Nancy’s Pizzeria

Ok so I was wondering what was taking this guy so long to make my sandwich. I got the #13, the…read moreItalian sub. Young man was slicing the meat so thin. It's thinner than tissue paper, so much I can see through the pepperoni and salmi. Top it off this location has changed the price for a giant sandwich now. It's 20 bucks. So for a meal for my self it's 27 dollars. I'm not at a fine restaurant or eating steak lunch for goodness sake!!! I come to jersey mikes a lot but I won't set foot in this place again unless they fix things. People come here vs subway or jimmy johns because of the pile of meat put on sandwich mine looks weak!!!

$17 for a sandwich with hard, stale bread? I see why this place is always empty, even at 7pm. How…read moredo they stay in business?

See all

McAlister's Deli

2.9(68 reviews)

0.3 mi

First time trying this establishment & definitely will return. Club sandwich is very good &…read morereasonably priced. I ordered the choose 2 for $11. Half a sandwich & broccoli cheddar soup with a delicious iced tea. The tea may be worth a trip whether you get food or not. Will also return for the carrot cake.

Our food was delicious as always but this Sunday on Aug.9 it was perfect because we received…read moreexceptional service from an amazing young man named Deshun. He asked us if our food was presentable, never been asked that before. He was extremely courteous. He consistently checked on us throughout our lunch asking us did we "desire" anything else. This all threw us for a loop how educated & well-spoken he was & I think he is in high school. We all loved this young man and definitely can show many older people in service how exceptional customer service should be given. The best we have ever received from this restaurant or any restaurant we eat at. We will definitely increase our visit due to him. He made us all feel special. My overall review...keep this young man named Deshun.

See all

Dave's Hot Chicken

4.0(36 reviews)

0.0 mi

I live in the land of hot chicken, and I was pleasantly surprised at the quality of this hot…read morechicken. I have eaten here a couple of times, and the food quality the first time was near perfect. You don't want to show up here hungry though, because it is not fast food. The first time we waited about 30 minutes - the second time about 45 minutes. The place is comfortable with red decor, and there are tables inside & outside. If it's busy, I can see all tables being taken. There's free parking outside in the lot. Love: service (kind); chicken (fried well, juicy); fries (crispy, seasoned well); portion (large) Like: spice level (good but not consistent) Dislike: (bathrooms are not clean; didn't check the second visit)

The establishment is a bit small and crowded. I do like the outside seating here, but when it's…read morereally packed there is nowhere to go. Usually the wait is also pretty long due to this. However, I do love their chicken and sauce. As much as the price point is pretty expensive for what you get, the chicken is crispy and pairs great with their Dave's sauce. I also love the pickles you get. The only reason I am giving a 4-star rating is due to the lack of seating, and from the one time I was in tears when trying their reaper mozzarella stick (do not do it).

See all

Jason's Deli

3.6(89 reviews)

0.5 mi

Food, Service was amazing. Truck drivers and we came hungry. They took good care of us. Amazing…read moreJason's Deli hope we get back here soon.

Worst customer service in the world. You are not greeted when you go in. You will wait a good 5+…read moreminutes before anyone acknowledges your presence.. they WILL continue personal conversations, take your order, and resume their conversations. Eventually, your meal will be prepared. I enjoy the food. Last don't leave without checking your order.

Seafood gumbo

Poor customer service, poor food quality

See all

New York Yankee

Newk's Eatery

3.4(67 reviews)

0.4 mi

The food is healthy and delicious! The staff are so friendly…read moreand helpful always and your food is always ready in no time.

Love this place! I…read morehave been eating here, throughout the tenure of my durations to Columbus, for the last few years! Newks serves amazing and high quality foods. I love their "Pair Combo," which I almost always get with Pizza (Sausage and Pepperoni) and Cup of Soup (Lobster Bisque). The sandwiches (I personally love "The Italian"), Pizza, and Soups here are amazing. Definitely better than other restaurant-equivalents (Panera Bread / Corner Bakery/ etc).) in my opinion. The ambiance here is peaceful, casual, and is always suited for any meal of the day. The service here has always been friendly, and I always leave happier than ai came. Don't forget to ask for your military discount! This place is an absolute must try!

Turkey avocado sandwich

See all

Firehouse Subs

2.7(32 reviews)

0.2 mi

The food here is very good but the service is not nice…read more.. the workers always have a attitude and I told the manger about the service and he didn't seem to care Great food terrible customer interaction

I love coming to firehouse. My favorite sub shop. Italian, fully involved no onions is my go-to…read more Consistent experience no matter what state we are in. Chatter was a little loud behind the counter today. See our YouTube channel Coolest Life

See all

Hudson’s At Main Street

3.6(139 reviews)

0.3 mi

We chose this for our Easter experience with our family…read more This had to be the worst buffet we have ever had, Six of us paid about $200.00 The food is overpriced, none of us enjoyed the food. Their hot buffet was a joke. It was stone cold! The chicken was tough and cold. I have catered many weddings with excellence results. I was ashamed for baker?? I would not serve my family their deserts. Fruity pebbles cookie was flat and not at all appealing. We would love to have a full refund! 229-869-5019 Elizabeth Brown

My experience was great ! I ordered the red velvet chicken & waffles on DoorDash, my food came fast…read more, the service was excellent Hailey handled my order she was very professional and helpful. The chicken and waffles were sooo delicious . I give it a 10/10 I do recommend. The ambiance of the restaurant on-line looks esthetically pleasing. I will be going in for dinner soon.

The shrimp and grits with a red velvet waffle

See all

Spicy Bloody

Panera Bread

2.6(90 reviews)

1.0 mi

My favorite place for French onion soup. So good and always a clean place. Order via a tablet…read morestand. See our YouTube channel Coolest Life.

Took the family for afternoon lunch and everything was great. The food was great but the portions…read morecould have been a little bit more. The service was excellent they were friendly and the food came out fast and hot. Panera always had a clean and nice ambiance.

Hearty Fireside Chili & Rustic Baked Potato Soup

Kickin' Grilled Cheese & Creamy Tomato Soup Value Duet

See all

New Sandwiches

Jim 'N Nick's Bar-B-Q

3.7(29 reviews)

0.6 mi

From the moment you step inside, the restaurant presents a clean, welcoming atmosphere that…read moreimmediately puts diners at ease. A prominent menu board greets you while waiting in line, complemented by another at the ordering counter for easy perusal. The restrooms are spotless and spacious, with surprisingly comfortable seating, while the thoughtful interior design and ample, easy-to-navigate parking further enhance the overall experience. Service was genuinely attentive and warm. Multiple staff members checked in on us throughout the meal, and the team maintained a diligent pace in clearing and cleaning tables to keep the space pristine. A minor hiccup with our order was quickly resolved--though it required a bit of coordination--thanks to their persistence, ensuring we received everything as intended. The beverage station offers Coca-Cola products alongside fresh sweet tea, unsweet tea, and lemonade. The sweet tea stands out as a refreshing standout: properly brewed, balanced, and genuinely flavorful without the cloying sweetness that plagues so many others. The Food: The cheese bread arrives as a fluffy, light delight with an ideal cheese-to-bread ratio. For a barbecue joint, it's exceptionally well-executed and harmonizes beautifully with the casual, smoky setting. The Morgan White sauce wings are nothing short of outstanding--meaty, perfectly cooked, and coated in a distinctive, vibrant sauce with just the right peppery zing to make your taste buds sing. I could easily devour dozens. Equally impressive are the Mango Habanero wings, which deliver a masterful balance of sweet and heat that builds gradually without overwhelming. The smoke from the cooking process shines through, and the generous portions include both drums and flats for excellent textural variety. These require no ranch to shine. The deviled eggs were competent but unmemorable--perfectly cooked, yet heavy on onion with muted overall flavor. They're unlikely to earn a repeat order. The ribs arrived in a solid portion of three generous pieces. They boast a deep, competition-style smoke with a firm bite that yields nicely upon chewing, leaving satisfying tooth marks. Not overly sauced or seasoned, they let the quality of the meat and smoke speak for themselves--an approach I deeply appreciate. The marble brisket, unfortunately, proved a disappointment. Though beautifully trimmed with good bark and seasoning, and passing the pull-apart and finger tests with ease, it was exceptionally dry. A rare miss that I won't be repeating. In contrast, the sausage is top-tier: excellent snap in the casing, flavorful filling, and spot-on texture. The cheddar jalapeño variety is very good, though I'd love to see a classic plain option alongside it. They've clearly mastered the difficult art of sausage-making here. The pulled pork offers a generous portion with great texture, visible bark, and pronounced smoke. The turkey breast was surprisingly moist for the category--certainly far better than the brisket--with a clean smoke and seasoning profile that might even convert non-turkey enthusiasts. Sides were a mixed bag. The coleslaw is lightly dressed, allowing the vegetables' natural flavors to come through with a pleasant peppery bite. It's solid but could use a touch more dressing for my taste. The French fries, however, are exceptional--crispy, beautifully seasoned, and dangerously addictive; they nearly stole the show before the mains arrived. The beans were a miss, with a peculiar tomato-sweet-vinegar profile that strayed far from traditional barbecue expectations. I wouldn't order them again. The mac and cheese arrived looking appealing but fell short in execution: overcooked noodles with a mushy, somewhat grainy texture and muted flavor, suggesting the sauce may have broken during preparation. Sauces were serviceable. The pepper vinegar paired wonderfully with the pork, while the Carolina mustard offered a creamy, mildly biting twist. The house ranch, however, was disappointingly bland and inferior to the benchmarks set by chains like Wingstop or Texas Roadhouse. Overall Ratings: * Service: A * Cleanliness: A * Layout & Ambiance: B Food: * S-tier: Morgan White wings, Mango Habanero wings, cheese bread * A-tier: Cheddar jalapeño sausage, ribs, French fries * B-tier: Turkey breast, pulled pork * C-tier: Coleslaw, deviled eggs, mac & cheese * D-tier: Brisket * F-tier: Beans, ranch, table BBQ sauce This is a comfortable, well-run spot with several standout items--particularly those magnificent wings and sausage--that make it worth visiting. With a few refinements on the weaker proteins and sides, it could easily rise to the top tier of local barbecue destinations

Came here again and got the nachos Same thing meat wasn't…read morewarm Also cheese wasn't fully melted They have a good taste to it Just those issues Customer service is good

Ordering

Smoked Wings

See all

Cheese Biscuit Mix

Chicken Salad Chick

4.1(62 reviews)

1.5 mi

*THIS REVIEW IS BASED ON THE MAC N' CHEESE ALONE*…read more The Mac N' Cheese was delicious. The cheese was a little runny but it was the perfect side to a fantastic sandwich. Overall, I would recommend.

After a long day, we decided to place an order for delivery to our hotel. Ordered 1/2 Fancy Nancy…read morechicken salad on a croissant and a cup of poblano chicken soup. It also came with a pickle spear and a mini round buttercream frosted cookie. The chicken salad sandwich was fresh and delicious, as was the soup. I highly recommend and would definitely eat at/order from this restaurant again!

Mac N' Cheese

See all

Nancy’s Pizzeria - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Nancy’s Pizzeria also viewed

Your Pie

4.1

(138 reviews)

Customer service was amazing here Lots of seating inside…read more Some seating outside The pizza had a good flavor to it. The sauces can also help with more flavor Cool spot on Broadway in Columbus Lemon pepper wings were so so

Casual pizza spot where you can build a pizza to your liking or choose one of their specials. It…read morechecks all the boxes for me! There are tons of ingredients to choose from (including vegan cheese) and toppings are unlimited - even if you start with one of the menu pizzas, you can make as many changes as you want. Lots of room to get creative. They also have a range of sizes: the 7" and 10" pizzas are both suitable for one person depending on your appetite, and the bigger size would be good for sharing. It's not the cheap greasy type of pizza, so depending on the ingredients you choose, you can create a relatively balanced meal. There's also pasta and salad on offer, which I did not try. For dessert, they have a modest gelato selection too (6-8 flavours if I remember correctly, mostly pretty standard stuff with a few specials), which also seems pretty high quality. Decent beer selection with the basics plus a few craft beers. First visit (2023): Tried the Kickin' BBQ Peach Pizza, a summer special menu item, and got rid of the bacon, added peppadew peppers and basil. It was really good! I love the pairing of fruity and spicy so the flavours were right on the mark for me. I might leave off the peppadew peppers if I were to redo my order just to keep things simple since the ingredients that came with the pizza were already really flavourful, but they were still a tasty addition. I had a scoop of peaches & cream gelato for dessert. Very creamy, with swirls of real peach compote. Second visit (2024): Same quality as last year. I did a custom order with a buffalo sauce base, vegan cheese, and some veggie toppings. The vegan cheese is standard stuff, same as you can buy at the grocery store; slightly gooier than real cheese but works fine. My pizza came out delicious. The service is pretty fast for food made to order. The staff were friendly and seemed eager to help customers customize their pizza, so I didn't feel like I was a bother for modifying the recipe.

Mellow Mushroom Columbus

3.8

(210 reviews)

Good restaurant and nice atmosphere. The food was delicious and the service was excellent. Would…read moredefinitely recommend the pizza.

Sad. A mile from our hotel and a nice looking website. Apparently the corporate vegan menu doesn't…read moreextend all the way to Columbus. I was able to order a pizza with nondairy cheese, green peppers and Italian sausage. The green peppers were raw and the crust was only partially cooked and doughy. Not much luck with the beer list I was handed either. My third choice was available but not much to my liking. The server should have pointed me to the updated tap list on the screen to my left. Instead I felt rushed and ordered something I wasn't sure about. Second time here as we pass through Columbus yearly. Likely to be the last.

Papa Johns Pizza

3.1

(7 reviews)

I recently tried the new Personal Pan Pizza from Papa John's, and unfortunately, my experience was…read moredisappointing. When I opened the pizza, it had a strong, off-putting smell that reminded me of vomit. While I was initially skeptical, I tried it and the taste was okay, but the bottom of the crust was tough. Some of my family members agreed that the smell was concerning, and one person chose not to eat it at all. I spoke with the store manager, who was apologetic and offered to remake the pizza if I returned it, but the pizza had already been eaten. He also suggested I submit a complaint online. Additionally, the brownies I had hoped to order were unavailable due to inventory issues, and I had to substitute Oreo bites. I've been a loyal customer and enjoy Papa John's, which is why this experience was especially disappointing. I hope this feedback helps the team review quality and preparation practices for this new item.

The pizza is kinda good but not good enough but I like it peace poppa Johnsread more

Caffe Amici

3.9

(122 reviews)

Superior service by our server, Brittany! Food was true Italian much like our visit a year ago in…read moreRome. & Venice. We enjoyed the Pescatorie and Salmon with Alfredo Linguine which were prepared fresh and served promptly. We're frequent visitors and havehad many of their dishes, none of whom have ever disappointed. Ambiance was warm and inviting with a nice wine list and casual attire.

We got to Columbus, GA, after a day's worth of driving & exhausted. We wanted something quick but…read morememorable. Caffe Amici is deceptive from outside, looking like a typical shopping center, run-of-the-mill themed restaurant. But it is nothing like that! Inside the fragrance of garlic and simmering past sauce let you know you are somewhere different than what you were expecting. The menu is eclectic but substantial of the traditional dishes are plentiful and worth exploring! I got the Gnocchi with a couple of meatballs and my Wife got the chicken in white sauce. Both were perfect and exactly what we needed in the moment! Definitely unexpected. The Tiramisu was spectacular and the wine list & cocktails were really good! Highly recommend!

Carrabba's Italian Grill

3.5

(158 reviews)

Our service was top notch from start to finish. My teenage daughter and I visited the day after…read moreValentine's Day. The restaurant was dimly lit and there wasn't a ton of noise. Tori was our waitress and we absolutely loved her! I could tell by the service that they all worked together to enhance our customer experience. The drinks and bread came out quickly and our food followed shortly thereafter. We were so famished after attending a basketball game that I forgot to take a picture of my entrée. However, I will say the rigatoni Al forno with sausage was delicious. I don't usually Yelp since this was a local establishment for me but the service was so impeccable that I just had to show some love. Give this spot a try...You won't be disappointed!

First time going to Carabbara's and wasn't disappointed! Waitress was attentive and sweet. Got an…read moreappetizer and almost didn't have room for my entree. Definitely a lot of food for the price. Cute date night idea.

Mabella

4.4

(356 reviews)

•$$$

Amazing service, food, drinks, and atmosphere. Everything we ordered highly exceeded our…read moreexpectations.

Very nice place to eat on a date or with friends/family. Server was good, but quiet. Restaurant was…read morequaint and a touch loud for dinner service (seated right next to the bar and entrance). We got the fried calamari and artichokes (great, good flavor). The table bread was toasted and garlic seasoned. My entree (mushroom ravioli with petite filet) was very good! That ravioli was 10/10! Perfectly cooked! That cheese sauce was so rich and creamy! Best pasta dish I've had in a while! My petite fillet was pretty good but only con was I requested medium and it was medium rare, but still great and I eat my meat either way. The only thing I didn't care for was the house salad. That dressing oil to vinegar ratio was off. It did not look or taste fancy and upscale like my entree did. The ceaser salad looked way more appealing. I tried a seasonal cocktail and man that was a refreshing orange spritz that was perfect for a hot day! I would for sure go back and try other things!

Kickin Bites

3.8

(16 reviews)

By what I ordered idk how this place would ever get 5 stars. They're not "terrible" it just doesn't…read moremake any sense to give it that much credit. Definitely not worth what they're charging. Seemed like eating at someone's house on a Saturday, that thinks they are a way better cook than they really are. Or that was tired and just throwing something together for the kids, so they just threw together a bunch of budget Walmart ingredients and called it a day. The fries seemed like those frozen fries bags at Walmart. The cheese on them was like the little cheese dip jars you buy at Walmart for chips. Same with the roast beef on the fries. Like the cheap roast beef packs thats like one strung together piece of roast beef because the whole pack was poorly cut. Same deal with the burger and everything on it. And they gave me the lemonade with no ice lol. Just room temperature lemonade, and no utensils. It's edible, i guess it's fine. But i didn't even eat half of anything, actually regret eating it at all bc of the lingering taste in my mouth, i could have cooked it better in the back yard, simply bc i would have added some seasonings, for way less and enough left over ingredients, and better ingredients, to last me a week. It's certainly not worth $40+ for everything I ordered. Very basic budget food you can make identical at home and give the left overs to the dog, for the price of a premium meal. Nothing special about this food at all. The cheap cheese on the fries is honestly probably the worst part of the whole meal and the bland burger and room temperature lemonade didn't help either. 3 stars bc i didn't experience the service or any other food options. But I'm also not eating from there again. I think 3 is perfectly generous. Hate to throw shade, but this place just honestly isn't worth it if you have any other options.

I ordered the Classic Philly along with the 10-piece wings, split between the Lemon Pepper Dry Rub…read moreand Cajun Dry Rub, and everything was phenomenal. The Philly was packed with flavor, and both wing flavors were seasoned perfectly. The staff were extremely friendly, welcoming, and knowledgeable about the menu. The prices were also very reasonable, especially considering the quality of the food. One thing that really stood out to me was learning that Kickin Bites is providing free meals to Georgia State Patrol. It is great to see a local business not only serving great food but also showing appreciation for those who serve the community. Great food, great service, reasonable prices, and a business that gives back. I will definitely be coming back!

Smoke Tavern and Grill

4.1

(8 reviews)

We tried this place for the first time. The staff were great. The food was really good. The salmon,…read morezucchini and collards amazing. 10/10. The Asian cucumber salad was good but spicy. The Cuban and fries was a 8/10. Would have been a 10/10 if they had used a crusty Cuban bread instead of a soft hoagie roll. The roll was a soggy. Put that pulled pork was very tasty. Will definitely be back.

Menu: Good variety Service: Great…read more The Food: Great Overall we enjoyed it and will definitely be back!

Country's Barbecue

3.2

(168 reviews)