I was pleasantly surprised! This place was good. The food came out timely. The women who brought it out was so nice. The bruschetta was amazing. The topping was fresh and flavorful and the bread was soft and crispy all at the same time. The greek salad was huge. The pizza was delicious and did truly remind me of NY style pizza, maybe just a little jucier though which I am fine with. Would definitely go back if I am in the area again. Only thing, the guy who took our order was acting strange. When we ordered he was abrupt and short. Had us repeat ourselves often. When we went back up 5 minutes later asking for water glasses he asked us if it was for togo...we were literally sitting in our booth 10 feet away. He just gave an overall nonfriendly vibe. Really weird because we saw he was friendly with others. It had to have been something with us, but no idea why. read more

New York Pizza and Pints - bruschetta - Pizza Near Me - Allen, Texas

See all

Great pies! Been coming here for 5 plus years. Always great pizza and service. I would add it to your. In a odd place read more

New York Pizza and Pints - By the Slice is huge - Pizza Near Me - Allen, Texas

Fantastic crust with an amazing crunch you can only get in the east coast typically. That alone carried the pie hard! The sauce was kinda lame and cheese just forgetful, so maybe extra sauce would have been the move. Looks like they had lots of TV and beer options on tap. Service was chill. I might consider coming back if I am shopping around in the mall! read more

See all

Terrible experience all round, I would not recommend. I have been going here off and on for almost ten years and never had an experience like this. I arrived at 11, just as they opened for the day. After quickly reviewing the menu for what I want, I order 2 slices of pepperoni pizza for $6 each according to the menu. When I go to pay the bill with my card, it seems rather high for 2 slices and a soda at $20. I pay and get the receipt noticing the 2 slices came to $15.52, $7.76 per slice (weird price btw). When I enquire, I was told that the video menu board is wrong and the correct price is in the computer. Further, someone is coming soon to update the board. I'm in no mood to argue other than to say that it's a bit slimey, getting nothing in return other than a curt head nod as he walks away. To make matters worse, I then notice a special for $8.99 on a side chalk board (who knows if this price is correct or not) for a slice, salad and soda. Had I known that, I would have opted for that. You'd think that is enough, but it gets much worse, cuz the food wasn't good and the food is everything, right? After a few mins, the 2 slices come out. Clearly this was from last nite. You can see in the pic that he did a lame job of trying to cover up the old, refrigerated cheese with a bit of new cheese. And he had only warmed it enough to melt the cheese and not warm it thru. The slice was luke warm at best with a soggy crust. Not a pleasant eat at all. I finished that slice and brought the other slice home hoping I can salvage my over-priced slice in my own oven. I don't think it's an unreasonable expectation to get freshly cooked pizza when they have just opened for the day. Needless to say, I will no longer eat at this place. Terrible customer service, prices AND food. No redeeming quality worth my money. read more

New York Pizza and Pints - Pepperoni Slice x2 - Pizza Near Me - Allen, Texas

As a NJ native (with proximity to NYC), I know good pizza, and for that, I'd give New York Pizza & Pints a solid 3.5. The pizza was better than a few other places I've visited while living in TX, so that was a plus. I also like how you can buy a slice of pizza without splurging on a whole pie if that's not what you want. (Moving to TX from the North and being unable to buy a single slice of pizza has presented its challenges #firstworldproblems). While I'm still on the hunt, this place did the job for a quick slice. read more

New York Pizza and Pints - Pizza Near Me - Allen, Texas

See all

I'm a southern girl who loves NYC. So this pizza is a nice close copy of the classics fold over cheese slice. Nothing else though. It's self service but order at register style. Sports on every channel which is nice during football season. Just a chill vibe overall. Good slice of NYC style pizza. Nothing else though bad will go back when I'm craving NYC. read more

Great pizza! Great beer also! We go there about once a week. They recognize us when we walk through the door.

This place was really good! We grabbed garlic knots, a 14" cheese and a pepperoni jumbo slice. The knots were dense dough in a good way with a large helping of heated marinara. It was really good but could've benefited from some more garlic. The pizza had delicious puffy and chewy dough but well cooked. The service was great with attentive and helpful staff. Definitely a good option when shopping in the area. read more

New York Pizza and Pints - Cheese Build Your Own Pizza Base 14 - Pizza Near Me - Allen, Texas

So I've been a regular customer for a while at this place whenever I just have a few bucks for a slice of pizza, and I don't know if he's the owner or what, but he was super nice to me and helped me out this one time. I always recommend this place when people ask me for "what's good to eat around here?" Thank you so so much for your kindness! There are good people in the world. read more

This place used to be our go-to for NY Style. It's a shame the only size options are 14 and 24. 14 is just too small for my fatass. In any case, the 24inch used to be great, but the last few times we ordered it (both from this location and the one off El Dorado), the crust has been so incredibly thin, I wouldn't have argued that they just took their 14inch dough and REALLY spread it out thin. read more

Solid three,3 Starzz! I am a pizza snob. I don't eat junk. My favorite pizza in Dallas is 30 minutes from my home without traffic. So, it's a stretch to get there but I enjoy it 2 times per year. Now there are the usual suspects around and some are good. None are great close to my home. In addition, the better ones are overpriced although nice. But, sometimes I just want a good slice of pepperoni and sausage without getting a second mortgage or driving an hour. I've had New York Pizza and pints on the radar for a couple of years. Reading through the reviews Ive seen some throw out the exuberant 5 stars that proclaim" it's the best pizza I've had in my life".! Give me a break. Just eat the meal and give an objective assessment thereby helping other Yelp users. Simple. Well, I've had a deep pizza hunger lately and was out this afternoon in the 100-degree heat. Heading back home it hit me! NY Pizza and pints. Yes, cold beer and pizza in air-conditioned comfort. So I made my way to the little shop tucked in the strip center in a hard-to-find location. Entering it looked like it could be in NYC. Ok, good sign consistent with the name. After ordering at the counter I took my beer and found a nice comfortable booth to wait for my pizza. The place has great service and they bring your food to the table which is just what I needed. Usually, I'm not a paper plate fan but in this case, it worked. My wedge salad was brought out on a tray with the various ingredients in plastic cups. Actually this read more

See all

The pies here are delicious. Get'em, fold'em, and eat'em! #boom Flavor explodes in your mouth and you're transported back to NY. The service is exemplary, whether you call for carryout or go into eat. The overall ambiance is a good ole pizza pub! Our family enjoys this restaurant and continues eat here regularly! If you haven't been here, try the pepperoni read more

New York Pizza and Pints - A huge Pepperoni Slice - Pizza Near Me - Allen, Texas

See all

Sat down with 3 other friends to try and enjoy a pizza and caprese salad. We were served under cooked pizza, the undercarriage was a lighter color than msbraids bread, and gave less support than a wet sock, severely lacking in cheese for a 30+$ pizza. The caprese salad was put together by clearly rotten food. The cheese was fine, but the cucumbers that had to be subbed in for medical concerns somehow left burns on my mouth, and had a unbearable bitterness that puts thermal receipt paper to shame. When bringing this issue up with the staff, they refused to issue any kind of refund or remake any of the food for us. After dealing with everything it seems we spoke directly with the owner/manager but were lied to about any kind of refund and told us to come back tomorrow to do something about it, they however offered to throw out our food we spent over 60$ on: Piezilla - 34$ 2 side salads - 6$ each (12$) Caprese salad - 12$ 4 drinks? (Charged for water) - ~10$ Total for our table : around 66$ before tax and regrettable tip. DO NOT EAT HERE. I will never be here or the sister location ever again. This place is a joke. No wonder there's so many horrendous reviews of people not getting refund or their food outright. read more

Very underrated spot! My family loves going to this place. The staff is super friendly and our orders always come out quick and fresh. Definitely try the garden pizza and the regular cheese pizza, the bread is perfect and everything melts in your mouth! read more

Born and Raise in New York.. I was impressed with the 24" pie. This is a luxury to have a place that understands what a true regular slice is!! And the garlic knots (we say 'gawlick') were spot on. Large and dripping with seasoned oil. The dipping sauce was perfect. Then to top off the meal, as if the pizza wasn't astonishing enough, the NY cheesecake and cannoli.. I thought I was back in the Bronx. Outstanding. I'll be back soon. read more

See all

One of the best slices of pizza I've ever had! Loved that everyone in my family was able to get exactly what they wanted. Food was delivered to our table quickly, place has a relaxed, intimate vibe. 100/10 read more

This is actually our second time having this pizza and totally forgot about it being a gem. We ordered a 24" pepperoni pizza and that baby was HUUUUGE. Each slice was def bigger than your head. It's super thin crust, which is a personal fave. Would have given it 5 starts if the crust was just a little more crisp, but we could have easily ordered it well done and totally forgot. The cheese bread was good and the marinara sauce that accompanied it was very tasty. Only one person was working, so as business picked up and he was making pies, those in line would have to wait a few mins, but nothing crazy. Overall, this place is worth a try if you're in the area and like thin crust! read more

New York Pizza and Pints - Pizza as big as your head! - Pizza Near Me - Allen, Texas

Ordered a lunch special, salad, cheese pizza, and drink. Salad was good, but pizza was really salty. Not sure if I was just unlucky. Since I was home I didn't go back. The place was fairly busy, so I think I just got a bad slice. read more

This was our first time trying this place, and unfortunately, it'll be our last -- all because of one employee's attitude. We walked in and ordered, and everything was fine until my friend took a cup for water. The male cashier immediately told her, "That's not permitted, you need to ask." Which is fair -- and we had no issue paying the 25 cents. But the way he said it came off as patronizing and accusatory, like we were trying to steal something. It was unnecessarily harsh and set a weird tone for the rest of the visit. After we finished our food (which was genuinely great), we asked for a to-go box. My friend even joked, "I'm scared to ask for a to-go box," because of how tense the vibe already was. And that's when things went downhill. The cashier overheard and started lecturing us about how we should have requested and paid for the box when we ordered. He escalated the situation quickly -- arguing with us, cutting off another staff member we were calmly speaking to, and even ignoring the customer he was helping to keep the argument going. He insisted we were just upset over paying 50 cents -- which was never the issue. It was his confrontational attitude and the way he talked to us like we were a problem. He even said, "If you don't like the service, just don't come back," and when we asked for a complaint book, he said they didn't have one. One of the other employees (a woman) was understanding, and tried to defuse things. But even the girl putting the pizza in the oven looked over it and eventually told us to just leave. This happened around 5:25 PM, in case management wants to look into it. If you care about keeping customers, this is the kind of behavior that drives people away -- and it's a shame, because the food really was good. But good food isn't enough when the service is this hostile. We won't be returning, and we'll be warning others to think twice too -- especially if that cashier is handling your order. read more

The guy that was cooking/serving at the time, didn't greet me when I walked in (literally walked right in front of me) and was obnoxiously rude and impatient with a customer. She was picking up the order for someone and wanted to double check that everything had been included. My cheese slice was just one big glob of cheese. I'll stick to the Wylie location... read more

Came here with a friend and was delighted to see that this place not only has character, but actually makes a pretty doggon good pizza. My friend frequents this place often, so he took the reigns on ordering. He ordered a couple pizza and I was not sure it was going to be enough. So ummmm yeah... The pizza comes out and its so big it can't fit on the table, I mean like Jolly Green Giant big!! The slices were delicious and intimidating at the same time, they were HUGE. Each bite of my slice was better than the last. I can't wait to host a party and bring in these bad boys!!! So I should mention we had appetizers prior to our pizza coming, we ordered Hummus Dip, Bruschetta and Buffalo wings. This was my idea since I had no idea how large the pizzas would be. My buddy was springing for the pizza, so I wanted to pitch in and order something to share as well. MISTAKE!! I would argue for some, one slice of the pizza is a meal, it was for my kids, especially after having a few appetizers. I tried to eat my weight in gold, but even my valiant effort was matched as the pizzas were as big as the table. Back to the food, I gotta say, the HUMMUS WAS BANGIN!! I love a good hummus and it was made VERY WELL. The food here is really good and the location is deceiving since once you're inside, you forget you're in a strip mall location. I loved it. When they finally brought the pizza boxes out to bring home the remaining pizza, the boxes were like mini-houses. This place is great to grab a nice big meal while dining in Allen and shopping at the outlets, but also great to grab a couple pizzas to go and feed big eaters. I'll return for sure. read more

This place checks all the important boxes for what I want at a pizza place. I don't have to have fancy decor, but this place feels homey. You walk to the counter and place your order - pro tip, go at lunch and get the lunch special if you are a pepperoni or cheese pizza person - pizza, salad and drink for less than $10. Husband orders this - salad is very simple and delicious. The pizza slice is giant, super thin and super crisp, very flavorful. I ordered a "Slicezilla" where you can choose three toppings - this time I had bacon, onion and tomato. Everything was delicious. It also comes with a pickle - I'm a fan of it!! For beer drinkers there are plenty choices, for kids and others, there are wonderful soda flavors. Important - iced tea was fresh as well. This is my favorite for the super thin crisp crust pizza. We have friends who take out whole pizzas and have never had issues - always spot on. The guy who took or order and cooked our food was very kind as well. It's a winner, y'all. read more

New York Pizza and Pints - Bacon, tomato and onion pizza - Pizza Near Me - Allen, Texas

See all

New York Pizza & Pints is a gem. The pizza is fantastic, and what you would imagine a New York pizza to taste like. (Not from there, but I've been there many times). The service is friendly, unlike NY. The local beers are a nice touch. FYI - they fill growlers, but they are expensive. read more

We've only ordered to go from this location, but love the quality of the dough and size of their slices. Cheese bread is also delicious. Online ordering is quick and easy. Pizza and sauces are well packed and delivered hot. We'll definitely order again. read more

I ordered via food delivery. Food came quickly, but I must admit, I feel a bit gypped. I order two pizzas, but I was not expecting them to be so small. They were delicious, don't get me wrong, but the size of a personal pan. read more

New York Pizza and Pints - Build Your Own Pizza with chicken, roasted red pepper, white sauce, spicy chicken sausage, chorizo, ricotta and pesto drizzle.. delicious - Pizza Near Me - Allen, Texas

See all

Very good spot. Huge slices. Good service. Clean location. Nice array of speciality sodas.

Owner seems real nice. Claims he is from NY and has a good pie. I beg to differ. "Pedro" cooks the pies. Pedro burned mine. The owner looked in the box, kind of looked like "oh no Pedro you burned this guys pie" Owner shuts the box and hands me the box. Get it home and it is burned up. Pull that stunt in NYC.. LOL Owner says "nice racist name" LOL. He was a Mexican. Was it Jose? Either way, I have never been back. Too many places that are much better. read more

horrible attitude guy was more concerned about parking then ordering my pizza 2 go lol what a disappointment did not get to try the pizza but next door Italian express made my day and earned my busines read more

This place was EVERYTHING I needed it to be!!! I'm from Indianapolis and we have limited authentic New York style pizza eateries so I jumped at this opportunity. I haven't had pizza this good since I was in New York! It was very simple, the crust/dough perfect, the saltiness and the different topping options. We got the giant pizza and it was perfect for 4 adults with leftovers to spare. Love love loved this place! read more

New York Pizza and Pints - Pizza Near Me - Allen, Texas

One of my pet peeves is restaurants that don't understand what opening on time means. This morning, we arrived 10 minutes before opening and waited in our car. 11:00 rolls around, and they just started putting chairs out. I stand at the door, waiting for them to unlock it. The employee eventually unlocks the door and tells me they aren't ready to open yet. I said we can wait inside since it's raining; he seems annoyed by this after waiting a few minutes inside us and another customer decide to take our business elsewhere. read more

My sister and I stumbled across this pizza parlor on our way out from the Allen Outlet Mall! So glad that we did because the pizza was superb! Upon walking in, we noticed that the place wasn't too busy-- given that it was a Saturday afternoon. The place was nice and clean and service was great. Being that it was our first time there, the cashier did a great job giving recommendations and just being patient with us. If you're anything like me, then you "eat with your eyes." We decided to get their special, 2 slices of pizza + salad + drink, for under $12. That was definitely a deal! One thing I will say is that the slices are HUGE! I honestly only ate one of the two slices that I purchased and took the other home. The pizza was hot and fresh while the lettuce in the salad was crisp and cold! I recommend stopping in and having a slice! You won't regret it! read more

New York Pizza and Pints - 5 5 Meat Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Allen, Texas

See all

I gave a 1 star for their pizza last week and then I got messaged by the owner for my review. My review was an honest review from everyone in my house. The two pies we received were indeed horrible and looked and tasted like frozen nursing home pizza. (Wylie location) read more

New York Pizza and Pints - Owners attitude - Pizza Near Me - Allen, Texas

My dad and I have been coming to New York pizza for the last several years and will be coming back again and again as long as we live. Not only is the pizza amazing, but the head chef Juan and his wife Carla are even more amazing. They are the friendliest and funniest bunch who always make us feel at home. The pizza and salads are gigantic and delicious and we would give them a million stars if we could. Best pizza ever!!!! read more

New York Pizza and Pints - Supreme pizza and ceasar salad - Pizza Near Me - Allen, Texas

DISCRIMINATED~I arrived here about 7:30 ish. There were 2 guys working, both Hispanic. As I was reviewing the menu, there was a lady who walked in. I let her go in front of me. He assisted her with no effort. After she was done, I walked up to begin my order & he told me to wait until he finish adding up the I guess daily tickets. He wasn't even polite about it....Let me point out, the lady he raced to assist was also Hispanic. Some may disregard this, but I felt totally discriminated against!!!! This prompted me to leave & I appreciate that because their lack of Customer Service drove me straight to Brothers Pizza in McKinney. Treat ALL your Customers with the same level of RESPECT! I will NOT patronize a business that makes me feel unwelcome! NEVER GOING BACK!!! read more

Seriously good pizza! Not sure how authentic it is but I know it's delish! HUGE slice of pie!!! And a shout out to Juan, thank you for your hospitality read more

This place must be under new ownership. Service is extremely slow. Cashier and cook barely speak any English. I had to repeat my order 6x. Cashier rang up one pizza for $53. I had to tell her that was the incorrect amount. The pizza took forever to be cooked. The pizza was a soggy crust...not crisp. The pizza here used to be terrific. I'm not sure what happened? ...maybe a new owner? read more

Great hole in the wall place. Great for a group as they have a massive pizza you can order. Food was super hot and fast. Only downside is if you eat there in the evening the sun is blasting you, but worth it for the great pizza. We go here everytime my mom is in town! read more

Not my favorite but I would go back. The pieces are huge, I could barely finish 1 piece. For lunch they have a 2 piece and a drink special so that's cool but not sure who can eat that many. read more

If I could leave negative I would Went shopping with my entire family -10 of us !!! Planned on meeting other family members here for lunch -would have been a party of 20 . But since we had to pay $350 to get our car back from y'all towing it we will NEVER EAT HERE read more

There is just something odd with my giant pizza. Feel like the doe is precooked then they add the toppings to order and reheat. Or they just lack on the sauce and cheese. Size is great but the toppings is off. read more