uniforms. I'm no fashion maven, but the black-and-white long-sleeve shirts gave me a strange sitcom-waiter vibe. Minor point, but I noticed it.
Service overall was solid, although there was room for improvement. After a long day of golf, I was THIRSTY, and my water glass spent too much time empty. Cocktails from the bar were also a little slow at times.
Speaking of cocktails, they make a good drink. I enjoyed a properly filthy Ketel One martini, although no blue cheese olives, which, in my world, is a legitimate strike. The ladies loved their lemon drops, and the Smokey Jane, a smoky riff on an Old Fashioned, was also very good.
We visited during Dine LA, which offered a prix-fixe menu. Two at our table went that route and enjoyed it, with the octopus appetizer receiving especially high praise. The chicken parmesan was also called out as excellent. They do use rich/heavy sauces on food items, like the Dine LA steak option.
Another small strike: substitutions.
The salmon came with rice, while one person wanted mashed potatoes. Our server explained that "the chef is not a fan of substitutions." Fair enough, although apparently the chef is perfectly comfortable with you BUYING a side of mashed potatoes. Such is life.
I also later realized the table bread comes with a charge. I'm old enough to remember when bread simply appeared without requiring a financial decision.
Dessert was mixed. The Dine LA brownie-and-ice-cream option didn't get much love, but my wife ordered the Bananas Foster, which was outstanding and easily the dessert winner.
Our server, Courtney D., was personable, did a nice job explaining the menu, and even served as our table photographer. Bonus points.
Finally, I went to the restroom before leaving and discovered they were out of paper towels. BOOOO. This resulted in my longtime friend flicking his wet hands all over me, which, between two old friends, was both predictable and apparently the only logical solution.
So where do I land? The evening had a few flaws, but nothing damning. Good food, good cocktails, an interesting room and, assuming you don't voluntarily sit facing the front door, a beautiful marina setting.
I'm at about 3.8 stars, which in Yelp mathematics rounds nicely to 4 stars.
Would I go back? Absolutely. The food was delicious, the setting was enjoyable, and most importantly, it was a great place to spend an evening with good friends.