Wow. Just drove to nellies and waited in line for 40 minutes to pick up a pizza -- only to be told by the lady ringing me up that there is a 20% tip automatically included in the charge. She said i could change it...if I'd like. I feel like this is so shady!! I'm sorry, you guys are not hurting for business or doing anything extra during Covid that warrants this type of additional charge. We are longtime customers but will be taking our business to Sicilian sun from now on until this practice is discontinued. If I'm going to be paying a tip it will be for someone who delivers. read more

I have been stopping by this place as a treat to myself for years. It has some really great thin crust pizza. I know everybody touts that Kinchley's in Mahwah is the best around but Nellies gives it a run for its money. I been to both if you gotta problem with I'll see you outside buddy! It has a full bar and the other fare is very good too. But really the whole reason to go there is the pizza. I do gotta say it gets very crowded there so maybe getting it to go would be better. Just stick the pizza back in the oven when you get home. But if your gonna stay it's worth the crowds so enjoy and have a pie for me. read more

I visited this venue in 2010. I posted a picture of me and a California and traditional pie. The size of the pie at the time was absolutely enormous. Probably one of the best pies I've ever had. I never wrote a review at that time but I'm writing one now because I came back today for the first time in 8 years. I was visiting a friend that I hadn't seen in almost 40 years so we had a lot to catch up on. The first waitress came to us immediately and took our drink orders. It took about 20 minutes to get a beer and a glass of wine. Then after we got her drinks and took her another 15 minutes to realize that we never got menus but because we were so caught up in talking we really didn't care and Let It Go. When we finally ordered the pizza came very quickly but I was kind of disappointed in the size of the pie because the last time I had been there in 2010 the thing was gargantuan. I asked her if this was the biggest pie she had and she said yes that maybe they had changed their size on the menu since the last time I was there. A large pie isn't much bigger than a personalized pie so you end up ordering two. Then this waitress who we didn't see the first 20 minutes of our visit shows up every 30 seconds to make sure everything's okay while you have a full mouth of food. Lol anyway I guess it was her time to leave and the new waitress came in. Enter nurse ratchet. OMG. SO we've been paying customers for now about an hour and nurse ratchet comes up and says are you done? And my friends and I look at each other like why are you asking us this... And we say no we're not my friend still has a half a glass of wine and we're still sitting here enjoying ourselves is that okay? We also then asked if she was expecting a large group and if she needed us to move because she was expecting to put tables together and she said no. Anyway fast-forward 20 minutes later she's still going back and forth between our tables and policing the area as if we're up to no good. We decided to stay and ignore her. So the total bill was $42 for two very small pizzas, one beer on tap, two glasses of Chardonnay, one iced tea and one Arnold Palmer and lots of aggravation from nurse ratchet. I think that's a lot of money for barely any food. Not sure if you are still reading but if you are just make sure that when you go in that you choose the largest table there and sit there as long as you can because it seems to me that they don't bother people that are single and sitting all by themselves and a really big table but they will bother two people in a single table. We blew it off and made fun of it and will probably laugh about it for the next 30 years of our friendship but nonetheless nurse ratchet annoyed the s*** out of me and made a 5-star into a one-star. read more

Nellies Place - 2010 extra large pie. YOU CANNOT GET THIS SIZE ANYMORE. HALF THE SIZE NOW IT'S CALLED A BAR PIE - Pizza Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

The pizza is excellent, I've had it plain, and I've had toppings. Also a fan of the buffalo wings, they're crispy, and the buffalo sauce isn't over powering. Good atmosphere, very clean, and my wait staff has always been on point, only one time did we have to wait a little long just for drinks, but I didn't mind. I'll def continue to eat at nellies. read more

Had the cheddar and Irish bacon burger. Very tasty. The fries are nice and crispy. Pizza is just OK...too thin for me.

The thin crust pizza at Nellie's is amazing. It's a great place to go with a few friends and order a few pies and a few pitchers of beer. They also have a considerable Italian/American menu, and I've never seen anyone disappointed in their food. Some of it might not blow you away, but it's always good. It tends to get really crowded on the weekends... sit in the section on the far side of the bar (shouldn't be an issue now that it's all non-smoking) if you want it to be a little quieter or if you are a small party. The main dining room is usually filled with families and larger parties. read more

For thin crust pizza and delicious apps this is the place to go in Northern NJ. I can't speak to other items on the menu as we only ever get an appetizer and the pizza. Fried calamari is good, wing are delicious. My husband craves them. I love their white pie with garlic. Other favorites are veggie, salami, plain but the truth is they have all been really yummy. I grew up in the area so have tried many pizza joints over the years and this one never fails. Soo good! read more

We are regulars here. Everyone we have brought has also liked the place Decor is old an worn an the tables can be crowded. Best thing about Nellies is the thin crust pizza and wings. Wings come in mild, medium, hot or Elkin (a spicy rub and taste almosted roasted). Top off with a pint from the bar and you got a good cheap meal. Sandwiches and burger are also good. Other entrees are typical. read more

Conveniently close, and on top of that, a tasty thin crust pizza! My personal favorite, half artichoke & half mushroom!! I've had pasta here a couple times... tasty but nothing crazy special, but it does come with the salad bar, where you can fill your plate with whatever you like. A chill place to have a drink in one hand, and pizza in the other. Not too overly crowded... (or maybe it's just because i go there after dinner rush?) The bar area in the front is just fine for me and my friends, but the back dining room is probably great for families with kids. Still on my list of things to do to try their Sunday brunch buffet. read more

Kinchley's was packed on a Monday night at 6 so we headed over to Nellie's for our pizza instead. 3 stars for two reasons- one, there were two hostesses when we walked in. One older, one younger. They continued talking to each other for a minute before looking our way to seat us. Even then, it was my husband who said two please. I heard the hostesses great other patrons with a "how are you tonight?" after we arrived. We did not receive that friendly greeting. The second reason for the 3 stars is the wait for a waiter to come over. We were sitting for ten minutes before our drink order was taken. It didn't bother me, but my husband was put off. After that though, our waiter was attentive and on point. As for the food, the bacon pie was delicious. Just the right crispiness (a word???!?) without being too crunchy. My husband loved the salad bar, but was not impressed with the cheesesteak sandwich. We will be back for the pizza! read more

Honestly the best thin crust pizza around! Recently renovated bar, reasonable prices. Just wish they delivered!

I think this is gonna be our new local pizza place. We've had takeout twice and both times we ordered thin crust, and gluten free pies. The thin crust is really good and crispy, just enough cheese and sauce. Plain pies are less than $10, how can you beat that? The gluten free is really good for gluten free but creeps up to the $15-20 range when you add toppings. We haven't had to wait more than 15 minutes for the order to be ready. Score!! read more

Nellies Place - Gluten free pizza with spinach and artichoke - Pizza Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

Seems like a typical American bar and restaurant. We just picked up some pizza for the kids but it seemed fairly packed / popular. The salad bar is a nice touch and the atmosphere seemed good. I'll definitely stop in again if we're on the area. As for the pizza, it was very thin crust (which I think they are known for). They didn't have by-the-slice or kids pizza's so we got a "bar pie". The regular size is only $1 more so I'd recommend going with the bigger one. read more

The service was good, the lady who was serving us was very nice too. I loved the pizza until I saw a bug in it. read more

Nellies Place - A fly in my pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

Used to go on a regular basis during high school. Haven't been in a while. Thin-crust pizza is very good! Fried raviolis are great and the cajun waffle fries at $2.50 are a steal! You can't hate Nellies pizza, and if you do, you are wrong. It's a 3.5 star place. Wish you could half star places on Yelp.... read more

Nellies has decent bar food- bar pies, apps, and sandwiches. Can't speak on behalf of any of their entree items or the salad bar, which I understand others may come back for (tbh seems small to me). Generally speaking, food has been consistent in our many visits here. The potato skins are great- though if you're like me, have to request that extra sour cream because they are a little stingy in that area. Have a lot of cheese and bacon though- so that makes up for it! Pizza overall is thin crust, pretty good. I am a fan of the white pie. Beer tap selection rotates pretty well. Prices are on the higher side for what I'd call bar food, and service in our many visits has left something to be desired, with exception to the bar- where bartenders seem to be attentive, interactive and courteous. read more

Heard this place was good, especially from the locals. What I received was totally the opposite. Bad pizza, bad service especially if you are a minority. I was at the waiting area to pick up a takeout order, first person there. The person working the front saw me and gave me a look of disdain. I stated that I was here to pick up my order. Totally ignored. She kept her head buried, pretending to be crossing out names on her seating list, which no one was behind me at the time. Three separate parties come in behind me later, and she had to talk around me to seat them. After 10 minutes, she finally relented and asked me why I was there, which was to pick up an order that was called in over 30 minutes ago. Without a word, she went back to the kitchen and got my order. I even said to have a good day, which I did not even get a response back. All the while, I got stares from some of the other patrons, as if I did not belong. I am a resident of the town, and never felt so ostracized anywhere else in the locale. Ordered a pizza, nothing special, and was even a bit mushy for a thin crust. People who actually know what good pizzas are, please do not go to Nellie's Place. According to 1/3 of the reviews currently on, they say bad service, and soggy thin crust. What defines a good thin crust is that it is crispy without being brittle. Many on these reviews say it was soggy. read more

I've grown up on Nellies. But I always feel like an inconvenience when I arrive. Staff are always checking their watches and hurrying you with attitude. The kitchen closes before the time they claim. The phone isn't picked up when you call. It's a bummer. read more

Outdoor seating was cozy but the perforated tables allowed spilled food and drinks on our feet. Service was fast and courteous. Turkey bacon Swiss burger was delicious but needed a much bigger bun. Steak fries were hot and crispy. Bathroom was clean. Plenty of parking. read more

I've always enjoyed coming to Nellie's in the past but the past couple of times have been very disappointing. It takes forever to get waitstaff to your table, the don't check to see if you are okay/need anything, and I was just informed (the first time since coming here for years) that they don't do free refills on soda?? Either that's a new rule or this is the first time anyone had told me. Plus, it's a bar-type establishment I can't believe they don't do free refills on soda. read more

Went in for an early dinner with my son. We always sit at high tops when we dine. We sat at a high top in the bar- which by the way, were all completely empty. I went to up to the bartender who Ignored me until I finally said "excuse me, can I have menus for us to eat". With an attitude he said that I need to go to the entrance around the corner and see a hostess to be seated. Even though we are already there and they are all empty? Yes! He said. As I was about to go do that he then barked at me that we can't sit there because my son isn't big enough. I did a double take and looked confused and he then said "it's an insurance policy". Like I've said I've dined out many times with my son even when he was smaller and have always sat at high tops- if it was too high for him to eat I wouldn't of sat there. In addition I was in the restaurant business for over 20 years and have never heard of such an "insurance policy". I decided to leave, not because of the policy but because of the attitude . It's not the first time I've seen this guy act this way towards guests in that restaurant. I love their pizza, but I'm not going to go there anymore. I go out to eat to enjoy myself, not to walk on egg shells because the bartender is miserable and only feels like taking care of certain guests not others. We then went to another neighborhood restaurant and sat at a high top in the bar- we were treated great and enjoyed our dinner. Guess their insurance doesn't have the same "policy"? read more

Nellies Elkins Wings are the best. Hands down, they prove that you dont need heat to make awesome wings. Pretzel bites? Fantastic!

Personal favorite. Have never had something I did not enjoy and I have tried almost everything. Great place for groups for families. If you want to avoid children you can eat in the bar area. Staff is funa nd friendly. Decor is a bit dated but it also has a bit of charm to it. read more

Good pizza, terrible service. The only thing they have over Kinchley's is that they take credit cards. The pizza was good, no complaints there. Good crust. Sauce was OK. Service was non-existent though, and the pizza wasn't good enough to overcome that. Next time I want thin crust, it's back over to Kinchley's! read more

Kinchley's has better thin crust pizza, maybe I caught them at the wrong time, but those giving this anymore than 3 stars, how do you compare it to kinchley's in ramsey? my crust was soggy. The decor was dated, and it seems "Depressing" in there. read more

Got food poisoning after eating the COLD food here. Was called the F slur, and after telling the bartender after I got groped they said "theres nothing we can do" Do yourself a favor, go anywhere else. read more

edit to something nellies doesn't take lightly; in regards to your very wrong response we were referring to a blue moon and a round of shots we did not order or receive i also mentioned that a table who was sitting there longer than we were weren't kicked out so your 90 minute policy is something you don't take seriously. you told us we were kicked out because we were wasted. we were not and if we were wasted you shouldnt have let us both leave in our own cars from your business stop lying. fuck nellie's!!!!!! i was waiting for the apology but clearly you're actually inept to realizing your dive bar is just trash lol read more

This is the best restaurant I have ever been to in my entire life. They have the best food in the country, the best service in new jersey and the best pizzas this side of new york city. As far as the pizza goes, I honestly can't compare it to anything i've ever eaten in my entire life. The best bar pie I've ever had has been at nellie's. The sauce, the dough, and the combination of herbs and spices combine to entice the taste bud. You cant just have one slice. I love nellie's with all my heart and will probably propose to many wives there. Thank you nellies for your awesome food. I love you. You da bestest. read more

This place seems like it has potential. I came with my family for dinner and waited about 20 minutes for a table. The wait didn't seem long though because the restaurant features live table updates straight to your phone while waiting. They also text you when your table is ready +1 star for that. Before ordering I went to check out the salad bar...it seemed mediocre and at the time we were there some of the contents didn't look turned over. One thing I hate about salad bars is when the grape tomatoes aren't sliced in half. Which is what Nellie's did not do. Our family ordered soup to start and they all seemed canned because of the high content. We also started with a bar pie. Although the crust seemed like it was pre made, the sauce on the pizza did not. The bar pie was the highlight of the Apps. My lil bro ordered a steak sandwich medium. He said it came out cold and they used sliced sandwich bread and not like a hero, so when it came out the bread was all soggy and unusable. My father had a burger and it was very good. I had a chicken panni. When it came out it looked perfect, however the chicken inside was cold while the rest of the panni was at a good temp. This happens all the time when I order a panni from any restaurant. I suspect the cold food was because of my server. Service here was bad. My server came to the table to take our order, drop our food off and filled my water once. He did not ask if everything was ok. And it took him a while to come back with the bill. As a former server in a restaurant I expect the same service I would give. I would of given this place 2.5 stars if I could but I rounded up because of the cool hostess system they have in place. read more

Went to this Waldwick Mainstay on a Friday night. What a mess. Doesn't take reservations for smaller parties. Place was overrun by people and kids. The greeter was AWOL for 15 minutes and no one was even able to take our name for a table. Pizza looked soggy and the place was dirty. Left without being seated. Avoid. read more

Great place for a drink! Solid Pizza and Salad Bar.

I have no idea how I didn't know about this place. A new favorite. I'm a pizza junkie. I travel long and far for a good pizza and this was certainly worth the trip. I put it up against what I consider the greats in the bar pie category such as star tavern in orange and reservoir in boonton. Great service, great beer menu, great salad and freaking amazing thin crust. Also worth mentioning, very busy nigh and the staff absolutely crushed it on a super busy night. read more

After 30 yrs as a customer of Nellie's this will be my First Bad Review After shopping and being hungry, 9pm, there was a choice between "The Fireplace" or Nellie's for Burgers Thus we choose Nellie's Let's start with service - service at McDonalds is better Then let's proceed with 1 order of soup Entree - 2 orders of Burgers ( 1 rare, 1 Med Rare ) Entrees came - soup never did ( omg I forgot, sorry) The med rare Burger was " well done" Buns were old and stale and tomato was not fresh We would have told the waitress, but she didn't come back! No worries - she took the med rare Burger off the bill Dessert time ! On the Board - Chocolate Mousse Cake And yes the waitress told us it was GF Many GF products are good, not an issue, however This dessert looked Old , Tasted Old , trying to find a "moist" area of the cake - was nowhere to be found ! It's a Tuesday night - minimal customers, thinking there should be no issues in the back of the house. The purpose of this post is for owner/management After all what would Bergen County be without Nellies The objective of Business ... To Stay in business by providing good quality food and service .... hmmmm not tonight ...1 star as a curtesy read more

Still the same good 'ol neighborhood joint..just wanted to add that the lasagna is delicious. Seriously. Yum. Oh yeah, one more thing. Sweet potato fries. "nuff said. read more

Went for dinner. It was very crowded. The hostess, while nice, didn't project her voice to call people when their tables were ready very well. It was clear they were down one wait staff member that evening, so I won't dock them for slow service. The salad bar was yummy, but they were missing a few items and didn't replace them. The pizza we ordered was good, but it was a bit doughy and cut inconsistently. The renovations look nice. I'm willing to try them again. It was good, but not the best. read more

Very nice bar area, good appetizers, great thin-crust pizza, friendly staff. Great place to meet a friend for drinks.

Service is interesting. I would assume our server was different nice and a little attitude. The pizza was similar to microwave pizza from the pizza isle in shoprite read more

I was in there after not being there in 3 years. I was with my daughter. The music was blasting at 8:30PM, there was a drunk group of guys , regulars, at the end of the bar and the owner/ bartender did nothing really. The pizza has changed so Kinchleys is now exclusive. I would have enjoyed a night club so much more. Last trip there after a lifetime of great memories. Leave it at that! It sucked Chris, We were there on Tuesday night at @ 8:45. There were numerous families in there. If you'd like to send me an email on Yelp I'd be more than happy to discuss with you. Like I said, been going there since I was a kid and enjoyed many memories . I really hate to see it end. But those guys that were in there needed to be thrown out. read more

Kind of a locals local hangout. Can decide whether bar or restaurant. But restaurant does cl I see first. Foods not bad. read more

I just went in there today for the first and I was treated so well by the bartender Terrance. Great service and hospitality. Thank you!