Best Deep Dish in STL! The closest deep dish to Chicago's Lou Malnati's. Their crust was flaky, perfect distribution of sauce, and ideal meat portions throughout. Warning: they do sprinkle parmesan cheese on the top of the pizza. (I prefer my parmesan on the side.) read more

We tried to order but when the person finally came up to the counter, he informed me they were cash only. So, needless to say, given the prices, I did not have sufficient cash. Not sure if it is always that way, but I guess I will never know. read more

Awesome Chicago style pizza. I'm from Chicago (born, raised, and 25 year resident)...it's exactly like a Giordano's pizza. Sauce has great flavor, and both cheese and crust are spot on. read more

It's definitely not a bad Chicago-style pizza. There isn't too many Chicago style parlors around so there isn't a place to compare it to but I would definitely order from here again. Mind you there is no delivery and there is no place to dine in read more

We enjoy Nancy's Chicago style pizza. Very good our son lives in Chicago We have enjoyed Nancy's pizza and wings several times. We get pepperoni Chicago style pizza and buffalo wings all were delicious. Enough for two meals for two people. read more

My heart hurt when I left Chicago to move here for my husband's job. I am totally a "foodie" and love my pizza! IMO's was not it for me! Nancy's pizza is fantastic! We even live outside of the delivery boundaries. If I ask nicely during the week, they are happy to deliver. I would never ask on a busy night. The point is- awesome pizza, awesome staff! I'm always recommending them. read more

So happy to be able to get a real Chicago style deep dish outside of Chicago. If you love Giordano's, you wont be disappointed in Nancy's. The quality here is fantastic. The prices look a little high, but when you have the pizza box in your hand, you'll understand why. The small deep dish is enough to feed me and my wife. Sometimes we end up having a slice left. This place is a must try for anyone missing that delicious Chicago style pizza. read more

Great pizza! New favorite pizza place in O'Fallon! Favorites are Rocco's Party & A Lot A' Meat. Get it Chicago style! Best Chicago style pizza in St. Louis. read more

We eat pizza all over the world and this is probably the top three that we have had! Order their rustic Italiano, as is, and you will thank me. The flavor is so good and the cheese is amazing. We started going here for their Chicago style deep dish and then tried this one and were so happy we did. We still order one Chicago style and then the rustic Italian, every time we go. My only minor complaint is that it's a little pricey. read more

Very overpriced for the food you get. A large salad was $7 (we requested cheese that they forgot to put in it) and it was the size of an individual side salad at any other pizza place in the area. The pizza was okay, but it was $29. There are a lot of pizza options in this area (I understand they aren't all deep dish) and most of them are much better buys for the money. The only reason I didn't give only 1 star is because the deep dish pizza was decent. read more

Pizza was great. Ordered a stuffed for me and a thin crust for my wife. Both delicious. Unfortunately costs as much as you would pay in downtown Chicago.I moved here from N. Illinois and am used to paying about half this price. I also ordered the fettuccine alfredo as it was advertised as award-winning. Stay away!. DRY DRY DRY. What was not advertised is this is a mushroom sauce. I am allergic to some mushrooms but ate it anyway. Tasted like paste. (Yes, I know what paste taste like. I ate some as a kid. And if most people are honest, so did they) I will go back here as the choices in STL for real pizza is dismal. But I will not go as often as I would otherwise if the prices were not so prohibitive. read more

Closest thing to actual Chicago deep-dish I've had outside Chicago. Had the Lots a Meat deep dish and Italian Veggie pan. Deep dish was slightly larger than the pan and had sauce instead of just tomatoes. They were both smalls and neither my wife nor I could eat more than 2 pieces, so cost-wise, we got 2 meals, which defuses the fact that they're a bit pricey. It took about an hour to deliver to north O'Fallon, which was exactly what I was told. Quality was great, delivery guy was friendly. A big win for a new place in O'Fallon. read more

Just ate here tonight and it is absolutely delicious. My new favorite pizza place. We ordered a deep dish with pepperoni and sausage. The best pizza place around!! read more

Hubs and I thought our pan pizza was really good. Nice tender crust, very cheesy, and I loved the savory chunky sauce on top. Side salad was ok, nothing special, but seemed fresh. No tables, pick-up only (well, I believe they have delivery to a limited area). We will probably be back, Hubs wants to try a thinner crust. read more

Got the rustic pizza. It was good. Lots of cheese and tomatoes. Mozzarella sticks however tasted like they had been sitting around all night. We would give them another try. Decent menu and decent prices read more

Ok so now I know I don't like deep dish pizza as well as good ole st.louis style pizza. That said the ingredients were good and the crust was tasty. I just could not get over the feeling that my pizza was inside out. The salad was over priced but ok. This is carry out or delivery only but the waiting area was clean. From the time I ordered to I walked out the door was @ 35 minutes was not sure what to expect on the cook time for deep dish but that seemed fair. read more

I love Nancy's. The pizza is super good and the staff is always willing to help. Each deep dish will feed 4-5 people.

Very good pizza. Had it twice in the last two weeks. A little pricey but well worth it for a treat. Deep dish was our pick.

Just had for the first time...hours not convenient, can't use more than one coupon at a time, 45 minute quoted wait time turned into an hour. The cashier said he'd bring it out to our car and then he forgot causing our wait to be longer and we had to go inside to get it.....they were not busy. Disappointed is Chicago-style pizza.....didn't seem to have any garlic and very little sausage and pepperoni. Over-priced for quality of pizza. We will not order from here again. read more

Ordered for delivery. Tried the rustic crust Uncle Tonys . a small garbage salad. For a medium pizza and a small salad the bill came to $31. Yikes. Salad was good. We were not really impressed with pizza. Meat seemed skimpy while large chunks of green pepper were overpowering. I picked off most of the pepper. It was delivered hot. Took right on an hour. Overall, Ill stick with stefaninas and pirrones. read more

Pizza was good but a little dry. I am from Chicago and have has Nancy's pizza, this location was not bad. I would order again. Service was good also. read more

Man I tried this pizza and dang was it good. The deep dish is really deep and delicious go get ya some.

Had the stuffed crust deep dish the way I like it and a thin crust for the kids. Thin crust crust was tasty lots of cheese kids loved it so did I. Deep dish was spot on for I was hoping for. Tons of cheese toppings tasted great sauce was well balanced. I will order again! read more

OMG! Almost unbelievable to have one of the best Pizza places in Chicago open up in my now hometown, O'Fallon, MO. And of course we had a deep dish delivered...Incredible! A deep dish pizza pie very similar to Gino's East but nowhere near as greasy. And the following week we ordered their thinner crust. Equally great. This place is almost too good to be true. Fantastic Chicago style pizza cooked to perfection. Here in STL the problem is often the crust doesn't match Chicago. Not a problem with Nancy's. To have a Nancy's Pizza in town is truly wonderful. read more

I don't traditionally choose to order food from a flyer i get in the mail. But when I saw the picture of a beautiful stuffed pizza on the front and how it was a business that originated in 1971, I decided to try it. I had looked forward to Friday when I was going to order for my family some stuffed pizza. Quick delivery! Very polite! The food.....holy cow! Delicious! Fresh and hot! Fresh meats that were amazing. Cheese was phenomenal! The sauce....an old time recipe that has been used since 1971! Hats off!!! Amazing taste! I was in heaven. More expensive then dominos, papa johns, Pizza Hut and others I have had. BUT more then worth it! I will pay more for higher end pizza! This is money well spent! I will eat here more! Welcome to the neighborhood! You will be around forever! read more

Ordered for the first time and was very happy. One of the best Chicago style pizza places around. I would not get the mot stick again. But I will definitely order here again. read more

Pretty solid Chicago style deep dish. Did the Uncle Tony's and it was good. Can't say it's the best deep dish I've ever had but probably one of the best St. Louis deep dish pizzas I've had! read more

Great place for some deep dish! Friendly and helpful service. Bonus that they deliver but it can run a little long at 45 min.

This is my new favorite pizza. I love the thick Chicago style but ordered the thin crust. We had it delivered. I couldn't believe how heavy the pizza box was. They put a lot of cheese on their thin crust as well. They also put foil over the pizza in the pizza box so it was delivered very hot. You can always go online and find coupons too. read more

If you love stuffed deep dish then this is the good stuff. The Mrs and I had our first small sausage pie and it was delicious. The cheese, crust, sausage and sauce were all great. We will be back for more. FYI - It is carry out or delivery only (i.e. just a waiting bench inside) and they have Pepsi products. read more

Being a native Chicagoan, this is a huge deal. Nancy's was a great Pizza in Chicago and they use the same everything. Had it tonight for the 1st time, and I can say that I won't go anywhere else. Tell everyone you know!!!! You will absolutely LOVE this place. read more

I tried this place for the first time today. My family love the deep dish pizza! We will be ordering more pizzas from the Great folks at Nancy's. read more

Always love Nancy's. Sausage and mushroom stuffed pizza is awesome, and reasonably priced. Probably had it half a dozen times, and it is consistent and delicious read more

Woo hoo! Recently moved here from Chgo and was having trouble finding pizza to our liking -- no provel, please. Ordered a deep dish pizza with sausage. Since I wanted to pick it up earlier in the day to serve for supper, they baked it and froze it. I put it in my fridge until about an hour before I wanted to reheat. Turned out perfectly except that the sauce got a bit dried out. Hoping to get one fresh next time, since they checked and noted that we are in their delivery area. Hurray!!!! read more

Great Chicago style pizza!' This is hard to find in STL! Great wings, and pasta too! If your missing Chicago style pizza, this is your kinda place!' The hot buffalo wings are perfectly moist! Enjoy! read more

Great Chicago style pizza we will definitely order again yummy I still must keep writing in order for it to accept my review

Delicious, great cheese, clean place, one and only in MO. Got the pepperoni deep dish large. The dough cook just right.

Awesome pizza! The closest we've found to Chicago pizza. The only negative is that there is no dining area. It has to be ordered to go.

Called to order a pizza with 3 toppings and they wanted 31 dollars. Needless to say I said I would "call back" and never did. Expensive prices like this will lead to your business not lasting long in this area. We already have plenty of pizza places. And no specials! What the heck. Never plan on even trying it. read more