Customer service was amazing here Lots of seating inside Some seating outside The pizza had a good flavor to it. The sauces can also help with more flavor Cool spot on Broadway in Columbus Lemon pepper wings were so so read more

Casual pizza spot where you can build a pizza to your liking or choose one of their specials. It checks all the boxes for me! There are tons of ingredients to choose from (including vegan cheese) and toppings are unlimited - even if you start with one of the menu pizzas, you can make as many changes as you want. Lots of room to get creative. They also have a range of sizes: the 7" and 10" pizzas are both suitable for one person depending on your appetite, and the bigger size would be good for sharing. It's not the cheap greasy type of pizza, so depending on the ingredients you choose, you can create a relatively balanced meal. There's also pasta and salad on offer, which I did not try. For dessert, they have a modest gelato selection too (6-8 flavours if I remember correctly, mostly pretty standard stuff with a few specials), which also seems pretty high quality. Decent beer selection with the basics plus a few craft beers. First visit (2023): Tried the Kickin' BBQ Peach Pizza, a summer special menu item, and got rid of the bacon, added peppadew peppers and basil. It was really good! I love the pairing of fruity and spicy so the flavours were right on the mark for me. I might leave off the peppadew peppers if I were to redo my order just to keep things simple since the ingredients that came with the pizza were already really flavourful, but they were still a tasty addition. I had a scoop of peaches & cream gelato for dessert. Very creamy, with swirls of real peach compote. Second visit (2024): Same quality as last year. I did a custom order with a buffalo sauce base, vegan cheese, and some veggie toppings. The vegan cheese is standard stuff, same as you can buy at the grocery store; slightly gooier than real cheese but works fine. My pizza came out delicious. The service is pretty fast for food made to order. The staff were friendly and seemed eager to help customers customize their pizza, so I didn't feel like I was a bother for modifying the recipe. read more

See all

Walked in not knowing what to expect, figured I'd just grab some pizza for lunch. I was immediately greeted by the very friendly staff, very open to questions, chill and seem to actually care about their work and the food they make. Food is customizable to your liking, and the pizza was phenomenal, made just to my liking, while I was sitting down, I like to absorb the atmosphere. Place has a really nice vibe, love the decorations. I would highly recommend this place to any soldier trying to get off base and grab a solid slice of pizza, much better than dominoes lol. read more

Quick friendly service. I think they lean toward less traditional pizzas but I did get a pepperoni pizza quickly. It was a bit bland but nothing a little seasoning couldn't fix. Nice atmosphere in restaurant while you wait. read more

AMAZING PIZZA IN UPTOWN COLUMBUS GEORGIA ================================= My husband, son and I went there twice during the course of the week, so we loved it. Their New York style thin crust pizza is probably the best I have had in ages. The first time I ordered a margarita style pizza and the second time my husband and I split a veggie style pizza. He added pepperoni to his side. Monday is a bargain for the military. You can buy one and get one free, so of course we went on a Monday. read more

See all

Wow! We wanted something small while walking around downtown. This place is the spot to hit up! We ordered a 10 inch pepperoni and drinks. The crust was PERFECT! Light and crispy, I had a sweet tea/regular tea mix it was great. The table next to us had wings as well with their pizza, next time I'm here we will get those as well. I'm a bit of a pizza snob, but seriously the sauce, the cheese, the pepperoni and the crust...pure perfection!! read more

Your Pie - BUILD YOUR OWN PIZZA - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Georgia

Kinda tough time to do a review. They were slammed with a high school theatre festival, and I have to say the staff handled it VERY well. Huge crowds, bit of course everyone was in a hurry. My guess is that on a less "line literally out the door day" the lies would get another minute in the oven and a little more attention. All that being said, it was still quite good, so kudos! read more

I went there for lunch. Had a 7" mini pizza with sausage and pepperoni. Thin crust, nice crunch. Had an IPA with it. The beer selection is pretty IPA heavy, but that's not unusual. Need to try the gelato. read more

Your Pie - 7" pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Georgia

We just got into town and didn't feel like doing much for dinner. We tried to order delivery, we're only 0.6 mi away from the store but it said they weren't doing delivery- not sure if that's an all the time thing or not so we just picked it up! Quick and easy process. The pizzas were DELISH. I ordered a specialty pizza (pictured) as is and I loved every bit of it. My husband ordered a custom pizza and devoured it. Toppings were fresh and plentiful. Crust is in the thinner side which is our preference anyways! And make sure you get some gelato read more

Your Pie - NAT'S CHICKEN PESTO - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Georgia

Tried the gluten free pizza with sausage and onions. Not greasy and can watch as the pizza is prepared. Really enjoyed the pizza. Plan to try the vegan cheese too. read more

Delicious!!! Be sure to know the process so nothing gets confused: 1st person starts your dough - just tell them whether you want white or wheat dough. Next person puts on your toppings. Everyone in our party loved their pizza & pasta. We will definitely be back!!! read more

Great little place we visited while in town to see our son who graduated from Auburn. You can build your own pizza and have a zillion options, so how can you downgrade them for making exactly what you like? Thin crust is really the only option, so you Chicago Style lovers would hate it, but we really liked our pizzas and sitting outside on the avenue. read more

Have visited Columbus and Your Pie several times in recent months , in fact, this trip my family and I ate at Your Pie twice as we have always enjoyed friendly service, great pizza and good value . Last evening the five of us sat at the high top table next to the order counter where I had a clear view into the back kitchen and now wish I didn't ! Simply the sanitation practices of a number of staff was appalling and unappetizing. Staff were observed vaping and exhaling their vapor over pizza boxes, food product and a shared pizza that were stuffing their faces with fingers to mouth and none washing or sanitizing their hands, fingers upon returning to make pizzas and give change, pour beer etc. Disgusting ! read more

Great flavor to the pie!!!! The crust is beyond perfect, and the oven they cook in is visible so you can see the whole making process cause they use also an open kitchen, the two females that took our order were really quiet spoken, however and made it a little tense when trying to order we ordered the new limited spicy Italian pizza. It was great but it look nothing like the picture and was missing the red sauce as described in the picture and there was no ground sausage hardly compared to the picture and there was hardly any pepperoni as well. The Unsung Hero is the peppers on the pizza and for mozzarella. Best components to the pie we had today. Pricy but delicious . Will come again!!! read more

See all

It was absolutely wonderful! The people making the pizzas were nice and very professional! The place was super clean ! Love the family environment. The price is fair ! Will definitely eat here again when I'm back in town! read more

the staff was super friendly , i ordered a pizza with basil i was sure when i saw the price of the pizza it would have basil (leaves) but to my disappointment just some dried basil sprinkles ( i guess) no basil flavor at all. read more

We like brick oven pizza, but it was burnt. There was no real flavor to the pizza. We ordered delivery, so I have no idea about the actual restaurant itself. read more

Not a Margarita, It has no Basil leaves, wake up. Portions are overpriced for what you get.

I cannot say enough about your pie! Staff is amazing, their pizza is delicious! I love how fast and easy they make it to order. My only recommendation would be sticking up on more dough. I've been some gluten free pizza and haven't been able to get my pizza gluten free when we visit as they're always out. read more

They don't let you see what they have beyond the glass to see what to have on your pizza. Insane you have to look at a small print typed menu taped on the front of glass. The grungy looking guy that waited on me was not clean looking. This one is not good downtown never got a good experience not to mention the table are not wiped down after use. Nasty floor and tables. Drive over to the one on the other side of Columbus its Awesome. read more

The food was great. From the salad to the custom ordered pie (pizza). They cater to the personal experience as well as from the individual by their self to families with children small to teens. The also have a small area for outdoor seating. read more

Great pizza, Great service. They cook the pizza infront of you the food was hot and ready

Came on a busy Saturday afternoon. Ordered a Caesar salad, my daughter ordered Alfredo pasta and a side of bread sticks. Everything was good. I tasted the pasta and was quite surprised by the amount of garlic flavor in it! My daughter loved that they included gelato with her kids meal as well. Will be returning and I may get the pasta for myself next time lol read more

Great pizza with awesome customer service! The staff was extremely kind to our 3 small kids and helpful with building different pizza. My wife said her vegan pizza was stellar and had to grab one to go. Sorry to mellow mushroom but between taste, price and customer service this place is the best in town for sure. read more

A very horrible establishment with horrible service. The cashier,Lindsey, was the icing on the cake. She snatched the cup out of my hand and I was .03 seconds away from making sure that she was baking along with my pizza. Although my pizza taste delicious, Lindsey has the most disgusting attitude and she needs a readjustment immediately. I hope she gets fired and humbled quickly. read more

Do not order delivery from this place. They will not take responsibility for screwed up orders. They blame grub hub, claiming that it's the driver's responsibility to get the order right. read more

First time here and it's delicious!! Great service!! Great atmosphere!! Ingredients are fresh!! If you love pizza this is definitely the place to come to!!! I love it!! read more

Your Pie - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Georgia

I searched for a pizza place downtown Columbus and Your Pie came on up on my iPhone. Not expecting much, my wife and I were blown away at how good the pizza was! Even the salads were good for being prepackaged when you walk in. This restaurant is sort of like Chipotle and Simple Greek but pizza-style. This place is my new favorite pizza place is Columbus! read more

Great pizza and service. They always use fresh ingredients. It's one of the better pizzeria's in Columbus.

2 hours waiting for my pizza. They take ages to serve u, but you ask them for a beer they bring it in no time. They just want u to keep spending money on alcohol. The worst service read more

See this right here is why I love Yelp! I got a surprise call from the Mister asking me to drive down to Columbus for the Fourth og July weekend. I wanted to try a new spot and in less than 5 minutes other Yelpers lead me here. I am so happy that I listened to y'all. We left Fido at the hotel and decided to grab a bite My eyes are wider than my belly so the first thing I said was 6 inches? WTH am I gonna do with that? Yes only 6 inches ladies. :) Anyway, you pick your dought white or wheat, then your sauce, and then you come to the Subway like veggie spread and pick out your toppings. I got a bunch of veggies, chicken, gorgonzola cheese on regular dough w marinara sauce. He got wheat dough with every meat known to man and a few veggies. The pizza was assume. The music was GREAT. The create your oen flavor Coke soda machine was fun as usual. You can sit inside or out. Pets were welcome outside on a leash. There is seating up and down the strip for eating or relaxing. I must say that I give this place a 3.5 Star because a lot of the veggies were not as fresh looking as I'd like for them to be. But they were still good. read more

See all

While in Columbus on business, I needed a change of pace from fried Southern food. Fired up the trusty Yelp app, and this branch of Your Pie was less than a block away from my hotel. It was a good find, a fast-casual brick oven pizza outlet. Ordered a personal size pie with several meats and veggies. Added a mini flight of microbrew 4 oz samples, total cost less than $20. Good deal! Both beer & pizza were very tasty and hit the spot! Definitely head back here the next time work takes me back to Columbus! Someplace to repeat and recommend! read more

Your Pie - $7 mini flight of micro brews - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Georgia

See all

This is a great establishment. Pizza is amazing and the ranch is out of this world!!!! If you don't like pizza they also have gelato ice cream it's also amazing read more

Yummmmmy! I was a little skeptical coming here as I've had mod pizza before and this is the same concept only 200x better tasting!! It's like the subway of pizza, AMAZING. You can get unlimited toppings and I waited no more than 10 minutes for my pizza! read more

Your Pie - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Georgia

Great pizza that is priced right! Love their gluten-free option, the kids actually eat it up! Customer service shines here too which is a big plus these days, when half the restaurants are staffed by clueless newbs. read more

My friend described it best: Your Pie is like Subway for pizza. I'm so glad we made this stop for lunch on our way through downtown Columbus. Just like Subway, you can choose from the menu or you can build your own. I kept it simple and ordered The Nat, basically because I'm obsessed with anything that has feta cheese. It was delicious! The only difference between Subway and Your Pie (besides the obvious sandwich vs. pizza) is they actually bring your food out to you when it's done. They also have one of those Coke machines where you can choose from like a zillion flavors, but I had to go for the sweet tea because it's the south, duh. I just wish there were some locations closer to my home! read more

Your Pie - The Nat - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Georgia

Been here countless times with the family and have never been disappointed. The options of ingredients are wide and varied. I'm not a vegetarian, but I always go all veggie because the flavors are just so good. Pesto, whole motz, artichoke, sun dried tomatoes, banana peppers, mushrooms, and jalapeños. So good. And. ANd. AND! They had a limited time pie with Zapps chips on it! My BP was through the roof but it was with it. read more

Your Pie - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Georgia

Outstanding option for our family as they take good care of our little girl on Wednesday with kids specials and "play dough"

Pizza cold. Waited longer than usual so 8 got up to check it sits in the cooling rack. I was running out of time to eat and get to work. 1:30b y the I got it. For two pizzas and two drinks $24. and change. I'll just go somewhere else next time. To bad cause use to get there often with friends. Maybe it should be a one star but it still was ok except not being HOT. read more

We love a make your own pizza spot. Clean, friendly staff and good selection of toppings. They even will cook our pizzas separate and not cut them to maintain our own comfort. read more