Very good deep dish pizza. I really enjoy the taste of their sauce. I plan to go back to try more items soon!!

Nancy's pizzeria Never in my lifetime did I expect to give a pizza place an undisputed 4 star rating, yet here I am wondering if I should round it up to a 5. To preface this review, I've had many a slices of pizza from all over the country (New York, Chicago, New Jersey and Connecticut to name a few). I've eaten at places where the wait is an hour long due to their reputation. I've grab pizza from one pizzeria and subsequently grab pizza from their competitors down the street for a side by side comparison (Frank Pepe's and Sally's Apizza). The scope of reach for these taste buds don't stop there. Italy has blessed me with fine dining of their finest 'za. So call my tongue promiscuous when it comes to cheese slapped on a crust, I know my pizza. That being said, the south is known for many things (good and bad) with pizza being in the latter. Yet today, today, I stumbled upon a potential shift in the tradition of southern states' notorious letdown in pizza quality. Nancy's gets a solid 4.4 stars from me putting them in competition with some sit down restaurants I've attended. Not only that, I drove nearly 40 mins back home, blowing red lights and hitting speeds upwards of 85 mph so that the "goods" would still be warm. To my surprise not only was it warm, it was hot to the touch. Now does the credit go to the driver or the stores expert packaging this remains a mystery. Now, this pizza for all the good does have one trade-off that can't go without being noticed: price. Save some money in the piggy bank for this one cause it was nearly 30 smackaroos. Is that high in absolute terms, yes. But when you look at relative terms considering the style of pizza deep dish, this is standard. All in all, I shall return. read more

Nancy’s Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Georgia

I've had the pizza and Italian beef. Let's start with the pizza, I'm from Chicago so I'm very familiar with the deep dish pizza, especially Nancy Pizza, Italian Fiesta, and Giordano's. The Nancy's here tastes like the one in Chicago which is delish and reminds me of home. The service is ok but not great because when I asked the girl at the restaurant if everything I ordered was in the bag? She replied yes, I checked my bag and the Au Jus was missing and I ordered sweet peppers, which I paid extra for, was missing. However, the sandwich was good and had plenty of meat. The ambiance, it's a takeout restaurant, no seating available. In my opinion Nancy's is the best pizza I've had in Columbus. read more

I've eaten here twice so far and it's pretty good. The staff is very helpful and polite. I want to try more of the menu. The price is a little steep but it's worth it. read more

Authentic Chicago Pizzeria! The real deal deep dish! The thin crust is superior as well !

The pizza was fantastic. The only true deep dish in town. The Uncle Tony's was amazing. read more

Nancy’s Pizzeria - The pizza was cooked perfectly. The small is enough for one person to eat a couple meals from. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Georgia

See all

We called ahead for all meat deep dish. It was one lady doing everything. The pizza was ready upon arrival. It was such a refreshing change for a take out pizza. It is pricey, but it was a special treat. read more

See all

Best pizza I've had in this town. Hands down. If you are looking for legitimate Chicago style food then this is your place! And to all of the reviewers that don't seem to know what that is, just give it a try. It's different than the pizza you are used to and that can be a good thing! We ordered on Uber eats and everything was packaged perfectly = great service to me! They nailed the toppings, cheese, sauce, and crust ratios to remind me of a real deep dish pizza. Best one I've had outside of Chicago. We got the Uncle Tony's and just wow. Can't wait to try more things here! read more

See all

So tasty! It's takeout only so plan for that. It was a long drive home with a delicious smelling pizza in the car!! Meatballs were good sized and well sauced, and the pizza was good. Had a coupon so we picked it up after some shopping in the area. I'd like to try a stuffed crust next time. This isn't close to home or work, but it will be a nice treat on the way home from a shopping run to the big box stores nearby. read more

Nancy’s Pizzeria - Small thin crust cheese pizza with an appetizer side of meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Georgia

They STILL have no dine in !! They told my family and vmyself that they were opening a dine in , sit down facility in March of 2024 . Are they too busy counting their cash from their $40.00 pizzas to give a shit about their customers ? NOBODY has pizza so good that I am inclined to pay the big bucks and have to eat on the sidewalk . Bye Bye , hello Cerrones . read more

They only do take out. But it's worth it! I really think this is the only place where you can get a good Chicago deep dish along with other great dishes to go. Everything is great on their pizza. We got the all the meats and it's delish! read more

Nancy’s Pizzeria - All meat deep stuffed pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Georgia

See all

We decided to try Nancy's Pizza today! Let me say it did not disappoint! We got the medium sausage and pepperoni pizza and it was enough . We both love Chicago style pizza and weren't impressed by others in town but Nancy's was great! My favorite was the meatballs! His favorite was the fettuccine Alfredo. I wasn't able to try everything because I was stuffed. But he said everything was great. We will definitely be back! read more

See all

Ordered online. Pizza tasted very similar to something you can get in Chicago. Would recommend! read more

Nancy’s Pizzeria - Uncle's Tony deep dish - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Georgia

See all

Great smells when you walk in. Was headed next door for a pedicure and popped in for a menu. Decided to order online while getting pampered. Got my order number and time for pick-up. Unfortunately, when I arrived after my pick-up time, it was not ready. After asking how much longer, the counter help inquired for me and was told about 10 more minutes. Meanwhile another customer picked up her order and I asked what time she had ordered. Her answer she walked in to order @ 5:45 a good 10 min after my online order was confirmed. I asked about the delay and was told that online orders sometimes are not seen if the kitchen is busy. So, call or walk in to order- still waiting and I ordered an hour ago. Pinning high hopes on the quality and taste! Will update then. read more

See all

10/10 WOULD NOT RECOMMEND!! The pizza was very bad. For one, the dough was not at ALL cooked. It looked kinda cooked, but it was not. The cheese was very rubbery and hard to chew, and the pizza was like eating a tire off an old gross truck. It's like it's been in a freezer since 1856. Where the crust is "cooked" it's like eating straight up cardboard. May as well eat the box. My brother ate a whole slice, and he said he hope he doesn't get food poisoning from the THING. I'd rather go eat from a trash can then lay my eyes on the "pizzas" that are made there. Nancy's pizzeria sounds similar to nasty pizzeria, but nobody took the hint. if someone said "hey you want a pizza from here for free?" I'd say no go torture someone else from this place, but jail food seems more appealing to me. Pizza from my hometowns school is better then this gross substabce they called "pizza." read more

So excited to find authentic Chicago deep dish locally!! Delicious!! The price is comparable with other quality pizza, especially with the amount of food you get, so worth it! read more

I'm a native of Chicago ( south side) and Nancy's pizza is the closest thing I've had that actually tasted like a Chicago pizza.

I've tried it twice. If you like a pizza with a whole tub of cheese this place is definitely for you. I mean the amount of cheese left over was nuts. We did the thin first and deep on the second visit and were underwhelmed. The price was very expensive. The sauce was pretty good but we won't be back. read more

Great Chicago style pizza on par with some of our favorite places! Super surprised to find this place down south! If you're a fan of deep dish or thin crust don't hesitate! read more

The pizza here is just okay. Not a ton of flavor, and the "toppings" are basically indistinguishable in the pizza. Too expensive for what you get. read more

ABSOLUTELY the best pizza in town. Ordered through Door Dash looking for somewhere we hadn't eaten before! Will definitely be a repeat customer! read more

True deep dish Chicago pizza with layers of cheese and toppings, ( the uncle Tony ) not just a thick crust wannabe. If this Is what you're looking for it's really good. We're two old people ( can't eat like I use to ) so we'll be able to eat on this thing for a couple of days. We'll probably go back to our regular pizza source, but this will not disappoint, and a great experience. read more

Nancy’s Pizzeria - 9" uncle Tony's Chicago deep dish pizza pie. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Georgia

I'm from the Chicago South suburbs so I know all about the square cut thin crust, deep dish, and stuffed pizzas. Since moving to Georgia, in 2017, I can honestly say this is the first time we've ordered pizza and been wow'd. It was amazing! We can't wait until the Italian Beef sandwiches are ready to order off the menu. I do have high expectations considering I've been spoiled with Portillos and Al's beef sandwiches but I'll take what I can get as long as there's mozzarella and giardiniera involved too. Nancy's will definitely be our new go to spot. read more

Nancy’s Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Georgia

See all

Pizza was good, this is not a sit down restaurant, it's a grab and go. Order ahead, takes about 20 minutes.

I would give it a 5 star but it lacks sitting space and ambiance because it's take out. However the food ..pizza was awesome the Chicago deep dish was on point. Did Taste like my favorite pizza place in Chicago. The service was great too, the gentleman was very helpful and explain the menu to me. Can't wait to come back they plan to open a sitting area so excited about that . read more

Got the original stuffed pizza, was relatively good, just a little to much cheese, it quite frankly bit me back, because we had a 10-15 minute drive home, but tasted good and service was nice read more

Food was amazing. Placed a to go order close to closing time and they stayed late to make and ensure our food was delivered. Would definitely recommend. read more

Nancy's deep dish is worth all the hype, I literally crave this pizza now. The cannolis were good too. The service was also pleasant, I've only dealt w the man when I've gone in but I have no complaints. Long live Nancy's! read more

Nancy’s Pizzeria - The cheese pull - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Georgia

See all

The best deep dish south of Chicago I was thoroughly pleased and had a wonderful experience

So the pizza here is very good. True to Chicago style pizza...although you would never know it by the name. We just lucked out and fell into it by accident so we were delighted to realize there was authentic Chi-town pizza right here in Columbus. My only fear is that it won't last long. The food is great but the prices are very high. A medium pizza with a few toppings was nearly $30. We don't mind paying for great food, but this demographic is more Little Caesar's or Domino's budget. Especially if you have a family to feed. If this is a franchise, they should have done a better market analysis. I give this place 6 months tops with prices at the current rate. Unfortunate, because we love it...trying not to get attached. read more

The pizza was outstanding and well garnished with ingredients! My wife and I couldn't help but reminisce about our trip to Chicago. The pizza is that good! Support local restaurants and businesses! read more

The deep dish pizza was amazing! The online ordering was efficient and easy to use and was ready when stated it would be.

I just bought an Uncle Tony's Original Stuff medium size pizza (10 - 8- 22) and I was not satisfied with it. For the price of the pizza, I got crust, tomato sauce, vegetables and very little or no Italian sausage and pepperoni. This visit to Nancy's Pizzeria did not meet my expectation. read more

I am originally from Chicago and heard of Nancy's, but never tried it. When I heard that a location was opening in Columbus, I wanted to give it a try. I ordered a small "Rocco's Party". It was delicious. I am a fan of Giordano's and I would have to say that I Nancy's stuffed pizza is equal to it. read more