We have been looking to try a different pizza shop for a while. We came across this one on Yelp. It stated NY style pizza so we gave it a try. The service was good very polite and decently quick. This place was smaller than expected. There were a few tables there to dine in, but it looked like mostly take out. Back to the pie, we got a Mushroom and Green pepper and it was delicious enough topping and not too much cheese and thin. Being from the east coast it's hard finding a decent pie here. I believe we found our go to pizza shop for now. We will definitely be back. read more

New York Pizza - Mushroom and Green Peppers - Pizza Near Me - Tustin, California

Great price for a great slice. At $3.50 a slice you definitely get your money's worth as the cut is large. The crust is thin and crispy, the cheese is flavorful and it has just the right amount of sauce. My one regret is I didn't buy two slices! I placed my order and received it within 3 minutes. Overall the customer service was good as the counter person was very polite and answered all of my questions. When they say New York pizza, this is very close to what you would get at a good pie shop in one of the boroughs or Manhattan. The only thing it was missing out on is a little bit more of a oregano and garlic punch. read more

This review has been a long time coming. I've tried almost every pizza spot in Tustin, and I can confidently say this is the best pizza in the city. The pizza is magnificently flavorful, has a perfect sauce to cheese ratio, the slices are huge, and it is reasonably priced. As you can see, I couldn't even wait to dig in before I remembered to take a picture so I could finally write this review. I've tried many different flavors and toppings and they all hit the spot. This place is amazing! read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tustin, California

Best Beef Pepperoni Pizza . Thin , juicy n full of flavors . The staff is very friendly n sweet . Highly recommend this place . read more

Great for a Scooby snack!!!! I'll make this short. I was getting boba next door and I couldn't deny the smell of pizza wafted in the air. I was starving and I haven't had just a slice one ages. I always order full size pizza with my sister elsewhere. Walked in and the gentleman at the counter was nice ans chill. Ordered a pepperoni slice and went back to the boba shop to get my drink and await my pizza. My slice was hot and ready and I tore into that mofo in the car and scarfed the rest at the gas station a few miles away. The slice was HUGE! Thin, with some crisp. Solid quick eat! I can't speak in their whole pies but I was left satisfied and will be back for a slice! read more

Walked into New York Pizza in Tustin and immediately time-traveled to 1998. You sit, you fold, you question your life choices, and then you keep eating because it actually hits... read more

See all

Just discovered this fabulous pizza place serving thin crust pizza by the pie OR by the slice! It's a father/son duo offering delicious pizza, variety of toppings, fast/friendly service and reasonable prices. I went in for the first time on Wed... went back Thurs, Fri, and Sun! So good! They have a great lunch special. Try it. You won't be sorry. (Mostly catering to take-out orders, but they do have 3 tables inside with sports playing on the TV. I ate there so my pizza was nice and hot.) read more

See all

One of my favorite pizza spots close to my mom's house. I have personally never been inside the location yet but their delivery service is top tier. They Have amazing customer over the phone and they are more than happy to provide you any paper plates and plastic cups.My pizza is always fresh and hot when delivered read more

What happened to this place? Used to be my go to. I ordered a pizza well done like I always do and it was black and crispy all over the toppings as well as the crust. Almost inedible. But I did try. It was so salty I cannot imagine coming back read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tustin, California

Do yourself a favor and do not order a medium. Also, unless you are specifically looking for thin crust then specify you that you want the thick crust. I think their bigger pizzas will probably be better but I wont be going back to find out. I ordered a buffalo chicken pizza that really was an onion pizza. Onion flavor was way too strong and I like onion but this was just bad. Flavorless chicken and barely any buffalo flavoring. Also, some of the slices barely had chicken on them which is saying a lot considering how small the pizza is. Just a terrible pizza to be honest. I also ordered a NY Super Combo that was slightly burnt and just lacked flavor. There was barely any sausage on it but they made sure to go to town with the mushrooms. The salami had a strange taste. Cheese didn't taste that good either. It's my fault for trusting a pizza place could pull off what they are selling. I normally don't care for reviews but after a long day of work, long traffic and then paying almost 40 dollars for two small very disappointing pizzas, I feel some people may want to know what they might experience. I wish I would've ordered a large thick crust pizza. Hard to mess that up. I chose to try this spot over other places and I just feel disappointed. Truly disappointed. It's just pizza right? I hope you have a better experience than I did just be ready to cough up some serious dough for it. read more

New York Pizza - Onion Pizza with bits of chicken - Pizza Near Me - Tustin, California

See all

Nothing inherently bad about this place. The thing is they're called New York Pizza. Yet only have a rolling oven like Pizza Press use at all their location. This makes the crust more so like a pita than actual pizza crust. I got a medium veggie while on break for work and it costed about $21. And by medium this was a pizza press individual size. Essentially you can get the same size with far more toppings at pizza press foe $12.99. As for service the lady at the register seemed a bit disappointed to be working there. I was the first to hi, I was the first to say thank you, she just seemed like she wasn't the happiest to be there. Overall there was nothing inherently wrong with the place but a name of 'Fast Pizza' or 'Pizza Stop' would be far more accurate than N Y Pizza as this is nothing like NY Pizza. read more

We think we found our new pizza spot! The pizza is cheesy,the crust is crisp and the sauce is flavorful. Prices are decent as well. Great service.Definitely Check it out if you're looking for small/local business to try! read more

New York Pizza - Mushroom/pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Tustin, California

5 stars! These guys make great NYC style pizza and the prices are crazy good affordable! The owners are super friendly and down to earth as well. Whenever I'm in this area I'll always pick up a pizza to go since theres not really any good pizza where I live. read more

We have made New York Pizza our go to pizza takeout place. We love the thin New York style crust and every pizza we have had has been fantastic. When we order, the pizzas are ready on time and always hot. We enjoy it so much I am ordering from here tonight! read more

My husband and I each ordered a single slice of pizza on a Friday night. Located in a strip mall with plenty of parking. It came to under $10 for two fresh slices. It took about 5-6 minutes to bake our slices. The pepperoni slice I ordered was large, delicious, fresh and perfect. It wasn't greasy. The sauce was perfect and I can taste the butter in the crust. A really great slice of pizza. We definitely recommend and will return for a full size pizza. Yes it was that delicious! read more

Came in here to get a snack as we were waiting for our spot at Manaow, and we were thoroughly impressed by how good and well valued their pizzas were! Each slice was big enough to share for 2 people, and their whole pie prices are amazing too so we are definitely coming back here for their King Kong pizza. The lady working today was also super sweet and made the pizza super well! I would get the pizza and the garlic knots again read more

Since moving to OC, this has been my goto spot for pizza. Tried a buncha spots, but this place is legit. Rip to JT as he referred me here. read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tustin, California

Been wanting to try this spot for some time now and I'm not disappointed!! Absolutely delicious did not expect slices to be that huge! read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tustin, California

Interesting. We ordered a thin crust pepperoni and mushroom. When the pizza arrived, it looked like it had no cheese. There was some but not much. The pizza was ok. Nothing special. We also ordered garlic knots. There wasn't much garlic and they were definitely not knots...more like phallic looking dough sticks. That was disappointing. All in all, I think we'll try another place next time. read more

I haven't had a better pizza in California. Their jalapeno pizza is the best. I always add more hot sauce and peppers to make it even spicier. They make really good pizzas. I always recommend going there. read more

This is my new go to pizza spot, the ratio of sauce to dough to cheese is spot on. Sell by the slice to and they're big slices.

I love this pizza. It's saucy and cheesy and the slices are hugeeee! The service is super quick. And you can hit up the Yogurtland afterwards. The Ninja Turtles would eat here. read more

New York Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tustin, California

See all

We ordered a large margarita while waiting for Thai take out next door. The crust lacked the slight chew of a new york pizza. The underside of the pizza was soggy. The toppings were ok, nothing stood out on this pizza, definitely not a New York style pizza. read more

New York Pizza - Large Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tustin, California

My husband and I stopped by tonight for a few slices. We got the pepperoni, the NY Super combo, and the Greek spinach. This pizza is GOOD. Like really good! The dough is delicious, thin and crispy, and the toppings and sauce are great. Hit the spot and wasn't super greasy! We will definitely be back. read more

Rating is way too low so I'm leaving a review. Ordered a slice of pepperoni and it was absolutely perfect. Crispy crust, slightly crisp pepperoni and perfectly melted cheese. read more

I can't let the bad reviews slide! I've been a returning customer for years now, and I'm never disappointed. It's one of the best pizza spots in OC, and I've tried a lot of different spots. They make it easy to call in or order online, and it's always fast service. It is a small space, two tables and a few bar style stools. I usually take out, but the staff is always nice. Everyone I've introduced to this spot has loved it and I'm sure you will to! read more

The Pizza is always made fresh and ready to go even for slices. Always tastes so good. Service is always impeccable. Interior could use some work but I don't care about that at all as the pizza is really good. read more

I just moved here and I have to say I love pizza and this place is good. I don't understand the reviews but I test places just off of their cheese or pepperoni pizza. Their thin crust wins. I've tried other places ranked higher than this place nearby and I just don't get how this place is rated lower. Try this place out. It's worth finding out for yourself. I think you will be glad you did. read more

delicious pizza and nice little place , It has air conditioning and it's clean . The pizza itself is really good and fresh

So I heard about this place on a Reddit forum and I decided to drive around 20 minutes from Lake Forest because they offered beef pepperoni. I am shocked that this food is so delicious, from the first bite I fell in love. The pizza is outstanding 10 out of 10 better than round table better than any other shop. I've been to in recent memory. The gentleman at the counter is so kind, and the whole experience was fantastic. I am definitely a repeat customer from here on out read more

Pizza was similar to the one in new york. The thin crust, sauce was so good. It makes you crave for more after one slice. Exactly what i was looking for read more

I've never been to New York. I've never had real New York Pizza. I've never ate pizza from Tustin, CA. Until... now! Well this is definitely a hole in the wall joint. See.. my man told me about it so I knew it *had* to be good. Not all pizza is created equal & I'm tired of always going to lame Pizza Hut to get my pizza fix. Fun fact: the pepperoni & meats are all halal safe! Off to flavor town we went. This place is nothing fancy... don't let that scare you away! Located off Newport ave in a strip mall with a very generic sign, this place is easy to miss... all you see is a sign in a sans serif font that says NY PIZZA. That's it! We ordered a large meatlovers with added onions & banana peppers. It took about 15 min but it was worth the wait. The crust was thin but oh so delicious. I loved how it wasn't a grease bomb. I appreciated how every bite didn't taste like preservative city like pizza does from Pizza Hut. The ingredients were all SO fresh. It was so flavorful & cooked to perfection. There wasn't too much sauce to where it goes everywhere when you take a bite, nope, there was just the right amount. me want more!!!! Fun Fact #2... my man told me the pizza slice sticker on the front window is an accurate scale of one slice of the King Kong size. read more

New York Pizza - Meat lovers + banana pepper + onion - Pizza Near Me - Tustin, California

Ordered a meet lover not very good. Wouldn't come here again. I would suggest to the cook to add more sauce and toppings

If you want a big piece of New York this is your place!!! The pizza I recommend is their King Kong. Not only is it fire grilled but it's perfectly cooked. The team here are extremely helpful and nice, this is our new pizza spot this truly the place when the moon hits your eye like a big pizza pie you know that's amore!!!! read more

See all

Pizza was thin and decently crunchy. Not bad for a California pizza spot that tries to imitate the New York Slice. I would recommend! Only wish they added just a little more toppings but even in New York sometimes you won't get much pepperonis on your slice. read more

We visited late before they closed, and it was on of best pizzas in OC! We ordered margarita and it was so fresh and memorized me real NY or Italian pizza! Employees were nice and friendly! I would recommend anyone to visit such a great place! read more

I've just enjoyed THE MOST DELICIOUS calzone I've had in 35 years, since moving to CA from NY!!! I'm so glad I found this place and can't to come back again, REAL SOON! read more

True New York pizza!!! I was in the area and decided to try it. Ordered 2 pepperoni slices, soda and a cannoli. The two slices were delicious and HUGE!!! Worth every penny. The crust was perfect, sauce tasty and crispy pepperonis!! Will definitely come back if I'm in the area. read more

New York Pizza - Soooo good!!! - Pizza Near Me - Tustin, California

Rating is too low tried for the first time today got a slice pep jalapeño and mushroom. great pizza awesome crust just what i was looking for! read more

The business name says it all. NEW YORK PIZZA! This place deserves a glowing review. I bet the owner works there and that is why everything was so tasty. We ordered last minute late last night, just before closing through Grubhub. We are out of towners, and they delivered to our hotel room. We had calzone, antipasto salad, and cheese sticks. I've never had so much flavor on a cheese sticks! It's more like a mini extra cheese pizza in the shape it was in. And the calzone?! Died and went to heaven. We ordered it with Alfredo sauce. Very impressed and definitely tastes like New York Pizza. One small small detail and I hate to even being it up because everything was so good, but the marinera sauce (which by the way was so good) was half cold have warm. Maybe it was refrigerated then they heated it up, but it didn't heat all the way thru. And it's not that it was bad, but I took a dip in it, it was warm, and then a second dip was cold. Just was noticeable but it was a till good tho. We will order from them again when we return to Cali. Love love this place!!! read more