Excellent dough and sauce. Cooked perfectly, fresh toppings. Friendly service, easy parking.

My son and daughter in law visited this location today. I was very upset to hear of their experience and thought it would be good to share in the event that someone else has been treated with the same lack of professionalism and customer service. Here is their story. After paying for a large pizza and a 2 liter plus a tip, my daughter in law inquired if they charged for ranch dressing. They do, so they proceeded with purchasing a few ranch and three cookies that they have at the register. While paying for the additional items, the lady at the register accused her of stealing a cookie. Insisting that she had put a cookie in her purse, the shop lady demanded that she open her bag. She obliged, of course, because there was nothing to hide but honestly, why would anyone steal a $2 cookie after purchasing all the other items, paying extra for the dressing, and even leaving a tip? All this to say, think twice about visiting this pizza store, you could be falsely accused! read more

This place has gone downhill so fast it's sad. We used to come here all the time, but now it's a joke. They are so unorganized, it's ridiculous. A while back we ordered a large cheese and a large supreme pizza. We were quoted a 25 minute wait time. When I went to pick up my order after the 25 minutes my order still wasnt ready. So I waited, no problem. 15 minutes later my order was ready. When the guy opened the lid quickly to show that it was a cheese pizza it looked burnt. I asked if it was burnt and he said no it was just a shadow. I had seen a guy working on pizzas and it looked like he was scraping something off. I didn't think anything of it at the time because our pizzas had always been good. Yep, it was mine. They were fully aware that they sold a burnt piece of junk and didn't care at all. When I got home the pizza was in fact BURNT. I called back to let them know and the guy who answered the phone promised a free pizza on our next visit. The next time we ordered I ordered an xl cheese and a large supreme, I reminded the guy about the mishap the time before and he said no problem it will be ready in 45 minutes. 25 minutes later my mom called me saying they called with a question about the pizza. I called back immediately and the guy who I spoke to said that free pizza was for a large and not and xl. We usually order an XL, so yes, that was my fault. I got it confused. I said the large was fine and I would see them in 20 minutes. He said uhhh... no your wait time is 45 minutes to an hour now. Since we were around the corner I said that I would be right there so I could figure out why my remaining 20 minutes turned into another hour face to face. I got there, waited in line, and when it was my turn I let the girl know what was going on and all she could say was sorry, that's what our wait time is right now. Umm, how did it add an extra 60 minutes? I looked at my husband and he said just forget it. I told her to forget the order and that this kind of service was unacceptable. I was planning on never coming back, but for some reason my mom wanted pizza from here. She called and ordered, told them we had a free pizza and they said it would be ready in 45 minutes. When she got there the snarky girl behind the counter told my mom that she remembered me and that I stormed out of their restaurant because my pizza wasn't ready when I wanted it to be and that they reason why was because I called back 3 or 4 times not being able to make up my mind. Obviously she got me confused with someone else because I knew exactly what I wanted and the only mixup was my mistaking that it was an xl and not a large. I left because there was no way that it should have taken an extra 60 minutes to make my pizza. It should have been put in as soon as I spoke to the guy, not put to the back of the line. Its not my fault that THEY took 25 minutes to call me back. And to the snarky misinformed girl, if you're reading this, no sweetheart, I did not slam the front door when i supposidly "stormed" out. I'm an adult. I don't need to waste my energy doing things like that. Plus not to mention my husband was holding the door the whole time for a couple who walked in after I walked out. It sounds like they need a more organized system so the girl who is obviously too overwhelmed to keep customers straight can verify right away what people were promised. I have a feeling between her attitude, the lack of integrity, and the unorganized mess they are probably giving out a lot of free "sorry" pizzas. read more

New York Pizzeria - The whole underside of the pizza was black. The cheese was so crispy and hard, we threw the whole pizza away - Pizza Near Me - Calimesa, California

They used give generous toppings. Now theyre not the same. They dont taist as good. I guess it depends who's making them I'm going to stop going there. The last time I was there , they were very unwelcoming read more

Pizza was so-so. Not sure who taught these people how to make "pasta salad".See picture below Older lady that was on duty was so very rude! read more

New York Pizzeria - Pasta Salad??? Lettuce tomato and spaghetti noodles? shake my head and for 11 bucks - Pizza Near Me - Calimesa, California

My family loves to order dinner from here! They have our favorite subs and pizza. My favorite is their eggplant parm that is absolutely doused in sauce. So good. They're fast with their takeout orders and never miss. read more

See all

Some of the worst pizza I've ever had. Rubbery, over salted, and poor quality ingredients. To top that off it was delivered to the back porch of the house and no one knocked. read more

Stopped by this New York pizzeria hoping for that classic New York slice, but it didn't quite hit the mark. The pepperoni pizza we got was decent, not bad, but nothing particularly special either. It tasted more like a standard restaurant-style pizza. I was pretty hungry, so it did the job, but if you're looking for that true NYC flavor and texture, this might not be the place. Also, the inside of the restaurant was quite warm, which made the dining experience a bit uncomfortable. read more

My family enjoyed the pizza. We will eat here again. I hope the menu pics help others. I couldn't find any when I searched. read more

See all

There is absolutely NOTHING "New York" about this place. Pizza was total garbage and is going straight to whatever homeless person I can find as to not let my money go to complete waste. Toppings fall right off and it was wet. Seriously.. WET! Garlic bread was basically corn meal with seasonings. Staff was nice, but I will never come to this place again read more

Customer Service was great. The restaurant and restrooms were super clean (probably because I was the first one there near opening). It got super busy within the hour though. About five pizzas for different parties, and three pickup orders. And the pizza? Pretty good! No complaints here. Fully cooked and fresh. I went without my ranch this time, but it was just a nice and chill experience. I was mainly here to check out Retrovolt arcade next door, but after Leeman let me know that the pizzeria partners with the arcade for private parties. I am a little wary about the reviews with uncooked pizza and/or hair, but based on my experience and a majority of the other reviews, I'd weigh in more on the 4 since this was closer to 3.5 for me. Cheers! read more

New York Pizzeria - Small Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Calimesa, California

My wife and went there for the first time today all I can say is that the pizza is damn good. It is old school pizza without the bells and whistle that modern pizza try to do nowadays. They are not cheap on the toppings and the prices are reasonable. In fact, they put so many toppings on the pizza that I was doing arm curls with it while walking to my truck and now my arms are bigger than The Mountain from Game of Thrones. In all seriousness, we will be back. read more

Best pizza in town and if you think different, you're wrong. Been coming here for 10+ years and the quality is STILL THERE. YIPPIEEEEEE read more

New York Pizzeria - Small pepperoni with extra cheese and jalapeño poppers - Pizza Near Me - Calimesa, California

This is delicious pizza! Literally better than any chain around! Order fast service and gives a family ambience good for after sports :)

We ordered the meatball sub and shared it between 2 people which was perfect. The sub was delicious! Had plenty of meatballs and it was flavorful. Would come back! read more

New York Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Calimesa, California

We ordered a large New York special medium crust pizza via delivery. I did not tell my husband where I was ordering from because I did not want the pizza that he wanted me to order from.. so I have my fingers crossed and trusted the reviews. Yes this was five stars and I thought he would be upset because I didn't order his usual commercial pizza but he absolutely loved it. Can't wait to have the leftovers tomorrow. I highly recommend. read more

We always order the Calimesa special Large pepperoni pizza Turkey sandwich Lasagna and Salad Something for everyone Service Always good read more

I have been coming here for a couple years They have the best cashew pepperoni pizza Good friendly service read more

I really like this place, and I love their pizza. On our latest visit, we ordered the Family Special ($29.99): XL 3 topping pizza ($1.75 each extra topping), large salad, and two soft drinks or a regular beer. It was a decent amount of food and would easily feed a family of four. The salad was fresh, and the pizza (pepperoni, sausage & black olive) was very tasty. Service has always been friendly, and the food has come out fairly quickly. Seems that most people take their orders to go, but we eat in. The dècor is a little dated, but it's clean. read more

New York Pizzeria - Large Pepperoni, Sausage & Black Olive - Pizza Near Me - Calimesa, California

First time trying here on a Friday night. Walked in about 8pm hoping to sit inside. No one else besides employees in the restaurant... I guess it's more of a takeout place? Pricing was decent. Got the special with one XL pizza, one salad, and two XL drinks. Added wings and a beer as well. Came out to $68. Once we sat down at our table, we were constantly getting up to pick up each item that was ready. Even when we were done, the workers asked us to bring our dirty dishes to them at the counter... Maybe it was just us, but I feel like if you have tables for people to sit at and are asking for tips on the receipts, your guests should not be working this much... Food was good, but not good enough to compensate. read more

The people were nice. They did advertise thin crust pizza. I've had thin crust pizza before and this place doesn't know what thin crust pizza is. I would like to upload a photo of thin crust pizza so this place would know what thin crust pizza looks like. The flavors were ok but the super thick crust pizza really took away from the experience. read more

New York Pizzeria - This is what thin crust pizza looks like. - Pizza Near Me - Calimesa, California

I'm writing this review in hopes that whoever's in charge of this restaurant put some pride into the inside of this establishment. I was completely grossed out with how dirty the walls were inside the restaurant and the fans. It's amazing what a little Dawn Power wash sprayed on the walls and a good wipe down daily will do! If the seating area of this restaurant looks as bad as it does, it scares me to think what the kitchen and the food handling is like at this place. The pizza was very good. But it was hard for me to eat grossed out after looking at the cleanliness or lack thereof inside. I really hope someone gets it together and make sure that the walls and the fans and everything get a good deep clean at the end of the day or at least for the love of God Once a week. 4 stars for pizza 1 star for cleanliness This place has potential for the owners of this establishment, take pride in your business. The inside is absolutely disgusting. I'm not talking about chair updates or anything like that. I'm just talking about cleaning the walls and the fans and the floors daily. read more

New York Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Calimesa, California

See all

I'm local and have been coming here semi-frequently but I'm done. They tried to sell me a burnt pizza at full price and I declined. They then expected me to wait another 30 minutes for them to remake it, instead of just proactively re-making me an acceptable pizza to begin with. At their inflated prices, the fact that they thought I would pay full price for a burnt pizza is ridiculous. The dude couldn't have cared less about wasting my time. Hearing the way he talks to other customers too was abhorrent. Very rude and ambivalent person. Horrible customer service for overpriced pizza. read more

Love the food but why the heck is the bigger part of the restaurant still closed off all the time?? The Asian guy was so rude to my dad about sitting there and now he refuses to go back‍ we use to love going there as a family too. Soo annoying and disappointing. The tiny section they want everyone to squeeze into is too cramped, especially for larger/disabled people. read more

The staff were very unfriendly. They made a mistake on our order (called our number and gave us the wrong salads). We had never eaten here before and we did order salads, but we didn't know what they are supposed to look like. The lady then came to our table and yelled at my husband saying he grabbed the wrong order (10 mins later). He explained she called our number he even showed her our ticket and we were not sure what the salads were supposed to look like, so we took the tray. She continued to yell and then kept making comments to other customers about "watch out someone else might take your food." Mind you we were here for a soccer party for my son, so this took place all in front of everyone, and those people were other parents in our group. The salad we got was someone else's in our group (even he heard her call the wrong number) Food was okay but due to the experience I will not be returning. This could have been handled so much better. read more

Pizza is so yummy! Just like pizza used to be back in the 1900's! Service was nice and we plan to go back every time we want pizza, no more fast food pizza! read more

This place is absolutely trash!!! The girl behind the phone never can take the order right. This is the third time now I've been here that I've called in and order and they claim my order was never taken. They need to get rid of the little girl upfront, cause she has absolutely no idea what she's doing. read more

Been coming here for probably 30 years! Always yummy authentic tasting pizza. Salads are great too. Always good customer service!

Lady taking order was extremely rude needs to be in the back making the food, plus I think she's a minor serving alcohol .Been here a ton of times and always deal with the gentleman who is very nice. Then she yells at us for seating in an area that's closed even tho there is costumers are seating over there. Plus section that's open for costumers is completely filthy. read more

We love this place! First place we ordered a meal when we moved to Calimesa. The lasagna is off the chain!

Cleanliness 4 Cost 1 Cuisine 2 Customer service 5 Wanted to try this place for the first time. We ordered 2 med one topping pizzas and 1 large pizza and wings... $53!!! We thought, ok maybe the price reflects the taste. Nope. Hardly any sauce on the pizza...it was like we were just eating cheese bread. Their large pizza's size is equivalent to a medium pizza at most other places. This place is way overpriced for the taste..We will not go back. read more

New York Pizzeria - Their menu - Pizza Near Me - Calimesa, California

Love the food and service!! Freshly made pizza and the staff is so friendly. Recommend it.

For the price it was decent food wasn't that flavorful but cheap if you just need to fill your stomach up. Tiramisu is rock hard and has ice crystal but if you can look past that and let it thaw it's a pretty good pre made tiramisu but wasn't something you'd go craving again but it definitely hits the home if you're looking for those 2000s cheap pizzerias read more

See all

Terrible service . True to the name on the building answered the phone with a brusque rudeness and simply said "HOLD". Sat the phone on the counter and went on about your business. I could hear employees chit chatting in the background about their personal life. After a lengthy hold I hung up and called Toscanos in Yucaipa. It was a longer drive but well worth it . Such great service and amazing pizza ! I decided to make a deal.. I'll keep my money and you can keep your pizza and rude service ... I'll order from toscanos for now on read more

Showed up at 8pm and was told that it's their closing are at 8pm so Yelp has it wrong. Owner I believe, told me that they don't participate on Yelp. Order was still taken. Hawaiian with cashews. Friend went back to get the order and said the person kinda just threw the pizza at him and no questions asked about utensils or condiments. A bit pricey for my taste but you do get what you pay for. Lots of cheese and ingredients. read more

New York Pizzeria - Hawaiian with cashews - Pizza Near Me - Calimesa, California

Pizza was amazing highly recommend.. we got the three topping deep dish and it was great. read more

New York Pizzeria - Deep dish - Pizza Near Me - Calimesa, California

Love this place! They are awesome and have the best wood burned pizza oven leaving their pizza delicious! We almost can't get enough. They do get incredibly busy on Friday nights and weekends but it's because they are so good! read more

Unfriendly employees, skimpy on the toppings and hair in the pizza, not to mention exceptionally slow service. I don't recommend this pizzeria. read more

Ordered three pizzas, cheese, vegetarian, and Hawaiian style for take out. Upon pick up, 1/3 of the vegetarian pizza was smashed where it hadn't been taken out of the oven correctly. That part of the pie can't be eaten without knife and fork. We were offered $5 off the pizza or wait about 45 minutes for them to remake it, while the other two were ready to go. The pizza was ruined and should have been comp'd, very poor customer service. Otherwise the pizza is too bready, but toppings are generous. There is plenty of other average pizza in Calimesa/Yucaipa. Based on this experience, we'll spend our money elsewhere. read more

Been eating here for a few years when we visit the area. The pizza has always been solid.. I enjoy a thick doughy pizza...