I stopped by sunday's on my way home from work as I pass by there. Deciding I wanted a snack but…read moredidn't want to commit to anything large. I thought why not get a small ice cream cone. I went around 5:00 on a Monday afternoon and I was the only person there granted. It's the winter and so I don't know how many people are regularly coming out. I can imagine in the summer this place would be significantly more busy. When I went inside I was greeted by the woman behind the counter. She was friendly and nice. I asked if I could sample one of the flavors and she obliged. I tried the tiramisu which was really delicious and I ended up getting a small cone with that and the s'more. I did really like the tiramisu better and if I went back I would probably just get that and has chunks of ladyfinger in there which adds to a very nice texture. All in all they had a lot of really good looking flavors and they even had ice cream cupcake looking things in the case. I bet this is a great place to come in the summer as well as getting some options for kids birthday parties, or adults if that's your style too.

Wouldn't recommend if you're a minority/not white. My father speaks English at a basic…read moreconversational level, it's not perfect, but he's completely understandable. While trying to practice his English, he placed his own order. During the entire ordeal, one of the male employees in the back started laughing and was giving "that look" to his co-workers. Furthermore throughout the entire experience they kept giving us strange looks, as if we didn't belong or something. Definitely won't be coming back due to this customer service.

Probably the WORST system possible!…read more Longest line for mediocre ice cream . The quietest "i can help the next group over here.." as kids are screaming running in and out of the line with ice cream cones in hands. No system, from ordering to paying. There's like 4 "servers" trying their best while they have to remember what each group has as people are cutting and coming in the exit. Cross contamination of peanut ice cream dumped into the sprinkles some guy talking to everyone as he grabs gummies out of a tub with his hands. Bad. Oh. P.s Got the wrong order! Thanks Nicholas! Great system ya got! Real good... no management anywhere. .5 stars

I've never been to a Nicholas creamery and I keep seeing it pop up all over my social media. There…read morewas a bunch of people on line when you walk in but the line moved pretty quickly. Definitely a nicer ice cream place with some fancy flavors named after local spots. We got the rainbow cookie which was amazing and the brown sugar cookie dough which they said was one of their top sellers, also so good. Can't wait to come back.

The guy (who I am assuming is the owner or otherwise a really bad hire) behind the counter was so…read moreunfriendly and annoyed by children that we turned around and left. If you own an ice cream shop, families and kids come with the territory. The ice cream itself wasn't much better--overloaded with food coloring and artificial ingredients, and it tasted exactly the way it looked: fake and overly processed. We won't be back. There are far better places in town serving real ice cream and treating customers with basic courtesy and respect.

One of the best cute little ice cream shops in red bank. They have a variety flavors and options…read morelike sundaes and waffles. The only thing I didn't love was if I wanted water, they wouldn't give me and my party a water cup.

Callie's Creamery is honestly a hidden gem. But in a sea of famous Jersey shore ice cream towns,…read morehow do they stand out you may ask. Their ice cream contains the highest quality ingredients and all of their flavor flavors are handcrafted in house. You can really taste the difference! We tried a variety of amazing flavors like the mint fudge swirl, Nutella Graham, Callie's cotton candy, and the Dubai chocolate, but my favorites were Cookie Monster and biscoff cookie butter! You can order an ice cream flight which is perfect for indecisive people like me. Six flavors, sounds good to me! Their sundaes are huge and could be shared with 2 people. The brownie sundae was decadent and dripping in fudge. Yum! I like that it's indoors which means you can come here year round. There's plenty of seating in their adorable ice cream shop, which is adorned with painted sprinkles all over the walls! There's claw machines for kids and even a photo booth. Pints, ice cream sandwiches, and more in their freezer ready to go. Can't wait to be back for more!

I have an unhealthy obsession with this ice cream. It's in a tie for 1st at all times. Specifically…read morethe biscoff cookie butter, cookies and cream, and s'mores are to die for. They also have a great rewards system where they'll randomly sent you a free $5 off which almost pays for a whole ice cream. The store is always very clean and you can try as many samples as you like. They clearly label the flavors with the allergens so you can be safe. If you ask them to use a clean scoop for severe allergies they are very accommodating. Another cute thing they do is theme night for kids so they'll have Bluey and characters come visit. Super cute, one of my all time favs.

I am a local who had a very bad day and went to the boardwalk to get ice cream from Eddie's. The…read moreowner just happened to be there and simply asked, "How ya doing?" and my eyes filled with tears and I go on how I am grateful that I can walk to the boardwalk but today was rough and she gave me the ice cream on the house. I was very touched and walked away still emotional and grateful while eating my salted praline ice cream. It was such a gift.

The young girl working there today was really odd. She came out of nowhere and just stood there for…read morea few seconds and then we realized she was a worker there when she asked for our order. I was taken aback because it was unexpected and because of the odd behavior of just getting into our space and just standing and not saying anything right away. Didn't expect the person to leave the shop and come out to take the order because we were next in line and it wasn't a long line. Stomach hurts so not sure they follow hygienic protocols - just hope it's not food poisoning . The whole experience was strange and unfortunate because we enjoyed it the last time we were there. Still gave her a tip and maybe she's new and was just being a bit awkward- but perhaps she needs better employee training or help with her customer service.

My husband and I stopped there today. A very nice selection of flavors in both the ice cream and…read morethe Italian ice. And the prices were very reasonable.

Most depressing soft serve I've ever seen in my life. It was genuinely a centimeter tall. If I get…read morea soft serve in a cone shouldn't it be towering ???? But noooooooooo. The workers are sweet btw. Cash only makes me mad though.

We all love stopping in Nicholas Creamery whenever we can. The staff is always super nice,…read moreattentive, and the flavors change often always fun to stop in and see what's new. We love you can get a pint too-and love that you taste a flavor or two to decide- Always fabulous highly recommend.

I came back for yet another flight of four different flavors. As always, they were all very creamy…read moreand fulfilling. Peanut Butter Palooza - This was homemade peanut butter ice cream with peanut butter cups and Oreos. This was unreal, one of my favorites tried here. There was plenty of peanut butter flavor, but not too much where it was an issue. Oreos were a nice compliment. Root Beer - This tasted exactly like root beer and was unique being in ice cream form but could not have too much of it as I became tired of it quickly. Grandma's Strawberry Shortcake - This was homemade strawberry sweet cream with strawberry jam swirl and shortbread cookie pieces. This was alright. The crumb pieces were too large, and surprised there was not more of a strawberry taste. Mango Lassi - This was homemade Greek yogurt sweet cream with homemade mango jam swirl. I wished there was more mango. I liked the slight change with Greek yogurt being used and it was very apparent. The sugar and whatever else was used helped to offset the blandness of regular Greek yogurt.

Loved stopping in for a sweet treat! I was even more excited to see that they offer vegan ice cream…read moreflavors, which can be hard to find. The vegan ice cream was absolutely delicious!!Creamy, flavorful, and just as satisfying as traditional ice cream. It's always a bonus when a place has great options for everyone, and this definitely exceeded my expectations. I can't wait to come back and try more of their vegan flavors. Highly recommend if you're looking for a delicious ice cream spot with something for everyone!

Ice cream isn't bad, workers are friendly, but what is so difficult about filling a container of…read moreice cream to the top? Ordered two quarts of ice cream that were filled a little over halfway before the worker decided to give up and throw a lid on it. It would be nice to get what you pay for, especially in this economy when everything is overpriced as is. Selling "quarts" that look like pints isn't a great way to keep customers coming back.