We all love stopping in Nicholas Creamery whenever we can. The staff is always super nice,…read moreattentive, and the flavors change often always fun to stop in and see what's new. We love you can get a pint too-and love that you taste a flavor or two to decide- Always fabulous highly recommend.

I came back for yet another flight of four different flavors. As always, they were all very creamy…read moreand fulfilling. Peanut Butter Palooza - This was homemade peanut butter ice cream with peanut butter cups and Oreos. This was unreal, one of my favorites tried here. There was plenty of peanut butter flavor, but not too much where it was an issue. Oreos were a nice compliment. Root Beer - This tasted exactly like root beer and was unique being in ice cream form but could not have too much of it as I became tired of it quickly. Grandma's Strawberry Shortcake - This was homemade strawberry sweet cream with strawberry jam swirl and shortbread cookie pieces. This was alright. The crumb pieces were too large, and surprised there was not more of a strawberry taste. Mango Lassi - This was homemade Greek yogurt sweet cream with homemade mango jam swirl. I wished there was more mango. I liked the slight change with Greek yogurt being used and it was very apparent. The sugar and whatever else was used helped to offset the blandness of regular Greek yogurt.

One of my favorite ice cream shops! Stumbled upon it by accident on the way home from Asbury and…read morenow it's always a stop after a beach day. I love the dipped waffle cones and the peanut butter crunch and triple x ice cream flavors are too good

Worker named LUKE very unprofessional asked him please help us he stated he's cleaning couldn't…read more Mean while there's line out door

Cute lighthouse decor, ice cream shop outdoor seating and a walk up, stand with all sorts of…read moreflavors, including hard ice cream and soft and a variety of waffle cones. They also have shakes, sundaes and something called the tsunami which I'm not sure exactly what that was but I'm assuming it was big. We had a couple of cones and sat out, enjoying the ocean breeze. Services fast and they have multiple windows.

Finally made it to Salty's over the 4th! I had a kids cup of the soft serve swirl and it hit the…read morespot. I'd like to go back to try one of their tsunami's or a sundae.

Wouldn't recommend if you're a minority/not white. My father speaks English at a basic…read moreconversational level, it's not perfect, but he's completely understandable. While trying to practice his English, he placed his own order. During the entire ordeal, one of the male employees in the back started laughing and was giving "that look" to his co-workers. Furthermore throughout the entire experience they kept giving us strange looks, as if we didn't belong or something. Definitely won't be coming back due to this customer service.

A solid choice for ice cream. Went on a rainy day and there was no wait. Fairly friendly staff who…read morequickly received ingredients in the flavors. Nice selection of ice creams and clean inside. Pricing was on par for ice cream. Ended up with a small Robert Brownie Jr. Overall, the experience and food was just okay - wouldn't seek it out again but wouldn't mind trying it again either.

The ice cream here is 5 stars. It tastes amazing! I use to come here all the time when they first…read moreopened because I loved the ice cream! My cup I ordered was thoroughly filled. The portions use to be great, and I always left feeling I received my moneys worth. It all stopped last year. I stopped coming last summer after I ordered a large, and I can see the sides of my cup when I looked down. I had 4 tiny scoops in the center of my cup. The cup was not filled. I was so pissed that I didn't come back that whole summer. I decided to give it another shot today after a year of not going, and the same thing happened again! This time I ordered a medium, and it only had three tiny scoops! I saw the sides of my cup once again when I looked into my cup. I will not be returning here due to being ripped off. I should have went to Sundaes, Nicholas, or Hoffmann where you get your moneys worth, and the cup is always filled!

Ice cream. 5/5. No notes…read more Service? I mean, the people who worked there were friendly. It was very little interaction to just get ice cream, though. But they knew what they were doing. It's a cute little building. One room with a counter...typical ice cream bar. The ice cream itself WAS something to write home about. Or at least to write a review about. It was creamy, cold, sweet...as I wanted. But it had a soft fluffy texture in a way, which made it easy to just keep eating.

This cute ice cream shop has delicious ice cream but leaves some room for improvement…read more I think the ice cream here is actually really good! I got the Elvis and midnight jersey and both were delicious mixed together! The service here was definitely lacking. Not sure if it was because it was midweek but the people working the counters didn't seem to really want to be there. Usually ice cream shops would at least offer one free sample but no such case here. Also, I had to come back up to get a bowl for my overly melted ice cream and they just kept looking at me and going away from the line to "help" others when other staff were already helping them. If you are okay with just getting ice cream and not caring about service, this is not a bad spot!

We wanted to treat the kids after a day at Sandy Hook beach and decided to go for a new spot. Glad…read morewe did! I went off the recommendation of other Yelpers and can confirm, yes the Elvis ice cream is incredible. My family members enjoyed all of their picks too. The line moved pretty quickly, so I am confident that I can come back anytime during the beach season for more.

Ordered A cup of ice cream wanted the hot fudge on the side because it melts the ice cream and…read morewasn't going to eat it for awhile but they said they don't do that!!! Makes 0 sense!! I was willing to pay for it not asking for it for free.. could have gave me the same amount they would have if they added it to the ice cream.. again makes no sense. And they use to do it. I was a frequent customer But sorry I won't be back

Ive been to a couple Nicholas Creamery Locations i do Love there Ice Cream but if i could Make 1…read moreSUGGESTION........the ingredients such as Pistachios, Coconut...etc....i believe there needs to be Way More in the ice cream. its very limited with there ingredients. When i had gotten both of those flavored ice creams there was hardly any pistachios in the pistachio ice cream or hardly and coconut flakes in the coconut ice cream. Def needs more toppings in it. When i get pics of there ice cream i feel im decieved by the way it looks as when i go there it doesnt come out like that at All!!!!

My husband and I stopped there today. A very nice selection of flavors in both the ice cream and…read morethe Italian ice. And the prices were very reasonable.

Most depressing soft serve I've ever seen in my life. It was genuinely a centimeter tall. If I get…read morea soft serve in a cone shouldn't it be towering ???? But noooooooooo. The workers are sweet btw. Cash only makes me mad though.