We all love stopping in Nicholas Creamery whenever we can. The staff is always super nice, attentive, and the flavors change often always fun to stop in and see what's new. We love you can get a pint too-and love that you taste a flavor or two to decide- Always fabulous highly recommend. read more

See all

I came back for yet another flight of four different flavors. As always, they were all very creamy and fulfilling. Peanut Butter Palooza - This was homemade peanut butter ice cream with peanut butter cups and Oreos. This was unreal, one of my favorites tried here. There was plenty of peanut butter flavor, but not too much where it was an issue. Oreos were a nice compliment. Root Beer - This tasted exactly like root beer and was unique being in ice cream form but could not have too much of it as I became tired of it quickly. Grandma's Strawberry Shortcake - This was homemade strawberry sweet cream with strawberry jam swirl and shortbread cookie pieces. This was alright. The crumb pieces were too large, and surprised there was not more of a strawberry taste. Mango Lassi - This was homemade Greek yogurt sweet cream with homemade mango jam swirl. I wished there was more mango. I liked the slight change with Greek yogurt being used and it was very apparent. The sugar and whatever else was used helped to offset the blandness of regular Greek yogurt. read more

We ran up on this creamery on chance while in the area. We were looking for dessert and pulled into the plaza. This place was hopping with the locals. The line was out the door. Everyone was waiting patiently. 3/4 young kids were working taking orders. They had a lot of flavors to choose from. I was interested in the brown butter cookie dough to try but ultimately went with pistachio. It was delicious. I just found out it had gluten whomp whomp!! We also tried a shake with coffee and chocolate chunks! They also sell ice cream cakes and ice cream sandwiches. The shop is cute modern. it has a cow to lay on just in case you get tired lol Overall I would def go back read more

Nicholas Creamery - Pistachio icecream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Long Branch, New Jersey

See all

Wish I could give it five stars and anyone that knows me, knows I'm not a cheap person but this ice cream and the cakes you have to take a mortgage out for. Don't get me wrong, It's fantastic, ice cream and I don't mind paying, but that's too much for a ice cream cake. read more

Delicious and creative ice cream, and sorbet. I mean, as a Jersey girl, how could I resist New Jersey sweet corn ice cream? And they had an absolutely divine fig, pear, and apple sorbet that worked surprisingly well not only on its own, but with a scoop of another flavor of ice cream. The ice cream was smooth and lush, and there are all the traditional flavors as well as the more creative ones. read more

I come down and visit my friend pretty often in Long Branch and usually we end the night with a sweet treat somewhere. This place is a frequent stop when we're in the mood for ice cream. They have some incredible flavors here. I haven't even tried that many of them unfortunately those the ones I have are very good. read more

Nicholas Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Long Branch, New Jersey

Sooo creamy and refreshing on a hot summer day. The staff at the front were so friendly and were quick to let you try whichever flavors they had. They have a cute cow chair in the store. We got the medium cup which includes 2 flavors. One was this Bourbon chocolate chunk (I can't remember the name) but it was boozy, rich and chocolate-y. Not pictured is the mint chocolate chip scoop. Equally as creamy and a strong mint flavor if that's your thing. Always loving the chocolate chunks :) that's all thanks for viewing read more

Nicholas Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Long Branch, New Jersey

Was looking for a bakery and we found Nicholas Creamery also! Ice cream was the best! We all got different flavors and each one was more delicious than the next! Will definitely stop back when in Long Beach again!!! read more

Nicholas Creamery, you've officially ruined all other ice cream for me--in the best way possible. I tried the Brown Sugar Cookie Dough and WOW. This flavor is next-level. The brown sugar ice cream is rich, smooth, and has that cozy, almost caramel-like warmth to it. And the cookie dough? They did not skimp. I mean tons and tons of cookie dough chunks in every single bite. It's like they read my mind and delivered my dessert dreams in a scoop. You can taste the homemade love in every bite, and the texture is perfection. Creamy, flavorful, and honestly addictive. I could've gone back for seconds (and probably will). Friendly staff, a cute, welcoming vibe, and the kind of ice cream that makes you smile before the first bite. This place is a gem. If you haven't tried it yet--what are you doing with your life? read more

Love craft ice cream and this was a really nice find! Flavors so good! Had a taste of the porta ricotta with olive oil, almost picked this it was so good!! Been a coffee kick so coffee bourbon with chocolate chunks won out. Not a fan of hazel nuts so an easy pick. The cow seat is so cute and perfect height for the little ones. Five locations, stop in when you find one and you won't be disappointed. read more

See all

It seems like you're near a Nicholas Creamery anywhere in eastern Monmouth County-good for your sweet tooth, bad for your waistline! But you'll find bright flavors without being a sugar bomb. read more

Found this creamery after a long day at the beach and I was so happy we decided to choose this one out of the few we found... First of all, the place was packed and that was the first sign it was a good choice. The staff was super friendly and understanding. We were a big group on top of the huge crowd that was there, and that can be challenging sometimes but it was as smooth as it could've gone. Almost all of us decided to get medium ice cream on a waffle cone... the cones are made at the store and those were the BEST cones I have had. You can tell they were fresh, and they were crispy but with some softness and thicker than usual, just the cones are business potential. I had cherry goat cheese and cookies and cream. The cookies and cream was as good as it could be, creamy, with tonsss of cookies... the cherry goat cheese flavor tasted just like cheesecake and was soooo good!!! Like 4 of us ended up choosing it after they gave us some to taste. Loved the creamery and will definitely be back if I'm ever around the area!! Totally worth it!!!! read more

See all

Excellent new location in Long Branch NJ, conveniently located in Ursula Plaza. This location has renovated the store where Hoffman's was. The store is bright and welcoming as is the staff. The ice cream and their cakes are top notch. Sundaes, cones, cups, shakes all dynamite. My favorite flavor this year is Coffee bourbon with Nutty Monkey (Banana) running a close second. Check out this Nicolas Creamery location if you are in the area. read more

Nicholas Creamery - Peanut butter and fudge ice cream cake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Long Branch, New Jersey

Love the various creations... PB&J, peach cobbler, watermelon chocolate chunk, apple cider...the list goes on. Every few weeks the flavors change. Homemade waffle bowls & cones. Really thick shakes. They have a few locations. I suggest visiting. read more

Nicholas Creamery - The cowch - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Long Branch, New Jersey

See all

Yes the best on ocean blvd flavors are delicious and have a mix. It's great. You will love each one of them. Great service a little pricey, but worth the money. read more

Excellent homemade ice cream in a strip mall next to seven presidents beach. Favorite flavors were the coffee crunch and brown sugar cookie dough. Loved the wide assortment of flavors and the dense yet creamy textures. read more

Went near closing time or 10 pm on Wednesday. The midnight chocolate peanut butter and American pie were delicious. Service was very good. read more

Nicholas Creamery - a scoop of chocolate ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Long Branch, New Jersey

See all

What's goodie SOCIETY TheMadScientist & Yann Yann was out and about cruise'n the coast to relieve our stresses and Yann want'd a SWEET TREAT SO BING Bang Boom we came along to the shore gem and yes it is a true gem The inside is very clean and organized with a whole bunch of space The servers knows the science (information) about the ice cream they served and they go above and beyond to give the best service TheMadScientist ask'd about the sprinkle and they went to the back and found out that they were vegan friendly ~~~~~now let's get to the grub~~~~~ So as you can see TheMadScientist had the waffle cone and boi that thing was hit'n all kind of taste buds for the best It was vegan peanut chocolate chip & vegan chocolate wit the chocolate sprinkles It was a tornado of chocolate and it was the greatest tornado you ever would want to be in on Big G Yann Yann choose the brown sugar cookie dough wit wet (candy) walnut it was really tasty and the wet walnut was a great addition to her ice cream like a hug from a taste angel in the greatest of ways To sum up the experience it was magnificent and we will make it a staple when in that area You know the Science SOCIETY Stay LYT Bah BAH BIG L.Y.T The BIGGEST of L.Y.TS Live Your Time read more

See all

Amazingly great flavors. They also make new flavors. This is one of my favorite places to meet up with friends.

Excellent homemade iced cream. Great selection of flavors including many unique. Nice sized portions. Cookies and cream had tons of cookies inside. Friendly, patient service. Tasters offered. Will definitely go back. read more

It's refreshing to find a creamery with such variety and quality. The family and I did quite enjoy their sweet threat. I can see this place becoming one of my regular ice cream place. read more

The ice cream was outstanding. Lots of choices and flavors. The restaurant was nice and clean. They only take cash but do have ATM available. read more

The previous tenant in long branch was Hoffmann ice cream which was solid, attentive service and a terrific option to standing in long lines at coney waffle or Lighthouse with the summer crowds. Nicholas has a superior product but two recent visits left me disappointed by service especially with Nicholas's premium pricing in a strip mall. Both instances I was left waiting while one or more workers surveyed their cellphones? Are they expecting to save lives or discover a cure for cancer as they review their IG accounts? The ice cream is delicious but if I want to wait I can walk to the competition around Pier Village. read more

Nicholas Creamery - The company logo inside the store - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Long Branch, New Jersey

Top 2 most overrated ice cream places in Monmouth county and it's not number 2. The coffee crunch feels like you are chewing on dirt pellets in your coffee ice cream and the cookie and cream tastes like it was made with water. Very disappointed with this place especially for the price. Save your money and pallet and go someplace else read more

Outstanding homemade ice cream with a bunch of interesting flavors. The bourbon coffee chocolate chunk was fantastic!

I went to the newly opened Nicholas creamery in long branch NJ. They just took over from Hoffmann ice cream. I asked a young guy for a small Chocalate soft ice cream with sprinkles and a medium soft Chocalate ice cream with sprinkles and Chocalate syrup. I saw a girl making another one and she came to the sprinkle area and put sprinkles on all the sides with a spoon and then dunk the ice cream in the sprinkles......wow very nice I thought. My guy comes over to the sprinkle section ad gets a spoonful of sprinkles and pours them over the top and half fall back into the pile of sprinkles. Oh well I guess 40 sprinkles are better then none. At the register I while paying I saw that there was no Chocalate syrup on the cream so I asked him and he said yes it's on the bottom. Ok I guess. As I walked away eating my I cream I didn't get any syrup and toward the end I could see some Chocalate syrup on the bottom maybe half a teaspoon. Maybe they do it different here but I'm used to the syrup being poured over the I cream so you get some with every spoonful. Sorry Nicholas creamery but I can't come back you got my $13 and change but never again. read more