Incredible pizza. Best that I've had in Nash area. NY style pizza. And pizza by the slice

We were recommended this place by a few people to try as one of their favorite restaurants in Spring Hill. Since we had never been here before, we tried a variety of items. The garlic knots were delicious, the cannoli was good, and the antipasto salad was as expected. Unfortunately the pizza just didn't do much for us. We ordered our usual half pepperoni half ham, and it just wasn't anything to write home about. It was cooked well and the crust was perfectly shaped, but it just didn't have that "yum" factor where we wanted more slices. Maybe that's the style people like around here and I'm not knocking it for just that, but for us it was just an average pizza. read more

For a place that advertises the "best pizza in town" we were beyond disappointed. Crust was nowhere near NY style thin crust that they advertise, it was more like cardboard. Sauce was barely even there, and flavor was just not good. I hate posting bad reviews but this was just not good at all; such a let down with a big group all craving pizza!! read more

Our favorite pizza in Spring Hill !! Everything about it is delicious! Crust sauce toppings

Opinionated statement: if you have to say "the best pizza in town" ...you're not the best pizza in town I came here because its literally right next to where I work. So the quality of convenience is great. What I ordered: the chicken parm Stromboli looked delicious so naturally I ordered it. The outcome: the cheese to meat ratio was 90/ 20. Not enough chicken, yet drowning and overflowing in mozzarella. So some may be thinking. Yum! What's the problem? For me I like to be chewing on more than a balloon of melted cheese. I may give this place 1 more shot and get their pizza by the slice...which is any of them. Oh yes...their salad...get the strawberry field salad..strawberries, spinach, candy walnuts, vinegarette, and blue cheese crumbles. Now this was actually good. Ps: rewards program...sign up..receive $10 off for every 10 pizzas ordered read more

This is my new favorite Italian place. Everything is delicious. We tried the lasagna and eggplant parm and split a slice of the stuffed pizza. It was almost as stuffed as I was. lol Also brought home a Stromboli for tomorrow. The thing is huge. In fact they cut it in half and the halves are huge and packed with meats and cheese. They serve a side of extra sauce with everything. The staff is very friendly and helpful. I also noticed a sign inviting you to sit at a table while waiting on your order so they might actually read these reviews. Super nice little place, I was impressed. read more

Good sauce, meatballs are good. A bit on higher price side. Pizza slices better than "mid", Sicilian slices good crust. 2 slices $12+ wasn't bad. read more

Food was tasty, and fresh Service was attentive [[HIGHLIGHT]]Ambiance - need to work on acoustics/very loud[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Everything we ate was delicious. The calzones had plenty of fillings. I was a bit confused when I entered because I couldn't tell how to order or where to stand while waiting. We figured it out but a sign or someone to tell me would've been great read more

See all

Best pizza in Spring Hill!!! The double crust supreme is our favorite. The staff are so friendly and helpful.

Have had the cannolis before and were amazing! [[HIGHLIGHT]]We brought them home so I can't say much about the store but it WAS well kept![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Found Nelly's on Yelp and so glad we did! They were packed when we got there but luckily a booth opened up while we paid for our order. Hubby ordered the lasagna and per recommendation of the girl that took our order I got the baked ziti. Since it was our first time, we also got a half order of garlic knots and split a supreme Stromboli to try out. First off their portion sizes are huge! Their portions are so big that it's as if you ordered 2 servings. All the food is made from scratch and they're so busy that even though they have the food displayed in the food bar it's always fresh. I enjoyed the garlic knots but they do use a lot of fresh garlic so if that's not your thing then you may want to stick with the yummy garlic bread that comes with the pasta. Hubby said he'd definitely order the lasagna again and the Stromboli was also good. I would also order the ziti again but will want to try other items as well. Along with our many leftovers, for dessert we took home a tiramisu and a traditional cannoli. The cannoli tasted exactly the way it should and the tiramisu is easily one of the best if not the best tiramisu we've ever eaten and we have a eaten a lot. It didn't cross my mind to take pictures but we will definitely add some the next time around. read more

I LOVE NELLYS!! The food is delicious, reasonably priced and fast! The chocolate covered cannolis have become a category in my food pyramid! Chicken Parm and pizza are both delicious. I go here all the time for takeout and you just really can't beat it. read more

Their food and service is awesome. Some of the best pizza and clazones I have ever had.

We love Nelly's! Great spot to grab a slice, or sit and have a casual dinner. Our favorite is picking up a few slices to go on the way home.

Nelly's is our go to for great pizza! Danielle and Ryan put a lot of time and effort into their work and it shows. The pizza is by far the best in town and as close to what I could see as being authentic NY style pizza. The double crust is enough for an army. 10 for 10 would recommend! read more

Sad they aren't open on mondays but food is always good and kids are always super nice there. No complaints!! Super yummy

Do these people understand Italian. I placed an order on the phone. I said sausage and peppers sub, I asked and said specifically, hoagie, submarine. ya know like at Jersey Mike's, subway etc. Yes was her response. I asked are they spicy sausage or sweet. She had to ask, she came back and said they are not hot or spicy. I get a spicy sausage, in a pita like bread. They have the gaul to call themselves Italian. Discraceful. Frankie's Grill and or Salvos they get Italian. 12 dollars for garbage! read more

Nelly's Italian Cafe - You call yourself Italian?! - Pizza Near Me - Spring Hill, Tennessee

Weary & hungry locals AND travelers please come here! Our family of 7 was sure blessed tonight! From the exceptionally kind staff THANK YOU JESSICA & y'all! INCREDIBLE garlic knots with REAL garlic! The double stuffed meat pizza was so worth it! Whoa did I mention we were starving so we may have also ordered totally unnecessary spaghetti while we waited for the pizza to cook(it was AL DENTE!!!) folks I don't even order spaghetti ever anywhere b/c I have an Italian husband #1 AND I make my own Italian food; noodles & all from scratch so it's usually not worth it. But these were exceptional! We may have also got a cannoli....say yes to the cannoli even if you save it for later or 30mins down the road read more

See all

Yo went for pizza hands down the best like back in Brooklyn .yo don't miss this place .kid from Brooklyn and I approve this message.the pie is the best .PRIMO read more

The best eggplant parm in Tennessee and their spaghetti is always cooked to perfection. The owner is sooooo nice and the team is pleasant and helpful and efficient. The restaurant is always clean and the food is always good. Their cannolis are AMAZING. My husband loves their lasagna and our friends love the meat lovers calzone. It's so good. And you can even order on your phone pay and pick up. Super convenient during covid. We love this place. It's our weekly Italian stop read more

Great NY style pizza. I love supporting local businesses. The employees are young and friendly and seem to really care about their jobs. I ordered online and everything was ready when I arrived. Absolutely one of the top 3 pizza places I've been to in the local area. read more

I always pass by this place and was meaning to try it some time, and I did! This is a typical example of "never judge a book by its cover"- their sign looks old, and sorry I did not have high expectations. But thanks to some helpful yelp reviews and pictures, I decided to try them and I was pleasantly surprised ! Inside is like deli, they have pasta and Strombolian made, salads and desserts and you tell them what you like. I had a lasagna , which I thought was a generous portion, served with a piece of bread. It was so tasty and had a lot of cheese inside. I'm leaving 4 stars because although it was yummy, it wasn't hot. It was just warm, which can cool quickly under AC. I got very full so that was all I had, but next time I want to try their desserts. read more

Nelly's Italian Cafe - Lasagna served with plenty of sauce and bread :) - Pizza Near Me - Spring Hill, Tennessee

Their pizza is top notch in the Spring Hill/Columbia area. In my opinion, the best around. Also their calzones and strombolis are insanely good. read more

Only came here once so far but as being a New Yorker it's been very difficult to find good food (especially Italian) in Tennessee so this place gets a 5 star rating. We ordered a regular cheese slice, 2 Sicilians and a couple of strawberry field salads. Very good all around. Keep up the great work. Friendly staff as well. read more

Good pizza by the slice. Good Italian Sandwich. Good service. Good prices. Simple place.

I love Nelly's and will absolutely go back. My experience today was not good. I ordered 2 slices of pizza to go. 1 pepperoni and one veggie. As they were making my oder, the guy came to me n said they are out of black olives, but had green olives. I said thank you for that heads up, but no green olives. Can you throw a couple jalapeños on there instead. Sure he said. When my order (no it was not busy, no line and the lunch crowd had left), I had 1 slice of veggie pizza and one slice of cheese pizza. No pepperoni... he saw his mistakes just before handing the box, so he puts the veggie slice on the top of the oven, heats up a pepperoni pizza, barely, and eventually I walk out with my order. When I get home, the pepperoni slice is stone cold and there is a handful of green olives on the veggie slice... Train your new people! read more

Working in Spring Hill i Always seen this place but never stopped. Today I stopped for a calzone and I do have to say it was pretty good. Not to mention I like the deli style for a quick lunch. Now that I know it's here, it won't be my last visit. The service was good and friendly as well. Oh and priced right to for lunch. read more

Nelly's Italian Cafe - Trying something new - Pizza Near Me - Spring Hill, Tennessee

No idea why this place had such great review. Staff is friendly. Pizza is ok, lots of toppings but the taste is really nothing special. We also ordered spaghetti with meatball. It tasted good, but the meatball was frozen in the middle. We sent it back. They heat it up but it was still not hot in the middle. At least their sauce is pipping hot. Now, here comes the garlic bread that came with the pasta. They tasted absolutely awful.....days old bread!! So, all in all, we will not go back and don't really have anything good to recommend unfortunately. read more

Hands down best pizza in the area- this was a mushroom, meatball, and Italian sausage.... Super pizza. Let's not forget the chicken Parm stuffed sandwich- forgettaboutit! My new favorite go to Italian! Lasagna- yes please.... Baddabing read more

Nelly's Italian Cafe - Hands down best pizza in the area- this was a mushroom, meatball, and Italian sausage.... - Pizza Near Me - Spring Hill, Tennessee

Yummy! Really good classic Italian food and great prices! Try a few things for a real Italian feast!

It's really good pizza and their very nice to their customers. and they have a classic pizza vibe.

The BEST chicken parm I've had besides my own. LOL I definitely recommend this place.

I am originally from NYC and have been searching for GOOD italian food for years. This place was recommended to my husband and me by a gentleman that we accidently bumped into at a local grocery store (a native New Yorker from Brooklyn). Nelly's hand-tossed pizza is awesome, and the staff/service friendly and delightful!! Totally worth the 35 minute drive just to get a slice. We will definitely be back! read more

Nelly's Italian Cafe - a pizza and catering sign - Pizza Near Me - Spring Hill, Tennessee

Absolutely delicious Italian food. Quality service - such a welcoming and warm space. Thank you for a FABULOUS MEAL read more

There food is amazing and service is fast! Best red sauce ever! Locally and family owned. Check them out! You won't be disappointed.

Our first visit and it was fantastic! I have worked with some of the best authentic Italian restaurant owners and chefs so I am a bit of an Italian food snob. This place has the authentic gravy and their pizza dough is delicious! You can small the quality of the food when you walk in the door. Reasonable prices and great customer service. Give them a try! We will be back for sure! read more

Best little independent business in Spring Hill (and beyond) - yes, I wrote that exactly as I meant it - this place is not just a great example of how a food service/hospitality establishment should operate; other businesses could take notes from these folks! They exude passion for what they do, (so much so that one of the owners/operators has a tattoo of the oven brand that they use on his arm!) - they are engaging and courteous and their product is consistently outstanding! I am a RAVING FAN of Nelly's and my family and I will continue to patronize this business as long as we live here! Thank you for being one of things I always include when asked "what sounds good...?" read more

Best pizza in town, keep it simple, x-large pepperoni w/ extra cheese. It cant be beaten!

Local mom and pop pizza joint. Friendly folks. Very tasty pizza. You can watch you food being prepared if you choose. Small dining area because most biz here is takeout. read more