So let me tell you this is one of the best hidden gems in Spring Hill! Went and order 30mins before they closed and got a large italian sausage large pizza. My only complaint is the sausage add was a little sad. The pizza had so much flavor, especially that rich, garlicky taste that tasted real and fresh, not like fake powdered garlic. You can really tell the difference. The sausage was flavorful, the pizza came out hot and fresh, and everything worked together perfectly. Here's a little secret if you didn't already know. The owner is related to Joey, who used to own Joey's House of Pizza in Nashville, which makes a lot of sense because the pizza had that same delicious quality. I love Joey's house pizza and the owner is Joey's daughter! If you are around definitely a spot worth trying if you love a well-made pizza. They have subs, desserts, pasta you name it! The people was fast and super friendly when we picked up our pizza even though it was close to closing time. read more

See all

I knowww you're waiting for my review remember it's my own opinion and experience Let go for what you're coming to read are this place it's what people and they said We order two cheese slices and 2 double crust and too be honest that pizza taste like was made 2 days ago so old and bad I was really disappointed because my expectations was high coming from family from joes the house pizza they let me down Cheese was gummy and not tasting right that crust you don't want me to said really waiting my time and money Overall maybe for Spring Hill area this place is good I don't know why because they can getting a fresh pizza anywhere else that old slice over heating like leftover from home when you order from regular pizza place for next day meal I amost forgot that lasagna oppsss straight to the trash cans I don't want go full detail on that....... read more

See all

I love dive pizza joints, and Nelly's has been a favorite for years. The Napolitano (regular) pizza is decent but the Sicilian is really bad. Altogether, they're not holding up their end of the bargain. Thirty bucks for four slices is a bit steep. Thirty bucks for a thirty minute wait for two cold slices and two decent slices is an insult. Plus the place needs a cleaning and some TLC. Hey, if you're gonna charge outrageous prices your standards need to match. Next time I'm jonesing for a slice I'll hit the Food Lion and buy frozen. read more

I couldn't decide if the atmosphere or the pizza was the best. what an amazing little place. it's about an hour and a half drive for me, but it was definitely worth it. 100% recommend. read more

They aren't lying when they say this place has the best pizza in town. I always order pick up and the employees are always quick and friendly. This is the only place we'll ever get Pizza from in Spring Hill! read more

I finally was able to try and stop by Nellys. I like this place a lot even though I didn't get the full experience with trying the rest of the menu. I wanted to just try a slice of pizza and it didn't disappoint. I think as far as the Nashville area goes, nellys puts themselves as a top tier pizza joint. There isn't much competition out there for a classic any slice so Nellys by far takes the cake, they are top 3 in my opinion. read more

Nelly's Italian Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Spring Hill, Tennessee

We love this place. Hands down the best pizza in the area. And this time we tried a Stromboli. Fantastic! And if that isn't enough, Nelly and her staff are always welcoming and have great customer service. And the online ordering was easy and quick. I recommend putting this place in your regular rotation when dinning out or take out. read more

Nelly's Italian Cafe - Half cheese half pepperoni and mushroom. And a Stromboli. - Pizza Near Me - Spring Hill, Tennessee

Nice family-owned local spot. Good pizza. Good, friendly service and clean establishment.

would definitely suggest nellys if you're looking for the taste of an authentic mom & pop pizza joint in NJ/NY. Portions are huge- really great value and tasty food. We got the last booth right before the dinner rush around 6:30. Ordered at the counter and the food was brought out piping hot a few minutes later. My favorite was the supreme slice, they are very generous with the toppings. My boyfriend's favorite was the double crust slice. The deep dish square pizza was awesome dipped in the marinara cup. Garlic knots were enormous! It was so refreshing to see a small joint like this packed with happy people. We also got 2 cannolis to go. Love this place. Staff was super friendly too! read more

See all

Dirty outrageously expensive slop. I've had better frozen pizza at home. Nothing special. read more

Walked in and greeted right away. Asked if we had any questions. Runner was cleaning off tables. Place very clean. Bathrooms very clean and stocked, too. Got the "moma Pizza" slice, pepperoni stromboli, 1/2 garlic knots and fountain drink all for $27.43. Pizza had pepperoni, jalapeño, Hoy-honey sauce. Pizza slice was huge, hot, too heavy to pick up at first bite. We give the Pizza rating a 9.5. also got a pepperoni Stromboli, which I would give a 9.4 as well, and the garlic knots were the best I ever had which I would give a 9.9 out of 10. wish Nelly's wasn't so far from Nashville. Will definitely make the drive again. It was well worth it. Food read more

See all

Definitely one of the best pizza joints in all of Nashville and especially Williamson county Spring Hill Try the pepperoni and sausage It's to die for. read more

I went there today to get the chicken Parm. The food was not very hot and served on a Styrofoam plate. Not a very good experience. read more

Nelly's Italian Cafe - Chicken Parm - Pizza Near Me - Spring Hill, Tennessee

Have eaten there a couple of times. Got the double crusted meat lovers the first time. The second time got the Stromboli. Both times was ok but not exceptional like I've seen on TikTok reviews. The sauce is what makes it better. So definitely get extra marinara to dip. The baked ziti is good. Tried my sisters and liked it better than the pizza orders. Staff is super friendly. Hated getting my order on paper plates. Will probably go again because I'm still searching for the cheese pull and maybe it's going to be on a regular piece of cheese pizza. read more

I've ate pizza and a lot of places in Tennessee now. Coming from California pizza in Tennessee typically is not very good. But one stands out from the rest and should be noted. Nelly's Café in Spring Hill is by far the best there is. Just had a pepperoni with jalapeño and hot Mike's honey on it last night and it was terrific. All I can do is give it a tan all day long and I can't wait to have another Nelly's pizza. Anyone who hasn't tried it should take their time out go there really experienced it. It's worth a trip if you have to drive by for the best pizza going read more

Everything is great .. food delicious.. and portions are filling .. and great customer service !!!!!!

I didn't like what I ordered BUT totally on me garlic knots great bf got husband got lasagna and I had some it was GREAT . Will be going back to try more. read more

Nelly's Italian Cafe - Garlic Knots Half (3)Lasagna Buffalo chicken Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Spring Hill, Tennessee

Amazing!!! Amazing!! We have been going for years. They are such a great crew and the food is consistently great.

I came back really excited and the pizza was not great. I asked for it well done and it wasn't. Then they saw 35 minutes til it is ready and I think it was sitting for 10 minutes when I picked it up. I also got a salad and the salad was gross. It was stored some where near heat and the salad was wilty and warm. I threw it away. The cheese cake wasn't bad. I am disappointed read more

Oh. My. GOD! This place is the hand down best pizza place I have ever been to. The cannolis are just, just, mmm! The service is a little slow, but its fun to watch them make the food, and its all worth it when you get that sweet, sweet pizza. Ambience wise, wow, the mens bathroom has authentic TMNT posters. Nelly, the woman who owns the place, comes from a line of pizza makers. her dad and uncle ran pizza places, both good. I would recommend to come here the next time you are in Spring Hill. read more

I'm giving it 2 stars because the employees were really nice. But as far as the pizza, not so good. My husband ordered x-tra cheese and they apparently didn't add it because it wasn't on the receipt. But his cheese pizza looked like the cheese was almost non existent. We did buy two large because they don't make any smaller so we figured we'd take it home. My large I added 3 toppings but not only did I not taste or see any cheese but it hardly had any sauce on it. Also, they must have forgotten to add the onions because you can tell they were added later, they were not cooked. When I went up to get some sauce they charged me .99 cents for a small cup. Our total bill was $57 which is a lot considering it was crust and 3 toppings on my pizza and just crust with a sprinkle of cheese on my husbands. Plus, it's not a very clean looking place, and the women's bathroom was okay but the men's my husband said was filthy. read more

You come to Nelly's for the food. Eat in or take away, enjoy the food. You will want to come back for the food. Yes, Nelly's is all about the food... read more

The tiramisu was the best thing about the meal. I will be back for the dessert. Tight on space.

The food here is exceptional. This place gets packed quick, and it's easy to see why. From the Chicken Parmesan, to the Double crust ultimate meat pizza, to Calzones, or Cannoli. All of the food I've had here is very good. I would say the best in Tennessee. Well worth the 45 minute drive for me. I recommend this place to all of my friends and family. read more

The best option in Spring Hill no question about it! I've never been disappointed with the quality of the food and it's always a pleasure to patronize their establishment read more

Made the drive here from Franklin because we had heard great things about their New York style pizza. We were not disappointed. We ordered a half pepperoni half sausage pizza and an antipasto salad. They were very busy and we were lucky to find a table that could seat 5 people. Our food got prepared in less than 15 minutes and was delivered to our table even though you order at the counter. The pizza is pretty darn close to true NY style pizza. Thin crust, good balance between sauce and cheese, and great flavor. The large antipasto salad fed 4 of us and all ingredients were fresh. Highly recommend this place! read more

Nelly's Italian Cafe - What's left of 1/2 pepperoni, 1/2 sausage pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Spring Hill, Tennessee

See all

2nd time coming here and let me just say this place is great. Food is top notch...you can't bring a party of 6 here but 4 or less you can get a table. This place is more of a take out restaurant but trust me it's so worth it. Give it a try...NOW. read more

While I try to support local and independent businesses, I draw the line when they disrespect their customers. If they charge added fees without informing the customer, they have lost my business. We were charged to use a credit card and tax was added to that 3% surcharge. There was no posting, no signage, nothing said to us by the employee and when I called to speak with a manager was told they would return my call which they did not. We will not be returning to any business that takes advantage of its customers. read more

Quality made with authentic Italian taste. Fresh ingredients on the pizza and real stretchy cheese. They were not skimpy on the toppings. If I could ask for anything I would request thicker Italian sausage and fresh mushrooms. Mushrooms were thin like freeze dried. Other than that our pizza was great! I would definitely recommend this place. A little pricy compare to other places. read more

Maybe this is a better place to visit in person and not for delivery. They were out of tiramisu but they were kind enough to call and ask what other item I would like in place of it. Delivery was with in their estimate BUT the pizza was hard and ice cold. It didn't sit at my door long, I picked it up before the driver even left my street. I ordered the Bianca -Our White Pizza with an olive oil base, Fresh Garlic , Ricotta , Romano and a blend of Mozzarella and it wasn't cheesy at all, like they forgot the mozzarella. We tried to warm it up but it just became hard, almost stale. Also, the raspberry with your cheesecake is just a fake syrup. read more

Good food, but a dirty restaurant, for the prices being charged for the food maybe would be a good idea to put some back into the establishment, the sitting booths most all had duct tape on them and left a sticky residue on my wife's white pants. The trashcan receptacles and floor were beyond disgusting. Need more pride in cleaning, our table / booth were dirty upon arriving. Wish I would've thought of taking pictures, I will return to do just that. On Another note the Cannoli's were fantastic read more

Nelly's is family owned and operated. That much is obvious, as their sauces (gravy, if you will) are house made and delicious. Pasta, stromboli, etc. are wonderful. And the pizza is among the best that I've had in Tennessee. It is NY style, but great (this coming from a Chicago transplant). Service is always friendly and quick/efficient. As for ambiance, this is a very casual place. There are some booths for up to four people each, but not a lot and it is a bit of a tight space. Many eat in for lunches, but it seems a lot of their business is carryout or delivery. Highly recommend! read more

The pizza we got from here was delicious! A bit pricey but it was also ginormous. Loaded with sauce and toppings. Tasted great the next day as well. Would order takeout again. Cannot speak to ambiance or service at this time because we ordered takeout but would absolutely go for dinner one day to check it out in person. read more

Nelly's Italian Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Spring Hill, Tennessee

See all

This place is not fancy and I mean that in the best way. The people working there are always hustling so everyone gets hot, good food. The portions are GIANT. Their meatballs are ridiculously good, you might not need pasta. Did I mention the portion sizes? Also, don't sleep on their salads!! They use the green lettuce mix, not iceberg !! Love both their ranch and house dressings. As far as your sweet tooth, I've only had the cannolis but they also have cheesecake and tiramisu . read more

Incredible pizza. Best that I've had in Nash area. NY style pizza. And pizza by the slice

We were recommended this place by a few people to try as one of their favorite restaurants in Spring Hill. Since we had never been here before, we tried a variety of items. The garlic knots were delicious, the cannoli was good, and the antipasto salad was as expected. Unfortunately the pizza just didn't do much for us. We ordered our usual half pepperoni half ham, and it just wasn't anything to write home about. It was cooked well and the crust was perfectly shaped, but it just didn't have that "yum" factor where we wanted more slices. Maybe that's the style people like around here and I'm not knocking it for just that, but for us it was just an average pizza. read more

For a place that advertises the "best pizza in town" we were beyond disappointed. Crust was nowhere near NY style thin crust that they advertise, it was more like cardboard. Sauce was barely even there, and flavor was just not good. I hate posting bad reviews but this was just not good at all; such a let down with a big group all craving pizza!! read more

Went to Nelly's with a buddy for lunch while working in Spring Hill. The create your own calzone was the best I've had in Tennessee and the sausage was delicious!!! I was very pleasantly surprised. Most of the little Italian joints I've tried here in Tennessee have been meh, but this place rocks!!! Go check 'em out!!! read more

See all

Our favorite pizza in Spring Hill !! Everything about it is delicious! Crust sauce toppings

Good sauce, meatballs are good. A bit on higher price side. Pizza slices better than "mid", Sicilian slices good crust. 2 slices $12+ wasn't bad. read more